Sources of Variability in Real-time Monitoring Data for Fine Particulate Matter: Comparability of Three Wearable Monitors in an Urban Setting.

The increasing availability of portable air pollution monitoring devices has greatly enhanced the ability to measure personal exposures in real time. However, these devices vary considerably in their cost and specifications, and questions remain as to their reliability and practicality for use in epidemiological investigations. In this field study, three personal PM2.5 exposure monitors (two nephelometers, one optical particle counter) were compared in an urban setting to assess their feasibility for use in future studies. In total, 3963 1-min measurements were collected over 12 days from locations of several types (e.g., above and below-ground subway stations, sidewalks next to urban traffic, outdoor construction sites) in the Washington, D.C. metropolitan area. Overall, we observed moderate-to-high agreement in pairwise comparisons of PM2.5 concentrations between devices (R2 range: 0.37 to 0.75). Bland-Altman plots showed that differences in device agreement varied over the range of mean concentrations. In linear mixed models adjusting for temperature and relative humidity, we saw significant interaction between device and location (p<0.05), suggesting that the relationship between devices was not constant in all locations. Our finding of heterogeneity in instrument comparability by location may have important implications in epidemiologic studies incorporating personal PM2.5 measurements.

Climate change and temperature extremes: A review of heat- and cold-related morbidity and mortality concerns of municipalities.

Cold and hot weather are associated with mortality and morbidity. Although the burden of temperature-associated mortality may shift towards high temperatures in the future, cold temperatures may represent a greater current-day problem in temperate cities. Hot and cold temperature vulnerabilities may coincide across several personal and neighborhood characteristics, suggesting opportunities for increasing present and future resilience to extreme temperatures. We present a narrative literature review encompassing the epidemiology of cold- and heat-related mortality and morbidity, related physiologic and environmental mechanisms, and municipal responses to hot and cold weather, illustrated by Detroit, Michigan, USA, a financially burdened city in an economically diverse metropolitan area. The Detroit area experiences sharp increases in mortality and hospitalizations with extreme heat, while cold temperatures are associated with more gradual increases in mortality, with no clear threshold. Interventions such as heating and cooling centers may reduce but not eliminate temperature-associated health problems. Furthermore, direct hemodynamic responses to cold, sudden exertion, poor indoor air quality and respiratory epidemics likely contribute to cold-related mortality. Short- and long-term interventions to enhance energy and housing security and housing quality may reduce temperature-related health problems. Extreme temperatures can increase morbidity and mortality in municipalities like Detroit that experience both extreme heat and prolonged cold seasons amidst large socioeconomic disparities. The similarities in physiologic and built-environment vulnerabilities to both hot and cold weather suggest prioritization of strategies that address both present-day cold and near-future heat concerns.