Effects of ecgonine methyl ester on cognition in scopolamine-impaired and aged rats.

RATIONALE: Searches for antidotes to cocaine, and for cognition enhancers potentially applicable to Alzheimer's disease, have revealed a novel regulatory site on nicotinic acetylcholine receptors. In the presence of an agonist, inhibitors binding to this site changed the ion channel equilibrium from the open-channel form towards the closed form. Other, related, molecules could bind to the site without changing the equilibrium. These latter compounds were predicted to displace the inhibitors without affecting receptor function per se. These compounds alleviated the inhibition. One of them is ecgonine methyl ester (EME), which is generally described as inactive, but this work suggested a beneficial effect on cognition. OBJECTIVE: This in vivo study tested for cognitive enhancement by EME in scopolamine-impaired, and aged, rats. METHODS: Memory was the primary endpoint, but thigmotaxis became an important secondary endpoint in the light of observations made during the study. Impaired cognition was pharmacologically induced by scopolamine in young rats, and spontaneously present in aged rats. Learning ability before and after administration of EME was tested in Morris water maze protocols. Concentrations of EME in the brain and plasma were analyzed by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry. RESULTS: A single dose of EME reversed scopolamine impairment, indicating involvement of acetylcholine receptors. Longer-term treatment improved cognition in aged rats, with enhanced rates of learning in the absence of an exogenous cognition-impairing compound. Impairment returned with a new challenge; the improvement could be re-established with continued dosing. EME also reversed thigmotaxis seen in aged rats; thigmotaxis is believed to indicate anxiety. The concentrations of EME in the brain proved adequate drug exposure. CONCLUSIONS: Since other investigators have shown cognition impairment caused by cocaine in aged rats, this work shows that cocaine and EME have opposite effects in Morris water maze models. EME might induce cognitive enhancement and relief of anxiety in cocaine-impaired humans, and in other cognitive disorders.

Scientific Prediction and Prophetic Patenting in Drug Discovery.

Pharmaceutical patenting involves writing claims based on both discoveries already made, and on prophesy of future developments in an ongoing project. This is necessitated by the very different timelines involved in the drug discovery and product development process on the one hand, and successful patenting on the other. If patents are sought too early there is a risk that patent examiners will disallow claims because of lack of enablement. If patenting is delayed, claims are at risk of being denied on the basis of existence of prior art, because the body of relevant known science will have developed significantly while the project was being pursued. This review examines the role of prophetic patenting in relation to the essential predictability of many aspects of drug discovery science, promoting the concepts of discipline-related and project-related prediction. This is especially directed towards patenting activities supporting commercialization of academia-based discoveries, where long project timelines occur, and where experience, and resources to pay for patenting, are limited. The need for improved collaborative understanding among project scientists, technology transfer professionals in, for example, universities, patent attorneys, and patent examiners is emphasized.

Translational science: past, present, and future.

The concept of translational science is at least 15 years old. However, in its most recent incarnation, it represents the identification of a funding category designed to encourage academic participation in a critical stage of the drug discovery and product development process. It is hoped that this will make the process both shorter and more efficient. In this review, the author first considers the historical development of the pharmaceutical R&D process. The place of translational science in the process, the scientific techniques involved, and aspects of the business environment necessary for its success are then considered. Translational science does not displace preclinical development. Both concepts are relevant to the paramount importance of successfully and expeditiously bridging the gap between preclinical science and clinical testing, "from bench to bedside." Translational science is particularly likely to stimulate biomarker research in the universities and related business community and will probably give a modest boost to early clinical testing and commercialization of discoveries within the academic setting. Whether there will be a consequent improvement in the quality and efficiency of the overall process remains to be seen.

Why have so many drugs with stellar results in laboratory stroke models failed in clinical trials? A theory based on allometric relationships.

The failure, in the clinic, of at least fourteen potential neuroprotective agents expected to aid in recovery from stroke, after studies in animal models had predicted that they would be successful, is examined in relation to principles of extrapolation of data from animals to humans. Allometric scaling of glutamate data, especially duration of elevated glutamate levels in CSF and plasma, is used to support a hypothesis that treatment needs to be extended for the time that glutamate is elevated in the individual patient. According to this scenario, trials should be restricted to patients with progressing stroke and associated elevated glutamate levels, and patients without elevated glutamate might show adverse effects of drug treatment if normal levels of glutamate, which may be associated with neuroprotection, are antagonized.