Assimilating South African medical students trained in Cuba into the South African medical education system: reflections from an identity perspective.

BACKGROUND: In terms of the Nelson Mandela Fidel Castro Medical Collaboration programme, an agreement between the governments of South Africa and Cuba, cohorts of South African students receive their initial five years medical training at a Cuban university before returning to South Africa for a six to twelve months orientation before integration into the local final year class. It is common for these students to experience academic difficulty on their return. Frequently this is viewed merely as a matter of a knowledge deficit. DISCUSSION: We argue that the problem arises from a fundamental divergence in the outcomes of the Cuban and South African medical curricula, each of which is designed with a particular healthcare system in mind. Using the discrepancy theory of identity proposed by Higgins in 1987, we discuss the challenges experienced by the returning Nelson Mandela Fidel Castro Medical Collaboration students in terms of a potential crisis of identity and suggest interventions which may prove valuable in promoting academic success and successful integration. CONCLUSIONS: Though providing additional training to address the gap in skills and knowledge in returning students is an important part of their successful reintegration, this could be insufficient on its own and must be complemented by a range of measures designed to ameliorate the discrepancies in identity which arise from the transition from one educational model to another.

Molecular characterization of erythropoietic protoporphyria in South Africa.

BACKGROUND: Erythropoietic protoporphyria (EPP) results from a partial deficiency of ferrochelatase (FECH). Clinical expression normally requires coinheritance of a common hypomorphic FECH allele (IVS3-48C) in trans to a deleterious (primary) FECH mutation. OBJECTIVES: To characterize South African subjects with EPP, by identification and assessment of FECH sequence variations, including the IVS3-48C polymorphism. METHODS: Polymerase chain reaction amplification, single-strand conformational polymorphism analysis and restriction endonuclease analysis were employed to identify and determine the frequencies of FECH sequence variations, including the IVS3-48C polymorphism, in a study cohort of symptomatic and asymptomatic South African EPP family members, and a matched control cohort. RESULTS: We identified 29 patients from 18 families. With the exception of one family, who may represent a phenocopy of EPP, the presentation of EPP was typical. All were of European immigrant stock, and we have not identified EPP in other ethnic groups. Ten sequence variations were identified, including four apparent disease-causing mutations, the IVS3-48T/C polymorphism and five further polymorphisms. The molecular basis of EPP was established for 15 of the 17 families. A 5-bp deletion in exon 7 (757_761delAGAAG) was present in 12 of these families and haplotype studies in these families suggested a single mutational event and thus a local founder effect for this deletion. The other mutations were family specific and included two previously described splice-site mutations (IVS3+2T>G and IVS7+1G>A) and a novel 7-bp deletion in exon 4 (356_362delTTCAAGA). CONCLUSIONS: The IVS3-48C allele appears to modulate the phenotypic expression of EPP in the South African EPP cohort as observed in other populations.

A structured assessment of newly qualified medical graduates.

INTRODUCTION: While there is extensive published experience with the assessment of procedural skills in undergraduate students, this is limited in newly qualified medical graduates at the time of entry to the pre-registration (internship) year. The few studies that have been published suggest that these skills are frequently deficient when objectively tested. We therefore chose to assess the competence of a group of South African medical graduates on entry to their pre-registration year. METHODS: A total of 58 graduates of South African medical schools were assessed. Each subject participated in a 7-station objective structured clinical examination (OSCE); 6 of these assessed individual competence in phlebotomy, intramuscular injection, female pelvic examination, bladder catheterisation, tracheal intubation and prescription writing, while competence in cardiopulmonary resuscitation was assessed in a seventh station in randomly allocated teams of 3 candidates. Candidates' opinions of their own competence was sought by questionnaire. RESULTS: There was a wide variation in competence between subjects and across the range of tasks studied. Mean scores ranged from 85.4% for phlebotomy to 55.3% for prescription writing. The average score across all stations was 67.5%, and no student obtained an overall cut-off score of 85% or more, which was established using a modified Angoff method. Subjects' assessment of their own performance was unduly optimistic; most believed that they had demonstrated competence despite clear shortcomings in technique. Objective scores for subjects who had been exposed to a structured skills laboratory programme were not significantly higher than for those who had not, although their self-assessed performance was indeed higher. DISCUSSION: Most of the South African medical graduates who participated in this study were unable to satisfactorily perform technical procedures appropriate to the house officer on entry to the pre-registration year. This is in line with the conclusions of the few studies published in other countries. We suggest that the learning outcomes of undergraduate medical programmes should include an explicit statement of the competencies required for practice in the pre-registration year, and that these should be adequately taught and rigorously assessed before graduation.

A systematic study of the clinical and biochemical expression of variegate porphyria in a large South African family.

BACKGROUND: Variegate porphyria (VP) is an autosomal dominant disorder associated with deficient haem synthesis. Recent reports indicate that the clinical penetrance of VP may have been overestimated in studies which predated the availability of DNA-based testing for VP. OBJECTIVES: To undertake a study specifically designed to assess the clinical and biochemical penetrance of VP in a kindred characterized by gene status. METHODS: We studied a large family carrying the South African founder mutation which is known to result in almost complete haplodeficiency. All informative members were tested for the R59W mutation. Biochemical evidence of porphyria was sought by porphyrin analysis and by plasma fluorescence scanning. The presence of clinically expressed porphyria was assessed using a structured questionnaire and telephone or personal interview. RESULTS: Of 62 informative subjects, 33 had inherited the mutation. Of 28 adults, one subject had experienced a single acute attack. She and a further 10 subjects had experienced photosensitivity. The frequency of acute attacks in this family is therefore 4% (95% confidence interval, CI 1-18%), and of photosensitivity is 39.3% (95% CI 24-58%). The sensitivity and specificity of porphyrin analysis in this family were 0.46 (95% CI 0.30-0.64) and 1.00 (95% CI 0.85-1.00), respectively, and for plasma scanning the values were 0.85 (95% CI 0.58-0.96) and 1.00 (95% CI 0.72-1.00), respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The clinical penetrance of VP in our family is approximately 40%. Many more subjects with VP are diagnosed in an asymptomatic phase than previously, and the acute attack is now an uncommon manifestation of VP. Plasma scanning is more sensitive than faecal porphyrin analysis, but neither is sufficiently sensitive for the detection of carrier status.

Administration of oral activated charcoal in variegate porphyria results in a paradoxical clinical and biochemical deterioration.

BACKGROUND: Porphyrinogens are the obligate intracellular precursors of haem. These compounds are, however, unstable and are easily oxidized to the corresponding porphyrins, which are the form in which they are usually measured in the laboratory. A substantial enterohepatic cycling of porphyrins has been shown. Administration of oral activated charcoal, by interrupting this cycle, may reduce plasma and urine porphyrin levels in patients with some forms of porphyria. The effect of charcoal in subjects with variegate porphyria (VP) has not been reported. OBJECTIVES: To determine the clinical and biochemical effects of the administration of oral activated charcoal in patients with VP. METHODS: Oral activated charcoal was administered to eight subjects with VP. Clinical activity was assessed by skin lesion counts fortnightly for 6 weeks, 6 weeks after cessation of therapy, and during a subsequent 6-week control period during which no charcoal was taken. Urine and plasma porphyrins and urine precursors were measured by standard techniques. RESULTS: Treatment resulted in a significant increase in skin disease, urine and plasma porphyrins. CONCLUSIONS: Oral charcoal administration results in a paradoxical aggravation of VP, suggesting a complex and as yet undefined interaction of hepatic porphyrin metabolism and bowel porphyrin reabsorption. Oral sorbents should not be prescribed to subjects with VP.

Porphyria cutanea tarda: the etiological importance of mutations in the HFE gene and viral infection is population-dependent.

A number of factors, including increased iron stores and alcohol consumption, are known to be associated with the development of porphyria cutanea tarda (PCT) in susceptible individuals. Recent reports have described a significant association between inheritance of the C282Y and H63D mutations in the HFE gene, associated with genetic hemochromatosis (GH) and PCT. A strong association between hepatitis C virus infection and PCT has also been demonstrated, while case reports record a link between human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) and PCT. We have investigated the frequency of these factors in a racially-mixed population of patients with PCT in Cape Town, South Africa. 57 patients with PCT drawn from three ethnic groups were screened for the presence of the C282Y and H63D mutations linked to GH, and the prevalences were compared with corresponding healthy control populations. The seroprevalence of markers for HCV, hepatitis B (HBV) and HIV infection were examined in 28 of these. In the control populations, we found that both the C282Y and H63D mutations are highly prevalent in South Africans of European origin. In a population of mixed or Asian origin, the C282Y mutation is very rare whereas the H63D mutation is common. Neither mutation was encountered in any African subject. Both mutations are associated with PCT, but the association is dependent on the ethnic origins of the population to which the patient belongs. In contrast to other studies, HCV infection is numerically unimportant in PCT in our patients. HIV infection is increasingly encountered in our patients with PCT, but the strength of the association cannot be determined in view of the high background prevalence of HIV infection in some sectors of the South African population. The contribution of specific risk factors may be heavily dependent on the population from which patients are drawn, and care should be taken in extrapolating from observations in one racial or geographic population to any other.

Treatment of acute porphyria.

Haem preparations are now available for the specific treatment of attacks of acute porphyria. This review focuses on their use in this uncommon but life-threatening medical emergency.

Identification of the first variegate porphyria mutation in an indigenous black South African and further evidence for heterogeneity in variegate porphyria.

Variegate porphyria is an autosomal dominant disorder of haem metabolism resulting from reduced levels of the penultimate enzyme in the pathway, protoporphyrinogen oxidase. Here we investigate the molecular basis of variegate porphyria in four non-R59W South African families. We report the identification of the first mutation in the protoporphyrinogen oxidase gene in a black South African individual (V290M). In addition, we document three further mutations, a missense mutation (L15F), a deletion followed by a substitution [c769delG;770T > A], and a nonsense mutation (Q375X), in individuals of European or mixed ancestry. Our data provide further evidence of genetic heterogeneity in South Africa.

Homozygous variegate porphyria in South Africa: genotypic analysis in two cases.

Variegate porphyria is an autosomal dominant disorder of heme metabolism which results from decreased activity of the enzyme protoporphyrinogen oxidase. Clinically, the disease manifests postpubertally and is characterized by photocutaneous sensitivity and/or acute neurovisceral crises. However, in homozygous variegate porphyria, onset of the disease usually occurs in infancy with severe skin manifestations. The molecular basis of variegate porphyria in two severely affected probands in two South African families is described. Mutation detection included combined SSCP-heteroduplex analysis followed by direct sequencing. The unrelated probands both had the common R59W mutation while the other lesion was Y348C or R138P (both novel mutations), causing homozygous variegate porphyria.

Identification and characterisation of a deletion (537delAT) in the protoporphyrinogen oxidase gene in a South African variegate porphyria family.

Variegate porphyria is an autosomal dominant disorder of haem metabolism resulting from a partial decrease in protoporphyrinogen oxidase activity. Variegate porphyria is highly prevalent in South Africa, the result of a founder effect now confirmed genetically as a single point mutation (R59W) which has been described in nearly all South African variegate porphyria patients studied. Only two other mutations (H20P, R168C) have been reported in South Africa. We utilised simultaneous, single-stranded conformational polymorphism and heteroduplex analysis, and direct sequencing to identify a further mutation; a 2 bp deletion in exon 6 which results in a premature stop codon 11 codons downstream from the mutation and is the first reported deletion in the protoporphyrinogen oxidase gene in a South African family. The familial segregation of this mutation strongly suggests that it is the disease causing mutation for variegate porphyria in this family. This further evidence for allelic heterogeneity limits the utility of tests for the R59W mutation in the diagnosis of variegate porphyria in South Africa.

Variegate porphyria.

Variegate porphyria is an autosomal dominant inherited trait resulting in decreased activity of protoporphyrinogen oxidase. It is characterized clinically by photosensitive skin disease and a propensity to acute neurovisceral crises. The disease is found worldwide but has an exceptionally high frequency in South Africa. The gene for human protoporphyrinogen oxidase has been identified and sequenced, and several mutations in the protoporphyrinogen oxidase gene sequence have been identified. In South Africa, fewer patients now present with acute attacks, leaving a greater proportion with skin disease or asymptomatic disease. Acute attacks of variegate porphyria appear to be less easily provoked and to be milder than those associated with acute intermittent porphyria.

Identification of two novel mutations in the hydroxymethylbilane synthase gene in three patients from two unrelated families with acute intermittent porphyria.

We have screened the hydroxymethylbilane synthase cDNAs of 3 patients from 2 families suffering from acute intermittent porphyria (AIP) from Scotland and South Africa using heteroduplex and chemical cleavage of mismatch analyses. Direct sequencing was used to characterise the mutations. The two novel mutations identified were a missense mutation at nucleotide position 64 in exon 3 (R22C) and a single base-pair deletion in exon 15. These mutations are predicted to affect the normal function of the enzyme and, therefore, are expected to be the primary cause of disease in these patients.

Acute intermittent porphyria: the in vitro expression of mutant hydroxymethylbilane synthase.

Acute intermittent porphyria (AIP) is an inborn error of haem biosynthesis caused by a variety of mutations in the gene coding for hydroxymethylbilane synthase (HMB-S). The entire coding sequence of this gene, from each of three South African AIP patients, was therefore screened for mutations using chemical cleavage mismatch (CCM) analysis and any changes detected characterized by DNA sequencing. Three single base changes were identified; a G77 to A in exon 3, a C346 to T in exon 8 and a G518 to A in exon 10. These missense mutations, previously reported to be present in other populations, are known to be responsible for the structurally deleterious amino acid replacements R26H, R116W and R173Q, respectively. The in vitro expression of the enzymes containing these mutations and the subsequent measurement of their specific activities revealed a reduction to approximately 4% of normal activity.

Variegate porphyria in South Africa, 1688-1996--new developments in an old disease.

Variegate porphyria, an autosomal dominant inherited trait resulting in decreased activity of protoporphyrinogen oxidase, the penultimate haem biosynthetic enzyme, is characterised clinically by photosensitive skin disease and a propensity to acute neurovisceral crises. The disease has an exceptionally high frequency in South Africa, owing to a founder effect. The specific mutation in the protoporphyrinogen oxidase gene sequence which represents this founder gene has been identified. Genetic diagnosis is therefore now possible in families in whom the gene defect is known. However, the exact nature and degree of activity of the porphyria can only be determined by detailed quantitative biochemical analysis of excreted porphyrins. The relative contributions of the acute attack and the skin disease to the total disease burden of patients with variegate porphyria is not static, and in South Africa there have been significant changes over the past 25 years, with fewer patients presenting with acute attacks, leaving a greater proportion to present with skin disease or to remain asymptomatic with the diagnosis being made in the laboratory. The most common precipitating cause of the acute attack of VP is administration of porphyrinogenic drugs. Specific suppression of haem synthesis with intravenous haem arginate is the most useful treatment of a moderate or severe acute attack. Although cutaneous lesions are limited to the sun-exposed areas, management of the skin disease of VP remains inadequate.