Debating the value of spine surgery.

Lumbar arthrodesis is a commonly performed operative procedure for the treatment of low back pain. Recently, total disc arthroplasty has gained some acceptance among surgeons and patients. However, the indications for and results of back pain surgery remain controversial and confusing. Available information suggests that meaningful functional improvement from these procedures is debatable and that the cost of such elective operations is high. Currently, lumbar disc replacement has gained minimal support from governmental and private payers. Among those attending this symposium at the 2009 Annual Meeting of the AOA, the vast majority concurred that Medicare and private insurance should not necessarily pay for disc replacement surgery. Interestingly, among this skeptical group of orthopaedic surgeons, only 23% believed that degeneration of the intervertebral disc is the major cause of low back pain. When asked the hypothetical question, "If you experienced chronic low back pain with degenerative changes at one level, what course of treatment would you opt for?" 61% responded that they would choose nonoperative treatment and 38%, that they would choose no treatment. Of more than 100 respondents, only one responded that he or she would undergo fusion and one admitted a willingness to undergo disc replacement in this hypothetical scenario.

Factors that predict site of outflow target artery anastomosis in infrainguinal revascularization.

INTRODUCTION: Lower extremity revascularization is indicated for limb salvage and incapacitating leg claudication. Many risk factors (age, hypertension, diabetes, tobacco use, dyslipidemia, etc) have been associated with atherosclerosis and the development of peripheral arterial occlusive disease. However, whether these risk factors or the surgical indication (claudication or limb salvage) influences the extent and location of infrainguinal disease and hence the target artery (distal anastomosis) is unclear. This study examines the risk factors and indication for infrainguinal revascularization with respect to the type of bypass performed. METHODS: Three hundred fifty-two infrainguinal revascularizations in 282 patients were retrospectively reviewed. Patient data, including demographics, cardiovascular risk factors, indications, types of revascularization, and perioperative complications and mortality, were collected. Data were analyzed with t test, chi(2) test, Fisher exact test, and multiple logistic regression. RESULTS: The indication for surgical revascularization was claudication in 70 patients and limb salvage in 282. The likelihood of a popliteal anastomosis (above or below knee) versus a tibial or pedal anastomosis was decreased with increasing age (P =.002) and diabetes (P =.0001), and smoking increased the likelihood (P =.056). However, popliteal bypass also was strongly associated with claudication as the surgical indication (odds ratio [OR], 8.7; P =.0001), and 90% of the claudicant group had undergone popliteal anastomosis. Claudication and popliteal anastomosis were both linked to smoking; 97% of subjects who underwent operation for claudication were smokers compared with 75% of subjects who underwent tibial or pedal anastomosis for limb salvage (P =.001). After adjustment for indication, the likelihood of popliteal anastomosis was still decreased with diabetes (OR, 0.46; P =.002), and age had a borderline significant effect (P =.077). When the analysis was stratified by indication for surgery, the likelihood of popliteal bypass among patients who underwent operation for claudication was not influenced by age, diabetes, or smoking. However, within the subset of patients who underwent operation for limb salvage, the likelihood of any popliteal anastomosis was diminished by diabetes (OR, 0.50; P =.007), age (OR, 0.968 per year; P =.01), and chronic renal insufficiency (OR, 0.476; P =.04). CONCLUSION: Infrainguinal peripheral arterial occlusive disease is not a homogenous disease entity. Claudication and limb salvage are associated with two distinct patterns of vascular disease with different risk factors. Patients who undergo operation for claudication are seen at an earlier age, have a high prevalence of smoking, and have proximal disease and a greater likelihood of a popliteal anastomosis. In contrast, patients for limb salvage are less likely to have a popliteal bypass, favoring a more distal target outflow anastomosis that is strongly influenced by advanced age, diabetes, and chronic renal insufficiency.