Barriers to utilization of pre-hospital emergency medical services among residents in Libreville, Gabon: a qualitative study

Introduction :In 2002; the West-African nation of Gabon established an emergency medical system (EMS); Service d'Aide Medicale Urgente (SAMU); in Libreville; yet few people access it. Our objective was to describe Libreville residents' knowledge and attitudes toward the SAMU in an effort to understand why this service is underutilized. Methods :Qualitative interviews consisting of nine open-ended questions were conducted on a convenience sample of twenty patients; three visitors and two patient/visitor dyads at the Jeanne Ebori Hospital Emergency Centre in October 2009. Eligible subjects arrived in vehicles other than the SAMU and were ill enough to require hospital admission. Exclusion criteria were: under 21years old; unable to speak French; or medically unstable. A bilingual team member audio-recorded the interviews in French and transcribed them into eng. Investigators organized text into codes; then into themes and theoretical constructs. Intercoder agreement was excellent. Data were collected until theoretical saturation was achieved. Results: Analysis of data revealed no difference in response between patients and visitors. People underused SAMU because of financial costs; lack of awareness of the program; use of traditional modes of transportation; infrastructure flaws; perceived response times and other misconceptions. Conclusion: We identified remediable barriers to EMS (SAMU) access in Libreville; Gabon: lack of awareness; misperceptions; established alternatives; and cost. Interventions and future investigations designed to increase EMS utilization in Gabon should target these four areas

Pediatric prehospital evaluation of NYC cardiac arrest survival (PHENYCS).

OBJECTIVES: The objective of this study was to describe the demographics of out-of-hospital cardiac arrests (OOHCAs) in children younger than 18 years and characteristics associated with survival among these children in New York City (NYC). METHODS: A prospective observational cohort of all children younger than 18 years with OOHCA in NYC between April 1, 2002, and March 31, 2003. Data were collected from prehospital providers by trained paramedics utilizing a previously validated telephone interview process. Data included Pediatric Utstein core measures and critical prehospital time intervals. Analyses utilized descriptive statistics and bivariate association with survival. RESULTS: Resuscitation was attempted on 147 pediatric OOHCA patients in NYC during the study period; outcome data were collected on these patients. The median age was 2 years; most (58%) were male. The majority of arrests occurred at home (69%). Lay bystanders witnessed 33% of all OOHCA; 68% of witnesses were family members. Bystander cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) was performed on 30% of children. Median emergency medical services response time was 3.6 minutes (range, 0.4-14.4 minutes). Initial rhythm was as follows: ventricular fibrillation, 2%; asystole, 50%; pulseless electrical activity, 9.5%; other rhythms, 11.6%; no rhythm recorded, 26%. Survival was 4% to hospital discharge and was present only among witnessed arrests (6/58 witnessed vs 0/70 unwitnessed, P < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: Pediatric OOHCA survival rate is low. Witnessed arrest was the most important determinant of survival. Ventricular fibrillation was an uncommon rhythm measured by emergency medical services. The majority of arrests occurred at home. The rate of bystander CPR was low. Strategies to increase the rate of bystander CPR for children, especially by family members, are needed.

Pediatric prehospital evaluation of NYC respiratory arrest survival (PHENYCS).

OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to describe the demographics, epidemiology, and characteristics associated with survival of children younger than 18 years who had an out-of-hospital respiratory arrest (OOHRA) during a 1-year period in a large urban area. METHODS: A prospective observational cohort of consecutive children younger than 18 years with OOHRA cared for by the New York City 911 emergency medical services (EMS) system from April 12, 2002, to March 31, 2003. Following resuscitative efforts, data were collected from prehospital providers by trained paramedics using a previously validated telephone interview process. Data included Pediatric Utstein core measures and critical prehospital time intervals. Analyses used descriptive statistics and bivariate association with survival. RESULTS: Resuscitation was attempted on 109 OOHRAs during the study period. The median age was 7 years, 52% were male. Lay bystanders witnessed 56%. Most occurred at home (77%). Witnesses were family members in 59%. Bystander cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) was performed in 31% of all respiratory arrests (RAs). A chronic medical condition existed in 28%. Median EMS response time was 4.4 minutes (range, 0-12 min). Overall survival was 79% to hospital discharge. Time interval to EMS arrival, witnessed arrest, bystander CPR, and ventilation method were not associated with survival. CONCLUSIONS: Most OOHRAs occurred at home, and bystander CPR occurred infrequently. The majority of children in OOHRA survived. Strategies to increase the rate of bystander CPR, especially by family members, are needed. Out-of-hospital RAs are a large proportion of all arrests in children. Future studies of pediatric arrest should include RA as well as cardiac arrest.

Training physician investigators in medicine and public health research.

OBJECTIVES: We have described and evaluated the impact of a unique fellowship program designed to train postdoctoral, physician fellows in research at the interface of medicine and public health. METHODS: We developed a rigorous curriculum in public health content and research methods and fostered linkages with research mentors and local public health agencies. Didactic training provided the foundation for fellows' mentored research initiatives, which addressed real-world challenges in advancing the health status of vulnerable urban populations. RESULTS: Two multidisciplinary cohorts (6 per cohort) completed this 2-year degree-granting program and engaged in diverse public health research initiatives on topics such as improving pediatric care outcomes through health literacy interventions, reducing hospital readmission rates among urban poor with multiple comorbidities, increasing cancer screening uptake, and broadening the reach of addiction screening and intervention. The majority of fellows (10/12) published their fellowship work and currently have a career focused in public health-related research or practice (9/12). CONCLUSIONS: A fellowship training program can prepare physician investigators for research careers that bridge the divide between medicine and public health.

Priorities for pediatric prehospital research.

UNLABELLED: Up to 3 million US children are cared for by emergency medical services (EMSs) annually. Limited research exists on pediatric prehospital care. The Pediatric Emergency Care Applied Research Network (PECARN) mission is to perform high-quality research for children, including prehospital research. Our objective was to develop a pediatric-specific prehospital research agenda. METHODS: Representatives from all 4 PECARN nodes and from EMS agency partners participated in a 3-step process. First, participants ranked potential research priorities and suggested others. Second, participants reranked the list in order of importance and scored each priority using a modified Hanlon method (prevalence, seriousness, and practicality of each research area were assessed). Finally, the revised priority list was presented at a PECARN EMS summit, and consensus was sought. RESULTS: Forty-two representatives participated, including PECARN representatives, EMS agency leaders, and nationally recognized prehospital researchers. Consensus was reached on the priority ranking. The prioritization processes resulted in 2 ranked lists: 15 clinical topics and 5 EMS system topics. The top 10 clinical priorities included (1) airway management, (2) respiratory distress, (3) trauma, (4) asthma, (5) head trauma, (6) shock, (7) pain, (8) seizures, (9) respiratory arrest, and (10) C-spine immobilization. The 5 EMS system topics identify methods to improve prehospital care on the system level. CONCLUSIONS: PECARN has identified high-priority EMS research topics for children using a consensus-derived method. These research priorities include novel EMS system topics. The PECARN EMS pediatric research priority list will help focus future pediatric prehospital research both within and outside the network.

Screening for developmental delay in high-risk users of an urban pediatric emergency department.

OBJECTIVE: To determine whether screening children in an urban pediatric emergency department (PED) would lead to identification of previously undiagnosed developmental delay. METHODS: This was a cross-sectional study of families presenting to an urban public hospital PED with children 6 to 36 months and no history of developmental delay. Children were screened for possible developmental delay using the Ages and Stages Questionnaire; parents completed an instrument that assesses 5 domains: communication, gross motor, fine motor, problem solving, and personal-social. Sociodemographic data were also obtained. RESULTS: One hundred thirty-eight children were enrolled, all accompanied by their mothers. Mean age of the children was 18.9 months; 51.5% were female; 56.8% of the mothers were high-school graduates; 59.9% were immigrants; 75.4% were Latino. Twenty-one percent did not have a regular source of primary care; 26.8% (95% confidence interval, 20.1%-34.8%) screened positive in at least 1 domain, with a trend toward the highest percentage of positive screens on the communication domain (z = 1.89, P = 0.059). In a simultaneous multiple logistic regression model including all predictor variables, child age of 12 to 30 months was associated with increased adjusted odds of positive screen (adjusted odds ratio, 8.4; 95% confidence interval, 1.4-48.9). Having a primary caregiver born in the United States was statistically significant for screening positive in at least 1 Ages and Stages Questionnaire domain (P = 0.03). CONCLUSIONS: Almost 30% of 6- to 36-month-old children presenting to an urban PED without prior developmental concerns screened positive for possible delay, suggesting the utility of performing routine developmental screening in the PED. Pediatric emergency department use alone may be an indication for screening. Further study is needed for feasibility of screening for delay in the PED.

Epidemiology of psychiatric-related visits to emergency departments in a multicenter collaborative research pediatric network.

OBJECTIVES: Describe the epidemiology of pediatric psychiatric-related visits to emergency departments participating in the Pediatric Emergency Care Applied Research Network. METHODS: Retrospective analysis of emergency department presentations for psychiatric-related visits (International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision, codes 290.0-314.90) for years 2003 to 2005 at 24 participating Pediatric Emergency Care Applied Research Network hospitals. All patients who had psychiatric-related emergency department visits aged 19 years or younger were eligible. Age, sex, race, ethnicity, insurance status, mode of arrival, length of stay, and disposition were described for psychiatric-related visits and compared with non-psychiatric-related visits. RESULTS: Pediatric psychiatric-related visits accounted for 3.3% of all participating emergency department visits (84,973/2,580,299). Patients with psychiatric-related visits were older (mean +/- SD age, 12.7 +/- 3.9 years vs. 5.9 +/- 5.6 years, P < 0.001), had a higher rate ambulance arrival (19.4% vs 8.2%, P < 0.0001), had a longer median length of stay (3.2 vs 2.1 hours, P < 0.0001), and had a higher rate of admission (30.5% vs 11.2%, P < 0.0001) when compared with non-psychiatric-related patient presentations. Older age, female sex, white race, ambulance arrival, and governmental insurance were factors independently associated with admission or transfer from the emergency department for psychiatric-related visits in multivariate regression analyses. CONCLUSIONS: Pediatric psychiatric-related visits require more prehospital and emergency department resources and have higher admission/transfer rates than non-psychiatric-related visits within a large national pediatric emergency network.

Lessons learned for pediatric disaster preparedness from September 11, 2001: New York City trauma centers.

The assault on the World Trade Center on September 11, 2001, has mandated that there be improved disaster preparedness for both children and adults in the immediate future. Fortunately, the events of September 11, 2001, spared 3,400 near miss children from substantial harm; however, NYC was not well prepared to handle significant numbers of pediatric patients had they been severely injured. Furthermore, there have been several medical sequelae of the attacks that have manifest long after the immediate postevent period. Both respiratory illness and mental health issues have been suffered by children because of the environmental toxins and the trauma of witnessing the event, respectively. The pediatric practitioners in the area did not feel well prepared to handle the increased demand for services. Also at the time, there was no pediatric-specific plan to either evacuate children in need of specialized care to centers with expertise in handling such patients or to mobilize pediatric practitioners (surgeons, critical care physicians, etc.) to the institutions where the masses of children would have initially been brought. Since then, there have been efforts to create educational materials to better prepare hospitals as well as proposals to create mobile pediatric disaster teams to deploy to hospitals in need of support. This review discusses these recognized and unrecognized issues in pediatric disaster preparedness to hopefully foster discussion for future strategies.

Referral and resource use patterns for psychiatric-related visits to pediatric emergency departments.

OBJECTIVE: To describe the patterns of referral and use of resources for patients with psychiatric-related visits presenting to pediatric emergency departments (EDs) in a pediatric research network. METHODS: We conducted a retrospective chart review of a random sample of patients (approximately 10 charts per month per site) who presented with psychiatric-related visits in 2002 to 4 pediatric EDs in the Pediatric Emergency Care Applied Research Network. Emergency department resource use variables evaluated included the use of consultation services, restraints, and laboratory tests as well as ED length of stay. RESULTS: We reviewed 462 patient visits with a psychiatric-related ED diagnosis. Mean (SD) age was 12.8 (3.7) years, 52% were male, and 49% were African American. The most common chief complaints were suicidality (47%), aggression/agitation (42%), and anxiety/depression (27%), alone or in combination. Ninety percent of patients (range across sites, 83%-94%) had a mental health consult in the ED, 5% were restrained (range, 3%-9%), and 35% had a laboratory test performed (range, 15%-63%). Mean (SD) ED length of stay was 5.1 (5.4) hours, and 52% were admitted (93% to a psychiatric bed, including transfers to separate psychiatric facilities). CONCLUSIONS: Children with psychiatric-related visits seem to require substantial ED resources. Interventions are needed to reduce the burden on the ED by increasing the linkage to mental health services, particularly for suicidal youths.

Randomized controlled trial of a pictogram-based intervention to reduce liquid medication dosing errors and improve adherence among caregivers of young children.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the efficacy of a pictogram-based health literacy intervention to decrease liquid medication administration errors by caregivers of young children. DESIGN: Randomized controlled trial. SETTING: Urban public hospital pediatric emergency department. PARTICIPANTS: Parents and caregivers (N = 245) of children aged 30 days to 8 years who were prescribed liquid medications (daily dose or "as needed"). INTERVENTION: Medication counseling using plain language, pictogram-based medication instruction sheets. Control subjects received standard medication counseling. OUTCOME MEASURES: Medication knowledge and practice, dosing accuracy, and adherence. RESULTS: Of 245 randomized caregivers, 227 underwent follow-up assessments (intervention group, 113; control group, 114). Of these, 99 were prescribed a daily dose medication, and 158 were prescribed medication taken as needed. Intervention caregivers had fewer errors in observed dosing accuracy (>20% deviation from prescribed dose) compared with caregivers who received routine counseling (daily dose: 5.4% vs 47.8%; absolute risk reduction [ARR], 42.4% [95% confidence interval, 24.0%-57.0%]; number needed to treat [NNT], 2 [2-4]; as needed: 15.6% vs 40.0%; ARR, 24.4% (8.7%-38.8%); NNT, 4 [3-12]). Of intervention caregivers, 9.3% were nonadherent (ie, did not give within 20% of the total prescribed doses) compared with 38.0% of controls (ARR, 28.7% [11.4%-43.7%]; NNT, 3 [2-9]). Improvements were also seen for knowledge of appropriate preparation for both medication types, as well as knowledge of frequency for those prescribed daily dose medications. CONCLUSION: A plain language, pictogram-based intervention used as part of medication counseling resulted in decreased medication dosing errors and improved adherence among multiethnic, low socioeconomic status caregivers whose children were treated at an urban pediatric emergency department. TRIAL REGISTRATION: clinicaltrials.gov Identifier: NCT00537433.

Disaster preparedness: hospital decontamination and the pediatric patient--guidelines for hospitals and emergency planners.

In recent years, attention has been given to disaster preparedness for first responders and first receivers (hospitals). One such focus involves the decontamination of individuals who have fallen victim to a chemical agent from an attack or an accident involving hazardous materials. Children often are overlooked in disaster planning. Children are vulnerable and have specific medical and psychological requirements. There is a need to develop specific protocols to address pediatric patients who require decontamination at the entrance of hospital emergency departments. Currently, there are no published resources that meet this need. An expert panel convened by the New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene developed policies and procedures for the decontamination of pediatric patients. The panel was comprised of experts from a variety of medical and psychosocial areas. Using an iterative process, the panel created guidelines that were approved by the stakeholders and are presented in this paper. These guidelines must be utilized, studied, and modified to increase the likelihood that they will work during an emergency situation.

Overcoming legal obstacles involving the voluntary care of children who are separated from their legal guardians during a disaster.

A large-scale disaster may separate children from their parents or guardians and may strand many children in the care of temporary caregivers, including physicians and nurses. In general, unless a physician or nurse is a member of a public sector emergency response program (a "VHP"), parental consent is required for the treatment of minors outside of an emergency department unless the minor is suffering from an imminently life-threatening condition. Physicians or nurses who are not VHP's may be held liable (civilly, criminally and administratively) if they provide care without parental consent outside of an emergency room to a child who is not suffering from an imminently life-threatening condition. The existing rules regarding parental consent would, in many cases, limit (or at least discourage) the provision of optimal health care to children in a large-scale disaster by restricting care aimed to alleviate pain, the treatment of chronic conditions as well as the treatment of conditions, or potential conditions, that could worsen or develop in the absence of treatment.Additionally, "Good Samaritan" laws that generally limit the liability of health care providers who voluntarily provide care in an emergency may not apply when care is provided in a crude or makeshift clinic or when care is not provided at the scene of the emergency. Thus, benevolent physicians and nurses who voluntarily provide care during a large-scale disaster unjustly risk liability. The prospect of such liability may substantially deter the provision of optimal medical care to children in a disaster. This article discusses the shortcomings of current laws and proposes revisions to existing state laws. These revisions would create reasonable and appropriate liability rules for physicians and nurses providing gratuitous care in emergencies and thus would create reasonable incentives for health care providers to deliver such care. ("Gratuitous care" is the legal term for care provided voluntarily and without expectation of payment.).

Optimising the role of the public health community in planning and implementing large-scale evacuations.

The public health community must advocate for the design and administration of plans and regulations that protect public health, promote effective medical response in evacuations, and require active participation by public health officials in evacuation planning. The public health response during recent natural disasters has highlighted the inadequacies of meeting the needs of complex populations of vulnerable individuals. Critical issues in the emergency management and public health systems with regard to the evaluation of a population are delineated, and potential solutions are suggested.

Organization-based incident management: developing a disaster volunteer role on a university campus.

BACKGROUND: Catastrophic events are an ongoing part of life, affecting society both locally and globally. Recruitment, development, and retention of volunteers who offer their knowledge and skills in the event of a disaster are essential to ensuring a functional workforce during catastrophes. These opportunities also address the inherent need for individuals to feel necessary and useful in times of crisis. Universities are a particularly important setting for voluntary action, given that they are based in communities and have access to resources and capabilities to bring to bear on an emergency situation. METHODS: The purpose of the study was to discern how one large private organization might participate and respond in the case of a large scale disaster. Using a 2-phase random sample survey, 337 unique respondents (5.7%) out of a sample of 6000 replied to the survey. RESULTS: These data indicate that volunteers in a private organization are willing to assist in disasters and have skills that can be useful in disaster mitigation. DISCUSSION: Much is to be learned related to the deployment of volunteers during disaster. These findings suggest that volunteers can and will help and that disaster preparedness drills are a logical next step for university-based volunteers.

Children requiring psychiatric consultation in the pediatric emergency department: epidemiology, resource utilization, and complications.

METHODS: A cohort of children younger than 18 years presenting to an urban pediatric emergency department (PED) who underwent psychiatric consultation was analyzed. A standardized data collection sheet was prospectively completed and included: patient characteristics, extent of medical evaluation and findings, ancillary diagnostic studies, resources utilized, dangerous behaviors, and disposition. RESULTS: Two hundred ten patients required psychiatric evaluation. Median age was 14 years; 51.9% were boys; 71.9% had a past psychiatric history; 39.0% had prior psychiatric admission(s), and 40.5% were on psychiatric medications. The admission rate was 49.5%. Patients spent a median of 5.7 hours in the PED. Hospital police monitored 51.9% patients. Forty-five patients had 91 dangerous behaviors. Those patients presenting with a complaint of aggressive behavior (P = 0.00006), a past psychiatric history (P = 0.003), or a history of prior psychiatric hospitalization (P = 0.005) were more likely to have dangerous behaviors. Two hundred nine patients underwent a complete medical evaluation, and 207 were considered medically cleared. Patients who had diagnostic evaluations for medically indicated reasons were significantly more likely to have abnormal results than those requested by the psychiatric consultant for screening purposes (43.6% vs. 9.2%; relative risk, 2.33; 95% confidence interval, 1.33-4.08) but were not statistically more likely to result in medical intervention (5.4% vs. 0%, P = 0.243). CONCLUSIONS: PED patients requiring psychiatric consultation and psychiatric admission had a prolonged PED stay and a high incidence of dangerous behaviors requiring intervention. History and physical examination adequately identified medical illness. Laboratory evaluation obtained for psychiatric transfer or admission purposes was of low yield.

Toddlers at risk for paper shredder injury in the home: easy access and severe injury.

A 2-year-old girl sustained severe injury to 2 fingers from a home paper shredder. This case illustrates the risk of injury from paper shredders, which are increasingly common household items. Toddlers are at risk of finger injury and amputation. The US Consumer Product Safety Commission performed an investigation of reported injuries and the characteristics of paper shredders that might have contributed to the injuries, and we summarize their findings.

Education of Out-of-Hospital Emergency Medical Personnel in Pediatrics: Report of a National Task Force.

The Pediatric Education Task Force has developed a list of major topics and skills for inclusion in pediatric curricula for EMS providers. Areas of controversy in the management of pediatric patients in the prehospital setting are outlined, and helpful learning tools are identified. [Gausche M, Henderson DB, Brownstein D, Foltin GL, for the Pediatric Education Task Force: Education of out-of-hospital emergency medical personnel in pediatrics: Report of a National Task Force. Ann Emerg Med January 1998;31:58-64.].

The Avianca plane crash : An emergency medical system's response to pediatric survivors of the disaster

Objective: On January 25, 1990, a jetliner crashed on Long Island, New York. Twenty-two children survived the crash. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the emergency medical system's response to these pediatric survivors. Conclusions:Pediatric survivors were neither adequately triaged not transported to appropriate facilities which could optimize their care. Possible explanations for this include (1) unique features of the rescue operation, (2) limited pediatric training of prehospital personnel, and (3) deficiencies of the regional disaster plan. Emergency medical services systems and disaster plans can be made more responsive to children's needs by (1) acknowledging that children have special needs requiring referral, (2) improving the training of prehospital personnel in pediatric emergency care, (3) classifying ill and injured children according to appropriate triage criteria, (4) recognizing existing tertiary care pediatric centers as the optimal location for the treatment of critically ill and injured children, and (5) designating these ecenters as the appropriate transport destination for critically ill and injured children (AU)