Measuring and Managing Healthcare Supply and Demand in Real-Time.

Measuring the supply and demand for access to and wait-times for healthcare is key to managing healthcare services and allocating resources appropriately. Yet, few jurisdictions in distributed, socialized medicine settings have any way to do so. In this paper, we propose the requirements for a jurisdictional patient scheduling system that can measure key metrics, such as supply of and demand for regulated health care professional care, access to and wait times for care, real-time health system utilization and provide the data to compute patient journeys. The system is also capable of tracking new supply of providers and who does not have access to a primary care provider. Benefits, limitations and risks of the model are discussed.

A Framework for Implementing Disease Prevention and Behavior Change Evidence at Scale.

The current corpus of evidence-based information for chronic disease prevention and treatment is vast and growing rapidly. Behavior change theories are increasingly more powerful but difficult to operationalize in the current healthcare system. Millions of Canadians are unable to access personalized preventive and behavior change care because our in-person model of care is running at full capacity and is not set up for mass education and behavior change programs. We propose a framework to utilize data from electronic medical records to identify patients at risk of developing chronic disease and reach out to them using digital health tools that are overseen by the primary care team. The framework leverages emerging technologies such as artificial intelligence, digital health tools, and patient-generated data to deliver evidence-based knowledge and behavior change to patients across Canada at scale. The framework is flexible to enable new technologies to be added without overwhelming providers, patients or implementers.

Towards a Regulatory Framework for Workflow Improvement in Electronic Medical Records.

Physicians have to complete several time-consuming and burnout-inducing tasks in their EMRs for everyday care of patients. Poor workflow design generates increased effort for physicians. In this study, we measure time doctors take to retrieve and review information in the patient chart at the beginning of a visit; one of approximately 12 tasks a doctor must do in the EMR during the visit. Information retrieval takes approximately 40 minutes per day. Automation could save 75% of that time. We estimate that if every family doctor in Canada could save 30 minutes through automation of just this one process, we could free up time equivalent to >3000 physicians and >5 million patients; enough to absorb the vast majority of patients who currently do not have a doctor. We know of no more powerful intervention than workflow automation in Canadian EMRs to increase the supply of doctors while simultaneously reducing a major cause of burnout. We recommend an accelerated research program to identify additional opportunities for workflow automation and a regulatory program to ensure that every physician has access to workflow automation in their EMR.

Towards a Regulatory Framework for Electronic Medical Record Interoperability in Canada.

All complex systems are potentially predisposed to failure. Healthcare systems are complex systems that are prone to many errors that can result in dire consequences for patients and healthcare providers. The healthcare system in Canada is under unprecedented strain due to shortages of healthcare providers, provider burnout, inefficient workflows, and a lack of appropriate digital infrastructure. We used failure mode and effects analysis (FMEA) to identify the failure modes for care provided in primary care settings. We identified failure modes in appointment scheduling, patient-provider communications, referrals, laboratory and diagnostic procedures, and medication prescriptions as the main failure modes. To mitigate the detected risks, we recommend solutions to 'close the loop' on failure modes to prevent patients from falling through the cracks, as vulnerable patients who cannot advocate for themselves are most likely to do so. We provide preliminary requirements for a regulatory regime for electronic health records that can reduce provider burnout, improve regulatory compliance, and improve system efficiency, all while improving patient safety, experience, and outcomes.

Validation of a Design Architecture to Deliver Health Management and Behavior Change Evidence at Scale.

Forty-four percent of Canadians over the age of 20 have a non-communicable disease (NCD). Millions of Canadians are at risk of developing the complications of NCDs; millions have already experienced those complications. Fortunately, the evidence base for NCD prevention and behavior change is large and growing and digital technologies can deliver them at scale and with high fidelity. However, the current model of in-person primary care is not designed nor capable of operationalizing that evidence. New developments in artificial intelligence that can predict who will develop NCD or the complications of NCD are increasingly available, making the challenge of delivering disease prevention even more urgent. This paper presents findings from stakeholder engagement on a design architecture to address three initial barriers to large-scale deployment of health management and behavior change evidence: 1) the challenges of regulating mobile health apps, 2) the challenge of creating a value-based rationale for payers to invest in deploying mobile health apps at scale, and 3) the high cost of customer acquisition for delivering mobile health apps to those at risk.

Artificial intelligence with temporal features outperforms machine learning in predicting diabetes.

Diabetes mellitus type 2 is increasingly being called a modern preventable pandemic, as even with excellent available treatments, the rate of complications of diabetes is rapidly increasing. Predicting diabetes and identifying it in its early stages could make it easier to prevent, allowing enough time to implement therapies before it gets out of control. Leveraging longitudinal electronic medical record (EMR) data with deep learning has great potential for diabetes prediction. This paper examines the predictive competency of deep learning models in contrast to state-of-the-art machine learning models to incorporate the time dimension of risk. The proposed research investigates a variety of deep learning models and features for predicting diabetes. Model performance was appraised and compared in relation to predominant features, risk factors, training data density and visit history. The framework was implemented on the longitudinal EMR records of over 19K patients extracted from the Canadian Primary Care Sentinel Surveillance Network (CPCSSN). Empirical findings demonstrate that deep learning models consistently outperform other state-of-the-art competitors with prediction accuracy of above 91%, without overfitting. Fasting blood sugar, hemoglobin A1c and body mass index are the key predictors of future onset of diabetes. Overweight, middle aged patients and patients with hypertension are more vulnerable to developing diabetes, consistent with what is already known. Model performance improves as training data density or the visit history of a patient increases. This study confirms the ability of the LSTM deep learning model to incorporate the time dimension of risk in its predictive capabilities.

Multi-Input Multi-Output Dynamic Modelling of Type 2 Diabetes Progression.

Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus (T2D) is a chronic health condition that affects millions of people globally. Early identification of risk can support preventive intervention and therefore slow down disease progression. Risk characterization is also necessary to monitor the mechanisms behind the pathology through the analysis of the interrelationships between the predictors and their time course. In this work, a multi-input multi-output Gaussian Process model is proposed to describe the evolution of different biomarkers in patients who will/will not develop T2D considering the interdependencies between outputs. The preliminary results obtained suggest that the trends in biomarkers captured by the model are coherent with the literature and with real-world data, demonstrating the value of multi-input multi-output approaches. In future developments, the proposed method could be applied to assess how the biomarkers evolve and interact with each other in groups of patients having in common one or more risk factors.

Characterization of Inclination Analysis for Predicting Onset of Heart Failure from Primary Care Electronic Medical Records.

The aim of this study is to characterize the performance of an inclination analysis for predicting the onset of heart failure (HF) from routinely collected clinical biomarkers extracted from primary care electronic medical records. A balanced dataset of 698 patients (with/without HF), including a minimum of five longitudinal measures of nine biomarkers (body mass index, diastolic and systolic blood pressure, fasting glucose, glycated hemoglobin, low-density and high-density lipoproteins, total cholesterol, and triglycerides) is used. The proposed algorithm achieves an accuracy of 0.89 (sensitivity of 0.89, specificity of 0.90) to predict the inclination of biomarkers (i.e., their trend towards a 'survival' or 'collapse' as defined by an inclination analysis) on a labeled, balanced dataset of 40 patients. Decision trees trained on the predicted inclination of biomarkers have significantly higher recall (0.69 vs. 0.53) and significantly higher negative predictive value (0.60 vs. 0.55) than those trained on the average values computed from the measures of biomarkers available before the onset of the disease, suggesting that an inclination analysis can help identify the onset of HF in the primary care patient population from routinely available clinical data. This exploratory study provides the basis for further investigations of inclination analyses to identify at-risk patients and generate preventive measures (i.e., personalized recommendations to reverse the trend of biomarkers towards collapse).

A novel method to derive personalized minimum viable recommendations for type 2 diabetes prevention based on counterfactual explanations.

Despite the growing availability of artificial intelligence models for predicting type 2 diabetes, there is still a lack of personalized approaches to quantify minimum viable changes in biomarkers that may help reduce the individual risk of developing disease. The aim of this article is to develop a new method, based on counterfactual explanations, to generate personalized recommendations to reduce the one-year risk of type 2 diabetes. Ten routinely collected biomarkers extracted from Electronic Medical Records of 2791 patients at low risk and 2791 patients at high risk of type 2 diabetes were analyzed. Two regions characterizing the two classes of patients were estimated using a Support Vector Data Description classifier. Counterfactual explanations (i.e., minimal changes in input features able to change the risk class) were generated for patients at high risk and evaluated using performance metrics (availability, validity, actionability, similarity, and discriminative power) and a qualitative survey administered to seven expert clinicians. Results showed that, on average, the requested minimum viable changes implied a significant reduction of fasting blood sugar, systolic blood pressure, and triglycerides and a significant increase of high-density lipoprotein in patients at risk of diabetes. A significant reduction in body mass index was also recommended in most of the patients at risk, except in females without hypertension. In general, greater changes were recommended in hypertensive patients compared to non-hypertensive ones. The experts were overall satisfied with the proposed approach although in some cases the proposed recommendations were deemed insufficient to reduce the risk in a clinically meaningful way. Future research will focus on a larger set of biomarkers and different comorbidities, also incorporating clinical guidelines whenever possible. Development of additional mathematical and clinical validation approaches will also be of paramount importance.

High cardiovascular disease risk-associated with the incidence of Type 2 diabetes among prediabetics.

BACKGROUND: Prediabetes is a risk factor for developing Type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2D). We report on the first cohort study of the association between high cardiovascular diseases (CVD) risk with the incidence of T2D in prediabetics. First, estimate the direct effect of developing T2D on patients with prediabetes who have high CVDs risk; and 2) assess the potential increased risk of developing T2D mediated by statins. METHODS: We conducted a population-based cohort study using a subset of data from the Canadian Primary Care Sentinel Surveillance Network (CPCSSN) from 2000 to 2015. Cox proportional hazards (PH) regressions were conducted to estimate our primary outcome, which is the time to T2D among patients with prediabetes. RESULTS: From the 4995 filtered prediabetic participants identified between 2000 and 2015, 2800 participants were diagnosed with high CVDs risk scores as measured by the Framingham risk score. 2195 participants were non-high CVDs risk controls. The covariate-adjusted hazard ratio (HR) of 1.24 [95% confidence interval (CI), 1.10-1.31] for T2D by CVDs risk among prediabetics was observed. The total effect of CVDs risk on developing T2D was decomposed to a natural direct effect of high CVDs risk HR= 1.18 [95% CI, 1.01-1.48] and an indirect effect through statin therapy of HR= 1.06 [95% CI, 0.97-1.30]. CONCLUSION: Patients with prediabetes and high CVDs risk had a 24% higher chance of developing T2D. The high CVDs risk effect was mediated by statin therapy. Regular monitoring and counselling of prediabetics using statins is likely warranted to prevent the incidence of T2D.

Design for a Virtual Peer-to-Peer Knowledge to Action Platform for Type 2 Diabetes.

Many patients with Type 2 Diabetes (T2D) have difficulty in controlling their disease despite wide-spread availability of high-quality guidelines, T2D education programs and primary care follow-up programs. Current diabetes education and treatment programs translate knowledge from bench to bedside well, but underperform on the 'last-mile' of converting that knowledge into action (KTA). Two innovations to the last-mile problem in management of patients with T2D are introduced. 1) Design of a platform for peer-to-peer groups where patients can solve KTA problems together in a structured and psychologically safe environment using all the elements of the Action Cycle phase of the KTA framework. The platform uses Self-Determination Theory as the behavior change theory. 2) A novel patient segmentation method to enable the formation of groups of patients who have similar behavioral characteristics and therefore who are more likely to find common cause in the fight against diabetes.

Improving Shared Decision-Making Using Cognitive Effort-Optimization.

Diabetes Prevention Programs (DPPs) can prevent or delay type 2 diabetes (T2D). However, the participation rates in DPPs have been limited. Many individuals at risk of developing diabetes have difficulties making healthy choices because of the cognitive effort required to understand the risks, the role of biomarkers, the consequences of inaction and the actions required to delay or avoid development of T2D. We report on the design and development of a prototype digital tool that decreases cognitive effort for people at risk of developing T2D using the effort-optimized intervention framework.

Characterization of Type 2 Diabetes Using Counterfactuals and Explainable AI.

Type 2 diabetes mellitus is a metabolic disorder of glucose management, whose prevalence is increasing inexorably worldwide. Adherence to therapies, along with a healthy lifestyle can help prevent the onset of disease. This preliminary study proposes the use of explainable artificial intelligence techniques with the aim of (i) characterizing diabetic patients through a set of easily interpretable rules and (ii) providing individualized recommendations for the prevention of the onset of the disease through the generation of counterfactual explanations, based on minimal variations of biomarkers routinely collected in primary care. The results of this preliminary study parallel findings from the literature as differences in biomarkers between patients with and without diabetes are observed for fasting blood sugar, body mass index, and high-density lipoprotein levels.

Behavioral Segmentation for Enhanced Peer-to-Peer Patient Education.

The aim of this study was to develop a peer-to-peer virtual intervention for patients with type 2 diabetes from different segments: patients who take several medications (medication group), patients who do not take diabetes medications (lifestyle group), and a mixed group. Preliminary results showed that patients in the lifestyle group were interested in preventive strategies, reporting better learning experience and higher motivation than those in the medication group. Future research is needed to design approaches tailored to patients in the medication group.

Comparison of Empirical Mode Decomposition, Wavelets, and Different Machine Learning Approaches for Patient-Specific Seizure Detection Using Signal-Derived Empirical Dictionary Approach.

Analysis of long-term multichannel EEG signals for automatic seizure detection is an active area of research that has seen application of methods from different domains of signal processing and machine learning. The majority of approaches developed in this context consist of extraction of hand-crafted features that are used to train a classifier for eventual seizure detection. Approaches that are data-driven, do not use hand-crafted features, and use small amounts of patients' historical EEG data for classifier training are few in number. The approach presented in this paper falls in the latter category, and is based on a signal-derived empirical dictionary approach, which utilizes empirical mode decomposition (EMD) and discrete wavelet transform (DWT) based dictionaries learned using a framework inspired by traditional methods of dictionary learning. Three features associated with traditional dictionary learning approaches, namely projection coefficients, coefficient vector and reconstruction error, are extracted from both EMD and DWT based dictionaries for automated seizure detection. This is the first time these features have been applied for automatic seizure detection using an empirical dictionary approach. Small amounts of patients' historical multi-channel EEG data are used for classifier training, and multiple classifiers are used for seizure detection using newer data. In addition, the seizure detection results are validated using 5-fold cross-validation to rule out any bias in the results. The CHB-MIT benchmark database containing long-term EEG recordings of pediatric patients is used for validation of the approach, and seizure detection performance comparable to the state-of-the-art is obtained. Seizure detection is performed using five classifiers, thereby allowing a comparison of the dictionary approaches, features extracted, and classifiers used. The best seizure detection performance is obtained using EMD based dictionary and reconstruction error feature and support vector machine classifier, with accuracy, sensitivity and specificity values of 88.2, 90.3, and 88.1%, respectively. Comparison is also made with other recent studies using the same database. The methodology presented in this paper is shown to be computationally efficient and robust for patient-specific automatic seizure detection. A data-driven methodology utilizing a small amount of patients' historical data is hence demonstrated as a practical solution for automatic seizure detection.

FIUS: Fixed partitioning undersampling method.

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: In the medical field, data techniques for prediction and finding patterns of prevalent diseases are of increasing interest. Classification is one of the methods used to provide insight into predicting the future onset of type 2 diabetes of those at high risk of progression from pre-diabetes to diabetes. When applying classification techniques to real-world datasets, imbalanced class distribution has been one of the most significant limitations that leads to patients' misclassification. In this paper, we propose a novel balancing method to improve the prediction performance of type 2 diabetes mellitus in imbalanced electronic medical records (EMR). METHODS: A novel undersampling method is proposed by utilizing a fixed partitioning distribution scheme in a regular grid. The proposed approach retains valuable information when balancing methods are applied to datasets. RESULTS: The best AUC of 80% compared to other classifiers was obtained from the logistic regression (LR) classifier for EMR by applying our proposed undersampling method to balance the data. The new method improved the performance of the LR classifier compared to existing undersampling methods used in the balancing stage. CONCLUSION: The results demonstrate the effectiveness and high performance of the proposed method for predicting diabetes in a Canadian imbalanced dataset. Our methodology can be used in other areas to overcome the limitations of imbalanced class distributions.

Predictive models for diabetes mellitus using machine learning techniques.

BACKGROUND: Diabetes Mellitus is an increasingly prevalent chronic disease characterized by the body's inability to metabolize glucose. The objective of this study was to build an effective predictive model with high sensitivity and selectivity to better identify Canadian patients at risk of having Diabetes Mellitus based on patient demographic data and the laboratory results during their visits to medical facilities. METHODS: Using the most recent records of 13,309 Canadian patients aged between 18 and 90 years, along with their laboratory information (age, sex, fasting blood glucose, body mass index, high-density lipoprotein, triglycerides, blood pressure, and low-density lipoprotein), we built predictive models using Logistic Regression and Gradient Boosting Machine (GBM) techniques. The area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AROC) was used to evaluate the discriminatory capability of these models. We used the adjusted threshold method and the class weight method to improve sensitivity - the proportion of Diabetes Mellitus patients correctly predicted by the model. We also compared these models to other learning machine techniques such as Decision Tree and Random Forest. RESULTS: The AROC for the proposed GBM model is 84.7% with a sensitivity of 71.6% and the AROC for the proposed Logistic Regression model is 84.0% with a sensitivity of 73.4%. The GBM and Logistic Regression models perform better than the Random Forest and Decision Tree models. CONCLUSIONS: The ability of our model to predict patients with Diabetes using some commonly used lab results is high with satisfactory sensitivity. These models can be built into an online computer program to help physicians in predicting patients with future occurrence of diabetes and providing necessary preventive interventions. The model is developed and validated on the Canadian population which is more specific and powerful to apply on Canadian patients than existing models developed from US or other populations. Fasting blood glucose, body mass index, high-density lipoprotein, and triglycerides were the most important predictors in these models.

Prognostic Modeling and Prevention of Diabetes Using Machine Learning Technique.

Stratifying individuals at risk for developing diabetes could enable targeted delivery of interventional programs to those at highest risk, while avoiding the effort and costs of prevention and treatment in those at low risk. The objective of this study was to explore the potential role of a Hidden Markov Model (HMM), a machine learning technique, in validating the performance of the Framingham Diabetes Risk Scoring Model (FDRSM), a well-respected prognostic model. Can HMM predict 8-year risk of developing diabetes in an individual effectively? To our knowledge, no study has attempted use of HMM to validate the performance of FDRSM. We used Electronic Medical Record (EMR) data, of 172,168 primary care patients to derive the 8-year risk of developing diabetes in an individual using HMM. The Area Under Receiver Operating Characteristic Curve (AROC) in our study sample of 911 individuals for whom all risk factors and follow up data were available is 86.9% compared to AROCs of 78.6% and 85% reported in a previously conducted validation study of FDRSM in the same Canadian population and the Framingham study respectively. These results demonstrate that the discrimination capability of our proposed HMM is superior to the validation study conducted using the FDRSM in a Canadian population and in the Framingham population. We conclude that HMM is capable of identifying patients at increased risk of developing diabetes within the next 8-years.

Patient Empowerment: The Role of Technology.

Patient empowerment is a buzzword that has gained much currency in recent years. It is defined as a process that helps people gain control over their own lives and increases their capacity to act on issues that they themselves define as important. This paper outlines the problems faced by the current medical model of patient empowerment and proposes a unique framework for patient empowerment that provides guidance on how health technology supports or detracts from empowering patients and families. The paper provides an ethical lens for physicians, policymakers, patients, and families in the health care system to consider the central role of the principles of autonomy and justice in patient empowerment. This paper also discusses how technology can be used to further patient empowerment and patient-centeredness of health care systems.