How safe are bioequivalence studies in healthy volunteers?

Between 1981 and 1994, 58 bioequivalence studies (b.s.) were performed in 885 healthy volunteers. 93.1 per cent were single-dose, mainly of two way cross-over design. According to ATC groups, 13 were of cardiovascular drugs(C), 11 musculoskeletal (M), nine alimentary (A), seven urogenital (G), seven antimicrobial (J), six haematological (B), three nervous (N) and two respiratory (R). 97.2 per cent of volunteers finished the studies. Out of 25 withdrawals, 14 did it by their own will, seven were excluded because of lack of compliance with the protocol, one because of an adverse drug reaction (ADR) (preputial oedema), one because of intercurrent illness, and two for other objective reasons. In 35 studies the probants have been males, in 23 both sexes. Subjects were between 18 and 40 years. 209 adverse events were reported in 18 studies (31 per cent). From 885 volunteers that came to first session at the time, 115 (13 per cent) had ADRs. The association of the drug and ADRs was defined as probable in 91 ADRs (45.9 per cent), definite in 66 (33.4 per cent) and possible in 41 (20.7 per cent). 73 (63.5 per cent) volunteers had one ADR, 22 (19.1 per cent) had two and 20 (17.4 per cent) more than two ADRs. The majority -117 (56 per cent)-of ADRs were mild, 78 (37.3 per cent) moderate and 14 (6.7 per cent) severe. The most frequent ADR was headache (22.9 per cent), followed by nasal congestion (12.9 per cent), sweating (12.4 per cent), nausea (6.7 per cent), restlessness (6.7 per cent), deafness and tinnitus (6.2 per cent), change of biochemical or haematological parameters (5.3 per cent) and other. An unusual and rare ADR was impotence and preputial oedema (two volunteers on frusemide). All studies of G group (7-100 per cent) had ADRs, followed by C group (5-38 per cent) and A (3-33 per cent). Glipizide (5 mg) had highest number of ADRs (64-30.6 per cent), bromocriptine (10 mg) had 31 (14.8 per cent) and frusemide (500 mg) 22 (10.6 per cent). The largest number of subjects with ADRs were on frusemide (13-72 per cent), glipizide (17-68 per cent) and bromocriptine (15-52 per cent). At a time when generic drugs are of increasing importance, the safety of b.s. is of considerable interest. Our data confirm their safety and indicate that the majority of ADRs are mild.

Adverse drug reactions resulting in hospital admission.

A 14-month (1992/3) prospective study was performed in two departments of the University Hospital Centre (UHC) in Zagreb. The aim of the study was to assess the rate of drug-related hospitalizations, drugs that caused adverse drug reactions (ADRs), and all factors which could have been of importance for their appearance. One hundred and thirty (2.5%) of 5,227 patients were admitted to hospital because of ADRs. The most frequently ADR-related drugs were nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs and analgesics (64.6%). They were followed by cardiovascular agents (20.8%) and antimicrobials (3.8%). Acetylsalicylic acid (aspirin) caused 38.5% of hospital admissions, other nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) 23.1% and medigoxin 15.4% of hospitalizations. The most frequent ADRs were upper gastro-intestinal tract bleeding (64.6%), cardiac rhythm disturbances (13.9%), blood cell disorders (4.6%) and hypoglycemia (2.3%). Regarding the patients' age, 52.3% of patients was younger and 47.7% older than 65. Sixty-one point five percent of patients was taking more than one drug, older patients (48 patients--77.4%) have been taking a significantly higher number of drugs than the younger (32 patients--47.1%) (p < 0.0001) ones. Drug interactions caused 23.8% of ADRs. Only 11 (8.5%) of patients suspected themselves that the drug might have caused the ADR. Improvement was observed in the majority of patients (65.4%), 25.4% recovered completely, 4 (3.0%) died in the hospital because of ADRs. 3.0% of patients as well died of their underlying diseases, 2.3% were transferred to other departments for their underlying diseases, and one patient left the hospital on his free will.