Quantum dynamical effects of vibrational strong coupling in chemical reactivity.

Recent experiments suggest that ground state chemical reactivity can be modified when placing molecular systems inside infrared cavities where molecular vibrations are strongly coupled to electromagnetic radiation. This phenomenon lacks a firm theoretical explanation. Here, we employ an exact quantum dynamics approach to investigate a model of cavity-modified chemical reactions in the condensed phase. The model contains the coupling of the reaction coordinate to a generic solvent, cavity coupling to either the reaction coordinate or a non-reactive mode, and the coupling of the cavity to lossy modes. Thus, many of the most important features needed for realistic modeling of the cavity modification of chemical reactions are included. We find that when a molecule is coupled to an optical cavity it is essential to treat the problem quantum mechanically to obtain a quantitative account of alterations to reactivity. We find sizable and sharp changes in the rate constant that are associated with quantum mechanical state splittings and resonances. The features that emerge from our simulations are closer to those observed in experiments than are previous calculations, even for realistically small values of coupling and cavity loss. This work highlights the importance of a fully quantum treatment of vibrational polariton chemistry.

Resonant Cavity Modification of Ground-State Chemical Kinetics.

Recent experiments have suggested that ground-state chemical kinetics can be suppressed or enhanced by coupling molecular vibrations with a cavity radiation mode. Here, we develop an analytical rate theory for cavity-modified chemical kinetics based on the Pollak-Grabert-Hänggi theory. Unlike previous work, our theory covers the complete range of solvent friction values, from the energy-diffusion-limited to the spatial-diffusion-limited regimes. We show that chemical kinetics is enhanced when bath friction is weak and suppressed when bath friction is strong. For weak bath friction, the resonant photon frequency (at which the maximum modification of the chemical rate is achieved) is close to the reactant well. In the strong friction limit, the resonant photon frequency is instead close to the barrier frequency. Finally, we observe that rate changes as a function of the photon frequency are much sharper and more sizable in the weak friction limit than in the strong friction limit.

Time evolution of ML-MCTDH wavefunctions. I. Gauge conditions, basis functions, and singularities.

We derive a family of equations-of-motion (EOMs) for evolving multi-layer multiconfiguration time-dependent Hartree (ML-MCTDH) wavefunctions that, unlike the standard ML-MCTDH EOMs, never require the evaluation of the inverse of singular matrices. All members of this family of EOMs make use of alternative static gauge conditions than those used for standard ML-MCTDH. These alternative conditions result in an expansion of the wavefunction in terms of a set of potentially arbitrary orthonormal functions, rather than in terms of a set of non-orthonormal and potentially linearly dependent functions, as is the case for standard ML-MCTDH. We show that the EOMs used in the projector splitting integrator (PSI) and the invariant EOM approaches are two special cases of this family obtained from different choices for the dynamic gauge condition, with the invariant EOMs making use of a choice that introduces potentially unbounded operators into the EOMs. As a consequence, all arguments for the existence of parallelizable integration schemes for the invariant EOMs can also be applied to the PSI EOMs.

Time evolution of ML-MCTDH wavefunctions. II. Application of the projector splitting integrator.

The multi-layer multi-configuration time-dependent Hartree (ML-MCTDH) approach can suffer from numerical instabilities whenever the wavefunction is weakly entangled. These instabilities arise from singularities in the equations of motion (EOMs) and necessitate the use of regularization of the EOMs. The Projector Splitting Integrator (PSI) has previously been presented as an approach for evolving ML-MCTDH wavefunctions that is free of singularities. Here, we will discuss the implementation of the multi-layer PSI with a particular focus on how the steps required relate to those required to implement standard ML-MCTDH. We demonstrate the efficiency and stability of the PSI for large ML-MCTDH wavefunctions containing up to hundreds of thousands of nodes by considering a series of spin-boson models with up to 106 bath modes and find that for these problems, the PSI requires roughly 3-4 orders of magnitude fewer Hamiltonian evaluations and 2-3 orders of magnitude fewer Hamiltonian applications than standard ML-MCTDH and 2-3/1-2 orders of magnitude fewer evaluations/applications than approaches that use improved regularization schemes. Finally, we consider a series of significantly more challenging multi-spin-boson models that require much larger numbers of single-particle functions with wavefunctions containing up to ∼1.3×109 parameters to obtain accurate dynamics.

Spin relaxation in radical pairs from the stochastic Schrödinger equation.

We show that the stochastic Schrödinger equation (SSE) provides an ideal way to simulate the quantum mechanical spin dynamics of radical pairs. Electron spin relaxation effects arising from fluctuations in the spin Hamiltonian are straightforward to include in this approach, and their treatment can be combined with a highly efficient stochastic evaluation of the trace over nuclear spin states that is required to compute experimental observables. These features are illustrated in example applications to a flavin-tryptophan radical pair of interest in avian magnetoreception and to a problem involving spin-selective radical pair recombination along a molecular wire. In the first of these examples, the SSE is shown to be both more efficient and more widely applicable than a recent stochastic implementation of the Lindblad equation, which only provides a valid treatment of relaxation in the extreme-narrowing limit. In the second, the exact SSE results are used to assess the accuracy of a recently proposed combination of Nakajima-Zwanzig theory for the spin relaxation and Schulten-Wolynes theory for the spin dynamics, which is applicable to radical pairs with many more nuclear spins. We also analyze the efficiency of trace sampling in some detail, highlighting the particular advantages of sampling with SU(N) coherent states.

Quantum mechanical spin dynamics of a molecular magnetoreceptor.

Radical pair recombination reactions are known to be sensitive to extremely weak magnetic fields and can therefore be said to function as molecular magnetoreceptors. The classic example is a carotenoid-porphyrin-fullerene (C•+PF•-) radical pair that has been shown to provide a "proof-of-principle" for the operation of a chemical compass [K. Maeda et al., Nature 453, 387 (2008)]. Previous simulations of this radical pair have employed semiclassical approximations, which are routinely applicable to its 47 coupled electronic and nuclear spins. However, calculating the exact quantum mechanical spin dynamics presents a significant challenge and has not been possible until now. Here, we use a recently developed method to perform numerically converged simulations of the C•+PF•- quantum mechanical spin dynamics, including all coupled spins. A comparison of these quantum mechanical simulations with various semiclassical approximations reveals that, while it is not perfect, the best semiclassical approximation does capture essentially all of the relevant physics in this problem.

Electron spin relaxation in radical pairs: Beyond the Redfield approximation.

Relaxation processes can have a large effect on the spin selective electron transfer reactions of radical pairs. These processes are often treated using phenomenological relaxation superoperators or with some model for the microscopic relaxation mechanism treated within Bloch-Redfield-Wangsness theory. Here, we demonstrate that an alternative perturbative relaxation theory, based on the Nakajima-Zwanzig equation, has certain advantages over Redfield theory. In particular, the Nakajima-Zwanzig equation does not suffer from the severe positivity problem of Redfield theory in the static disorder limit. Combining the Nakajima-Zwanzig approach consistently with the Schulten-Wolynes semiclassical method, we obtain an efficient method for modeling the spin dynamics of radical pairs containing many hyperfine-coupled nuclear spins. This is then used to investigate the spin-dependent electron transfer reactions and intersystem crossing of dimethyljulolidine-naphthalenediimide (DMJ-NDI) radical ion pairs. By comparing our simulations with experimental data, we find evidence for a field-independent contribution to the triplet quantum yields of these reactions which cannot be explained by electron spin relaxation alone.

How quantum is radical pair magnetoreception?

Currently the most likely mechanism of the magnetic compass sense in migratory songbirds relies on the coherent spin dynamics of pairs of photochemically formed radicals in the retina. Spin-conserving electron transfer reactions are thought to result in radical pairs whose near-degenerate electronic singlet and triplet states interconvert coherently as a result of hyperfine, exchange, and dipolar couplings and, crucially for a compass sensor, Zeeman interactions with the geomagnetic field. In this way, the yields of the reaction products can be influenced by magnetic interactions a million times smaller than kBT. The question we ask here is whether one can only account for the coherent spin dynamics using quantum mechanics. We find that semiclassical approximations to the spin dynamics of radical pairs only provide a satisfactory description of the anisotropic product yields when there is no electron spin-spin coupling, a situation unlikely to be consistent with a magnetic sensing function. Although these methods perform reasonably well for shorter-lived radical pairs with stronger electron-spin coupling, the accurate simulation of anisotropic magnetic field effects relevant to magnetoreception seems to require full quantum mechanical calculations.

On the calculation of quantum mechanical electron transfer rates.

We present a simple interpolation formula for the rate of an electron transfer reaction as a function of the electronic coupling strength. The formula only requires the calculation of Fermi golden rule and Born-Oppenheimer rates and so can be combined with any methods that are able to calculate these rates. We first demonstrate the accuracy of the formula by applying it to a one dimensional scattering problem for which the exact quantum mechanical, Fermi golden rule, and Born-Oppenheimer rates are readily calculated. We then describe how the formula can be combined with the Wolynes theory approximation to the golden rule rate, and the ring polymer molecular dynamics (RPMD) approximation to the Born-Oppenheimer rate, and used to capture the effects of nuclear tunneling, zero point energy, and solvent friction on condensed phase electron transfer reactions. Comparison with exact hierarchical equations of motion results for a demanding set of spin-boson models shows that the interpolation formula has an error comparable to that of RPMD rate theory in the adiabatic limit, and that of Wolynes theory in the nonadiabatic limit, and is therefore as accurate as any method could possibly be that attempts to generalize these methods to arbitrary electronic coupling strengths.

Spin-selective electron transfer reactions of radical pairs: Beyond the Haberkorn master equation.

Radical pair recombination reactions are normally described using a quantum mechanical master equation for the electronic and nuclear spin density operator. The electron spin state selective (singlet and triplet) recombination processes are described with a Haberkorn reaction term in this master equation. Here we consider a general spin state selective electron transfer reaction of a radical pair and use Nakajima-Zwanzig theory to derive the master equation for the spin density operator, thereby elucidating the relationship between non-adiabatic reaction rate theory and the Haberkorn reaction term. A second order perturbation theory treatment of the diabatic coupling naturally results in the Haberkorn master equation with an additional reactive scalar electron spin coupling term. This term has been neglected in previous spin chemistry calculations, but we show that it will often be quite significant. We also show that beyond the second order in perturbation theory, i.e., beyond the Fermi golden rule limit, an additional reactive singlet-triplet dephasing term appears in the master equation. A closed form expression for the reactive scalar electron spin coupling in terms of the Marcus theory parameters that determine the singlet and triplet recombination rates is presented. By performing simulations of radical pair reactions with the exact hierarchical equations of motion method, we demonstrate that our master equations provide a very accurate description of radical pairs undergoing spin-selective non-adiabatic electron transfer reactions. The existence of a reactive electron spin coupling may well have implications for biologically relevant radical pair reactions such as those which have been suggested to play a role in avian magnetoreception.

Simple and Accurate Method for Central Spin Problems.

We describe a simple quantum mechanical method that can be used to obtain accurate numerical results over long timescales for the spin correlation tensor of an electron spin that is hyperfine coupled to a large number of nuclear spins. This method does not suffer from the statistical errors that accompany a Monte Carlo sampling of the exact eigenstates of the central spin Hamiltonian obtained from the algebraic Bethe ansatz, or from the growth of the truncation error with time in the time-dependent density matrix renormalization group (TDMRG) approach. As a result, it can be applied to larger central spin problems than the algebraic Bethe ansatz, and for longer times than the TDMRG algorithm. It is therefore an ideal method to use to solve central spin problems, and we expect that it will also prove useful for a variety of related problems that arise in a number of different research fields.

Path integrals with higher order actions: Application to realistic chemical systems.

Quantum thermodynamic parameters can be determined using path integral Monte Carlo (PIMC) simulations. These simulations, however, become computationally demanding as the quantum nature of the system increases, although their efficiency can be improved by using higher order approximations to the thermal density matrix, specifically the action. Here we compare the standard, primitive approximation to the action (PA) and three higher order approximations, the Takahashi-Imada action (TIA), the Suzuki-Chin action (SCA) and the Chin action (CA). The resulting PIMC methods are applied to two realistic potential energy surfaces, for H2O and HCN-HNC, both of which are spectroscopically accurate and contain three-body interactions. We further numerically optimise, for each potential, the SCA parameter and the two free parameters in the CA, obtaining more significant improvements in efficiency than seen previously in the literature. For both H2O and HCN-HNC, accounting for all required potential and force evaluations, the optimised CA formalism is approximately twice as efficient as the TIA formalism and approximately an order of magnitude more efficient than the PA. The optimised SCA formalism shows similar efficiency gains to the CA for HCN-HNC but has similar efficiency to the TIA for H2O at low temperature. In H2O and HCN-HNC systems, the optimal value of the a1 CA parameter is approximately 13, corresponding to an equal weighting of all force terms in the thermal density matrix, and similar to previous studies, the optimal α parameter in the SCA was ∼0.31. Importantly, poor choice of parameter significantly degrades the performance of the SCA and CA methods. In particular, for the CA, setting a1 = 0 is not efficient: the reduction in convergence efficiency is not offset by the lower number of force evaluations. We also find that the harmonic approximation to the CA parameters, whilst providing a fourth order approximation to the action, is not optimal for these realistic potentials: numerical optimisation leads to better approximate cancellation of the fifth order terms, with deviation between the harmonic and numerically optimised parameters more marked in the more quantum H2O system. This suggests that numerically optimising the CA or SCA parameters, which can be done at high temperature, will be important in fully realising the efficiency gains of these formalisms for realistic potentials.

Path integral Monte Carlo simulations of H2 adsorbed to lithium-doped benzene: A model for hydrogen storage materials.

Finite temperature quantum and anharmonic effects are studied in H2-Li(+)-benzene, a model hydrogen storage material, using path integral Monte Carlo (PIMC) simulations on an interpolated potential energy surface refined over the eight intermolecular degrees of freedom based upon M05-2X/6-311+G(2df,p) density functional theory calculations. Rigid-body PIMC simulations are performed at temperatures ranging from 77 K to 150 K, producing both quantum and classical probability density histograms describing the adsorbed H2. Quantum effects broaden the histograms with respect to their classical analogues and increase the expectation values of the radial and angular polar coordinates describing the location of the center-of-mass of the H2 molecule. The rigid-body PIMC simulations also provide estimates of the change in internal energy, ΔUads, and enthalpy, ΔHads, for H2 adsorption onto Li(+)-benzene, as a function of temperature. These estimates indicate that quantum effects are important even at room temperature and classical results should be interpreted with caution. Our results also show that anharmonicity is more important in the calculation of U and H than coupling-coupling between the intermolecular degrees of freedom becomes less important as temperature increases whereas anharmonicity becomes more important. The most anharmonic motions in H2-Li(+)-benzene are the "helicopter" and "ferris wheel" H2 rotations. Treating these motions as one-dimensional free and hindered rotors, respectively, provides simple corrections to standard harmonic oscillator, rigid rotor thermochemical expressions for internal energy and enthalpy that encapsulate the majority of the anharmonicity. At 150 K, our best rigid-body PIMC estimates for ΔUads and ΔHads are -13.3 ± 0.1 and -14.5 ± 0.1 kJ mol(-1), respectively.