Gender inclusive and affirming practices across undergraduate nursing curriculum: A scoping review.

OBJECTIVES: There are increasing calls for gender affirming care, yet there remains uncertainty as to how nursing education is preparing students. The purpose of this scoping review was to map gender inclusive and affirming practices across the three levels of curriculum (formal, informal, and hidden) in the education of undergraduate nursing students. This novel approach allows consideration of transgender and gender diverse nurses (students and educators). DESIGN: Scoping review as per Arksey and O'Malley and Levac et al. DATA SOURCES: Four databases (Medline, Embase, CINAHL, and Scopus) were searched for literature that addressed transgender and gender diversity, discussed at any level of curriculum. In addition, we searched key schools of nursing websites for inclusion of gender inclusive and affirming practices in documents and faculty profiles. We limited our search of peer-reviewed articles and websites to those in English, from Canada and the USA. REVIEW METHODS: The article search and extraction were conducted by two independent reviewers while the school of nursing websites were searched by the lead author. RESULTS: Forty-seven articles were included and categorized as either (a) Doing (n = 32) (formal, intervention-based) or (b) Thinking (n = 15) (discussion- or evaluation-based) gender inclusive and affirming practices. Twenty-five of the intervention-based articles were single-instance occurrences of learning, primarily by simulation (n = 17). Recommendations at each level of curriculum are offered. Of the 22 schools of nursing websites searched, less than 2 % of faculty profiles list pronouns. CONCLUSIONS: While there has been an uptake of formal interventions on gender affirming care there remains a gap in addressing gender inclusive and affirming practices at the informal and hidden curriculum levels. Gender inclusive and affirming practices across all levels of nursing education can help advance culturally safe practices for TGD patients and experiences for TGD nurses and students.

Gender-affirming care in undergraduate nursing education: a scoping review protocol.

INTRODUCTION: Transgender and gender-diverse (TGD) people face a multitude of barriers to safe, accessible healthcare. One way to overcome access inequities is through the provision of gender-affirming care. Gender-affirming care is culturally safe and engaged care that values TGD identities and is focused on depathologising TGD people. Additionally, gender-affirming care encompasses awareness and support of TGD individuals as unique beings, including supporting gender-affirming medical goals for those who are interested. The discipline of nursing is well situated to advocate for gender-affirming care, however, receives little undergraduate education in the subject. Undergraduate schools of nursing (including faculty and curriculum) are in a crucial position to implement gender-affirming care, though how they have done this is not widely known. Our scoping review aims to understand how Canadian and US undergraduate schools of nursing teach and integrate gender-affirming education. METHODS AND ANALYSIS: Our scoping review will follow the six stages by Arksey and O'Malley and the advancements by Levac et al, reported on as per the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for scoping reviews. The review will be completed in 2023, with the database searches carried out in spring 2023, followed by screening and analysis. ETHICS AND DISSEMINATION: Ethics approval is not required for this protocol. To aid in knowledge translation, a visual representation of the findings will be created. Results from the final scoping review will be published in a peer-reviewed journal, promoted on social media to schools of nursing, and presented at conferences and seminars. PROTOCOL REGISTRATION NUMBER: Open Science Framework (https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/Q68BD).

Should the concepts chosen to guide concept-based curricula be threshold concepts?

In this paper we propose that the concepts guiding concept-based curricula should be threshold knowledge concepts. We briefly discuss some of the hurdles of current concept-based curricular designs and describe how the concepts themselves, paradoxically, might perpetuate the continued emphasis on content in nursing courses. Until now, threshold concept theory has not been part of the mainstream conversation about concept-based curricula. Threshold concepts act as portals to professional identity development and are recognized by their troublesome and transformative potential to enhance knowledge acquisition and change worldviews. This feature differentiates them from the core concepts often described within concept-based curriculum literature. The identification of threshold concepts in existing nursing courses might help structure curricular revision with the goal of enhancing transfer of learning and decreasing faculty resistance to the concept-based curricular approach.