In vitro selection of the Naegleria GIR1 ribozyme identifies three base changes that dramatically improve activity.

NanGIR1 is a member of a new class of group I ribozymes whose putative biological function is site-specific hydrolysis at an internal processing site (IPS). We have previously shown that NanGIR1 requires 1 M KCl for maximal activity, which is nevertheless slow (0.03 min(-1)). We used in vitro selection and an RNA pool with approximately nine mutations per molecule to select for faster hydrolysis at the IPS in 100 mM KCl. After eight rounds of selection, GIR1 variants were isolated that catalyzed hydrolysis at 300-fold greater rates than NanGIR1 RNA. Although not required by the selection, many of the resultant RNAs had increased thermal stability relative to the parent RNA, and had a more compact structure as evidenced by their faster migration in native gels. Although a wide spectrum of mutations was found in generation 8 clones, only two mutations, U149C and U153C, were common to greater than 95% of the molecules. These and one other mutation, G32A, are sufficient to increase activity 50-fold. All three mutations lie within or proximal to the P15 pseudoknot, a structural signature of GIR1 RNAs that was previously shown to be important for catalytic activity. Overall, our findings show that variants of the Naegleria GIR1 ribozyme with dramatically improved activity lie very close to the natural GIR1 in sequence space. Furthermore, the selection for higher activity appeared to select for increased structural stability.

Kinetic and secondary structure analysis of Naegleria andersoni GIR1, a group I ribozyme whose putative biological function is site-specific hydrolysis.

NanGIR1 is a catalytic element inserted in the P6 loop of a group I intron (NanGIR2) in the small subunit rRNA precursor of the protist Naegleria andersoni [Einvik, C., Decatur, W. A., Embley, T. M., Vogt, V. M., and Johansen, S. (1997) RNA 3, 710-720]. It catalyzes site-specific hydrolysis at an internal processing site (IPS) after a G residue that immediately follows the P9 stem-loop. Functional and structural analyses were initiated to compare NanGIR1 to group I introns that carry out self-splicing. Chemical modification and site-directed mutagenesis studies showed that NanGIR1 shares many structural elements with other group I introns, but also contains a pseudoknot (P15), which is important for catalytic activity. Deletion analysis revealed the boundaries of the minimum self-cleaving unit (178 nucleotides). The rate of self-cleavage was measured as a function of mono- and divalent ion concentration, temperature, and pH. The reaction at the IPS yields 5'-phosphate and 3'-hydroxyl termini, requires Mg2+or Mn2+ ions, and is first-order in [OH-] between pH 5.0 and 8.5. The latter results suggest that the nucleophile in the reaction is hydroxide or possibly a Mg2+-coordinated hydroxide. With a second-order rate constant of 1 x 10(5) min-1 M-1, the self-cleavage reaction of NanGIR1 is 2 orders of magnitude faster than a similar site-specific hydrolysis reaction of the circular form of the Tetrahymena group I intron.

Structures of the Klebsiella aerogenes urease apoenzyme and two active-site mutants.

Urease from Klebsiella aerogenes [Jabri et al. (1995) Science 268, 998-1004] is an (alpha beta gamma)3 trimer with each alpha-subunit having an (alpha beta)8-barrel domain containing a binickel active center. Here we examine structure-function relations for urease in more detail through structural analysis of the urease apoenzyme at 2.3 A resolution and mutants of two key catalytic residues (H219A and H320A) at 2.5 A resolution. With the exception of the active site, in which a water molecule takes the place of the missing carbamate and nickel atoms, the structure of the apoenzyme is nearly identical to that of the holoenzyme, suggesting a high degree of preorganization which helps explain the tight binding of nickel. In the structure of H219A, the major change involves a conformational shift and ordering of the active site flap, but a small shift in the side chain of Asp alpha 221 could contribute to the lower activity of H219A. In the H320A structure, the catalytic water, primarily a Ni-2 ligand in the holoenzyme, shifts into a bridging position. This shift shows that the nickel ligation is rather sensitive to the environment and the change in ligation may contribute to the 10(5)-fold lower activity of H320A. In addition, these results show that urease is resilient to the loss of nickel ions and mutations. Analysis of the urease tertiary/quaternary structure suggests that the stability of this enzyme may be largely due to its burial of an unusually large fraction of its residues: 50% in the gamma-subunit, 30% in the beta-subunit, and 60% in the alpha-subunit.

Characterization of the mononickel metallocenter in H134A mutant urease.

A mutant form of Klebsiella aerogenes urease possessing Ala instead of His at position 134 (H134A) is inactive and binds approximately half the normal complement of nickel (Park, I.-S., and Hausinger, R. P.(1993) Protein Sci. 2, 1034-1041). The crystal structure of the H134A protein was obtained at 2.0-A resolution, and it confirms that only Ni-1 of the two nickel ions found in the native enzyme is present. In contrast to the pseudotetrahedral geometry observed for Ni-1 in native urease (where it is liganded by His-246, His-272, one oxygen atom of carbamylated Lys-217, and a water molecule at partial occupancy), the mononickel metallocenter in the H134A protein was found to possess octahedral geometry and was coordinated by the above protein ligands plus three water molecules. The nickel site of H134A urease was probed by UV-visible, variable temperature magnetic circular dichroism, and x-ray absorption spectroscopies. The spectroscopic data are consistent with the presence of Ni(II) in octahedral geometry coordinated by two histidylimidazoles and additional oxygen and/or nitrogen donors. These data underscore the requirement of Ni-2 for formation of active urease and demonstrate the important role of Ni-2 in establishing the proper Ni-1 coordination geometry.

Urease activity in the crystalline state.

Crystalline Klebsiella aerogenes urease was found to have less than 0.05% of the activity observed for the soluble enzyme under standard assay conditions. Li2SO4, present in the crystal storage buffer at 2 M concentration, was shown to inhibit soluble urease by a mixed inhibition mechanism (Ki's of 0.38 +/- 0.05 M for the free enzyme and 0.13 +/- 0.02 M for the enzyme-urea complex). However, the activity of crystals was less than 0.5% of the expected value, suggesting that salt inhibition does not account for the near absence of crystalline activity. Dissolution of crystals resulted in approximately 43% recovery of the soluble enzyme activity, demonstrating that protein denaturation during crystal growth does not cause the dramatic diminishment in the catalytic rate. Finally, crushed crystals exhibited only a three-fold increase in activity over that of intact crystals, indicating that the rate of substrate diffusion into the crystals does not significantly limit the enzyme activity. We conclude that urease is effectively inactive in this crystal form, possibly due to conformational restrictions associated with a lid covering the active site, and propose that the small amounts of activity observed arise from limited enzyme activity at the crystal surfaces or trace levels of enzyme dissolution into the crystal storage buffer.

The crystal structure of urease from Klebsiella aerogenes.

The crystal structure of urease from Klebsiella aerogenes has been determined at 2.2 A resolution and refined to an R factor of 18.2 percent. The enzyme contains four structural domains: three with novel folds playing structural roles, and an (alpha beta)8 barrel domain, which contains the bi-nickel center. The two active site nickels are 3.5 A apart. One nickel ion is coordinated by three ligands (with low occupancy of a fourth ligand) and the second is coordinated by five ligands. A carbamylated lysine provides an oxygen ligand to each nickel, explaining why carbon dioxide is required for the activation of urease apoenzyme. The structure is compatible with a catalytic mechanism whereby urea ligates Ni-1 to complete its tetrahedral coordination and a hydroxide ligand of Ni-2 attacks the carbonyl carbon. A surprisingly high structural similarity between the urease catalytic domain and that of the zinc-dependent adenosine deaminase reveals a remarkable example of active site divergence.

Preliminary crystallographic studies of urease from jack bean and from Klebsiella aerogenes.

Ureases from both jack bean (Canavalia ensiformis) seeds and Klebsiella aerogenes have been crystallized by the hanging drop method. The plant-derived urease crystals are regular octahedra analogous to those obtained by Sumner. Preliminary X-ray diffraction studies show that the crystals belong to the cubic space group F4(1)32, with a = 364 A, and appear to contain one or two subunits in the asymmetric unit. Using a synchrotron source, the crystals diffract to near 3.5 A resolution. Crystals of urease from K. aerogenes belong to the cubic space group I23 or I2(1)3, with a = 170.8 A and appear to contain a single catalytic unit per asymmetric unit. The crystals diffract to better than 2.0 A resolution and are well suited for structural analysis.