A low affinity TCR ligand restores positive selection of CD8+ T cells in vivo.

The T cell repertoire is shaped by the processes of positive and negative selection. During development, the TCR binds self peptide-MHC complexes in the thymus, and the kinetics of this interaction are thought to determine the thymocyte's fate. For development of CD8(+) T cells, the data supporting such a model have been obtained using fetal thymic organ culture. To confirm the fidelity of this model in vivo, we studied development of OT-I TCR-transgenic mice that expressed different individual K(b) binding peptides in thymic epithelial cells under the control of the human keratin 14 promoter. We used a system that allowed TAP-independent expression of the peptide-MHC complex, such that the ability of given peptides to restore positive selection in TAP(o) mice could be assessed. We found that transgenic expression of a TCR antagonist peptide (E1) in vivo efficiently restored positive selection of OT-I T cells in TAP(o) mice. An unrelated transgenic peptide (SIY) did not restore selection of OT-I T cells, nor did the E1-transgenic peptide restore selection of an unrelated receptor (2C), showing that positive selection is peptide specific in vivo, as observed in organ cultures. Neither E1 nor SIY transgenes increased the polyclonal CD8 T cell repertoire size in non-TCR-transgenic animals, arguing that single class I binding peptides do not detectably affect the size of the CD8 T cell repertoire when expressed at low levels. We also observed that OT-I T cells selected in TAP(o)-E1 mice were functional in their response to Ag; however, there was a lag in this response, suggesting that the affinity of the TCR interaction with MHC-self peptide can result in fine-tuning of the T cell response.

Signal strength in thymic selection and lineage commitment.

During development, alphabeta T cells undergo positive or negative selection and CD4(+)/CD8(+) lineage commitment-events that have a major impact on the functionality of the T cell repertoire. The precise mechanisms of these differentiative steps remain elusive. Research this year has focused on quantitative models of signaling. For positive selection, the timing and extent of ERK activation may be important. For lineage commitment, the extent of Lck recruitment and activation may be the decisive factor. Next, the search is on for the genes that commit the cell to the fate determined by these quantitative differences in signals.

Assays of thymic selection. Fetal thymus organ culture and in vitro thymocyte dulling assay.

The in vitro methods of FTOC and DP dulling assay have been useful for defining the structural ligand requirements for positive selection of thymocytes. Both techniques, but especially the latter, have restrictions on their interpretation, which are outlined in the notes. The ability to study a cellular process in vitro has been, and will continue to be, of critical importance for immunologists. However, one should always be careful to confirm a hypothesis using in vivo techniques, whenever possible.

CD8 binding to MHC class I molecules is influenced by T cell maturation and glycosylation.

CD8 serves both as an adhesion molecule for class I MHC molecules and as a coreceptor with the TCR for T cell activation. Here we study the developmental regulation of CD8-mediated binding to noncognate peptide/MHC ligands (i.e., those not bound by the TCR). We show that CD8's ability to bind soluble class I MHC tetramers and to mediate T cell adhesion under shear flow conditions diminishes as double-positive thymocytes mature into CD8(+) T cells. Furthermore, we provide evidence that this decreased CD8 binding results from increased T cell sialylation upon T cell maturation. These data suggest that CD8's ability to interact with class I MHC is not fixed and is developmentally regulated through the T cell's glycosylation state.

Positive selection is limited by available peptide-dependent MHC conformations.

Recent data suggest that the diversity of self peptides presented in the thymus during development contributes to positive selection of a diverse T cell repertoire. We sought to determine whether a previously defined "hole in the immunological repertoire" could be explained by the absence of an appropriate selecting self peptide. The repertoire defect in question is the inability of bm8 mice to make an H-2K-restricted response to OVA. Like other OVA-specific, H-2K-restricted receptors, OT-I-transgenic T cells are not positively selected in bm8 mice. Using criteria we had previously established for identifying positive selection ligands, we found peptides that could restore positive selection of OT-I thymocytes in bm8 mice. Thus, the T cell repertoire can be limited by a requirement for specific self peptides during development. Data with MHC-specific Abs suggested that peptides might be able to force MHC residues to adopt different conformations in Kb vs Kbm8. This shows that peptides can potentially contribute to ligand diversity both directly (via variability in the solvent-exposed side chains) and indirectly (through their effect on the MHC conformation). Our data support a model where self peptide diversity allows selection of T cells specific for a broad range of MHC conformations.

Receptor editing in developing T cells.

A central tenet of T cell development postulates that if a developing thymocyte encounters self-antigen, it is induced to die via apoptosis, thereby protecting the organism from autoreactive T cells. We created transgenic mice that expressed a peptide antigen in the cortical epithelial cells of the thymus. This did not, however, result in deletion of specific T cells. Instead, antigen presentation by epithelial cells caused T cell receptor (TCR) internalization and increased gene rearrangement at the endogenous TCR alpha locus, or receptor editing. This editing mechanism in immature T cells parallels that which occurs in immature B cells, and has important implications for understanding positive and negative selection signaling in the thymus, and the limits of self-tolerance.

Cutting edge: a test of the dominant negative signal model for TCR antagonism.

The mechanism by which TCR antagonists interfere with T cell activation is unclear. One popular hypothesis is that incomplete early signaling events induced by these ligands dominantly inhibit the T cell's ability to respond to a copresented agonist ligand. Here we test this "dominant negative" signal hypothesis by studying T cells expressing two distinct MHC class I-restricted TCRs (2C and OT-I). Although responses through each TCR can be efficiently inhibited by their specific antagonists, we found no evidence for "cross-antagonism" in which an antagonist for receptor "A" blocks responses through receptor "B." Such inhibition would have been expected were the dominant negative signaling hypothesis correct, and alternative models for TCR antagonism are discussed.

Qualitative and quantitative differences in T cell receptor binding of agonist and antagonist ligands.

The kinetics of interaction between TCR and MHC-peptide show a general relationship between affinity and the biological response, but the reported kinetic differences between antigenic and antagonistic peptides are very small. Here, we show a remarkable difference in the kinetics of TCR interactions with strong agonist ligands at 37 degrees C compared to 25 degrees C. This difference is not seen with antagonist/positive selecting ligands. The interaction at 37 degrees C shows biphasic binding kinetics best described by a model of TCR dimerization. The altered kinetics greatly increase the stability of complexes with agonist ligands, accounting for the large differences in biological response compared to other ligands. Thus, there may be an allosteric, as well as a kinetic, component to the discrimination between agonists and antagonists.

Antigen-induced coreceptor down-regulation on thymocytes is not a result of apoptosis.

The various stages of T cell development are typically characterized by the expression level of the two coreceptors, CD4 and CD8. During the CD4+CD8+ (double-positive, DP) stage of development, thymocytes that perceive a low avidity signal through the TCR go on to differentiate (positive selection), and ultimately down-regulate one coreceptor to express either CD4 or CD8. Alternatively, thymocytes that perceive a high avidity signal down-regulate both coreceptors and are induced to die via apoptosis (negative selection). However, it has recently been suggested that positively selected thymocytes may also partially down-regulate both coreceptors before up-regulating the one coreceptor that is ultimately expressed. This would imply that coreceptor down-regulation (dulling) is not a consequence of commitment to the death pathway. To explore this possibility, we have utilized an in vitro assay to demonstrate that dulling occurred in response to both positive and negative selecting ligands in vitro, was not a result of nonspecific membrane perturbation, was not dependent on the type of APC, and occurred before death in vitro. Furthermore, when thymocyte apoptosis was blocked, CD4 and CD8 were down-regulated in response to TCR stimulation. These data suggest that dulling in response to TCR ligation is distinct from death, and support a model in which DP dulling occurs during both positive and negative selection. The biological implications of this phenomenon are discussed.

Preselection thymocytes are more sensitive to T cell receptor stimulation than mature T cells.

During T cell development, thymocytes which are tolerant to self-peptides but reactive to foreign peptides are selected. The current model for thymocyte selection proposes that self-peptide-major histocompatibility complex (MHC) complexes that bind the T cell receptor with low affinity will promote positive selection while those with high affinity will result in negative selection. Upon thymocyte maturation, such low affinity self-peptide-MHC ligands no longer provoke a response, but foreign peptides can incidentally be high affinity ligands and can therefore stimulate T cells. For this model to work, thymocytes must be more sensitive to ligand than mature T cells. Contrary to this expectation, several groups have shown that thymocytes are less responsive than mature T cells to anti-T cell receptor for antigen (TCR)/CD3 mAb stimulation. Additionally, the lower TCR levels on thymocytes, compared with T cells, would potentially correlate with decreased thymocyte sensitivity. Here we compared preselection thymocytes and mature T cells for early activation events in response to peptide-MHC ligands. Remarkably, the preselection thymocytes were more responsive than mature T cells when stimulated with low affinity peptide variants, while both populations responded equally well to the antigenic peptide. This directly demonstrates the increased sensitivity of thymocytes compared with T cells for TCR engagement by peptide-MHC complexes.

Development of peptide-selected CD8 T cells in fetal thymic organ culture occurs via the conventional pathway.

Fetal thymic organ culture of TCR transgenic (Tg) tissue has been used to study issues of timing and specificity in T cell development. Because most TCR Tgs express a rearranged alphabeta TCR on the cell surface at an earlier stage in development than normal mice, there is a possibility that the conclusions of studies using TCR Tg cultures may not apply to normal development. In particular, in our studies of peptide-induced development of CD8 T cells, it is possible that the peptide acts on the immature double-negative cell, driving development of CD8 T cells without passing through a double-positive stage. This issue was examined by asking whether MHC class I restriction was required and by analyzing CD8beta levels and endogenous TCR alpha chain rearrangements. We found that if nonstimulatory peptides were used in fetal thymic organ culture, CD8 T cells developed via the conventional pathway, transiting through a double-positive stage. However, we could not rule out that cells selected in the presence of stimulatory peptides (agonists) did not develop directly from double-negative precursors.

CD8 lineage commitment in the absence of CD8.

The absence of cytotoxic T lymphocyte activity and the failure of MHC class I-restricted T cell receptor (TCR) transgenic thymocytes to mature in CD8alpha-deficient mice suggest that CD8 may be essential for CD8 lineage commitment. We report that variants of the antigenic peptide that delete TCR transgenic thymocytes from CD8 wild-type but not CD8alpha-deficient mice can restore positive selection of CD8 lineage cells in the absence of CD8. The positively selected cells down-regulate CD4, up-regulate TCR, respond to the antigenic peptide, and express CD8beta mRNA. Interestingly, there was no enhanced selection of CD4+ T cells, implying that the TCR-MHC interaction, even in the absence of CD8, provided instructive signaling for commitment to the CD8 lineage. Our results are discussed in terms of recent models of T cell lineage commitment.

Identification of a naturally occurring ligand for thymic positive selection.

In the thymus, positive and negative selection shape the T cell repertoire. It has previously been shown that positive selection, like negative selection, is the result of the interaction of the TCR with self-peptides bound to MHC. However, little is known about the number or nature of the self-peptide ligands that mediate positive selection in vivo. We devised a novel assay with enhanced sensitivity for low affinity TCR ligands to identify self-peptides that may be biologically relevant. At least eight K(b)-bound self-peptides were detected by this assay using thymocytes bearing the OT-I TCR (specific for OVAp/K(b)). The sequence of one of these peptides was determined using the recently developed technique of membrane preconcentration-capillary electrophoresis-tandem mass spectrometry. This peptide, CP alpha1, has limited sequence similarity to OVAp, yet was found to induce positive selection of OT-I thymocytes in fetal thymic organ culture.

Positive and negative selection invoke distinct signaling pathways.

During T cell development, interaction of the T cell receptor (TCR) with cognate ligands in the thymus may result in either maturation (positive selection) or death (negative selection). The intracellular pathways that control these opposed outcomes are not well characterized. We have generated mice expressing dominant-negative Ras (dnRas) and Mek-1 (dMek) transgenes simultaneously, either in otherwise normal animals, or in animals expressing a transgenic TCR, thereby permitting a comprehensive analysis of peptide-specific selection. In this system, thymocyte maturation beyond the CD4+8+ stage is blocked almost completely, whereas negative selection, assessed using an in vitro deletion protocol, is quantitatively intact. This suggests that activation of the mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) cascade is necessary for positive selection, but irrelevant for negative selection. Generation of gamma/delta and of CD4-8- alpha/beta T cells proceeds normally despite blockade of the MAPK cascade. Hence, only cells that mature via conventional, TCR-mediated repertoire selection require activation of the MAPK pathway to complete their maturation.

The nature of the peptide/MHC ligand involved in positive selection.

Positive and negative selection in the thymus occur when the TCR on an immature thymocyte engages self peptide/MHC complexes present on epithelial cells. The signaling mechanism which dictates the selection outcome is currently a matter of intense investigation. Here we review experiments that defined the peptide ligands for positive selection. A comparison of these to the peptide ligands that induce negative selection (antigenic peptides) sheds some insight into how a thymocyte interprets peptide/MHC interactions leading to life versus death of the cell.

Strong agonist ligands for the T cell receptor do not mediate positive selection of functional CD8+ T cells.

Positive selection of functional CD8+ T cells expressing an MHC class I-restricted T cell receptor can be induced in fetal thymus organ culture by class I-binding peptides related to the antigenic peptide ligand. Peptides that act as antagonist or weak agonist/antagonist ligands for mature T cells work efficiently in this regard. In the present study, we have investigated whether low concentrations of the original agonist peptide, or variants that still have a strong agonist activity can also mediate positive selection. The antigenic peptide did not induce positive selection at any concentration tested. A strong agonist variant was capable of stimulating the differentiation of TCRhi CD8+ cells, giving the appearance of phenotypic positive selection. However, these cells lacked biological function, since they could not proliferate in response to antigen. The most efficient positive selection resulted with ligands that did not activate mature T cells or stimulate negative selection.

Positive selection of thymocytes.

Differentiation of alpha beta T cell receptor (TCR)-expressing T cells involves an obligatory interaction with self-major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules in the thymus. This process, called positive selection, both rescues thymocytes from programmed cell death and induces their differentiation into mature T cells. Another critical event in thymic development is to prevent maturation of hazardous autoreactive T cells; thus, mechanisms exist to eliminate T cells with self-reactive receptors (negative selection). How can these two pathways be distinguished? This question, which has long taxed immunologists, is more opposite because many features of the interactions in positive and negative selection are shared: Both processes are exquisitely MHC-allele specific, they involve MHC-bound peptide recognition, and employ at least some overlapping signal transduction pathways. However, resolution of this paradox has become much more feasible with the advent of powerful systems for withdrawing and reconstituting individual components involved in positive selection. This review describes recent advances in our understanding of the cells, receptors, ligands, and signaling pathways involved in this process. A pivotal part of this puzzle is the basis for discrimination between TCR ligands that induce positive vs negative selection. Recent work suggests that the peptide/MHC ligand for positive selection may bind with low avidity to the TCR. The implications of these data for the nature of T cell recognition during positive selection are discussed below.

Major histocompatibility complex class I allele-specific peptide libraries: identification of peptides that mimic an H-Y T cell epitope.

We describe a novel method for screening large libraries of random peptides for T cell antigens. Two libraries were constructed, containing fixed amino acids representing the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I anchor residues for H-2Kb-restricted octamers and H-2Db-restricted nonamers. Peptides from the Kb-restricted library (KbL: SXIXFXXL) and the Db-restricted library (DbL: XXXXNXXXIM) specifically stabilize empty Kb and Db molecules, respectively. The libraries contain peptides that mimic several H-2b-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocyte epitopes, and 21 mimotopes for a Db-restricted H-Y epitope were isolated. A degenerate synthetic peptide of limited complexity containing the identified H-Y sequence motif was found to be similar to the natural H-Y epitope by reverse-phase high performance liquid chromatography analysis. This peptide is also capable of immunizing female mice against male splenocytes. Several applications for MHC-restricted peptide libraries are discussed.

Specificity and flexibility in thymic selection.

During positive selection, developing thymocytes are rescued from programmed cell death by T-cell receptor (TCR)-mediated recognition of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules. MHC-bound peptides contribute to this process. Recently we identified individual MHC-binding peptides which can induce positive selection of a single TCR. Here we examine peptide fine specificity in positive selection. These data suggest that a direct TCR-peptide interaction occurs during this event, and strengthens the correlation between selecting peptides and TCR antagonists. Certain positively selecting peptides are weakly antigenic. We demonstrate that thymocytes 'educated' on such a peptide are specifically non-responsive to it and have decreased CD8 expression levels. Similar reduction of CD8 expression on mature T cells converts a TCR agonist into a TCR antagonist. These data indicate that thymocytes may maintain self-tolerance towards a positively selecting ligand by regulating co-receptor expression.