Scoping Review of Existing Evaluations of Smokeless Tobacco Control Policies: What Is Known About Countries Covered, Level of Jurisdictions, Target Groups Studied, and Instruments Evaluated?

OBJECTIVE: The implementation of smokeless tobacco control policies lags behind those for smoking. This scoping review summarizes the studies that evaluated public policies on smokeless tobacco regulation (SLT) and provides an overview of the jurisdictional level, target groups, and policy instruments. METHODS: Seven databases were systematically searched for studies reporting on public policies regulating SLT. Two reviewers independently screened all studies. Data extraction was performed using a predefined extraction form. Extraction was replicated for 10% of the identified studies for quality assurance. A narrative synthesis of the included studies was used to analyze and interpret the data. The protocol was published beforehand with the Open Science Foundation (OSF). RESULTS: Fourty articles comprising 41 studies were included. Most of the studies reported in the articles were conducted in the United States (n = 17) or India (n = 14). Most studies reported outcomes for students (n = 8), retailers/sellers (n = 8), and users/former users (n = 5). The impact of public policies on smokeless tobacco use, in general, was most frequently assessed (n = 9), followed by the impact of taxes (n = 7), product bans (n = 6), sales/advertising bans near educational institutions (n = 4), and health warnings (n = 3) on consumer behavior. CONCLUSIONS: There are significant gaps in the evaluation of smokeless tobacco regulation studies that need to be filled by further research to understand the observed outcomes. WHO reporting on Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC) implementation should be linked to studies evaluating smokeless tobacco control measures at all levels of jurisdictions and in countries not members of the WHO FCTC or do not provide data. IMPLICATION: Large gaps in the evaluation of SLT control policies exist. For some countries, WHO FCTC evaluations are available for different levels of jurisdictions. In countries with a strong federal structure, there is a lack of data beyond the national level to provide a more detailed look at compliance, indirect effects, or implementation gaps. More research is needed at all levels of jurisdictions, which add to the work of the WHO to understand what works for which target group, how the different levels of jurisdiction interact, how the real-world context can be incorporated, and what indirect effects may occur.

Predictors of cessation in smokers suspected of TB: Secondary analysis of data from a cluster randomized controlled trial.

BACKGROUND: Smoking cessation services are rarely found within health services in low income countries. Given the interactions between Tuberculosis (TB) and tobacco, including cessation support within TB programs offers a promising cost-effective solution. We conducted secondary analysis of data from a cluster randomized controlled trial of smoking cessation in health centers in Pakistan to identify predictors of continuous and short-term abstinence in smokers suspected of TB using cigarettes or hookah. METHODS: Predictor variables of those continuously abstinent at 5 and 25 weeks post quit-date (continuous abstinence) and those abstinent only at 5 weeks (short-term abstinence) were compared with those who continued smoking and with each other. Self-reported abstinence at both time points was confirmed biochemically. RESULTS: Data obtained from 1955 trial participants were analyzed. The factors that predicted continued smoking when compared to continuous abstinence were: being older RR 0.97 (0.95 to 0.98), smoking higher quantities of tobacco RR 0.975 (0.97 to 0.98) and sharing a workplace with other smokers RR 0.88 (0.77 to 0.99). Those with a confirmed TB diagnosis were more likely to remain continuously abstinent than those without RR 1.27 (1.10-1.47). CONCLUSIONS: Those diagnosed with TB are more likely to be abstinent than those diagnosed with other respiratory conditions. Beyond this, predictors of continued smoking in Pakistan are similar to those in high income contexts. Taking advantage of the 'teachable moment' that a TB diagnosis provides is an efficient means for resource-poor TB programs in low income settings to increase tobacco cessation and improve health outcomes.

Second-hand smoke and the risk of tuberculosis: a systematic review and a meta-analysis.

There is limited evidence and lack of consensus whether second-hand smoke (SHS) increases risk of tuberculosis (TB), which has substantial implications for unrestricted smoking indoors and TB control policies. We aimed to establish the association between SHS and the risk of acquiring and worsening of TB in non-smokers. We identified 428 articles in the initial search and 12 comparative epidemiological studies met our inclusion criteria. Exposure to SHS was found to have a higher risk of TB infection [risk ratio (RR) 1·19, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0·90-1·57] compared to non-exposure; however, this did not reach statistical significance. There was marked variability (I 2 = 74%, P = 0·0008) between studies' results, which could be explained by the differences in the diagnostic criteria used. Exposure to SHS was found to be statistically significantly associated (RR 1·59, 95% CI 1·11-2·27) with the risk of TB disease. There was significant heterogeneity (I 2 = 77%, P = 0·0006) between studies' results, which was sourced to the internal characteristics of the studies rather than combining different study designs. We did not find any studies for SHS and TB treatment-related outcomes. Thus, we conclude that SHS exposure may increase the risk of acquiring TB infection and progression to TB disease; however, the evidence remains scanty and weak.

Tuberculosis in women from Pashtun region: an ecological study in Pakistan.

SUMMARY In general, tuberculosis (TB) is more common in men than women. However, for reasons currently not understood, women are 1.5-2 times more likely to report TB compared to men in Pashtun region (Afghanistan, adjacent provinces Pakistan and Iran). We explored whether or not gender disparity in TB notifications in the Pashtun region of Pakistan can be explained by Pashtun ethnicity. Using an ecological linear regression design, we estimated the effect of Pashtun ethnicity on female-to-male ratio (FMR) in TB notifications after adjusting for other determinants of women's health, in Pakistan. Districts with a high proportion of women of Pashtun ethnicity had a 44% (95% confidence interval 27-61) increase in FMR of notified TB cases compared to those with low proportions, after controlling for confounders. Genetic predisposition and distinct socio-cultural determinants could be possible causative factors. However, these hypotheses need further evaluation through rigorous longitudinal studies.

Xpert(®) MTB/RIF under routine conditions in diagnosing pulmonary tuberculosis: a study in two hospitals in Pakistan.

Xpert(®) MTB/RIF testing was offered to consecutive patients with presumptive tuberculosis (TB) attending two hospitals in Pakistan during April-May 2012, in addition to routine diagnostic protocol (smear microscopy, chest radiography and clinical judgement). We assessed the relative contribution of each tool in detecting pulmonary TB under routine conditions. Of 606 participants, 121 (20%) were detected as pulmonary TB: 46 (38%) by microscopy, 38 (31%) by Xpert alone and 37 (31%) on clinical and radiological grounds; 41 (65%) were detected by both Xpert and microscopy. One patient had rifampicin resistance. Although Xpert detected approximately twice as many TB cases as microscopy (n = 79, 65%), clinical judgement remained favoured by clinicians even when smear and Xpert were negative.

En plus d'un protocole de diagnostic de routine (examen microscopique des frottis, cliché thoracique et évaluation clinique), on a offert Xpert® MTB/RIF à des patients consécutifs suspects de tuberculose (TB) qui présentaient à deux hôpitaux du Pakistan au cours de la période avril­mai 2012. Nous avons évalué la contribution relative de chaque outil à la détection de la TB pulmonaire dans les conditions de routine. Sur 606 participants, 121 (20%) ont été diagnostiqués comme TB pulmonaire : 46 (38%) par l'examen microscopique, 38 (31%) par Xpert seul, et 37 (31%) sur une base clinique et radiologique ; 41 (65%) ont été détectés par l'examen microscopique et Xpert. Chez un patient, on a trouvé une résistance à la rifampicine. Quoique l'Xpert ait détecté approximativement deux fois le nombre de cas de TB détectés par l'examen microscopique (n = 79, 65%), le jugement clinique reste favorisé par les cliniciens, même lorsque le résultat du frottis et de l'Xpert est négatif.

En dos hospitales de Paquistán se propuso a un grupo de pacientes con presunción de tuberculosis (TB) que acudieron de manera consecutiva entre abril y mayo del 2012 la prueba Xpert® MTB/RIF, además del protocolo diagnóstico corriente (que comportaba la baciloscopia, la radiografía de tórax y la evaluación clínica). Se analizó la contribución relativa de cada instrumento en el diagnóstico de la TB pulmonar en las condiciones corrientes. De los 606 participantes, en 121 (20%) se estableció el diagnóstico de TB pulmonar de la siguiente manera: en 46 casos (38%) por microscopia, en 38 (31%) mediante la prueba Xpert sola y en 37 casos (31%) con base en las características clínicas y radiográficas; 41 (65%) fueron detectados por microscopia y Xpert. Un paciente exhibió resistencia a rifampicina. Si bien la prueba Xpert permitió el diagnóstico de cerca del doble de casos de tuberculosis que la baciloscopia (n = 79, 65%), el juicio clínico predomina aun en la decisión de los médicos, incluso frente a un resultado negativo de la baciloscopia y la prueba Xpert.