Comments on the paper 'A novel 3D wavelet-based filter for visualizing features in noisy biological data', by Moss et al.

Moss et al. (2005) describe, in a recent paper, a filter that they use to detect lines. We noticed that the wavelet on which this filter is based is a difference of uniform filters. This filter is an approximation to the second-derivative operator, which is commonly implemented as the Laplace of Gaussian (or Marr-Hildreth) operator. We have compared Moss' filter with (1) the Laplace of Gaussian operator, (2) an approximation of the Laplace of Gaussian using uniform filters and (3) a few common noise reduction filters. The Laplace-like operators detect lines by suppressing image features both larger and smaller than the filter size. The noise reduction filters only suppress image features smaller than the filter size. By estimating the signal-to-noise ratio and mean square difference of the filtered results, we found that the filter proposed by Moss et al. does not outperform the Laplace of Gaussian operator. We also found that for images with extreme noise content, line detection filters perform better than the noise reduction filters when trying to enhance line structures. In less extreme cases of noise, the standard noise reduction filters perform significantly better than both the Laplace of Gaussian and Moss' filter.

Analysis of integral membrane protein contributions to the deformability and stability of the human erythrocyte membrane.

Three major hypotheses have been proposed to explain the role of membrane-spanning proteins in establishing/maintaining membrane stability. These hypotheses ascribe the essential contribution of integral membrane proteins to (i) their ability to anchor the membrane skeleton to the lipid bilayer, (ii) their capacity to bind and stabilize membrane lipids, and (iii) their ability to influence and regulate local membrane curvature. In an effort to test these hypotheses in greater detail, we have modified both the membrane skeletal and lipid binding interactions of band 3 (the major membrane-spanning and skeletal binding protein of the human erythrocyte membrane) and have examined the impact of these modifications on erythrocyte membrane morphology, deformability, and stability. The desired changes in membrane skeletal and protein-lipid interactions were induced by 1) reaction of the cells with 4,4'-diisothiocyanostilbene-2,2'-disulfonate (DIDS), an inhibitor of band 3-mediated anion transport that dissociates band 3 into dimers (increasing its surface area in contact with lipid) and severs band 3 linkages to the membrane skeleton; 2) a fragment of ankyrin that ruptures the same ankyrin-band 3 bridge to the membrane skeleton, but drives the band 3 subunit equilibrium toward the tetramer (i.e. decreasing the band 3 surface area in contact with lipid); and 3) an antibody to the ankyrin-binding site on band 3 that promotes the same changes in band 3 skeletal and lipid interactions as the ankyrin fragment. We observed that although DIDS induced echinocytic morphological changes in the treated erythrocytes, it had little impact on either membrane deformability or stability. In contrast, resealing of either the ankyrin fragment or anti-band 3 IgG into erythrocytes caused spontaneous membrane fragmentation and loss of deformability/stability. Because these and other new observations cannot all be reconciled with any single hypothesis on membrane stability, we suggest that more than one hypothesis may be operative and provide an explanation of how each might individually contribute to net membrane stability.

Membrane dynamics of the water transport protein aquaporin-1 in intact human red cells.

Aquaporin-1 (AQP1) is the prototype integral membrane protein water channel. Although the three-dimensional structure and water transport function of the molecule have been described, the physical interactions between AQP1 and other membrane components have not been characterized. Using fluorescein isothiocyanate-anti-Co3 (FITC-anti-Co3), a reagent specific for an extracellular epitope on AQP1, the fluorescence photobleaching recovery (FPR) and fluorescence imaged microdeformation (FIMD) techniques were performed on intact human red cells. By FPR, the fractional mobility of fluorescently labeled AQP1 (F-alphaAQP1) in the undeformed red cell membrane is 66 +/- 10% and the average lateral diffusion coefficient is (3.1 +/- 0.5) x 10(-11) cm2/s. F-alphaAQP1 fractional mobility is not significantly affected by antibody-induced immobilization of the major integral proteins band 3 or glycophorin A, indicating that AQP1 does not exist as a complex with these proteins. FIMD uses pipette aspiration of individual red cells to create a constant but reversible skeletal density gradient. F-alphaAQP1 distribution, like that of lipid-anchored proteins, is not at equilibrium after microdeformation. Over time, approximately 50% of the aspirated F-alphaAQP1 molecules migrate toward the membrane portion that had been maximally dilated, the aspirated cap. Based on the kinetics of migration, the F-alphaAQP1 lateral diffusion coefficient in the membrane projection is estimated to be 6 x 10(-10) cm2/s. These results suggest that AQP1 lateral mobility is regulated in the unperturbed membrane by passive steric hindrance imposed by the spectrin-based membrane skeleton and/or by skeleton-linked membrane components, and that release of these constraints by dilatation of the skeleton allows AQP1 to diffuse much more rapidly in the plane of the membrane.

Erythrocyte membrane vesiculation: model for the molecular mechanism of protein sorting.

Budding and vesiculation of erythrocyte membranes occurs by a process involving an uncoupling of the membrane skeleton from the lipid bilayer. Vesicle formation provides an important means whereby protein sorting and trafficking can occur. To understand the mechanism of sorting at the molecular level, we have developed a micropipette technique to quantify the redistribution of fluorescently labeled erythrocyte membrane components during mechanically induced membrane deformation and vesiculation. Our previous studies indicated that the spectrin-based membrane skeleton deforms elastically, producing a constant density gradient during deformation. Our current studies showed that during vesiculation the skeleton did not fragment but rather retracted to the cell body, resulting in a vesicle completely depleted of skeleton. These local changes in skeletal density regulated the sorting of nonskeletal membrane components. Highly mobile membrane components, phosphatidylethanolamine- and glycosylphosphatidylinositol-linked CD59 with no specific skeletal association were enriched in the vesicle. In contrast, two components with known specific skeletal association, band 3 and glycophorin A, were differentially depleted in vesicles. Increasing the skeletal association of glycophorin A by liganding its extrafacial domain reduced the fraction partitioning to the vesicle. We conclude that this technique of bilayer/skeleton uncoupling provides a means with which to study protein sorting driven by changes in local skeletal density. Moreover, it is the interaction of particular membrane components with the spectrin-based skeleton that determines molecular partitioning during protein sorting.

Cooperative action between band 3 and glycophorin A in human erythrocytes: immobilization of band 3 induced by antibodies to glycophorin A.

The ability of transmembrane receptor proteins to change their association with the cytoskeleton in response to ligand binding seems to be a key mechanism of signal transduction across membranes. To investigate the molecular features of this mechanism we have used the red cell membrane as a model system to study signal transduction through the integral protein, glycophorin A. In these studies the lateral mobility of integral proteins was measured in situ by fluorescence recovery after photobleaching, and membrane rigidity was characterized by micropipette aspiration technique. We found that binding either a monoclonal antibody or its monovalent Fab to the exoplasmic domain of glycophorin A in normal red cells immobilized the receptor and rigidified the membrane. Further, immobilization and rigidification did not occur when antibodies were bound to Miltenberger V cells containing a mutant form of glycophorin A lacking the cytoplasmic domain. These results imply that the site of the immobilization/rigidification lies within the membrane skeletal structure, not in exofacial receptor crosslinking, and requires the extended cytoplasmic domain of normal glycophorin A. In addition, we found that glycophorin A immobilization and membrane skeletal rigidification were accompanied by immobilization of band 3 receptors. This unexpected result indicates a cooperative coupling between liganded glycophorin A, band 3, and the membrane skeleton. We speculate that cooperation of this type may represent a general mechanism for cytoskeletal linkage and transformation initiated by receptors with short cytoplasmic sequences, such as integrins.

Instructor facilitation of the preceptorship relationship in nursing education.

In recognition of the growing popularity of preceptorships as a means of teaching in nursing, a research study was conducted to examine the development of the preceptor relationship. Three questions were addressed: what are the specific elements essential to the development of the preceptorship relationship?; what is the role of the instructor in facilitating the developing preceptorship relationship?; and what are the variables affecting the developing preceptorship relationship? Based on naturalistic observations and direct feedback from 12 preceptor RNs, 12 students, and 2 instructors in acute care hospitals, seven commonly occurring themes were identified as important aspects of the developing relationship.