A systematic review and meta-analyses on animal models used in bone adhesive research.

Currently, steel implants are used for osteosynthesis of (comminuted) fractures and intra-articular bone defects. These osteosyntheses can sometimes be complicated procedures and can have several drawbacks including stress shielding of the bone. A bone glue might be a safe and effective alternative to current materials. Despite numerous animal studies on bone adhesives, no such material is clinically applied yet. We have conducted a systematic review to summarize the evidence in experimental animal models used in research on bone adhesive materials for trauma and orthopedic surgery. Additionally, we analysed the efficacy of the different bone adhesives for different experimental designs. A heterogeneity in experimental parameters including animal species, defect types, and control measurements resulted in a wide variety in experimental models. In addition, no standard outcome measurements could be identified. Meta-analysis on bone regeneration between adhesive treatment and nonadhesive treatment showed a high heterogeneity and no statistically significant overall effect (M: -0.71, 95% confidence interval [CI]: -1.63-0.21, p = 0.13). Besides, currently there is not enough evidence to draw conclusions based on the effectiveness of the individual types of adhesives or experimental models. A positive statistically significant effect was found for the adhesive treatment in comparison with conventional osteosynthesis materials (M: 2.49, 95% CI: 1.20-3.79, p = 0.0002). To enhance progression in bone adhesive research and provide valuable evidence for clinical application, more standard experimental parameters and a higher reporting quality in animal studies are needed. Statement of Clinical Significance: Current materials restoring anatomical alignments of bones have several drawbacks. A (biodegradable) adhesive for fixating bone defects can be a treatment breakthrough. Although numerous bone adhesives have been researched, most seemed to fail at the preclinical stage. An overview in this field is missing. This systematic review highlights the relevant parameters for design of experimental bone adhesive studies. It demonstrates evidence regarding benefit of bone adhesives but also that the quality of reporting and the risk of bias in studies need to be improved. The results will aid in designing better quality animal studies for bone adhesive research with higher translational value.

New polyoxazoline loaded patches for hemostasis in experimental liver resection.

A new cost-effective NHS functionalized polyoxazoline (POx) loaded polymer with strong hemostatic properties has been developed. In this study, we investigate POx loaded hemostatic patches regarding hemostatic efficacy, local inflammatory reaction and wound-healing, as compared to the non-POx treated blanks and commercially available hemostatic products. Hundred and ten rats divided into 11 groups of 10 animals underwent partial liver lobe resection. Eight groups received experimental patches, two groups commercially available hemostatic patches (TachoSil® and Veriset™, positive controls), one group with gauzes (negative control). Each animal received twice a patch with a size 1.5 × 2.5 cm, on each partially resected lobe. Primary endpoint was time to hemostasis (TTH). The rats were sacrificed at different time points (1, 3, or 7 days) to measure local inflammatory response and early wound healing. Of the POx loaded patches, GFC NHS-POx (TTH 20.4 s, p = .019) and GFC-NHS-POx1.5 (TTH 0.0 s, p = .003) showed significantly faster TTH compared to TachoSil® (TTH 95.4 s), and were comparable to Veriset™ (TTH 17.0 s). Three patches, GFC-NHS-POx 1.5 (TTH 0.0 s, p = .016), ORC NHS-POx:NU-POx (TTH 91.4 s, p = .033), and ORC-PLGA NHS-POx:NU-POx (TTH 105.6 s, p = .04) had a lower TTH compared to their own blank carrier (TTH 74.9, 157.8, and 195.7 s, respectively). With regard to biocompatibility, all POx loaded patches showed results comparable to TachoSil® and Veriset™. NHS-POx-loaded hemostatic patch demonstrate fast and effective hemostasis, comparable or better than commercially available hemostatic patches, with similar early biocompatibility.

Bone-Adhesive Hydrogels Based on Dual Crosslinked Poly(2-oxazoline)s.

The development of bone glues based on bone-adhesive hydrogels to allow for facile bone fracture fixation remains a major challenge. Herein, dual crosslinked hydrogels that combine tunable stiffness, ductility, and self-healing capacity are successfully synthesized. The resulting double network hydrogel is formed by chemical crosslinking of N-hydroxysuccinimide-functionalized poly(2-oxazoline)s(POx-NHS)"?> with amine-functionalized poly(2-oxazoline)s, and physical crosslinking of alendronate-functionalized poly(2-oxazoline)s (POx-Ale) with calcium ions in solution. The use of an excess of alendronate-functionalized POx-Ale polymers also ensures affinity toward calcium cations in the mineral phase of bone, thereby rendering these hydrogels adhesive to bone. The mechanical and bone-adhesive properties of these novel hydrogels are superior to commercially available fibrin sealants. Moreover, hydrogels retain their bone-adhesive properties under wet conditions. Although the dual crosslinked hydrogels swell considerably, they are stable upon immersion in phosphate-buffered saline (up to 12 d) and even in ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid solution. The enhanced mechanical and bone-adhesive properties of these hydrogels, as well as their in vitro stability, indicate that they have much application potential as bone-adhesive glues.

Bone-adhesive barrier membranes based on alendronate-functionalized poly(2-oxazoline)s.

To create a novel generation of barrier membranes with bone-adhesive properties, three-component membranes were successfully developed using a solvent-free approach by combining an occlusive polyester backing layer with a bone-adhesive fibrous gelatin carrier impregnated with calcium-binding alendronate-functionalized poly(2-oxazoline)s (POx-Ale). The mechanical properties of these novel membranes were similar to other commercially available barrier membranes. In contrast, the adhesion of our membranes towards bone was by far superior (i.e. 62-fold) compared to conventional commercially available Bio-Gide® membranes. Moreover, alendronate-functionalized membranes retained their bone-adhesive properties under wet conditions in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) solutions with and without collagenase. Finally, the in vitro degradation of the membranes was studied by monitoring their weight loss upon immersion in PBS solutions with and without collagenase. The membranes degraded in a sustained manner, which was accelerated by the presence of collagenase due to enzymatic degradation of the carrier. In conclusion, our results show that surface functionalization of barrier membranes with alendronate moieties renders them adhesive to bone. As such, the biomaterials design strategy presented herein opens up new avenues of research on bone-adhesive membranes for guided bone regeneration.

Alendronate-Functionalized Poly(2-oxazoline)s with Tunable Affinity for Calcium Cations.

A library of poly(2-oxazoline)s functionalized with controllable amounts of alendronate, hydroxyl, and carboxylic acid side groups was successfully synthesized to create novel polymers with tunable affinity for calcium cations. The affinity of alendronate-containing polymers for calcium cations was quantified using isothermal titration calorimetry. Thermodynamic measurements revealed that the Ca2+-binding affinity of these polymers increased linearly with the amount of alendronate functionalization, up to values (KCa2+ = 2.4 × 105 M-1) that were about 120-fold higher than those for previously reported polymers. The calcium-binding capacity of alendronate-functionalized poly(2-oxazoline)s was exploited to form robust hydrogel networks cross-linked using reversible physical bonds. Oscillatory rheology showed that these hydrogels recovered more than 100% of their initial storage modulus after severe network destruction. The versatile synthesis of alendronate-functionalized polymers and their strong and tunable affinity for calcium cations render these polymers promising candidates for various biomedical applications.

Next Generation Hemostatic Materials Based on NHS-Ester Functionalized Poly(2-oxazoline)s.

In order to prevent hemorrhage during surgical procedures, a wide range of hemostatic agents have been developed. However, their efficacy is variable; hemostatic devices that use bioactive components to accelerate coagulation are dependent on natural sources, which limits reproducibility. Hybrid devices in which chain-end reactive poly(ethylene glycol) is employed as active component sometimes suffer from irregular cross-linking and dissolution of the polar PEG when blood flow is substantial. Herein, we describe a synthetic, nonbioactive hemostatic product by coating N-hydroxysuccinimide ester (NHS)-functional poly(2-oxazoline)s (POx-NHS) onto gelatin patches, which acts by formation of covalent cross-links between polymer, host blood proteins, gelatin and tissue to seal the wound site and prevent hemorrhage during surgery. We studied different process parameters (including polymer, carrier, and coating technique) in direct comparison with clinical products (Hemopatch and Tachosil) to obtain deeper understanding of this class of hemostatic products. In this work, we successfully prove the hemostatic efficacy of POx-NHS as polymer powders and coated patches both in vitro and in vivo against Hemopatch and Tachosil, demonstrating that POx-NHS are excellent candidate polymers for the development of next generation hemostatic patches.

Size matters: effects of PLGA-microsphere size in injectable CPC/PLGA on bone formation.

The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of PLGA microsphere dimensions on bone formation after injection of calcium phosphate cement (CPC)/PLGA in a guinea pig tibial intramedullarly model. To this end, injectable CPC/PLGA formulations were prepared using PLGA microspheres with either a small (~25 µm) or large (~100 µm) diameter, which were incorporated at a 20:80 ratio (wt%) within apatite CPC. Both CPC/PLGA formulations were injected into a marrow-ablated tibial intramedullary cavity and, after an implantation period of 12 weeks, histology and histomorphometry were used to address bone formation. The results demonstrated bone ingrowth throughout the entire scaffold material for both CPC/PLGA formulations upon PLGA microsphere degradation. More importantly, bone formation within the CPC matrix was > two-fold higher for CPC-PLGA with 25 µm PLGA microspheres. Additionally, the pattern of bone and marrow formation showed distinct differences related to PLGA microsphere dimension. In general, this study demonstrates that PLGA microsphere dimensions of ~25 µm, leading to pores of ~25 µm within CPC, are sufficient for bone ingrowth and allow substantial bone formation. Further, the results demonstrate that PLGA microsphere dimensions provide a tool to control bone formation for injectable CPC/PLGA bone substitutes. Copyright © 2013 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Accelerated calcium phosphate cement degradation due to incorporation of glucono-delta-lactone microparticles.

Injectable calcium phosphate cements (CPC) are frequently used for filling of bone defects due to their excellent osteocompatibility. Their poor degradability, however, limits complete regeneration of bone defects. Organic additives that produce acid by-products are particularly attractive to create macroporosity in situ since CPC degrade by acid dissolution. The aim of the current study was to investigate whether glucono-delta-lactone (GDL) can be used as acid-producing microparticles for incorporation into CPC without compromising its osteocompatibility. Characterization studies confirmed that CPCs containing either low or high amounts of GDL were injectable and self-setting, while a considerable amount of porosity was formed already within 1 day of incubation in phosphate buffered saline due to dissolution of GDL. Histomorphometrical evaluation after 2 weeks of implantation revealed that CPC containing 10% of GDL degraded faster and was replaced by more bone tissue than CPCs containing either Poly (lactic-co-glycolic acid) (PLGA) or gelatin microspheres. Summarizing, the current study showed that CPCs containing appropriate amounts of GDL display accelerated degradation and new bone formation compared with CPCs containing microparticles made of conventional polymers such as PLGA or gelatin.

RANKL delivery from calcium phosphate containing PLGA microspheres.

Ideally, bone substitute materials would undergo cell-mediated degradation during the remodeling process of the host bone tissue while being replaced by newly formed bone. In an attempt to exploit the capacity of Receptor Activator of Nuclear factor Kappa-B Ligand (RANKL) to stimulate osteoclast-like cells formation, this study explored different loading methods for RANKL in injectable calcium phosphate cement (CPC) and the effect on release and biological activity. RANKL was loaded via the liquid phase of CPC by adsorption onto or incorporation into poly(lactic-co-glycolic acid) (PLGA) microspheres with two different morphologies (i.e., hollow and dense), which were subsequently embedded in CPC. As controls nonembedded PLGA-microspheres were used as well as plain CPC scaffolds with RANKL adsorbed onto the surface. RANKL release and activity were evaluated by Reverse Phase High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (RP-HPLC) and osteoclast-like cells formation in cell culture experiments. Results indicated that sustained release of active RANKL can be achieved upon RANKL adsorption to PLGA microspheres, whereas inactive RANKL was released from CPC-PLGA formulations with RANKL incorporated within the microspheres or within the liquid phase of the CPC. These results demonstrate that effective loading of RANKL in injectable CPC is only possible via adsorption to PLGA microspheres, which are subsequently embedded within the CPC-matrix.

Physicochemical properties and applications of poly(lactic-co-glycolic acid) for use in bone regeneration.

Poly(lactic-co-glycolic acid) (PLGA) is the most often used synthetic polymer within the field of bone regeneration owing to its biocompatibility and biodegradability. As a consequence, a large number of medical devices comprising PLGA have been approved for clinical use in humans by the American Food and Drug Administration. As compared with the homopolymers of lactic acid poly(lactic acid) and poly(glycolic acid), the co-polymer PLGA is much more versatile with regard to the control over degradation rate. As a material for bone regeneration, the use of PLGA has been extensively studied for application and is included as either scaffolds, coatings, fibers, or micro- and nanospheres to meet various clinical requirements.

Three different strategies to obtain porous calcium phosphate cements: comparison of performance in a rat skull bone augmentation model.

Preprosthetic surgery has become a routine procedure to obtain sufficient bone quantity and quality for dental implant installation in patients with an initial inadequate bone volume. Although autologous bone onlay or inlay grafting is still the preferred bone augmentation technique, a broad range of synthetic bone substitutes have been developed, for example, calcium phosphate cement (CPC). The introduction of porosity within CPC can be used to increase CPC degradation and bone ingrowth. Therefore, three different strategies to obtain porous CPCs were evaluated in this preclinical study. Instantaneously porous CPC (CPC-IP) was compared with delayed porous CPC in vitro and in vivo. CPC-IP was obtained by the creation of CO2 bubbles during setting, whereas delayed porous CPC was obtained after the degradation of incorporated poly(lactic-co-glycolic acid) (PLGA) microspheres. As an additional aspect, delayed porous CPC was created by the incorporation of either hollow or dense degradable PLGA microspheres (CPC-hPLGA and CPC-dPLGA). All CPC compositions showed appropriate clinical handling properties and an interconnected porous structure with a final porosity above 70% (v/v). In vitro degradation studies showed the gradual formation of pores and further CPC-matrix dissolution for CPCs containing PLGA microspheres (dPLGA microspheres > hPLGA microspheres). For in vivo evaluation of the CPCs, an augmentation model was used, allowing a CPC injection into a rigidly immobilized Teflon ring on the rat skull. Histological evaluation after 12 weeks of implantation showed bone formation using all three CPCs. Bone apposition reached volumetric amounts of up to 10% of the augmentation area and a maximum augmentation height of ∼1 mm. CPC-IP showed significantly more bone formation and resulted in a superior bone apposition height compared with both CPCs containing PLGA microspheres. No differences in biological performance were observed between the CPCs containing hPLGA and those containing dPLGA microspheres. Further research is necessary to enhance the bone appositional speed and amount of CPCs for bone augmentation procedures before them being used in a potential clinical setting.

Influence of the pore generator on the evolution of the mechanical properties and the porosity and interconnectivity of a calcium phosphate cement.

Porosity and interconnectivity are important properties of calcium phosphate cements (CPCs) and bone-replacement materials. Porosity of CPCs can be achieved by adding polymeric biodegradable pore-generating particles (porogens), which can add porosity to the CPC and can also be used as a drug-delivery system. Porosity affects the mechanical properties of CPCs, and hence is of relevance for clinical application of these cements. The current study focused on the effect of combinations of polymeric mesoporous porogens on the properties of a CPC, such as specific surface area, porosity and interconnectivity and the development of mechanical properties. CPC powder was mixed with different amounts of PLGA porogens of various molecular weights and porogen sizes. The major factors affecting the properties of the CPC were related to the amount of porogen loaded and the porogen size; the molecular weight did not show a significant effect per se. A minimal porogen size of 40 µm in 30 wt.% seems to produce a CPC with mechanical properties, porosity and interconnectivity suitable for clinical applications. The properties studied here, and induced by the porogen and CPC, can be used as a guide to evoke a specific host-response to maintain CPC integrity and to generate an explicit bone ingrowth.

Bone response to fast-degrading, injectable calcium phosphate cements containing PLGA microparticles.

Apatitic calcium phosphate cements (CPC) are frequently used to fill bone defects due to their favourable clinical handling and excellent bone response, but their lack of degradability inhibits complete bone regeneration. In order to render these injectable CaP cements biodegradable, hollow microspheres made of poly (D,L-lactic-co-glycolic) acid (PLGA) have been previously used as porogen since these microspheres were shown to be able to induce macroporosity upon degradation as well as to accelerate CPC degradation by release of acid degradation products. Recently, the capacity of PLGA microspheres to form porosity in situ in injectable CPCs was optimized by investigating the influence of PLGA characteristics such as microsphere morphology (dense vs. hollow) and end-group functionalization (acid terminated vs. end-capped) on acid production and corresponding porosity formation in vitro. The current study has investigated the in vivo bone response to CPCs containing two types of microspheres (hollow and dense) made of PLGA with two different end-group functionalizations (end capped and acid terminated). Microspheres were embedded in CPC and injected in the distal femoral condyle of New Zealand White Rabbits for 6 and 12 weeks. Histological results confirmed the excellent biocompatibility and osteoconductivity of all tested materials. Composites containing acid terminated PLGA microspheres displayed considerable porosity and concomitant bone ingrowth after 6 weeks, whereas end capped microspheres only revealed open porosity after 12 weeks of implantation. In addition, it was found that dense PLGA microspheres induced significantly more CPC degradation and bone tissue formation compared to hollow PLGA microspheres. In conclusion, it was shown that PLGA microspheres have a strong capacity to induce fast degradation of injectable CPC and concomitant replacement by bone tissue by controlled release of acid polymeric degradation products without compromising the excellent biocompatibility and osteoconductivity of the CPC matrix.