Measuring Integrated Care - Methodological Reflections from Monitoring and Evaluation Process of the PHC Plus Pilot Program in Poland.

Introduction: Integrated care is an important strategy for increasing health system performance. Despite its growing significance, detailed evidence on the measurement properties of integrated care instruments remains vague and limited. This article aims to present the Monitoring and Evaluation Framework (M&EF) used in the pilot program of coordinated primary care in Poland. It can serve as an example of Monitoring and Evaluation (M&E) concept for the countries taking their first steps in the care integration implementation or establishing PHC reforms. This article belongs to the series of publications entitled: "Highway to hell or stairway to heaven - evaluating complex integrated care models - lessons from the Primary Healthcare Plus pilot program (PHC Plus) in Poland". Methods: The M&EF of the PHC Plus was based on the Theory of Change within which a shift was to take place in the following 4 aspects: (1) change in health outcomes among participating patients; (2) change in health care experience among participating patients; (3) change in the fragmentation of care provided for chronic diseases among participating patients; (4) change in overall spending on health services for the patients in the PHC Plus facilities. Data for the M&EF of the PHC Plus came from two main sources: the National Health Fund (national insurer) database and the results survey questionnaires. Results: Based on the established M&EF of PHC Plus it was possible to monitor and evaluate the change in patients' health outcomes, health experience and health literacy, fragmentation of care index, and overall spending on healthcare services offered in the pilot. Some of the analyzes planned could not be carried out due errors in data reporting systems, the lack of data of adequate quality or the pandemic. However, M&E implementation process provided many insightful information supporting broader PHC reform in Poland. Inclusive process of information and data sharing, discussions with the country health stakeholders and solid analytical background allowed for better informed policy making and scaling up the pilot. Conclusion: M&E process was put in place to help identify interventions, processes and approaches that could be scaled up and implemented at the country level. This approach resulted in broader understanding and acceptance of the proposed reforms in the PHC in Poland, following PHC Plus pilot implementation. Tools and approaches available and used to evaluate care integration in the PHC setting may not fully respond to the PHC and care integration system characteristic and country capacity. Therefore, revised M&E approach should be an integral part of the health policy interventions and further development of the PHC. Care integration specific measurement tools should be considered. Integration is a complex, multidimensional concept that requires measurement at multiple levels, including the patient level, the provider (professional) level, organizational and systems level. The M&E system of care integration requires use of multidimensional approach, complexed data systems, but also active sharing process of key findings. A phased approach is recommended to help researchers define clearly where they are in the research process and show progress on the outcomes' achievement. Some simplification of the M&EF used in the PHC Plus is recommended to increase its sustainability without loosing key analytics.

The impact of aging on long-term care in Europe and some potential policy responses.

The article examines recent data on the impact of increasing numbers of elderly people in Europe on expenditures for long-term care services. After reviewing recent and projected future costs of long-term care, the authors examine current national strategies for long-term care as well as potential policy options that could reduce future expenditures due to aging. Although long-term care expenditures in Europe will rise over the next several decades, countries can adopt a variety of strategies--many of them in social sectors outside the health system--to reduce or mitigate the overall effects of likely long-term care needs.

The impact of hospital management reforms on absenteeism in Costa Rica.

The reduction of high levels of absenteeism among health care workers was one the objectives of the reforms undertaken to improve public hospital performance during the 1990s in Costa Rica. This paper attempts to assess the impact of changes in reimbursement methods and organizational reform on absence rates among health care personnel in Costa Rican public hospitals for the period 1995-2001. Our results show the reforms to have had a negative impact on absenteeism, which increased throughout the considered period. Results further indicate that the policy of not substituting absentee workers, which was introduced through the reforms, did not work as expected in a permissive environment in which peer pressure mechanisms were lacking. In addition, the explicit incentives for workers included in the reforms were retained and used at facility level. There is a pressing need in the future for control and disciplinary mechanisms for health care personnel and for the introduction of absence rates as an explicit goal to be monitored and evaluated.

Provision of ambulatory health services in Poland: a case study from Krakow.

This study provides a comprehensive picture of the organization and delivery of ambulatory health care services in Poland. A main finding of the study is that, following the introduction of health insurance in 1999, the newly introduced Sickness Funds have become the main players in the medical services market, introducing new bidding procedures and contracts for provision of medical services. Contracts, and negotiations which precede them, have introduced elements of market competition, which has affected the number and types of services provided by health care centers operating under a contract. The health financing reforms have led to an even playing field for public and non-public providers, marked by a proliferation of structurally smaller health units. The introduction of a market environment has changed the way in which providers are compensated, with a discernible shift away from salary-based systems to capitation and fee-for-service compensation. The analysis of the provider market for outpatient care underscores the importance of understanding the organization and supply of health services, particularly insofar as it relates to the design of appropriate financial and other incentives for providers of health services and of policy interventions necessary for achieving systemic changes.

Autoimmune hepatitis: a study of 50 patients.

INTRODUCTION: Autoimmune hepatitis (AIH) is a well-defined entity in the West but there are sparse Indian data on this disease. AIM: To study the clinical profile and response to treatment of Indian patients with AIH. METHODS: This is a part retrospective and part prospective study of 50 patients (median age 48 years, range 11-82; 43 women) seen between 1995 to 2001, diagnosed to have AIH as per the revised scoring system. Clinical and laboratory profile, response to treatment, and complications of treatment were analyzed. RESULTS: AIH accounted for 6% of all patients with liver disease seen during the period. The presenting symptoms were gastrointestinal in 43 and non-gastrointestinal in 7, with median symptom duration of 6 months (range 2 weeks to 40 years). Forty patients (80%) had chronic liver disease. Associated illnesses were present in 28 patients. Twenty-six patients were classified as definite and the rest as probable AIH. Forty-nine patients had Type 1 AIH. Five patients had overlap syndrome. Forty-five patients (90%) received immunosuppressive therapy. Twelve of 18 patients receiving only prednisolone and 21 of 27 patients receiving prednisolone and azathioprine combination responded. Thirteen (26%) patients had therapy-related complications (infectious 5, non infectious 8) with two treatment-related deaths. CONCLUSION: Type 1 AIH was the predominant type of AIH. The majority of patients with AIH presented with chronic liver disease. There was good response to immunosuppressive therapy. Therapy-related complications occurred in one-fourth of patients.

Ascites due to pacemaker syndrome.

We describe a 65-year-old man who had had a permanent cardiac pacemaker implanted in 1994 and presented now with ascites. He was investigated for 3 months without finding any cause. He was admitted with a colonic bleed due to a polyp; on cardiac evaluation he was found to have pacemaker syndrome. After adjusting the pacemaker settings his ascites and pleural effusion (which had developed later) disappeared.

Movilización de recursos para el sector salud en Bolivia: documento de trabajo

El principal propósito del presente estudio es presentar un panorama general del financiamiento, producción y prestación de los servicios de salud en Bolivia; analizar el flujo de fondos, con particular énfasis en la contribución de los impuestos, seguros, pagos de los usuarios, cooperación internacional, etc., para financiar los servicios de salud en los últimos 5 a 10; analizar la contribución de diferentes métodos de financiamiento, como impuestos generales, impuestos específicos, seguros sociales, seguros privados, pagos de los usuarios, cooperación internacional; y discutir de casos específicos: el seguro de maternidad y niñez y PROSALUD