Ligand electronic properties modulate tau filament binding site density.

Small molecules that bind tau-bearing neurofibrillary lesions are being sought for premortem diagnosis, staging, and treatment of Alzheimer's disease and other tauopathic neurodegenerative diseases. The utility of these agents will depend on both their binding affinity and binding site density (B(max)). Previously we identified polarizability as a descriptor of protein aggregate binding affinity. To examine its contribution to binding site density, we investigated the ability of two closely related benzothiazole derivatives ((E)-2-[[4-(dimethylamino)phenyl]azo]-6-methoxybenzothiazole) and ((E)-2-[2-[4-(dimethylamino)phenyl]ethenyl]-6-methoxybenzothiazole) that differed in polarizability to displace probes of high (Thioflavin S) and low (radiolabeled (E,E)-1-iodo-2,5-bis(3-hydroxycarbonyl-4-methoxy)styrylbenzene; IMSB) density sites. Consistent with their site densities, Thioflavin S completely displaced radiolabeled IMSB, but IMSB was incapable of displacing Thioflavin S. Although both benzothiazoles displaced the low B(max) IMSB probe, only the highly polarizable analog displaced near saturating concentrations of the Thioflavin S probe. Quantum calculations showed that high polarizability reflected extensive pi-electron delocalization fostered by the presence of electron donating and accepting groups. These data suggest that electron delocalization promotes ligand binding at a subset of sites on tau aggregates that are present at high density, and that optimizing this aspect of ligand structure can yield tau-directed agents with superior diagnostic and therapeutic performance.

Research towards tau imaging.

Tau-bearing neurofibrillary lesions present a promising biomarker for premortem diagnosis and staging of Alzheimer's disease and certain forms of frontotemporal lobar degeneration by whole brain imaging methods. Although brain penetrating compounds capable of binding tau aggregates with high affinity have been disclosed for this purpose, the major barrier to progress remains the need for tau lesion binding selectivity relative to amyloid-beta plaques and other deposits of proteins in cross-beta-sheet conformation. Here we discuss challenges faced in the development of tau lesion-selective imaging agents, and recent preclinical advances in pursuit of this goal.

Ligand polarizability contributes to tau fibril binding affinity.

Whole brain imaging of tau-bearing neurofibrillary lesions has the potential to improve the premortem diagnosis and staging of Alzheimer's disease. Diverse compounds with high affinity for tau aggregates have been reported from high-throughput screens, but the affinity driving features common among them have not been determined. To identify these features, analogs of compounds discovered by high-throughput screening, including phenothiazine, triarylmethine, benzothiazole, and oxindole derivatives, were tested for their ability to displace fluorescent thioflavin dyes from filaments made from recombinant tau protein or authentic paired helical filaments purified from Alzheimer's disease tissue. When representative members of all scaffolds were assayed, the rank order of binding affinity determined for synthetic and authentic filaments correlated strongly, indicating that synthetic filaments have predictive utility for ligand development. Within individual scaffold families, binding affinity was found to correlate with compound polarizability, consistent with a role for dispersion forces in mediating ligand binding. Overall, the data indicate that polarizability is an important commonality among structurally diverse tau binding ligands, and that affinity for tau aggregates can be maximized by integrating formal assessment of this parameter into ligand discovery efforts.

Modulation and detection of tau aggregation with small-molecule ligands.

Recent results from high-throughput and other screening approaches reveal that small molecules can directly interact with recombinant full-length tau monomers and fibrillar tau aggregates in three distinct modes. First, in the high concentration regime (>10 micromolar), certain anionic molecules such as Congo red efficiently promote tau filament formation through a nucleation-elongation mechanism involving a dimeric nucleus and monomer-mediated elongation. These compounds are useful for modeling tau aggregation in vitro and in biological models. Second, in the low concentration regime (<1 micromolar), other ligands, including cyanine dyes, display aggregation antagonist activity. Compounds that can prevent or reverse fibrillization are candidate modifiers of disease pathology. Finally, certain compounds bind mature tau fibrils with varying affinities at multiple binding sites without modulating the aggregation reaction. For some ligands, >10-fold selectivity for tau aggregates relative to filaments composed of beta-amyloid or alpha-synuclein can be demonstrated at the level of binding affinity. Together these observations suggest that small-molecules have utility for interrogating the tau aggregation pathway, for inhibiting neuritic lesion formation, and for selective pre-mortem detection of neurofibrillary lesions through whole brain imaging.

Small-molecule mediated neuroprotection in an in situ model of tauopathy.

Small-molecule inhibitors of neurofibrillary lesion formation may have utility for treatment of Alzheimer's disease and certain forms of frontotemporal lobar degeneration. These lesions are composed largely of tau protein, which aggregates to form intracellular fibrils in affected neurons. Previously it was shown that chronic overexpression of human tau protein within identified neurons (anterior bulbar cells) of the sea lamprey induced a phenotype-resembling tauopathic neurodegeneration, including the formation of tau filaments, fragmentation of dendritic arbors, and eventual cell death. Development of this neurodegenerative phenotype was blocked by chronic administration of a benzothiazole derivative termed N3 ((E)-2-[[4-(dimethylamino)phenyl]azo]-6-methoxybenzothiazole) to lamprey aquaria. Here we examined the mechanism of action of N3 and an alkene analog termed N4 ((E)-2-[2-[4-(dimethylamino)phenyl]ethenyl]-6-methoxybenzothiazole) in vitro and in the lamprey model. Results showed that although both compounds entered the lamprey central nervous system, only N3 arrested tauopathy. On the basis of in vitro aggregation assays, neither compound was capable of directly inhibiting tau filament formation. However, N3, but not N4, was capable of partially antagonizing the binding of Thioflavin S to synthetic tau filaments. The results suggest that occupancy of N3-binding sites on nascent tau filaments may significantly retard the progressive degeneration accompanying tau overexpression in lamprey.

Potent inhibition of tau fibrillization with a multivalent ligand.

Small-molecule inhibitors of tau fibrillization are under investigation as tools for interrogating the tau aggregation pathway and as potential therapeutic agents for Alzheimer's disease. Established inhibitors include thiacarbocyanine dyes, which can inhibit recombinant tau fibrillization in the presence of anionic surfactant aggregation inducers. In an effort to increase inhibitory potency, a cyclic bis-thiacarbocyanine molecule containing two thiacarbocyanine moieties was synthesized and characterized with respect to tau fibrillization inhibitory activity by electron microscopy and ligand aggregation state by absorbance spectroscopy. Results showed that the inhibitory activity of the bis-thiacarbocyanine was qualitatively similar to a monomeric cyanine dye, but was more potent with 50% inhibition achieved at approximately 80nM concentration. At all concentrations tested in aqueous solution, the bis-thiacarbocyanine collapsed to form a closed clamshell structure. However, the presence of tau protein selectively stabilized the open conformation. These results suggest that the inhibitory activity of bis-thiacarbocyanine results from multivalency, and reveal a route to more potent tau aggregation inhibitors.

Substrate-induced changes in the ammonia channel for imidazole glycerol phosphate synthase.

IGP synthase is a glutamine amidotransferase that incorporates ammonia derived from glutamine into the unusual nucleotide, N(1)-[(5'-phosphoribulosyl)-formimino]-5-aminoimidazole-4-carboxamide ribonucleotide (PRFAR) to form 5'-(5-aminoimidazole-4-carboxamide) ribonucleotide (AICAR) and imidazole glycerol phosphate (IGP). A common feature of all glutamine amidotransferases is the upregulation of glutamine hydrolysis in the presence of an acceptor substrate. A refined assay system was developed to establish that Saccharomyces cerevisae IGP synthase shows a 4900-fold stimulation of glutaminase in the presence of the substrate acceptor PRFAR. The structure and function of IGP synthase acceptor substrate binding site were probed with competitive inhibitors that are nucleotide substrate and product analogues. In addition, these analogues were also used to establish that the normal steady-state turnover cycle involves a random sequential mechanism. Upregulation of the glutaminase active site occurs when these competitive inhibitors bind in the nucleotide site over 30 A away. One of the key structural features of IGP synthase is that the transfer of ammonia from the glutaminase site occurs through the (beta/alpha)(8) core of the protein. Upon the basis of the recent substrate-occupied structure for yeast IGP synthase (1), kinetic investigations of site-directed mutants revealed that a conserved K258 residue is key to productive binding and the overall stoichiometry of the reaction. The binding of the ribulosyl phosphate portion of the substrate PRFAR appears to be transduced through reorientation of K258 resulting in a conformational switch at the base of the (beta/alpha)(8) core that enables the passage of ammonia through the core of the protein. The overall analysis also leads to further discussion of how the residues that cover the opening of the (beta/alpha)(8) in the closed state may assist the channeling of ammonia at the interface of the two functional domains in the open state.