Dynamin1 long- and short-tail isoforms exploit distinct recruitment and spatial patterns to form endocytic nanoclusters.

Endocytosis requires a coordinated framework of molecular interactions that ultimately lead to the fission of nascent endocytic structures. How cytosolic proteins such as dynamin concentrate at discrete sites that are sparsely distributed across the plasma membrane remains poorly understood. Two dynamin-1 major splice variants differ by the length of their C-terminal proline-rich region (short-tail and long-tail). Using sptPALM in PC12 cells, neurons and MEF cells, we demonstrate that short-tail dynamin-1 isoforms ab and bb display an activity-dependent recruitment to the membrane, promptly followed by their concentration into nanoclusters. These nanoclusters are sensitive to both Calcineurin and dynamin GTPase inhibitors, and are larger, denser, and more numerous than that of long-tail isoform aa. Spatiotemporal modelling confirms that dynamin-1 isoforms perform distinct search patterns and undergo dimensional reduction to generate endocytic nanoclusters, with short-tail isoforms more robustly exploiting lateral trapping in the generation of nanoclusters compared to the long-tail isoform.

Discovering optimal kinetic pathways for self-assembly using automatic differentiation.

Macromolecular complexes are often composed of diverse subunits. The self-assembly of these subunits is inherently nonequilibrium and must avoid kinetic traps to achieve high yield over feasible timescales. We show how the kinetics of self-assembly benefits from diversity in subunits because it generates an expansive parameter space that naturally improves the "expressivity" of self-assembly, much like a deeper neural network. By using automatic differentiation algorithms commonly used in deep learning, we searched the parameter spaces of mass-action kinetic models to identify classes of kinetic protocols that mimic biological solutions for productive self-assembly. Our results reveal how high-yield complexes that easily become kinetically trapped in incomplete intermediates can instead be steered by internal design of rate-constants or external and active control of subunits to efficiently assemble. Internal design of a hierarchy of subunit binding rates generates self-assembly that can robustly avoid kinetic traps for all concentrations and energetics, but it places strict constraints on selection of relative rates. External control via subunit titration is more versatile, avoiding kinetic traps for any system without requiring molecular engineering of binding rates, albeit less efficiently and robustly. We derive theoretical expressions for the timescales of kinetic traps, and we demonstrate our optimization method applies not just for design but inference, extracting intersubunit binding rates from observations of yield-vs.-time for a heterotetramer. Overall, we identify optimal kinetic protocols for self-assembly as a powerful mechanism to achieve efficient and high-yield assembly in synthetic systems whether robustness or ease of "designability" is preferred.

Discovering optimal kinetic pathways for self-assembly using automatic differentiation.

During self-assembly of macromolecules ranging from ribosomes to viral capsids, the formation of long-lived intermediates or kinetic traps can dramatically reduce yield of the functional products. Understanding biological mechanisms for avoiding traps and efficiently assembling is essential for designing synthetic assembly systems, but learning optimal solutions requires numerical searches in high-dimensional parameter spaces. Here, we exploit powerful automatic differentiation algorithms commonly employed by deep learning frameworks to optimize physical models of reversible self-assembly, discovering diverse solutions in the space of rate constants for 3-7 subunit complexes. We define two biologically-inspired protocols that prevent kinetic trapping through either internal design of subunit binding kinetics or external design of subunit titration in time. Our third protocol acts to recycle intermediates, mimicking energy-consuming enzymes. Preventative solutions via interface design are the most efficient and scale better with more subunits, but external control via titration or recycling are effective even for poorly evolved binding kinetics. Whilst all protocols can produce good solutions, diverse subunits always helps; these complexes access more efficient solutions when following external control protocols, and are simpler to design for internal control, as molecular interfaces do not need modification during assembly given sufficient variation in dimerization rates. Our results identify universal scaling in the cost of kinetic trapping, and provide multiple strategies for eliminating trapping and maximizing assembly yield across large parameter spaces.

Temporal control by cofactors prevents kinetic trapping in retroviral Gag lattice assembly.

For retroviruses like HIV to proliferate, they must form virions shaped by the self-assembly of Gag polyproteins into a rigid lattice. This immature Gag lattice has been structurally characterized and reconstituted in vitro, revealing the sensitivity of lattice assembly to multiple cofactors. Due to this sensitivity, the energetic criterion for forming stable lattices is unknown, as are their corresponding rates. Here, we use a reaction-diffusion model designed from the cryo-ET structure of the immature Gag lattice to map a phase diagram of assembly outcomes controlled by experimentally constrained rates and free energies, over experimentally relevant timescales. We find that productive assembly of complete lattices in bulk solution is extraordinarily difficult due to the large size of this ∼3700 monomer complex. Multiple Gag lattices nucleate before growth can complete, resulting in loss of free monomers and frequent kinetic trapping. We therefore derive a time-dependent protocol to titrate or "activate" the Gag monomers slowly within the solution volume, mimicking the biological roles of cofactors. This general strategy works remarkably well, yielding productive growth of self-assembled lattices for multiple interaction strengths and binding rates. By comparing to the in vitro assembly kinetics, we can estimate bounds on rates of Gag binding to Gag and the cellular cofactor IP6. Our results show that Gag binding to IP6 can provide the additional time delay necessary to support smooth growth of the immature lattice with relatively fast assembly kinetics, mostly avoiding kinetic traps. Our work provides a foundation for predicting and disrupting formation of the immature Gag lattice via targeting specific protein-protein binding interactions.

Structure of the HIV immature lattice allows for essential lattice remodeling within budded virions.

For HIV virions to become infectious, the immature lattice of Gag polyproteins attached to the virion membrane must be cleaved. Cleavage cannot initiate without the protease formed by the homo-dimerization of domains linked to Gag. However, only 5% of the Gag polyproteins, termed Gag-Pol, carry this protease domain, and they are embedded within the structured lattice. The mechanism of Gag-Pol dimerization is unknown. Here, we use spatial stochastic computer simulations of the immature Gag lattice as derived from experimental structures, showing that dynamics of the lattice on the membrane is unavoidable due to the missing 1/3 of the spherical protein coat. These dynamics allow for Gag-Pol molecules carrying the protease domains to detach and reattach at new places within the lattice. Surprisingly, dimerization timescales of minutes or less are achievable for realistic binding energies and rates despite retaining most of the large-scale lattice structure. We derive a formula allowing extrapolation of timescales as a function of interaction free energy and binding rate, thus predicting how additional stabilization of the lattice would impact dimerization times. We further show that during assembly, dimerization of Gag-Pol is highly likely and therefore must be actively suppressed to prevent early activation. By direct comparison to recent biochemical measurements within budded virions, we find that only moderately stable hexamer contacts (-12kBT<∆G<-8kBT) retain both the dynamics and lattice structures that are consistent with experiment. These dynamics are likely essential for proper maturation, and our models quantify and predict lattice dynamics and protease dimerization timescales that define a key step in understanding formation of infectious viruses.

Secretion-Catalyzed Assembly of Protein Biomaterials on a Bacterial Membrane Surface.

Protein-based biomaterials have played a key role in tissue engineering, and additional exciting applications as self-healing materials and sustainable polymers are emerging. Over the past few decades, recombinant expression and production of various fibrous proteins from microbes have been demonstrated; however, the resulting proteins typically must then be purified and processed by humans to form usable fibers and materials. Here, we show that the Gram-positive bacterium Bacillus subtilis can be programmed to secrete silk through its translocon via an orthogonal signal peptide/peptidase pair. Surprisingly, we discover that this translocation mechanism drives the silk proteins to assemble into fibers spontaneously on the cell surface, in a process we call secretion-catalyzed assembly (SCA). Secreted silk fibers form self-healing hydrogels with minimal processing. Alternatively, the fibers retained on the membrane provide a facile route to create engineered living materials from Bacillus cells. This work provides a blueprint to achieve autonomous assembly of protein biomaterials in useful morphologies directly from microbial factories.

Modeling membrane reshaping driven by dynamic protein assemblies.

Remodeling of membranes in living systems is almost universally coupled to self-assembly of soluble proteins. Proteins assemble into semi-rigid shells that reshape attached membranes, and into filaments that protrude membranes. These assemblies are temporary, building from reversible protein and membrane interactions that must nucleate in the proper location. The interactions are strongly influenced by the nonequilibrium environment of the cell, such as gradients of components or active modifications by kinases. From a modeling perspective, understanding mechanisms and control thus requires 1. time-dependent approaches that ideally incorporate 2. macromolecular structure, 3. out-of-equilibrium processes, and 4. deformable membranes over microns and seconds. Realistically, tradeoffs must be made with these last three features. However, we see recent developments from the highly coarsened molecule-based scale, the continuum reaction-diffusion scale, and hybrid approaches as stimulating efforts in diverse applications. We discuss here methodological advances and progress towards simulating these processes as they occur physiologically.

Large self-assembled clathrin lattices spontaneously disassemble without sufficient adaptor proteins.

Clathrin-coated structures must assemble on cell membranes to internalize receptors, with the clathrin protein only linked to the membrane via adaptor proteins. These structures can grow surprisingly large, containing over 20 clathrin, yet they often fail to form productive vesicles, instead aborting and disassembling. We show that clathrin structures of this size can both form and disassemble spontaneously when adaptor protein availability is low, despite high abundance of clathrin. Here, we combine recent in vitro kinetic measurements with microscopic reaction-diffusion simulations and theory to differentiate mechanisms of stable vs unstable clathrin assembly on membranes. While in vitro conditions drive assembly of robust, stable lattices, we show that concentrations, geometry, and dimensional reduction in physiologic-like conditions do not support nucleation if only the key adaptor AP-2 is included, due to its insufficient abundance. Nucleation requires a stoichiometry of adaptor to clathrin that exceeds 1:1, meaning additional adaptor types are necessary to form lattices successfully and efficiently. We show that the critical nucleus contains ~25 clathrin, remarkably similar to sizes of the transient and abortive structures observed in vivo. Lastly, we quantify the cost of bending the membrane under our curved clathrin lattices using a continuum membrane model. We find that the cost of bending the membrane could be largely offset by the energetic benefit of forming curved rather than flat structures, with numbers comparable to experiments. Our model predicts how adaptor density can tune clathrin-coated structures from the transient to the stable, showing that active energy consumption is therefore not required for lattice disassembly or remodeling during growth, which is a critical advance towards predicting productive vesicle formation.

Integrating protein copy numbers with interaction networks to quantify stoichiometry in clathrin-mediated endocytosis.

Proteins that drive processes like clathrin-mediated endocytosis (CME) are expressed at copy numbers within a cell and across cell types varying from hundreds (e.g. auxilin) to millions (e.g. clathrin). These variations contain important information about function, but without integration with the interaction network, they cannot capture how supply and demand for each protein depends on binding to shared and distinct partners. Here we construct the interface-resolved network of 82 proteins involved in CME and establish a metric, a stoichiometric balance ratio (SBR), that quantifies whether each protein in the network has an abundance that is sub- or super-stoichiometric dependent on the global competition for binding. We find that highly abundant proteins (like clathrin) are super-stoichiometric, but that not all super-stoichiometric proteins are highly abundant, across three cell populations (HeLa, fibroblast, and neuronal synaptosomes). Most strikingly, within all cells there is significant competition to bind shared sites on clathrin and the central AP-2 adaptor by other adaptor proteins, resulting in most being in excess supply. Our network and systematic analysis, including response to perturbations of network components, show how competition for shared binding sites results in functionally similar proteins having widely varying stoichiometries, due to variations in both abundance and their unique network of binding partners.

Correction: A continuum membrane model can predict curvature sensing by helix insertion.

Correction for 'A continuum membrane model can predict curvature sensing by helix insertion' by Yiben Fu et al., Soft Matter, 2021, 17, 10649-10663, DOI: 10.1039/D1SM01333E.

A continuum membrane model can predict curvature sensing by helix insertion.

Protein domains, such as ENTH (epsin N-terminal homology) and BAR (bin/amphiphysin/rvs), contain amphipathic helices that drive preferential binding to curved membranes. However, predicting how the physical parameters of these domains control this 'curvature sensing' behavior is challenging due to the local membrane deformations generated by the nanoscopic helix on the surface of a large sphere. We here use a deformable continuum model that accounts for the physical properties of the membrane and the helix insertion to predict curvature sensing behavior, with direct validation against multiple experimental datasets. We show that the insertion can be modeled as a local change to the membrane's spontaneous curvature, cins0, producing excellent agreement with the energetics extracted from experiments on ENTH binding to vesicles and cylinders, and of ArfGAP helices to vesicles. For small vesicles with high curvature, the insertion lowers the membrane energy by relieving strain on a membrane that is far from its preferred curvature of zero. For larger vesicles, however, the insertion has the inverse effect, de-stabilizing the membrane by introducing more strain. We formulate here an empirical expression that accurately captures numerically calculated membrane energies as a function of both basic membrane properties (bending modulus κ and radius R) as well as stresses applied by the inserted helix (cins0 and area Ains). We therefore predict how these physical parameters will alter the energetics of helix binding to curved vesicles, which is an essential step in understanding their localization dynamics during membrane remodeling processes.

Speed limits of protein assembly with reversible membrane localization.

Protein assembly is often studied in a three-dimensional solution, but a significant fraction of binding events involve proteins that can reversibly bind and diffuse along a two-dimensional surface. In a recent study, we quantified how proteins can exploit the reduced dimensionality of the membrane to trigger complex formation. Here, we derive a single expression for the characteristic timescale of this multi-step assembly process, where the change in dimensionality renders rates and concentrations effectively time-dependent. We find that proteins can accelerate dimer formation due to an increase in relative concentration, driving more frequent collisions, which often win out over slow-downs due to diffusion. Our model contains two protein populations that dimerize with one another and use a distinct site to bind membrane lipids, creating a complex reaction network. However, by identifying two major rate-limiting pathways to reach an equilibrium steady-state, we derive an excellent approximation for the mean first passage time when lipids are in abundant supply. Our theory highlights how the "sticking rate" or effective adsorption coefficient of the membrane is central in controlling timescales. We also derive a corrected localization rate to quantify how the geometry of the system and diffusion can reduce rates of membrane localization. We validate and test our results using kinetic and particle-based reaction-diffusion simulations. Our results establish how the speed of key assembly steps can shift by orders-of-magnitude when membrane localization is possible, which is critical to understanding mechanisms used in cells.

Thermodynamics and Free Energy Landscape of BAR-Domain Dimerization from Molecular Simulations.

Proteins with BAR domains function to bind to and remodel biological membranes, where the dimerization of BAR domains is a key step in this function. These domains can dimerize in solution or after localizing to the membrane surface. Here, we characterize the binding thermodynamics of homodimerization between the LSP1 BAR domain proteins in solution, using molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. By combining the MARTINI coarse-grained protein models with enhanced sampling through metadynamics, we construct a two-dimensional free energy surface quantifying the bound versus unbound ensembles as a function of two distance variables. With this methodology, our simulations can simultaneously characterize the structures and relative stabilities of a range of sampled dimers, portraying a heterogeneous and extraordinarily stable bound ensemble, where the proper crystal structure dimer is the most stable in a 100 mM NaCl solution. Nonspecific dimers that are sampled involve contacts that are consistent with experimental structures of higher-order oligomers formed by the LSP1 BAR domain. Because the BAR dimers and oligomers can assemble on membranes, we characterize the relative alignment of the known membrane binding patches, finding that only the specific dimer is aligned to form strong interactions with the membrane. Hence, we would predict a strong selection of the specific dimer in binding to or assembling when on the membrane. Establishing the pairwise stabilities of homodimer contacts is difficult experimentally when the proteins form stable oligomers, but through the method used here, we can isolate these contacts, providing a foundation to study the same interactions on the membrane.

NERDSS: A Nonequilibrium Simulator for Multibody Self-Assembly at the Cellular Scale.

Currently, a significant barrier to building predictive models of cellular self-assembly processes is that molecular models cannot capture minutes-long dynamics that couple distinct components with active processes, whereas reaction-diffusion models cannot capture structures of molecular assembly. Here, we introduce the nonequilibrium reaction-diffusion self-assembly simulator (NERDSS), which addresses this spatiotemporal resolution gap. NERDSS integrates efficient reaction-diffusion algorithms into generalized software that operates on user-defined molecules through diffusion, binding and orientation, unbinding, chemical transformations, and spatial localization. By connecting the fast processes of binding with the slow timescales of large-scale assembly, NERDSS integrates molecular resolution with reversible formation of ordered, multisubunit complexes. NERDSS encodes models using rule-based formatting languages to facilitate model portability, usability, and reproducibility. Applying NERDSS to steps in clathrin-mediated endocytosis, we design multicomponent systems that can form lattices in solution or on the membrane, and we predict how stochastic but localized dephosphorylation of membrane lipids can drive lattice disassembly. The NERDSS simulations reveal the spatial constraints on lattice growth and the role of membrane localization and cooperativity in nucleating assembly. By modeling viral lattice assembly and recapitulating oscillations in protein expression levels for a circadian clock model, we illustrate the adaptability of NERDSS. NERDSS simulates user-defined assembly models that were previously inaccessible to existing software tools, with broad applications to predicting self-assembly in vivo and designing high-yield assemblies in vitro.

An implicit lipid model for efficient reaction-diffusion simulations of protein binding to surfaces of arbitrary topology.

Localization of proteins to a membrane is an essential step in a broad range of biological processes such as signaling, virion formation, and clathrin-mediated endocytosis. The strength and specificity of proteins binding to a membrane depend on the lipid composition. Single-particle reaction-diffusion methods offer a powerful tool for capturing lipid-specific binding to membrane surfaces by treating lipids explicitly as individual diffusible binding sites. However, modeling lipid particle populations is expensive. Here, we present an algorithm for reversible binding of proteins to continuum surfaces with implicit lipids, providing dramatic speed-ups to many body simulations. Our algorithm can be readily integrated into most reaction-diffusion software packages. We characterize changes to kinetics that emerge from explicit vs implicit lipids as well as surface adsorption models, showing excellent agreement between our method and the full explicit lipid model. Compared to models of surface adsorption, which couple together binding affinity and lipid concentration, our implicit lipid model decouples them to provide more flexibility for controlling surface binding properties and lipid inhomogeneity, thus reproducing binding kinetics and equilibria. Crucially, we demonstrate our method's application to membranes of arbitrary curvature and topology, modeled via a subdivision limit surface, again showing excellent agreement with explicit lipid simulations. Unlike adsorption models, our method retains the ability to bind lipids after proteins are localized to the surface (through, e.g., a protein-protein interaction), which can greatly increase the stability of multiprotein complexes on the surface. Our method will enable efficient cell-scale simulations involving proteins localizing to realistic membrane models, which is a critical step for predictive modeling and quantification of in vitro and in vivo dynamics.

Modeling the Self-Assembly of Protein Complexes through a Rigid-Body Rotational Reaction-Diffusion Algorithm.

The reaction-diffusion equations provide a powerful framework for modeling nonequilibrium, cell-scale dynamics over the long time scales that are inaccessible by traditional molecular modeling approaches. Single-particle reaction-diffusion offers the highest resolution technique for tracking such dynamics, but it has not been applied to the study of protein self-assembly due to its treatment of reactive species as single-point particles. Here, we develop a relatively simple but accurate approach for building rigid structure and rotation into single-particle reaction-diffusion methods, providing a rate-based method for studying protein self-assembly. Our simplifying assumption is that reactive collisions can be evaluated purely on the basis of the separations between the sites, and not their orientations. The challenge of evaluating reaction probabilities can then be performed using well-known equations based on translational diffusion in both 3D and 2D, by employing an effective diffusion constant we derive here. We show how our approach reproduces both the kinetics of association, which is altered by rotational diffusion, and the equilibrium of reversible association, which is not. Importantly, the macroscopic kinetics of association can be predicted on the basis of the microscopic parameters of our structurally resolved model, allowing for critical comparisons with theory and other rate-based simulations. We demonstrate this method for efficient, rate-based simulations of self-assembly of clathrin trimers, highlighting how formation of regular lattices impacts the kinetics of association.

Cytosolic proteins can exploit membrane localization to trigger functional assembly.

Cell division, endocytosis, and viral budding would not function without the localization and assembly of protein complexes on membranes. What is poorly appreciated, however, is that by localizing to membranes, proteins search in a reduced space that effectively drives up concentration. Here we derive an accurate and practical analytical theory to quantify the significance of this dimensionality reduction in regulating protein assembly on membranes. We define a simple metric, an effective equilibrium constant, that allows for quantitative comparison of protein-protein interactions with and without membrane present. To test the importance of membrane localization for driving protein assembly, we collected the protein-protein and protein-lipid affinities, protein and lipid concentrations, and volume-to-surface-area ratios for 46 interactions between 37 membrane-targeting proteins in human and yeast cells. We find that many of the protein-protein interactions between pairs of proteins involved in clathrin-mediated endocytosis in human and yeast cells can experience enormous increases in effective protein-protein affinity (10-1000 fold) due to membrane localization. Localization of binding partners thus triggers robust protein complexation, suggesting that it can play an important role in controlling the timing of endocytic protein coat formation. Our analysis shows that several other proteins involved in membrane remodeling at various organelles have similar potential to exploit localization. The theory highlights the master role of phosphoinositide lipid concentration, the volume-to-surface-area ratio, and the ratio of 3D to 2D equilibrium constants in triggering (or preventing) constitutive assembly on membranes. Our simple model provides a novel quantitative framework for interpreting or designing in vitro experiments of protein complexation influenced by membrane binding.

Stoichiometric balance of protein copy numbers is measurable and functionally significant in a protein-protein interaction network for yeast endocytosis.

Stoichiometric balance, or dosage balance, implies that proteins that are subunits of obligate complexes (e.g. the ribosome) should have copy numbers expressed to match their stoichiometry in that complex. Establishing balance (or imbalance) is an important tool for inferring subunit function and assembly bottlenecks. We show here that these correlations in protein copy numbers can extend beyond complex subunits to larger protein-protein interactions networks (PPIN) involving a range of reversible binding interactions. We develop a simple method for quantifying balance in any interface-resolved PPINs based on network structure and experimentally observed protein copy numbers. By analyzing such a network for the clathrin-mediated endocytosis (CME) system in yeast, we found that the real protein copy numbers were significantly more balanced in relation to their binding partners compared to randomly sampled sets of yeast copy numbers. The observed balance is not perfect, highlighting both under and overexpressed proteins. We evaluate the potential cost and benefits of imbalance using two criteria. First, a potential cost to imbalance is that 'leftover' proteins without remaining functional partners are free to misinteract. We systematically quantify how this misinteraction cost is most dangerous for strong-binding protein interactions and for network topologies observed in biological PPINs. Second, a more direct consequence of imbalance is that the formation of specific functional complexes depends on relative copy numbers. We therefore construct simple kinetic models of two sub-networks in the CME network to assess multi-protein assembly of the ARP2/3 complex and a minimal, nine-protein clathrin-coated vesicle forming module. We find that the observed, imperfectly balanced copy numbers are less effective than balanced copy numbers in producing fast and complete multi-protein assemblies. However, we speculate that strategic imbalance in the vesicle forming module allows cells to tune where endocytosis occurs, providing sensitive control over cargo uptake via clathrin-coated vesicles.

Protein-protein binding selectivity and network topology constrain global and local properties of interface binding networks.

Protein-protein interactions networks (PPINs) are known to share a highly conserved structure across all organisms. What is poorly understood, however, is the structure of the child interface interaction networks (IINs), which map the binding sites proteins use for each interaction. In this study we analyze four independently constructed IINs from yeast and humans and find a conserved structure of these networks with a unique topology distinct from the parent PPIN. Using an IIN sampling algorithm and a fitness function trained on the manually curated PPINs, we show that IIN topology can be mostly explained as a balance between limits on interface diversity and a need for physico-chemical binding complementarity. This complementarity must be optimized both for functional interactions and against mis-interactions, and this selectivity is encoded in the IIN motifs. To test whether the parent PPIN shapes IINs, we compared optimal IINs in biological PPINs versus random PPINs. We found that the hubs in biological networks allow for selective binding with minimal interfaces, suggesting that binding specificity is an additional pressure for a scale-free-like PPIN. We confirm through phylogenetic analysis that hub interfaces are strongly conserved and rewiring of interactions between proteins involved in endocytosis preserves interface binding selectivity.

Theory of bi-molecular association dynamics in 2D for accurate model and experimental parameterization of binding rates.

The dynamics of association between diffusing and reacting molecular species are routinely quantified using simple rate-equation kinetics that assume both well-mixed concentrations of species and a single rate constant for parameterizing the binding rate. In two-dimensions (2D), however, even when systems are well-mixed, the assumption of a single characteristic rate constant for describing association is not generally accurate, due to the properties of diffusional searching in dimensions d ≤ 2. Establishing rigorous bounds for discriminating between 2D reactive systems that will be accurately described by rate equations with a single rate constant, and those that will not, is critical for both modeling and experimentally parameterizing binding reactions restricted to surfaces such as cellular membranes. We show here that in regimes of intrinsic reaction rate (ka) and diffusion (D) parameters ka/D > 0.05, a single rate constant cannot be fit to the dynamics of concentrations of associating species independently of the initial conditions. Instead, a more sophisticated multi-parametric description than rate-equations is necessary to robustly characterize bimolecular reactions from experiment. Our quantitative bounds derive from our new analysis of 2D rate-behavior predicted from Smoluchowski theory. Using a recently developed single particle reaction-diffusion algorithm we extend here to 2D, we are able to test and validate the predictions of Smoluchowski theory and several other theories of reversible reaction dynamics in 2D for the first time. Finally, our results also mean that simulations of reactive systems in 2D using rate equations must be undertaken with caution when reactions have ka/D > 0.05, regardless of the simulation volume. We introduce here a simple formula for an adaptive concentration dependent rate constant for these chemical kinetics simulations which improves on existing formulas to better capture non-equilibrium reaction dynamics from dilute to dense systems.