Pregnancy, antiseizure medications and unexplained intrauterine foetal death.

OBJECTIVE: To assess the role of antiseizure medication (ASM) regimens and other factors in relation to the occurrence of intrauterine foetal death (IUFD) in pregnant women with epilepsy (WWE) enrolled in the Raoul Wallenberg Australian Pregnancy Register of Antiepileptic Drugs (APR). RESULTS: IUFDs occurred in 70 (3.01 %) of 2,323 prospective pregnancies from WWE with known outcomes in the APR. Factors associated with IUFD occurrence included older maternal age, enrolment in the APR at an earlier stage of pregnancy, history of pregnancies which did not result in livebirths, parental history of foetal malformations, and maternal use of carbamazepine, lamotrigine or ethosuximide. Individual ASM dosages were not associated with IUFD occurrence. Relative to no exposure, the risk of IUFD increased with the increasing number of ASMs used in combination (2 ASMs: relative risk, RR = 5.45 [95 % CI: 0.73-41.80]; 3 ASMs: RR = 10.70 [95 % CI: 1.27-90.17]), >3 ASMs: RR = 10.70 [95 % CI: 1.27-90.17]), but this finding was attenuated after adjusting for other factors implicated in IUFD occurrence. Several ASM pairs were associated with an increased risk of IUFD relative to no exposure, but these associations were lost after accounting for confounders. CONCLUSIONS: Although it is possible that prenatal ASM exposure may increase the risk of IUFD, other non-pharmacological factors are more relevant to the occurrence to IUFD in pregnant WWE.

Teratogenicity of zonisamide and other little-used antiseizure medications.

PURPOSE: To investigate the risk of teratogenesis occurring in relation to intrauterine exposure to infrequently used antiseizure medications in Australia. METHODS: Analysis of data contained in the Raoul Wallenberg Australian Pregnancy Register of Antiepileptic Drugs. RESULTS: There was statistically significant evidence that zonisamide, but not any other of nine infrequently used antiseizure medications in Australia, was associated with a risk of teratogenesis related to the maternal dose of the drug taken in at least the earlier half of pregnancy. CONCLUSIONS: The teratogenesis associated with zonisamide, like that associated with topiramate and possibly acetazolamide, may be an expression of a class effect shared among sulphonamide-derived carbonic anhydrase inhibitors that possess anti-seizure activity.

The teratogenesis risk associated with antiseizure medication duotherapy in women with epilepsy.

PURPOSE: To investigate rates of occurrence of pregnancies associated with a foetal malformation (FM pregnancy rates) following simultaneous intrauterine exposure to two antiseizure medications in 524 pregnancies in women with epilepsy from the Australian Pregnancy Register who were treated simultaneously with various combinations and dosages of two antiseizure medications (duotherapy). RESULTS: FM pregnancy rates tended to be higher in those exposed simultaneously to two antiseizure medications, each of which was a statistically significant teratogen (valproate, topiramate, or carbamazepine), than when there was exposure to only one such teratogen. When there was exposure to only one such teratogen together with clonazepam or levetiracetam, for neither of which there was statistically significant evidence of heightened teratogenicity, the FM pregnancy rates also tended to be higher, but less so. When lamotrigine was the other component of the duotherapy with an established teratogen, FM pregnancy rates tended to be lower than that for the teratogen used as monotherapy. CONCLUSION: Leaving aside issues in relation to seizure control, our data suggest that it would be best to avoid using established teratogenic antiseizure medications (carbamazepine, valproate and topiramate) in combination with each other due to the increased FM risks. When combining an established teratogenic medication with a less teratogenic one, i.e. lamotrigine, levetiracetam or clonazepam, lamotrigine appears to be the safer option.

W. J. Adie and his "pyknolepsy," a century ago.

On November 8, 1923, William John Adie described an unusual disorder to the Section of Neurology of the Royal Society of Medicine. The condition comprised frequent momentary stereotyped impairments of consciousness that occurred in children, did not respond to antiseizure medications, and did not develop into epilepsy, as that term was then commonly understood, since no convulsive seizures occurred. After some time, the episodes terminated spontaneously, leaving the sufferer unhandicapped and neurologically intact. Almost certainly, Adie had described the present-day entity of childhood absence epilepsy. He termed it "pyknolepsy," knowing that the name "pyknolepsie" had been used for a similar disorder in Germany from 1916 onwards, though not reported elsewhere. Following Adie's account, published in 1924, reports of the disorder appeared in the English and French-language literature and continued to be published in German. It became increasingly accepted that pyknolepsy was a form of epilepsy that was part of Lennox's petit mal triad. The word pyknolepsy itself never became widely used and is now largely forgotten. Adie never took up the topic in print again. However, he had awakened English-language readers to one component in a broadening of the concept of what constituted epilepsy.

Economic Evaluation of the Community Benefit of the Australian Pregnancy Register of Antiseizure Medications.

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: The Raoul Wallenberg Australian Pregnancy Register (APR) was established to collect, analyze, and publish data on the risks to babies exposed to antiseizure medications (ASMs) and to facilitate quality improvements in management care over time. It is one of the seveal prospective observational pregnancy registers of ASMs that has been established around the world. Although the APR and other registries have contributed to knowledge gain that has been applied to decrease adverse pregnancy outcomes, their cost-effectiveness remains unknown. Here, we aimed to evaluate the economic impacts of the APR from both societal and health care system perspectives. METHODS: Using decision analytic modeling, we estimated the effectiveness (prevention of adverse pregnancy outcomes) and costs (costs of adverse pregnancy outcomes and the register itself) of the APR over a 20-year time horizon (2000-2019). The comparator was set as the adverse pregnancy outcomes collected by the APR between 1998 and 2002 (i.e., no APR derived improvements in care). In the scenario analysis, we conservatively assumed a 2.5% and 5% contribution of the APR to the savings in health care and societal costs. Adverse pregnancy outcomes included stillbirth, birth defects, and induced abortion. All cost data were derived from published sources. Health and economic outcomes were extrapolated to the total target Australian epilepsy population. The primary outcomes of interest were the return of investment (ROI) for the APR and incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) for cost per adverse outcome avoided. RESULTS: Over the 20-year time horizon, the ROI from the APR from a societal perspective was Australian dollars (AUD) 2,250 (i.e., every dollar spent on the program resulted in a return of AUD2,250). Over this time, it was estimated that 9,609 adverse pregnancy outcomes were avoided, and health care and societal costs were reduced by AUD 191 million and AUD 9.0 billion, respectively. Hence, from a health economic point of view, the APR was dominant, providing cost saving ICERs from both perspectives. DISCUSSION: Following its inception 20+ years ago, the APR has represented excellent value for investment for Australia, being also health-saving and cost saving from a societal and a health care perspective. With the growing number of marketed ASMs, the APR is expected to continue to have a major impact in the foreseeable future.

Seizure control in successive pregnancies in Australian women with epilepsy.

OBJECTIVES: To investigate control of epileptic seizures during pairs of successive pregnancies in antiseizure medication (ASM)-treated women with epilepsy. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Analysis of seizure freedom rates during 436 pairs of successive pregnancies in Australian women with epilepsy, in nearly all instances long-standing epilepsy. RESULT: There was a higher rate of seizure-free second pregnancies compared with first paired pregnancies (63.1% vs. 51.4%; Relative Risk (R.R.) = 1.2277; 95% CI 1.0930, 1.3789) and of seizure-free pre-pregnancy years before second as compared with first paired pregnancies in the same women (63.6% vs. 52.4%; R.R. = 1.2616; 95% CI 1.1337, 1.4040). In 108 women whose ASM therapy was unaltered throughout both of their pregnancies, the seizure-freedom rate was higher in the second of the paired pregnancies (82.4% vs. 69.4%; R.R. = 1.1867, 95% CI 1.0189, 1.3821). CONCLUSIONS: Altered ASM therapy after the first of a pair of successive pregnancies did not fully account for the better overall seizure control in the corresponding second pregnancies. Some additional factor may have been in operation, possibly a greater preparedness to undertake a further pregnancy if seizures were already fully controlled.

E. H. Sieveking and his cephalalgia epileptica.

Edward Henry Sieveking (1816-1904) was a professionally successful and well respected nineteenth-century London physician who, over the span of some half a century, continuously held appointment to British royalty, including Queen Victoria and King Edward VII. In 1858, he published a monograph On Epilepsy and Epileptiform Seizures, with a second edition in 1861. In both editions, he described an entity cephalalgia epileptica that comprised the occurrence of headache in association with phenomena that resembled the premonitory symptom of some epileptic seizures. However, the sufferers did not have epilepsy, in that they did not experience generalized convulsions. Sieveking, like most of his British contemporaries, had little awareness of the existence of the variety of migraine phenomena apart from headache itself. In retrospect, it seems likely that migraine with aura probably was the main basis of the disorder Sieveking designated, one that later may have been termed migralepsy.

Epileptic seizure control during and after pregnancy in Australian women.

OBJECTIVES: To study factors that affected previous epileptic seizure control throughout pregnancy, during labour, and in the post-natal weeks. MATERIALS & METHODS: Analysis of data concerning seizure freedom that was available at various stages of 2337 pregnancies in the Raoul Wallenberg Australian Pregnancy Register of Antiepileptic Drugs, mainly employing multiple variable logistic regression techniques. RESULTS: Based on data available at the outset of pregnancy, the risk of seizure-affected that is, not seizure-free pregnancy was statistically significantly (p < .05) higher in pregnancies where there was previously uncontrolled epilepsy (78.1% vs. 20.8%) and focal epilepsy (51.3% vs. 39.7%), and decreased with later onset-age epilepsy (41.8% vs. 52.2% with onset before age 13 years), The risk did not differ between initially antiseizure medication (ASM)-treated or untreated pregnancies. For epilepsy receiving ASM therapy, 90.6% of 160 pregnancies of women with uncontrolled focal epilepsy that began before the age of 13 were seizure-affected. None of the above factors influenced the risk of seizures during labour, though having seizures during pregnancy increased the hazard (3.93 vs. 0.6%). Either ASM-treated pregnancy or labour being seizure-affected increased the risk of post-partum period seizures (33.0% vs. 6.67% for both stages being seizure-free). Use of particular ASMs had no statistically significant effect on the seizure control situation at any of the pregnancy stages studied. CONCLUSIONS: Obtaining full seizure control before pregnancy appeared to be the main factor in maintaining seizure freedom during pregnancy, labour and the post-natal weeks.

Achieving neurologically desirable outcomes to pregnancy in women with epilepsy.

OBJECTIVES: To investigate possible factors that influenced whether pregnancy in women with epilepsy resulted in the desirable outcome of a live-born non-malformed infant and a mother whose pregnancy had been seizure free. RESULTS: The desirable outcome, as defined, occurred in 46.3% of unselected pregnancies in the database of the Australian Register of Antiepileptic Drugs in Pregnancy (APR). The only factor investigated that had a statistically significant (P < 0.05) effect, increasing the chance of such a desirable outcome, was freedom from seizures in the pre-pregnancy year. However, anti-seizure medication (ASM) doses, particularly valproate doses, had been reduced prior to 15.6% of the pregnancies, and this may have concealed factors that otherwise may have adversely affected the desirable outcome rate. Analysis of data for monotherapy with the more commonly used ASMs appears to suggest that employing levetiracetam at the outset of antiseizure therapy may offer a better chance of a desirable outcome to future pregnancies than monotherapy with other ASMs, but this finding is not confirmed statistically. CONCLUSIONS: In pregnancies where valproate use has already been minimized, seizure control throughout the pre-pregnancy year was associated with the best chance of a desirable outcome, as defined above. In most Australian women starting therapy for epilepsy initiating treatment with levetiracetam monotherapy may offer the best chance of such a desirable outcome to a future pregnancy, yet to be confirmed.

The control of treated generalized and focal epilepsies during pregnancy.

OBJECTIVES: To examine factors contributing to failure to achieve full seizure control during pregnancy in women with anti-seizure medication (ASM) treated generalized epilepsy compared with focal epilepsy. RESULTS: Full seizure control was not attained in 51.4% of 1223 pregnancies of women with focal epilepsies in the Australian Pregnancy Register, and in 38.7% of 1026 pregnancies in women with generalized epilepsy (P < 0.05). For convulsive seizures only, the corresponding figures of 20.8% and 22.9% were reasonably similar. Where seizures had occurred in the pre-pregnancy year, 82.5% of the focal epilepsy pregnancies were seizure affected, and 70.1% of the generalized epilepsy ones (P < 0.05). Where the pre-pregnancy year was seizure free, the corresponding figures were 22.6% and 16.4% (P < 0.05), a roughly four-fold lower rate. Maternal age, epilepsy onset age, and epilepsy duration also differed between the focal and generalized epilepsy pregnancies. Multivariate regression analysis showed that generalized epilepsy and younger maternal age were associated with statistically significant decreased risks of seizure-affected pregnancy, and having seizure-affected pre-pregnancy years with an increased risk. However, for convulsive seizures only, the risk of seizure-affected pregnancy appeared increased in generalized epilepsy. CONCLUSIONS: The risk of seizure-affected pregnancy appears lower in women with generalized epilepsy, independently of pre-pregnancy seizure control, itself a major determinant of the risk. The risk of having only convulsive seizures in pregnancy was not lower in generalized epilepsy than in focal epilepsy. ASM therapy seemed less effective in controlling focal than generalized epileptic seizures during pregnancy.

Pregnancy outcomes in women with surgically treated epilepsy.

OBJECTIVE: To ascertain whether epileptic seizure control during pregnancy differed between Australian women with previously surgically treated epilepsy, and those with only medically treated epilepsy. MATERIALS/METHODS: Analysis of data for 74 pregnancies of women with surgically treated focal epilepsy, compared with that from 1013 pregnancies in women with medically treated focal epilepsy, both groups drawn from the Australian Register of Antiepileptic Drugs in Pregnancy between 1999 and 2020. RESULTS: Seizures of all types, and also convulsive seizures, were less well controlled during pregnancy in the previously surgically treated cases, the difference for seizures of all types (68.9% versus 50.1%) being statistically significant (p < .05). This result was contrary to the outcome of a previously published study of the same question carried out in India. CONCLUSIONS: At present, it may be premature to conclude that previous epilepsy surgery will be associated with a better chance of seizure-free, or seizure-controlled, pregnancy.

Pregnancy and the Control of Epileptic Seizures: A Review.

Over the past 50 years, published studies have provided quantitative data on the control of epileptic seizures during pregnancy. The studies have varied in quality, and particularly in the ways in which seizure control has been assessed. However, most studies have shown that seizure occurrence rates are more likely to worsen than improve during pregnancy, though in most pregnancies the rates have been unaltered. Nearly all of the studies have involved women with antiseizure medication-treated epilepsy, but there is a little evidence that seizure control also tends to worsen in pregnancies of women with untreated epilepsy. The factors likely to contribute to the seizure worsening are (i) patient non-compliance, (ii) increased antiseizure medication clearance during pregnancy resulting in lower circulating drug concentrations relative to dose, (iii) the effects of the higher female sex hormone levels during pregnancy, oestrogens being pro-epileptogenic and progesterone anti-epileptogenic, and (iv) reluctance to use the potential teratogen valproate in women capable of pregnancy, depriving them of the most effective drug for certain types of epilepsy. Compliance can be encouraged, but at the present time only one other factor is readily correctable, i.e. the increased drug clearance. This can be compensated for by raising antiseizure medication dosage during pregnancy, guided by measurement of circulating drug concentrations. This course of action appears to reduce the chance of seizure disorder worsening during pregnancy, but so far it has not provided a complete solution to the issue.

The contribution of non-drug factors to fetal malformation in anti-seizure-medication-treated pregnancy.

PURPOSE: To assess the possible contribution of factors in additional to intrauterine anti-seizure medication (ASM) exposure in the occurrence of fetal malformation in women with ASM-treated epilepsy. RESULTS: Logistic regression analysis showed that maternal age over 31 years, family histories of fetal malformation, and conception after assisted fertility treatment, and also dosage of valproate, carbamazepine, and topiramate, made statistically significant (P<0.05) contributions to the fetal malformation rate in 2223 pregnancies in Australian women with epilepsy. The malformation rates were lower in pregnancies where the non-ASM-associated contributory factors were not present: statistically significantly so for all ASM-exposed pregnancies, and those pregnancies exposed to the more potent teratogenic drugs. CONCLUSION: It is important to consider the possible roles of identified, and also possible non-identified, non-ASM factors in relation to the occurrence of fetal malformations in the pregnancies of women with ASM-treated epilepsy.

Disease modifying therapies for relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis: Use and costs in Australia (1996-2019).

BACKGROUND: New disease modifying therapies (DMT) to control relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis (RRMS) have been introduced to the market in the past few years and are now widely used in Australia. OBJECTIVE: To analyse the dispensed use of government subsidised RRMS DMTs in Australia from 1996 to 2019. METHODS: We obtained data of dispensed use of DMTs from the Australian Government's Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme (PBS) administered by Medicare Australia. We measured use as defined daily dose (DDD) per 100,000 population per day. We obtained jurisdictional population data from the Australian Bureau of Statistics. RESULTS: Total DMT use increased by an average of 18% annually, from 2.4 (in 1996) to 69.9 DDD/100,000/day in 2019. Interferon ß1B was the most commonly used medicine between 1996 and 2000, Interferon ß1A between 2001 and 2014, and fingolimod subsequently. Among Australian states, Tasmania (the southernmost state) had the highest dispensed DMT use of 94.6 DDD/100,000/day in 2019. Concession beneficiaries under the Government's PBS had both lower use and cost per patient than general beneficiaries did. Fingolimod and ocrelizumab accounted for 55% of total expenditure on MS drug therapy in 2019. CONCLUSION: The use of oral DMTs might increasingly replace parenteral treatments in the near future. Given the current substantial government expenditure on oral DMTs, it will be imperative to examine the real world effectiveness of DMTs.

Folic acid dose, valproate, and fetal malformations.

OBJECTIVE: To determine whether there is a relationship between folic acid dose and the degree of protection against valproate-associated and other antiepileptic drug (AED)-associated fetal structural malformations in women with AED-treated epilepsy. METHODS: Statistical analysis of data from the Raoul Wallenberg Australian Register of Antiepileptic Drugs in Pregnancy involving 2104 folic acid-treated pregnancies in women with epilepsy. RESULTS: Multiple variable logistic regression failed to demonstrate any statistically significant effect of folic acid dosage in reducing overall fetal malformation rates in women taking folic acid either before and during pregnancy (P = 0.640) or during early pregnancy only (P = 0.801), and in reducing spina bifida occurrence rates (P = 0.409). CONCLUSIONS: In the present state of knowledge, it would seem misguided to hope that a folic acid dose of 5 mg/day taken before and during pregnancy would protect against the occurrence of valproate-associated and other AED-associated fetal structural malformations. Future studies are required to determine whether high-dose periconceptional folate use may decrease the risk of other valproate-associated adverse fetal outcomes, including impaired post-natal neurobehavioral development.

Antiepileptic drugs and depression during pregnancy in women with epilepsy.

OBJECTIVES: To assess the possibility that the occurrence of seizures or the use of antiepileptic drug (AED) therapy might have influenced the rate of occurrence of volunteered histories of patient-recognized depression during pregnancy in women with epilepsy. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Analysis of data from 2039 pregnancies in the Raoul Wallenberg Australian Register of Antiepileptic Drugs in Pregnancy (APR) followed during pregnancy and to the end of the year after its end. RESULTS: Patient-recognized depression occurrence rates during pregnancy were a little lower rather than higher in seizure-affected than in seizure-free pregnancies (5.67% vs 6.41%), though higher in AED-treated than AED-untreated pregnancies (6.24% vs 5.26%; RR = 1.185, 95% CI 0.612, 2.295). Logistic regression analysis showed that carbamazepine dosage had a statistically significant relationship with a decreasing rate of patient-recognized depression occurring during pregnancy and topiramate dosage with an increasing rate. CONCLUSIONS: Carbamazepine and topiramate both have established potentials for causing teratogenesis, and it is possible that replacement of carbamazepine with a less teratogenic AED, for example levetiracetam, might result in any subsequent depression that occurs in pregnancy being inappropriately attributed to the newly introduced agent.

Twin pregnancy in women with epilepsy.

OBJECTIVE: We report data from the Raoul Wallenberg Australian Register of Antiepileptic Drugs in Pregnancy (APR) to see if there are significant differences in relation to the courses and outcomes of the twin pregnancies contained in the register, as compared with the singleton ones. METHODS: The APR has been under the oversight of Melbourne institutional Human Ethics Research Committees; all women enrolled in the APR have provided written informed consent. Data from the APR were transferred to a spreadsheet and then analyzed using simple statistical techniques including logistic regression. RESULTS: The population studied comprised 44 twin and 2261 singleton pregnancies; thus, twin pregnancies accounted for 1.91% of all pregnancies studied. The women carrying twins tended to be older than the women with singleton pregnancies to a statistically significant extent, their pregnancies more often originated from assisted fertilization techniques, and their babies were more often delivered by cesarean section. There were no statistically significant differences in relation to antiepileptic drug (AED) therapy. Individual twins had statistically significantly lower mean birthweights than singleton babies and they were statistically significantly more often involved structurally malformed foetuses. In the first year of life, the twin pregnancies statistically significantly more often produced offspring that were affected by seizures in infancy. SIGNIFICANCE: The data suggest that there may be an increased hazard of fetal malformation in the offspring of twin pregnancy in women with epilepsy, but that with contemporary standards of management of epilepsy and pregnancy, there is unlikely to be an increased hazard of seizure-affected pregnancy.

The outcome of altering antiepileptic drug therapy before pregnancy.

We investigated the outcome of altering antiepileptic drug (AED) therapy in the year before pregnancy on 2233 occasions in Australian women in the 20-year period of functioning of the Raoul Wallenberg Australian Pregnancy Register (APR). Therapy had been altered in 358 instances (16%) in the months prior to the pregnancy (median interval: 18 weeks). Antiepileptic drug doses had been changed in 141 pregnancies (39.4%), being decreased in 94; drugs changed in 151 (42.2%); drugs withdrawn without replacement in 66 (18.4%) but resumed in 40 before pregnancy ended. The main drugs involved were valproate (34%), phenytoin (16.5%), topiramate (12.6%), and carbamazepine (11.4%). Antiepileptic drug doses were increased significantly more often (16.9% vs. 6.4%) when epilepsy before pregnancy was not controlled, and AED treatment ceased significantly less often (13.6% vs. 24.0%). The alterations were more often made in women with generalized epilepsies and in those whose seizure disorders were not fully controlled in the prepregnancy year, suggesting that avoidance of teratogenicity and achieving improved seizure control often motivated the changes. Overall, the alterations did not result in improved rates of seizure freedom during pregnancy, as compared with pregnancies where therapy was unchanged; however, fetal malformation rates were lower 3.6% vs. 5.4%, but this difference did not attain statistical significance. The same trends regarding seizure control and malformations persisted after pregnancies involving valproate exposure were excluded. In conclusion, this analysis of the APR cohort did not demonstrate that altering AEDs before pregnancy produced a significant improvement in seizure control and the reduction in fetal malformation rate that occurred was not statistically significant.

Pregnancy after valproate withdrawal-Fetal malformations and seizure control.

OBJECTIVE: To assess the outcomes in women with epilepsy in relation to fetal malformation and epileptic seizure control during pregnancy when valproate (VPA) intake was ceased, or the drug's dose was reduced before pregnancy. METHODS: Statistical analysis of data collected in the Australian Pregnancy Register between 1999 and 2018 concerning 580 pregnancies previously treated with VPA, with the VPA dose reduced or the drug withdrawn prior to pregnancy in 158 cases. RESULTS: Although the available data have limitations, fetal malformation rates in the pregnancies studied were lower in the VPA changed pregnancies (4.5%) than in the VPA unchanged comparator pregnancies (10.9%, hazard ratio [HR] 0.412, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.190-0.892), and were only 2.7% where VPA intake was ceased before pregnancy (HR 0.262, 95% CI 0.083-0.826). Seizure-affected pregnancies were more frequent in the VPA changed pregnancies than in the VPA unchanged ones (46.2% vs 30.8%, HR 1.500, 95% CI 1.203-1.870). Convulsive seizure-affected pregnancies also were increased, but the difference was not statistically significant. SIGNIFICANCE: Prepregnancy reduction in VPA dosage reduced the hazard of fetal malformations, whereas ceasing intake of the drug decreased the hazard to one similar to that which applies in the general population, but at a cost of decreased control of epileptic seizures during the pregnancies studied. Further investigations are needed to see whether such findings apply more widely in women with epilepsy.