Using Multiple Phenotype Assays and Epistasis Testing to Enhance the Reliability of RNAi Screening and Identify Regulators of Muscle Protein Degradation.

RNAi is a convenient, widely used tool for screening for genes of interest. We have recently used this technology to screen roughly 750 candidate genes, in C. elegans, for potential roles in regulating muscle protein degradation in vivo. To maximize confidence and assess reproducibility, we have only used previously validated RNAi constructs and have included time courses and replicates. To maximize mechanistic understanding, we have examined multiple sub-cellular phenotypes in multiple compartments in muscle. We have also tested knockdowns of putative regulators of degradation in the context of mutations or drugs that were previously shown to inhibit protein degradation by diverse mechanisms. Here we discuss how assaying multiple phenotypes, multiplexing RNAi screens with use of mutations and drugs, and use of bioinformatics can provide more data on rates of potential false positives and negatives as well as more mechanistic insight than simple RNAi screening.

Calpains mediate integrin attachment complex maintenance of adult muscle in Caenorhabditis elegans.

Two components of integrin containing attachment complexes, UNC-97/PINCH and UNC-112/MIG-2/Kindlin-2, were recently identified as negative regulators of muscle protein degradation and as having decreased mRNA levels in response to spaceflight. Integrin complexes transmit force between the inside and outside of muscle cells and signal changes in muscle size in response to force and, perhaps, disuse. We therefore investigated the effects of acute decreases in expression of the genes encoding these multi-protein complexes. We find that in fully developed adult Caenorhabditis elegans muscle, RNAi against genes encoding core, and peripheral, members of these complexes induces protein degradation, myofibrillar and mitochondrial dystrophies, and a movement defect. Genetic disruption of Z-line- or M-line-specific complex members is sufficient to induce these defects. We confirmed that defects occur in temperature-sensitive mutants for two of the genes: unc-52, which encodes the extra-cellular ligand Perlecan, and unc-112, which encodes the intracellular component Kindlin-2. These results demonstrate that integrin containing attachment complexes, as a whole, are required for proper maintenance of adult muscle. These defects, and collapse of arrayed attachment complexes into ball like structures, are blocked when DIM-1 levels are reduced. Degradation is also blocked by RNAi or drugs targeting calpains, implying that disruption of integrin containing complexes results in calpain activation. In wild-type animals, either during development or in adults, RNAi against calpain genes results in integrin muscle attachment disruptions and consequent sub-cellular defects. These results demonstrate that calpains are required for proper assembly and maintenance of integrin attachment complexes. Taken together our data provide in vivo evidence that a calpain-based molecular repair mechanism exists for dealing with attachment complex disruption in adult muscle. Since C. elegans lacks satellite cells, this mechanism is intrinsic to the muscles and raises the question if such a mechanism also exists in higher metazoans.

Integrated control of protein degradation in C. elegans muscle.

Protein degradation is a fundamental cellular process, the genomic control of which is incompletely understood. The advent of transgene-coded reporter proteins has enabled the development of C. elegans into a model for studying this problem. The regulation of muscle protein degradation is surprisingly complex, integrating multiple signals from hypodermis, intestine, neurons and muscle itself. Within the muscle, degradation is executed by separately regulated autophagy-lysosomal, ubiquitin-proteasome and calpain-mediated systems. The signal-transduction mechanisms, in some instances, involve modules previously identified for their roles in developmental processes, repurposed in terminally differentiated muscle to regulate the activities of pre-formed proteins. Here we review the genes, and mechanisms, which appear to coordinately control protein degradation within C. elegans muscle. We also consider these mechanisms in the context of development, physiology, pathophysiology and disease models.

Identification and functional clustering of genes regulating muscle protein degradation from amongst the known C. elegans muscle mutants.

Loss of muscle mass via protein degradation is an important clinical problem but we know little of how muscle protein degradation is regulated genetically. To gain insight our labs developed C. elegans into a model for understanding the regulation of muscle protein degradation. Past studies uncovered novel functional roles for genes affecting muscle and/or involved in signalling in other cells or tissues. Here we examine most of the genes previously identified as the sites of mutations affecting muscle for novel roles in regulating degradation. We evaluate genomic (RNAi knockdown) approaches and combine them with our established genetic (mutant) and pharmacologic (drugs) approaches to examine these 159 genes. We find that RNAi usually recapitulates both organismal and sub-cellular mutant phenotypes but RNAi, unlike mutants, can frequently be used acutely to study gene function solely in differentiated muscle. In the majority of cases where RNAi does not produce organismal level phenotypes, sub-cellular defects can be detected; disrupted proteostasis is most commonly observed. We identify 48 genes in which mutation or RNAi knockdown causes excessive protein degradation; myofibrillar and/or mitochondrial morphologies are also disrupted in 19 of these 48 cases. These 48 genes appear to act via at least three sub-networks to control bulk degradation of protein in muscle cytosol. Attachment to the extracellular matrix regulates degradation via unidentified proteases and affects myofibrillar and mitochondrial morphology. Growth factor imbalance and calcium overload promote lysosome based degradation whereas calcium deficit promotes proteasome based degradation, in both cases myofibrillar and mitochondrial morphologies are largely unaffected. Our results provide a framework for effectively using RNAi to identify and functionally cluster novel regulators of degradation. This clustering allows prioritization of candidate genes/pathways for future mechanistic studies.

Opposed growth factor signals control protein degradation in muscles of Caenorhabditis elegans.

In addition to contractile function, muscle provides a metabolic buffer by degrading protein in times of organismal need. Protein is also degraded during adaptive muscle remodeling upon exercise, but extreme degradation in diverse clinical conditions can compromise function(s) and threaten life. Here, we show how two independent signals interact to control protein degradation. In striated muscles of Caenorhabditis elegans, reduction of insulin-like signaling via DAF-2 insulin/IGF receptor or its intramuscular effector PtdIns-3-kinase (PI3K) causes unexpected activation of MAP kinase (MAPK), consequent activation of pre-existing systems for protein degradation, and progressive impairment of mobility. Degradation is prevented by mutations that increase signal downstream of PI3K or by disruption of autocrine signal from fibroblast growth factor (FGF) via the FGF receptor and its effectors in the Ras-MAPK pathway. Thus, the activity of constitutive protein degradation systems in normal muscle is minimized by a balance between directly interacting signaling pathways, implying that physiological, pathological, or therapeutic alteration of this balance may contribute to muscle remodeling or wasting.

Delayed development and lifespan extension as features of metabolic lifestyle alteration in C. elegans under dietary restriction.

Studies of the model organism Caenorhabditis elegans have almost exclusively utilized growth on a bacterial diet. Such culturing presents a challenge to automation of experimentation and introduces bacterial metabolism as a secondary concern in drug and environmental toxicology studies. Axenic cultivation of C. elegans can avoid these problems, yet past work suggests that axenic growth is unhealthy for C. elegans. Here we employ a chemically defined liquid medium to culture C. elegans and find development slows, fecundity declines, lifespan increases, lipid and protein stores decrease, and gene expression changes relative to that on a bacterial diet. These changes do not appear to be random pathologies associated with malnutrition, as there are no developmental delays associated with starvation, such as L1 or dauer diapause. Additionally, development and reproductive period are fixed percentages of lifespan regardless of diet, suggesting that these alterations are adaptive. We propose that C. elegans can exist as a healthy animal with at least two distinct adult life histories. One life history maximizes the intrinsic rate of population increase, the other maximizes the efficiency of exploitation of the carrying capacity of the environment. Microarray analysis reveals increased transcript levels of daf-16 and downstream targets and past experiments demonstrate that DAF-16 (FOXO) acting on downstream targets can influence all of the phenotypes we see altered in maintenance medium. Thus, life history alteration in response to diet may be modulated by DAF-16. Our observations introduce a powerful system for automation of experimentation on healthy C. elegans and for systematic analysis of the profound impact of diet on animal physiology.

Signal-transduction networks and the regulation of muscle protein degradation.

Protein degradation in muscle functions in maintaining normal physiological homeostasis and adapting to new homeostatic states, and is required for muscle wasting or atrophy in various pathological states. The interplay between protein synthesis and degradation to maintain homeostasis is complex and responds to a variety of autocrine and intercellular signals from neuronal inputs, hormones, cytokines, growth factors and other regulatory molecules. The intracellular events that connect extracellular signals to the molecular control of protein degradation are incompletely understood, but likely involve interacting signal-transduction networks rather than isolated pathways. We review some examples of signal-transduction systems that regulate protein degradation, including effectors of proteolysis inducing factor (PIF), insulin and insulin-like growth factor (IGF) and their receptors, and fibroblast growth factor (FGF) and its receptors.

Degradation of transgene-coded and endogenous proteins in the muscles of Caenorhabditis elegans.

To develop reporter systems to study the regulation of protein degradation in innervated muscle, we have used strains of the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans containing transgenes that fuse lacZ or green fluorescent protein (GFP) coding regions to muscle-specific promoter/enhancer regions, such that the fusion proteins are expressed exclusively in body-wall and vulval muscle cells. The starvation-induced degradation of the beta-galactosidase reporter protein is quantitatively similar to that of two endogenous muscle proteins, arginine kinase and adenylate kinase. A soluble GFP in the muscle cytosol is degraded during starvation, but when GFP is fused to a full-length myosin heavy chain and incorporated into myofibrils, it is resistant to starvation-induced degradation. This suggests that under some conditions soluble muscle proteins may be extensively catabolized in preference to the proteins of the contractile fibers.

Activated EGL-15 FGF receptor promotes protein degradation in muscles of Caenorhabditis elegans.

Signaling by fibroblast growth factors (FGFs) and their receptors has been previously implicated in control of cell proliferation, differentiation and migration. Here we report a novel role for signaling by the EGL-15 FGFR of Caenorhabditis elegans in controlling protein degradation in differentiated muscle. Activation of EGL-15, by means of a reduction of function mutation (clr-1) affecting an inhibitory phosphatase, triggers protein degradation in adult muscle cells using a pre-existing proteolytic system. This activation is not suppressed by mutation in either of the known genes encoding FGF ligands (egl-17 or let-756) but is well suppressed when both are mutated, indicating that either ligand is sufficient and at least one is necessary for FGFR activation. Activity of the Ras pathway through mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) is required to trigger protein degradation. This is the first report that degradation of intracellular protein can be triggered by a growth factor receptor using an identified signal transduction pathway. The data raise the possibility that FGF-triggered proteolysis may be relevant to muscle remodeling or dedifferentiation.

Activation of Ras and the mitogen-activated protein kinase pathway promotes protein degradation in muscle cells of Caenorhabditis elegans.

To discover and study intracellular signals that regulate proteolysis in muscle, we have employed transgenic strains of Caenorhabditis elegans that produce a soluble LacZ reporter protein limited to body-wall and vulval muscles. This reporter protein is stable in well-fed wild-type animals, but its degradation is triggered upon a shift to 25 degrees C in a strain carrying a temperature-sensitive activating mutation in the Ras oncogene homologue let-60. These mutants are not physiologically starved, inasmuch as growth rates are normal at 25 degrees C. Ras-induced degradation is not prevented by the presence of cycloheximide added at or before the temperature shift and thus uses preexisting proteolytic systems and signaling components. Furthermore, degradation is triggered when adult animals are shifted to conditions of 25 degrees C, confirming that Ras acutely promotes protein degradation in muscles whose developmental history is normal. Reduction-of-function mutations in the downstream protein kinase Raf (lin-45), MEK (mek-2), or mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) (mpk-1) prevent Ras-induced protein degradation, whereas activated MPK-1 is sufficient to trigger degradation, indicating that this kinase cascade is the principal route by which Ras signaling triggers protein degradation in muscle. This pathway is activated in hypodermal cells by the LET-23 epidermal growth factor receptor homologue, but an activating mutation in let-23 does not promote proteolysis in muscle. Starvation-induced LacZ reporter degradation is unaffected by reduction-of-function mutations in Ras, Raf, MEK, or MAPK, implying that Ras activation and starvation trigger proteolysis by mechanisms that are at least partially independent. This is the first evidence that Ras-Raf-MEK-MAPK signaling activates protein degradation in differentiated muscle.