Exploratory and habituation phenotype of heterozygous and homozygous COMT knockout mice.

Catechol-O-methyltransferase (COMT) inactivates dopamine in prefrontal cortex and is associated clinically with a schizophrenia endophenotype. Using an ethologically based approach, the phenotype of mice with heterozygous COMT deletion was characterised by decreased rearing with increased sifting and chewing. Heterozygous COMT deletion is associated with a distinctive phenotype. This differs from that which we have reported previously for heterozygous deletion of the schizophrenia risk gene neuregulin-1.

Susceptibility genes for schizophrenia: characterisation of mutant mouse models at the level of phenotypic behaviour.

A wealth of evidence indicates that schizophrenia is heritable. However, the genetic mechanisms involved are poorly understood. Furthermore, it may be that genes conferring susceptibility interact with one another and with non-genetic factors to modulate risk status and/or the expression of symptoms. Genome-wide scanning and the mapping of several regions linked with risk for schizophrenia have led to the identification of several putative susceptibility genes including neuregulin-1 (NRG1), dysbindin (DTNBP1), regulator of G-protein signalling 4 (RGS4), catechol-o-methyltransferase (COMT), proline dehydrogenase (PRODH) and disrupted-in-schizophrenia 1 (DISC1). Genetic animal models involving targeted mutation via gene knockout or transgenesis have the potential to inform on the role of a given susceptibility gene on the development and behaviour of the whole organism and on whether disruption of gene function is associated with schizophrenia-related structural and functional deficits. This review focuses on data regarding the behavioural phenotype of mice mutant for schizophrenia susceptibility genes identified by positional candidate analysis and the study of chromosomal abnormalities. We also consider methodological issues that are likely to influence phenotypic effects, as well as the limitations associated with existing molecular techniques.

Potential and limitations of genetic manipulation in animals.

Over the last decade, sequencing and characterisation of the mouse genome has been accompanied by unparalleled advances in functional genomics. In the context of drug action, we analyse the strengths and limitations of classical mutagenesis and gene targeting techniques, as well as alternative approaches such as chemical mutagenesis, gene trap, recombineering, transposon-mediated mutagenesis, chromosomal engineering, viral transgenesis and RNA interference. This review also focuses on the emerging importance of genetic manipulation in other species and related logistical issues of experimental work using mutants.:

D1-like dopamine receptor-mediated function in congenic mutants with D1 vs. D5 receptor "knockout".

Current understanding of the functional roles of individual dopamine D1-like [D1, D5] and D2-like [D2L/s, D3, D4] receptor subtypes remains incomplete. In particular, the lack of pharmacological agonists and antagonists able to distinguish between D1 and D5 receptors means that any differential roles in the regulation of behavior are poorly understood. Mutant mice with targeted gene deletion ("knockout") of individual dopamine receptor subtypes offer an important alternative approach to resolving these functional roles. In congenic D1 mutants examined ethologically, progressive increases in specific topographies of behavior over wildtypes were considerably greater than those in D1 mutants on a mixed genetic background; D1 knockout appears to influence the neuronal substrate(s) of habituation to disrupt sculpture of the changing topography of behavior from initial exploration through to quiescence. Similarly, the D1 receptor appears to regulate specific topographies of orofacial movement in the mouse as these are "sculpted" in a time-dependent manner. Although the well-recognized role of the D1-like family in regulating several aspects of behavioral topography has been assumed to involve primarily D1 receptors, this presumption may require modification to accommodate a subtle but not negligible role for their D5 counterparts as evidenced in the phenotype of congenic D5 mutants.

Comparative phenotypic resolution of spontaneous, D2-like and D1-like agonist-induced orofacial movement topographies in congenic mutants with dopamine D2 vs. D3 receptor "knockout".

Using a novel system, the role of D2-like dopamine receptors in distinct topographies of orofacial movement was assessed in mutant mice with congenic D2 vs. D3 receptor knockout, and compared with findings in D1A mutants. Under spontaneous conditions, D2 mutants evidenced increased vertical jaw movements and unaltered horizontal jaw movements, with reductions in tongue protrusions and incisor chattering; in D3 mutants, only incisor chattering was reduced. Given previous evidence that D1A mutants show reduced horizontal but not vertical jaw movements, this indicates that apparent oppositional D1-like:D2-like interactions in the regulation of composited jaw movements may in fact reflect the independent actions of D2 receptors to inhibit vertical jaw movements and of D1A receptors to facilitate horizontal jaw movements. Effects of the D2-like agonist RU 24213 to exert greater reduction in horizontal than in vertical jaw movements were not altered prominently in either D2 or D3 mutants. The D1-like agonists A 68930 and SK&F 83959 induced vertical jaw movements, tongue protrusions, and incisor chattering; induction of tongue protrusions by A 68930 was reduced in D2 mutants. D2 receptors exert topographically specific regulation of orofacial movements in a manner distinct from their D1A counterparts, while D3 receptors exert only minor regulation of such movements.

Topographical Assessment of Ethological and Dopamine Receptor Agonist-Induced Behavioral Phenotype in Mutants with Congenic DARPP-32 'Knockout'.

Congenic (10 backcrosses into C57BL/6J) mutants with targeted gene deletion of DARPP-32, a neuronal phosphoprotein regarded as an essential mediator of the biological effects of dopamine (DA), were assessed phenotypically using an ethologically based approach that resolves all topographies of behavior in the mouse repertoire. Over initial exploration, female, but not male, DARPP-32 mutants evidenced increased locomotion and decreased grooming, while a decrease in rearing seated was evident in mutants of both genders; continuing assessment over several hours did not reveal additional phenotypic effects. Following challenge with the nonselective DA receptor agonist apomorphine, low doses were associated with reduced levels of sniffing, grooming, total rearing, and rearing seated in DARPP-32 mutants relative to wildtypes; this would suggest some role for DARPP-32 in mediating the biological effects of presynaptic D(2)-like autoreceptor or inhibitory postsynaptic D(2)-like receptor activation. Following challenge with higher doses, while stereotyped sniffing and locomotion with chewing was largely unaltered, the additional murine response of Straub tail was essentially abolished in DARPP-32 mutants, indicating some specific involvement of DARPP-32 in mediating this topography of behavior; additionally, there were overall reductions in levels of sniffing, total rearing, rearing seated, and grooming in DARPP-32 mutants that were unrelated to the dose of apomorphine administered, indicating broader topographical effects following the stress of the injection procedure relative to more naturalistic conditions. The developmental absence of DARPP-32 following targeted gene deletion appears to be associated with compensatory processes that maintain certain topographies of spontaneous and agonist-induced DAergic function, while other topographies remain impaired.

Neurochemical changes in dopamine D1, D3 and D1/D3 receptor knockout mice.

Neurochemical changes were examined in dopamine D1 receptor knockout (D1(-/-)), dopamine D3 receptor knockout (D3(-/-)) and dopamine D1/D3 receptor double knockout (D1(-/-)D3(-/-)) mice. The level of dopamine D1- and D2-like receptors and gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA(A)) receptor was assessed by ligand autoradiography and dopamine D1- and D2 receptor, enkephalin, dynorphin and substance P transcripts measured by in situ hybridization. D1(-/-) mice had normal GABA(A) receptor levels, reduced dynorphin and substance P, and increased enkephalin mRNA and dopamine D2-like binding. D1(-/-)D3(-/-) mice evidenced decreased dynorphin and substance P but normal enkephalin expression, whereas dopamine D2-like and GABA(A) receptor binding were increased. Major changes occur in substance P and dynorphin expression in D1(-/-) mice and these changes are unaffected by loss of dopamine D3 receptors. Upregulated dopamine D2-like binding and enkephalin in D1(-/-) mice may be due to decreased dopamine turnover. Upregulated enkephalin in D1(-/-) mice is dependent on functional dopamine D3 receptors.

Relationship of orofacial movements to behavioural repertoire as assessed topographically over the course of 6-month haloperidol treatment followed by 4-month withdrawal.

RATIONALE: Late-onset vacuous chewing movements (VCMs) arise in a significant proportion of rats treated chronically with conventional antipsychotic drugs. Given their common action to block dopamine D2-like receptors, VCMs may be related to changes in dopaminergic function; if so, other typical dopamine-mediated behaviours might be altered also. OBJECTIVE: To examine this hypothesis, behavioural repertoire was studied topographically over the course of chronic treatment and withdrawal. METHODS: Animals were injected with haloperidol decanoate 28 mg/kg IM, or vehicle, every 3 weeks for 27 weeks, and then maintained without treatment for a further 18 weeks. Immediately before each injection and during withdrawal, VCMs and other topographies of behaviour were assessed. RESULTS: In both control and haloperidol-treated rats, exploratory behaviours declined over the study, indicating habituation effects. Conversely, VCMs emerged after 6 weeks of treatment with haloperidol and persisted after withdrawal; VCM and locomotion were not related, indicating that in treated rats, increased VCMs are not an artifact of reduced locomotion. Treated animals with VCMs evidenced increases in buccal tremor and grooming behaviour relative to those without VCMs, although no clear relationship to the emergence of VCMs was established; there were no material differences in any other topographies of behaviour. CONCLUSION: The effect of long-term treatment with haloperidol to induce VCMs is not reflected in fundamental changes in dopamine-mediated behavioural topography but, rather, appears to affect neural mechanisms involved in orofacial movement preferentially.

Essential conservation of D1 mutant phenotype at the level of individual topographies of behaviour in mice lacking both D1 and D3 dopamine receptors.

RATIONALE: In the absence of agonists and antagonists evidencing appropriate selectivities, individual and interactive properties of D(1) and D(3) dopamine receptors would be illuminated most powerfully by their co-deletion. OBJECTIVES: To define and contrast the behavioural phenotype of D(1)/D(3) double knockout mice in comparison with wild types, and with individual D(1) and D(3 )mutants. METHODS: Behavioural phenotype was characterised using an ethologically based topographical technique. RESULTS: On comparison with wild types, D(1)/D(3) double mutants were characterised topographically as follows: increases in sniffing and locomotion, which evidenced delayed habituation; reductions in rearing free, rearing seated, grooming, chewing and stillness. Though the D(1)/D(3) double mutant ethogram comprised elements of both single mutant D(1) and D(3) lines, this phenotype was largely reflective of the D(1) mutant component. CONCLUSIONS: Distinct patterns of initial exploratory behaviour and of temporal change over subsequent habituation were evident across the three genotypes, with particular conservation of the D(1) phenotype in D(1)/D(3 )double mutants. Under the present conditions, there was little systematic evidence for D(1):D(3) interactions in the regulation of these aspects of behaviour.

Congenic D1A dopamine receptor mutants: ethologically based resolution of behavioural topography indicates genetic background as a determinant of knockout phenotype.

D(1A)-null mice were backcrossed over 14 generations into a C57BL/6 background to result in essential elimination (to <0.005%) of any contribution from the 129/Sv component of their initially mixed (129/SvxC57BL/6) background. Their phenotype was assessed using an ethologically based approach that resolves each individual topography of behaviour in the natural repertoire. Habituation of sniffing, locomotion, rearing seated, and rearing to wall in wild types over several hours was profoundly retarded in congenic D(1A) mutants; conversely, rearing free and sifting were essentially abolished. Resultant increases in individual topographies of behaviour were substantially greater in congenic D(1A) mutants than in those on a mixed background. This phenotype was little altered by the selective D(1)-like antagonist SCH 23390 and could not be blocked by the selective D(2)-like antagonist YM 09151-2. The selective D(1)-like agonist SK&F 83959 could not further elevate those behaviours already heightened in congenic D(1A) mutants, while the induction of stereotyped sniffing and plodding locomotion by the selective D(2)-like agonist RU 24213 was disrupted. Genetic background appears to modulate critically the magnitude but not the general nature of the D(1A)-null phenotype, which may involve compensatory processes independent of other D(1)-like or D(2)-like receptors.

Phenotypic, ethologically based resolution of spontaneous and D(2)-like vs D(1)-like agonist-induced behavioural topography in mice with congenic D(3) dopamine receptor "knockout".

Uncertainty as to the functional role of the D(3) dopamine receptor, due primarily to a paucity of selective agonists or antagonists, is being addressed in mice with targeted gene deletion ("knockout") thereof. This study describes, for the first time, the phenotype of congenic D(3)-null mice. Initially, 129/Sv x C57BL/6 D(3)-null mice were backcrossed 14 times onto C57BL/6; they were then assessed using an ethologically based approach which resolves all topographies of behaviour within the mouse repertoire. The ethogram of D(3)-null mice, on comparison with wildtypes, was characterised by no alteration in any topography of behaviour over an initial period of exploration; subsequent assessment over several hours revealed only increased rearing among females due to delayed habituation. Low doses of the selective D(2)-like agonist RU 24213 (0.016-0.25 mg/kg) inhibited topographies of exploratory behaviour; this effect was diminished in D(3)-null mice only when investigated following prolonged habituation, and then only for certain topographies of behaviour, primarily sniffing and rearing. High doses of RU 24213 (0.1-12.5 mg/kg) induced stereotyped sniffing and "ponderous" locomotion, while the selective D(1)-like agonist SK&F 83959 (0.016-2.0 mg/kg) promoted characteristic grooming syntax; these effects did not differ materially between the genotypes. When examined topographically on an essentially congenic C57BL/6 background (<0.005% 129/Sv), the resultant phenotype indicated essential conservation of the mouse ethogram, high-dose D(2)-like stimulatory effects, and D(1)-like stimulatory effects in the absence of D(3) receptors. A role for D(3) receptors in inhibitory processes appeared topographically circumscribed and only when baseline levels of behaviour were low.