Ischemic mitral valve reconstruction and replacement: comparison of long-term survival and complications.

OBJECTIVE: This study reviews the 223 consecutive mitral valve operations for ischemic mitral insufficiency performed at New York University Medical Center between January 1976 and January 1996. The results for mitral valve reconstruction are compared with those for prosthetic mitral valve replacement. METHODS: From January 1976 to January 1996, 223 patients with ischemic mitral insufficiency underwent mitral valve reconstruction (n = 152) or prosthetic mitral valve replacement (n = 71). Coronary artery bypass grafting was performed in 89% of cases of mitral reconstruction and 80% of cases of prosthetic replacement. In the group undergoing reconstruction, 77% had valvuloplasty with a ring annuloplasty and 23% had valvuloplasty with suture annuloplasty. In the group undergoing prosthetic replacement, 82% of patients received bioprostheses and 18% received mechanical prostheses. RESULTS: Follow-up was 93% complete (median 14.6 mo, range 0-219 mo). Thirty-day mortality was 10% for mitral reconstruction and 20% for prosthetic replacement. The short-term mortality was higher among patients in New York Heart Association functional class IV than among those in classes I to III (odds ratio 5.75, confidence interval 1.25-26.5) and was reduced among patients with angina relative to those without angina (odds ratio 0.26, confidence interval 0.05-1.2). The 30-day death or complication rate was similarly elevated among patients in functional class IV (odds ratio 5.53; confidence interval 1.23-25.04). Patients with mitral valve reconstruction had lower short-term complication or death rates than did patients with prosthetic valve replacement (odds ratio 0.43, confidence interval 0.20-0.90). Eighty-two percent of patients with mitral valve reconstruction had no insufficiency or only trace insufficiency during the long-term follow-up period. Five-year complication-free survivals were 64% (confidence interval 54%-74%) for patients undergoing mitral valve reconstruction and 47% (confidence interval 33%-60%) for patients undergoing prosthetic valve replacement. Results of a series of statistical analyses suggest that outcome was linked primarily to preoperative New York Heart Association functional class. CONCLUSIONS: Initial mortalities were similar among patients undergoing prosthetic replacement and valve reconstruction. Poor outcome was primarily related to preexisting comorbidities. Patients undergoing valve reconstruction had fewer valve-related complications. Valve reconstruction resulted in excellent durability and freedom from complications. These findings suggest that mitral valve reconstruction should be considered for appropriate patients with ischemic mitral insufficiency.

Minimally invasive versus sternotomy approaches for mitral reconstruction: comparison of intermediate-term results.

BACKGROUND: This study compares intermediate-term outcomes of mitral valve reconstruction after either the standard sternotomy approach or the new minimally invasive approach. Although minimally invasive mitral valve operations appear to offer certain advantages, such as reduced postoperative discomfort and decreased postoperative recovery time, the intermediate-term functional and echocardiographic efficacy has not yet been documented. METHODS: From May 1996 to February 1999, 100 consecutive patients underwent primary mitral reconstruction through a minimally invasive right anterior thoracotomy and peripheral cardiopulmonary bypass and Port-Access technology (Heartport, Inc, Redwood City, Calif). Outcomes were compared with those for our previous 100 patients undergoing primary mitral repair who were operated on with the standard sternotomy approach. RESULTS: Although patients were similar in age, the patients undergoing the minimally invasive approach had a lower preoperative New York Heart Association classification (2.1 +/- 0.5 vs 2.6 +/- 0.6, P <.001). There was one (1.0%) hospital mortality with the sternotomy approach and no such case with the minimally invasive approach. Follow-up revealed that residual mitral insufficiency was similar between the minimally invasive and sternotomy approaches (0.79 +/- 0.06 vs 0.77 +/- 0.06, P =.89, 0- to 3-point scale); likewise, the cumulative freedom from reoperation was not significantly different (94.4% vs 96.8%, P =.38). Follow-up New York Heart Association functional class was significantly better in the patients undergoing the minimally invasive approach (1.5 +/- 0.05 vs 1.2 +/- 0.05, P <.01). CONCLUSIONS: These findings demonstrate comparable 1-year follow-up results after minimally invasive mitral valve reconstruction. Both echocardiographic results and New York Heart Association functional improvements were compatible with results achieved with the standard sternotomy approach. The minimally invasive approach for mitral valve reconstruction provides equally durable results with marked advantages for the patient and should be more widely adopted.

Late results of isolated mitral annuloplasty for "functional" ischemic mitral insufficiency.

BACKGROUND: Repair of functional ischemic mitral regurgitation (MR) due to annular deformity and leaflet restriction remains a challenge for the surgeon and lacks well-documented outcomes. We investigated outcomes in the treatment of functional ischemic MR corrected by annuloplasty techniques alone. METHODS: From May 1980 to July 1999, 174 patients underwent repair for functional ischemic mitral insufficiency with annuloplasty alone (128 ring annuloplasty; 46 suture annuloplasty). Acute insufficiency was present in 25 (14.4%). Concomitant procedures included CABG (n = 152; 87.4%). Patients were studied longitudinally with annual follow-up and echocardiograms. RESULTS: Overall hospital mortality was 17.8% and was increased by NYHA Class 4 (23.8% vs. 8.7%; p = 0.011), diabetes (25.0% vs. 13.6%; p = 0.059), and chronic mitral insufficiency (16.4% vs. 8.0%; p = 0.070). Multivariate analysis revealed age (beta = 0.099; p = 0.049) and ejection fraction < 30% (beta = 1.260; p = 0.097) as significant predictors of hospital death. Mean postoperative mitral insufficiency was 0.84 +/- 0.86 (scale of 0-4). NYHA Class 4 (beta = 2.33; p = 0.034) and simple suture annuloplasty (beta = 2.08; p = 0.07) were associated with increased risk of late cardiac death. Cumulative incidence of mitral reoperation was 7.7% at 5 years. At follow-up, 89.7% of patients were in NYHA Class 1 or 2 with 83.4% having none or only mild mitral insufficiency. CONCLUSIONS: Ring annuloplasty is associated with a survival benefit when compared to simple suture repair in ischemic patients who require annuloplasty alone to correct the MR. Mitral reconstruction with a ring annuloplasty offers durable results in this homogeneous subset of functional ischemic MR patients. Ischemic mitral insufficiency is associated with significant late mortality.

Late results of mitral valve reconstruction in the elderly.

BACKGROUND: This study attempts to confirm favorable results with mitral valve reconstruction (MVP) in patients greater than or equal to 70 years of age and to examine complication rates by actual analysis. METHODS: Between June of 1980 and December of 1997, 278 patients 70 years of age or older (mean, 75.2 years; range, 70 to 87 years) underwent MVP for mitral regurgitation. Most involved insertion of an annuloplasty ring. Concomitant procedures were performed in 72.3%, and 55.0% required coronary revascularization. RESULTS: For isolated MVP, the in-hospital mortality rate was 6.5% and 17.0% when combined with coronary revascularization. The mortality rate when combined with another valve procedure was 13.2%. The 5-year freedom from late cardiac death was 100% in the isolated MVP group and 79.7% for MVP with a concomitant procedure (p = 0.006). Complications were analyzed using actual (cumulative incidence) analysis to eliminate the competing risk of noncardiac death. Mean NYHA class improved from 3.32 to 1.71 postoperatively. Repair failure was rare, with a 5-year freedom from reoperation of 91.2%. CONCLUSIONS: These findings confirm the favorable outcome of MVP in elderly patients. Late repair failures are rare; comorbid disease is an important predictor of outcome.

Recent developments and evolving techniques of mitral valve reconstruction.

Experiences with 1,000 patients undergoing mitral valve reconstruction at New York University over the past 18 years are summarized. A continuing follow-up (98% complete) demonstrated that 88% of patients are free from recurrent insufficiency 10 years after the operation. Reconstruction is feasible in nearly 90% of patients with mitral valve prolapse, with an operative mortality near 2%. Accordingly, operation is now recommended at an early stage with the first sign of left ventricular systolic dysfunction, while the patient is still in sinus rhythm. Most operations have been done with the Carpentier techniques of segmental resection with annuloplasty and insertion of a Carpentier ring. Recently, two other repair techniques and a minimally invasive operative approach have been evaluated. A triangular resection of a prolapsing anterior leaflet has been done in more than 100 patients with excellent results. Also, a posterior "folding plasty" has been employed in more than 40 patients with a large redundant posterior leaflet, minimizing the need for annular plication. A minimally invasive approach to the mitral valve has now been employed in 130 patients over the past year, using a right mini-thoracotomy and the Port-Access (Heartport, Inc, Menlo Park, CA) approach. This technique employs catheters introduced through femoral vessels to institute cardiopulmonary bypass and cardioplegic arrest. The operative approach and techniques for mitral valve reconstructive operations continue to evolve, with excellent results and improved patient benefits.

Valve repair versus replacement for mitral insufficiency: when is a mechanical valve still indicated?

OBJECTIVES: Although many advantages of mitral valve reconstruction have been demonstrated, whether specific subgroups of patients exist in whom mechanical valve replacement offers advantages over mitral reconstruction remains undetermined. METHODS: This study examined the late results of mitral valve surgery in patients with mitral insufficiency who received either a St. Jude Medical valve (n = 514) or a mitral valve reconstruction with ring annuloplasty (n = 725) between 1980 and 1996. RESULTS: Overall operative mortality was 7.2% in the patients receiving a St. Jude Medical mitral valve and 5.4% in those undergoing mitral valve reconstruction (no significant difference); isolated mortality was 2.5% in the St. Jude Medical group and 2.2% in the valve reconstruction group (no significant difference). The follow-up interval was more than 5 years for 340 patients with a mean of 39.8 months (98.5% complete). Overall 8-year freedom from late cardiac death, reoperation, and all valve-related complications was 72.8% for the St. Jude Medical group and 64.8% for valve reconstruction group (no significant difference). For patients with isolated, nonrheumatic mitral valve disease, 8-year freedom from late cardiac death and reoperation was better in the mitral valve reconstruction group (88.3%) than in the St. Jude Medical valve group (86.0%; p = 0.05). Furthermore, Cox proportional hazards regression revealed that mitral valve reconstruction was independently associated with a lesser incidence of late cardiac death (p = 0.04), irrespective of preoperative New York Heart Association class. However, the St. Jude Medical valve offered better 8-year freedom from late cardiac death, reoperation, and all valve-related complications than did mitral valve reconstruction in patients with multiple valve disease (77.0% vs 45.3%; p < 0.01). CONCLUSIONS: Therefore, mitral valve reconstruction appears to be the procedure of choice for isolated, nonrheumatic disease, whereas insertion of a St. Jude Medical valve should be preferred for patients with multiple valve disease.

Atrial arrhythmia following a biatrial approach to mitral valve surgery.

The biatrial approach to exposing the mitral valve during surgery has the potential for improving visualization of the valve with minimal cardiac manipulation. This procedure, involving a right atriotomy and an extended transseptal incision, may isolate the sinus node from its normal blood supply and autonomic innervation. Thirty-eight consecutive patients undergoing this procedure were examined. Twenty-two of these patients (58%) were admitted in normal sinus rhythm and 15 (40%) were in atrial fibrillation (AF) or atrial flutter. Of the 22 patients admitted in normal sinus rhythm, only 3 patients remained in this rhythm at discharge. Fourteen of the 22 patients were discharged in a slow, low atrial rhythm. All of the patients admitted in AF were discharged in AF. Of the 14 patients discharged in a low atrial rhythm, the rhythm persisted in eleven patients (80%) at a mean of 6-month follow-up. The routine use of this transseptal approach to mitral valve surgery needs further assessment in light of the predictable loss of the sinus mechanism.

Selective approach to descending thoracic aortic aneurysm repair: a ten-year experience.

BACKGROUND: A variety of surgical techniques has been developed to attempt to minimize the risk of paraplegia after descending thoracic aortic aneurysm repair. This study reviews our institutional experience with several basic techniques over a period of 10 years. METHODS: Seventy-eight consecutive patients underwent repair of descending thoracic aortic aneurysm between 1983 and 1993. Two basic repair strategies were used: (1) distal perfusion with somatosensory evoked potential monitoring (n = 54) and (2) cross-clamping (n = 24), alone (n = 6) or with controlled distal exsanguination (n = 18). RESULTS: The operative mortality rate was 6.5% for elective repair (n = 62), 25.0% for emergent repair (n = 16), and 10.3% overall. Univariate predictors of increased operative risk were emergent operation, rupture, and shock. Neither death nor paraplegia was related to the operative technique used. The incidence of paraplegia was 3.7% in perfused patients and 4.2% in cross-clamping patients (p > 0.05). Paraplegia did not occur after any elective operation (zero of 62) but occurred in 18.6% of emergent cases (p < 0.01). In perfused patients, paraplegia did not occur when the distal pressure was maintained above 55 mm Hg and somatosensory evoked potentials remained intact. When somatosensory evoked potentials were lost (n = 7) in perfused patients, the operative technique was altered successfully in 5 patients, whereas in 2 patients (28.6%), paraplegia developed. CONCLUSIONS: The risks associated with elective descending thoracic aortic aneurysm repair were extremely low using an operative strategy that was flexible but skewed toward perfusion with somatosensory evoked potential monitoring. In perfused patients, paraplegia did not occur when distal pressure was greater than 55 mm Hg and somatosensory evoked potentials remained intact. However, the risks of death and paraplegia were primarily related to emergent presentation, not to technique, and the technique of cross clamping with controlled distal exsanguination was found to be valuable in unstable or in anatomically complicated subsets of patients.

Endoventricular remodeling of left ventricular aneurysm. Functional, clinical, and electrophysiological results.

BACKGROUND: Recent advances in surgical techniques for the repair of left ventricular aneurysms (LVAs) include the use of an endoventricular patch to exclude the aneurysm cavity. This technique has replaced conventional linear plication of the aneurysm. The endoventricular patch technique remodels the left ventricular cavity to a more physiological geometry that improves function. METHODS AND RESULTS: From December 1989 through November 1993, 45 patients underwent an LVA repair with an endoventricular patch. This procedure was performed in association with coronary artery bypass grafting in 40 patients. Twenty-eight patients (62.2%) also had nonguided encircling subendocardial incisions. Operative procedures included 7 emergency operations, 3 concomitant valve procedures, and a mean of 2.2 bypass grafts per patient. Eight patients had previous cardiac operations. Hospital mortality was 15.6% (7/45) for all patients and 9.1% (3/33) for nonemergent revascularization and LVA repairs. Ejection fraction improved from a mean of 25.8% preoperatively to 37.8% postoperatively; the mean New York Heart Association classification improved from 3.5 to 1.5. Of patients known to have preoperative arrhythmias (inducible or sudden death), 69% were not inducible postoperatively without antiarrhythmic medication. Survival from late cardiac death (including death of unknown origin) was 86.5% at 2 years. Freedom from documented ventricular arrhythmias was 94.3% at 2 years. CONCLUSIONS: These results indicate that the patch endoaneurysmorrhaphy technique can provide an excellent functional and physiological outcome in patients with LVAs and severely impaired ventricular function.

Anterior leaflet procedures during mitral valve repair do not adversely influence long-term outcome.

OBJECTIVES: This study was done to assess the impact of anterior mitral leaflet reconstructive procedures on initial and long-term results of mitral valve repair. BACKGROUND: It has been suggested that involvement of the anterior leaflet in mitral valve disease adversely affects the long-term outcome of mitral valve repair. Our policy has been to aggressively repair such anterior leaflets with procedures that include triangular resections in some cases. METHODS: From June 1979 through June 1993, 558 consecutive Carpentier-type mitral valve repairs were performed. The anterior mitral leaflet and chordae tendineae were repaired in 156 patients (mean age 58 years). The procedures included anterior chordal shortening in 78 patients (50%), anterior leaflet resections in 44 (28%), resuspension of the anterior leaflet to secondary chordae in 42 (27%) and anterior chordal transposition in 27 (17%). Concomitant cardiac surgical procedures were performed in 75 patients (48%). RESULTS: The operative mortality rate was 2.5% (2 of 81) for isolated mitral valve anterior leaflet repair and 3.8% (6 of 156) for all mitral valve anterior leaflet repair. Freedom from reoperation at 5 and 10 years was, respectively, 89.7% (n = 160) and 83.4% (n = 24) for the entire series of 558 patients, 91.9% (n = 51) and 81.2% (n = 10) for patients with anterior leaflet procedures, 88.8% (n = 109) and 84.4% (n = 14) for patients without anterior leaflet procedures and 91.7% (n = 118) and 88.9% (n = 18) for patients without rheumatic disease. Logistic regression showed that rheumatic origin of disease (odds ratio 2.99), but not anterior leaflet repair, increased the risk for reoperation. CONCLUSIONS: These results demonstrate that expansion of mitral valve techniques to include anterior leaflet disease yields immediate and long-term results equal to those seen in patients with posterior leaflet disease.

Severe calcification does not affect long-term outcome of mitral valve repair.

Some surgeons have suggested that the presence of severe calcification in the mitral valve annulus or leaflets precludes successful repair. Our institution has attempted to repair these calcified valves when good annular and leaflet mobility could be achieved by annular debridement and leaflet resection. From June 1979 through June 1993 558 mitral valve repairs were performed using Carpentier's techniques. When calcified valves were encountered, these techniques were modified to include annular debridement and mechanical leaflet decalcification. Calcification was identified preoperatively in 49 patients (8.8%) by either left ventricular fluoroscopy or echocardiography and was debrided in 64 patients (11.5%). This included 24 annular debridements, 28 leaflet debridements, and 12 annular and leaflet debridements. Patient ages ranged from 13 to 83 years (mean age, 62.3 years), and 25 patients (39.1%, 25/64) had concomitant cardiac procedures. Operative mortality was 6.2% (4/64) overall and 2.6% (1/39) for isolated mitral valve repairs. Calcium debridement was performed in 19.3% (23/119) of patients with a rheumatic cause compared with 9.3% (41/439) of the nonrheumatic patients (p < 0.01). Long-term follow-up revealed the necessity for reoperation in 7.8% (5/64) in patients with calcium debridement as compared with 7.7% (38/494) with no debridement (p = not significant). Cumulative freedom from reoperation at 10 years was 83.3% for all patients, 88.1% for debrided patients, and 82.6% for nondebrided patients (p = not significant). Cox proportional hazards analysis revealed that the presence of rheumatic disease significantly increased the risk of reoperation (odds ratio = 3.28; p < 0.001), whereas calcium debridement had no significant effect. These results demonstrate that when good annulus and leaflet motion can be achieved in calcified mitral valves, calcium debridement allows durable repairs.