Influence of curriculum type on student performance in the United States Medical Licensing Examination Step 1 and Step 2 exams: problem-based learning vs. lecture-based curriculum.

INTRODUCTION: The results of the United States Medical Licensing Examination Step 1 and 2 examinations are reported for students enrolled in a problem-based and traditional lecture-based curricula over a seven-year period at a single institution. There were no statistically significant differences in mean scores on either examination over the seven year period as a whole. There were statistically significant main effects noted by cohort year and curricular track for both the Step 1 and 2 examinations. These results support the general, long-term effectiveness of problem-based learning with respect to basic and clinical science knowledge acquisition. CONTEXT: This paper reports the United States Medical Licensing Examination Step 1 and Step 2 results for students enrolled in a problem-based and traditional lecture-based learning curricula over the seven-year period (1992-98) in order to evaluate the adequacy of each curriculum in supporting students learning of the basic and clinical sciences. METHODS: Six hundred and eighty-nine students who took the United States Medical Licensing Examination Step 1 and 540 students who took Step 2 for the first time over the seven-year period were included in the analyses. T-test analyses were utilized to compare students' Step 1 and Step 2 performance by curriculum groups. RESULTS: United States Medical Licensing Examination Step 1 scores over the seven-year period were 214 for Traditional Curriculum students and 208 for Parallel Curriculum students (t-value = 1.32, P=0.21). Mean Step 2 scores over the seven-year period were 208 for Traditional Curriculum students and 206 for Parallel Curriculum students (t-value=1.08, P=0.30). Statistically significant main effects were noted by cohort year and curricular track for both the Step 1 and Step 2 examinations. CONCLUSION: The totality of experience in both groups, although differing by curricular type, may be similar enough that the comparable scores are what should be expected. These results should be reassuring to curricular planners and faculty that problem-based learning can provide students with the knowledge needed for the subsequent phases of their medical education.

Cost-effectiveness of aerobic and resistance exercise in seniors with knee osteoarthritis.

PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to determine, in a randomized clinical trial of 439 individuals with knee osteoarthritis, the incremental cost-effectiveness of aerobic versus weight resistance training, compared with an education control intervention. METHODS: Cost estimates of the intervention were based upon the cost of purchasing from the community similar services to provide exercise or health education. Effect at 18 months was measured using several variables, including: self-reported disability score, 6-min walking distance, stair climb, lifting and carrying task, car task, and measures of pain frequency and pain intensity on ambulation and transfer. RESULTS: The total cost of the educational intervention was $343.98 per participant. The aerobic exercise intervention cost $323.55 per participant, and the resistance training intervention cost $325.20 per participant. On all but two of the outcome variables, the incremental savings per incremental effect for the resistance exercise group was greater than for the aerobic exercise group. CONCLUSION: The data obtained from this study suggest that, compared with an education control, resistance training for seniors with knee osteoarthritis is more economically efficient than aerobic exercise in improving physical function. However, the magnitude of the difference in efficiency between the two approaches is small.

An ethical paradox: the effect of unethical conduct on medical students' values.

OBJECTIVE: To report the ethical development of medical students across four years of education at one medical school. DESIGN AND SETTING: A questionnaire was distributed to all four classes at the Wake Forest University School of Medicine during the Spring of 1996. PARTICIPANTS: Three hundred and three students provided demographic information as well as information concerning their ethical development both as current medical students and future interns. MAIN MEASUREMENTS: Results were analyzed using cross-tabulations, correlations, and analysis of variance. RESULTS: Results suggested that the observation of and participation in unethical conduct may have disparaging effects on medical students' codes of ethics with 35% of the total sample (24% of first years rising to 55% of fourth years) stating that derogatory comments made by residents/attendings, either in the patient's presence or absence, were "sometimes" or "often" appropriate. However, approximately 70% of the sample contended that their personal code of ethics had not changed since beginning medical school and would not change as a resident. CONCLUSIONS: Results may represent an internal struggle that detracts from the medical school experience, both as a person and as a doctor. Our goal as educators is to alter the educational environment so that acceptance of such behaviour is not considered part of becoming a physician.

Utilities for major stroke: results from a survey of preferences among persons at increased risk for stroke.

BACKGROUND: Patient beliefs, values, and preferences are crucial to decisions involving health care. In a large sample of persons at increased risk for stroke, we examined attitudes toward hypothetical major stroke. METHODS AND RESULTS: Respondents were obtained from the Academic Medical Center Consortium (n = 621), the Cardiovascular Health Study (n = 321 ), and United Health Care (n = 319). Preferences were primarily assessed by using the time trade off (TTO). Although major stroke is generally considered an undesirable event (mean TTO = 0.30), responses were varied: although 45% of respondents considered major stroke to be a worse outcome than death, 15% were willing to trade off little or no survival to avoid a major stroke. CONCLUSIONS: Providers should speak directly with patients about beliefs, values, and preferences. Stroke-related interventions, even those with a high price or less than dramatic clinical benefits, are likely to be cost-effective if they prevent an outcome (major stroke) that is so undesirable.

Medical students' perceptions of unethical conduct at one medical school.

PURPOSE: To assess medical students' perceptions of the ethical environment across four years of medical school. METHOD: In the spring of 1996, the authors distributed a questionnaire to all four classes at the Wake Forest University School of Medicine. The students provided demographic information and information about their exposures to or participation in unethical situations. Results were analyzed using multiple analysis of variance, univariate analysis of variance, Pearson correlation, and cross-tabulations. RESULTS: The response rate was 71%. The students reported that exposures to unethical behavior started early and continued to increase with each year in school. For example, 35% of the first-year students reported observing unethical conduct by residents or attending physicians. This percentage rose to 90% of the fourth-year students. The authors found no significant relationship between demographic variables other than the year in school and the ethical dilemma variables. CONCLUSION: Medical students face perceived ethical dilemmas beginning as early as the first year of medical school. Thus ethics instruction must begin in the freshman year. In addition, there must be changes to the environment in which clinical education is conducted to enhance the positive enculturation of students into the medical profession.

Knowledge of risk among patients at increased risk for stroke.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Patients who recognize their increased risk for stroke are more likely to engage in (and comply with) stroke prevention practices than those who do not. We describe perceived risk of stroke among a nationally diverse sample of patients at increased risk for stroke and determine whether patients' knowledge of their stroke risk varied according to patients' demographic and clinical characteristics. METHODS: Respondents were recruited from the Academic Medical Center Consortium (n = 621, five academic medical centers, inpatients of varying age); the Cardiovascular Health Study (n = 321, population-based sample of persons aged 65+ years); and United HealthCare (n = 319, five health plans, inpatients and outpatients typically younger than 65 years). The primary outcome was awareness of being at risk for stroke. RESULTS: Only 41% of respondents were aware of their increased risk for stroke (including less than one half of patients with previous minor stroke). Approximately 74% of patients who recalled being told of their increased stroke risk by a physician acknowledged this risk in comparison with 28% of patients who did not recall being informed by a physician. Younger patients, depressed patients, those in poor current health, and those with a history of TIA were most likely to be aware of their stroke risk. CONCLUSIONS: Over one half of patients at increased risk of stroke are unaware of their risk. Healthcare providers play a crucial role in communicating information about risk, and successful communication encourages adoption of stroke prevention practices. Educational messages should be targeted toward patients least likely to be aware of their risk.

Health status of individuals with mild stroke.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Diminished quality of life and limitations in higher levels of physical functioning are often underestimated in stroke and are not fully captured by measures such as the Barthel Index and the Rankin Outcome Scale. This study used additional measures to assess the health status of 304 persons with mild stroke and to compare these individuals with 184 persons with transient ischemic attack and 654 persons without history of stroke/transient ischemic attack but at elevated risk for stroke (asymptomatic group). METHODS: Subjects were recruited from the Academic Medical Center Consortium (inpatients), the Cardiovascular Health Study (population-based sample of community-dwelling persons 65 years and older), and United HealthCare (inpatients and outpatients typically younger than 65 years). Subjects were interviewed by telephone or in person to assess activities of daily living (Barthel Index), depression (Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale), health status (MOS-36), and utility for current health state. RESULTS: Most respondents were independent on all Barthel items. The stroke group was more impaired on the MOS-36 than the asymptomatic group but similar to the group with transient ischemic attack. Health-related quality of life was lowest for persons with stroke. While symptom status and Barthel Index score were the strongest predictors of health status, the Barthel Index showed a consistent ceiling effect when compared with the physical function subscale of the MOS-36. CONCLUSIONS: The consequences of even mild stroke affect all dimensions of health except pain. Standardized assessment of persons with stroke must evaluate across the entire continuum of health-related functions.

Operative treatment of abdominal aortic aneurysms in octogenarians. When is it too much too late?

OBJECTIVE: This study evaluated the value of operation for treatment of all octogenarians with ruptured abdominal aortic aneurysms (AAA). SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: Elective AAA resection in octogenarians is safe, with published operative mortality rates of approximately 5%. Published operative mortality rates of ruptured AAA in this age group, however, vary from 27 to 92%. METHODS: To evaluate this question, we extracted the clinical course of the 34 octogenarians submitted to AAA resection by the authors from our total experience of 548 resections performed during the past 7 1/2 years. In this subgroup of octogenarians, 18 underwent elective AAA replacement, 5 were submitted to urgent resection of active but intact AAAs, and 11 had operations for ruptured AAAs. There were 23 males and 11 females in the group. The ages ranged from 80 to 91 years. RESULTS: Operative mortality in the patients managed electively was 5.6%. Two of the five patients (40%) submitted to operation for active yet unruptured aneurysms died in the preoperative period. Finally, 10 of the 11 patients (91%) with ruptured AAAs were operative mortalities. All of these operative mortalities in the ruptured AAA subgroup had severe hypotension preoperatively (mean systolic blood pressure: 23 mm Hg). The charges associated with the management of the ruptured AAA group averaged $84,486 (range $12,537-$199,233). CONCLUSIONS: Although elective replacement of AAA in properly selected octogenarians appears valuable to prolong worthwhile life expectancy, this experience leads us to consider observation only in the treatment of octogenarians with ruptured AAA who present with severe hemodynamic instability.

Impact of the Medicare fee schedule on an academic department of medicine.

OBJECTIVE: To examine the effect of the Medicare Fee Schedule (MFS) on Medicare revenues in the department of medicine at an urban academic medical center after the MFS is fully implemented. METHODS: Department revenues from Medicare were compared with projected revenues using the MFS proposed by the Health Care Financing Administration on June 5, 1991. National Medicare claims data were used to determine differences in service mix between community and academic internists and the impact of the geographic component of the MFS on department revenues. RESULTS: Department revenues from Medicare in 1996 are projected to be 25.5% lower under the MFS than if the current system had continued. Subspecialty sections that perform large numbers of procedures and special tests had the largest decrease in revenues (eg, gastroenterology, -29.8%); however, this did not differ greatly from decreases in sections that mainly provide visits and consultations (eg, general internal medicine, -24.7%). CONCLUSION: The proposed MFS is projected to lead to substantial reductions in department revenues from Medicare. While relative values for services and geographic location will play a role in how individual departments fare under the MFS, the value of the conversion factor used in the final MFS will be the factor of greatest importance.