Descripción y aplicación clínica de las escalas de valoración geriátrica integral: una revisión sistemática rápida de revisiones / Description and clinical application of comprehensive geriatric assessment scales: a rapid systematic review of reviews

Objetivo Realizar una descripción de las principales escalas utilizadas en la valoración geriátrica integral mediante un análisis narrativo detallando su aplicación clínica en relación con sus ventajas y desventajas en función de sus propiedades psicométricas (valoración mental) y los sesgos en su aplicación. Las escalas seleccionadas fueron: índice de Barthel, índice de Katz, escala de Lawton y Brody, mini-examen del estado mental, test del reloj, escala de depresión geriátrica y la escala de recursos sociales. Métodos Se realizó una revisión sistemática rápida de revisiones en MEDLINE (PubMed) hasta enero de 2021, informando de los hallazgos mediante PRISMA, 2020. Para construir la estrategia de búsqueda reproducible se empleó el lenguaje MeSH, palabras clave y los operadores booleanos AND y OR. Resultados Se seleccionaron 31 que cumplieron los criterios de elegibilidad; 18 revisiones sistemáticas, 12 revisiones de la literatura y una revisión de alcance. Se encontraron múltiples versiones para algunas de las escalas y se constataron sesgos en su interpretación. Se recomienda la administración de cuestionarios cortos y fáciles de aplicar y se aconseja que los puntos de corte se definan según la educación formal. Conclusión Las escalas de valoración geriátrica integral son instrumentos baratos, eficaces y útiles para detectar problemas y potencialidad en las personas mayores. Deben ser de fácil aplicación, no extensas, válidas para múltiples culturas y distintos niveles de educación formal y aplicables a diferentes grados de discapacidad. Es recomendable que los profesionales sanitarios se entrenen en su uso para evitar sesgos en la interpretación de los resultados (AU)

Objective This work aims to describe the main scales used in comprehensive geriatric assessment through a narrative analysis detailing their clinical application in relation to their advantages and disadvantages in terms of their psychometric properties (mental assessment) and biases in their application. The scales selected were: Barthel Index, Katz Index, Lawton and Brody Scale, Mini-Mental State Examination, Clock Test, Geriatric Depression Scale, and the Social Resources Scale. Methods We conducted a rapid systematic review of reviews in MEDLINE (PubMed) up to January 2021, reporting findings using PRISMA, 2020. MeSH language, keywords, and the Boolean operators AND and OR were used to construct the reproducible search strategy. Results Thirty-one works were selected that met the eligibility criteria: 18 systematic reviews, 12 literature reviews, and one scoping review. Multiple versions were found for some of the scales and biases in their interpretation were observed. Short, easy-to-administer questionnaires are recommended and cut-off points should be defined by formal education. Conclusion Comprehensive geriatric assessment scales are inexpensive, effective, and useful instruments for identifying problems and potential problems in the elderly. They should be easy to apply, not extensive, valid for multiple cultures and different levels of formal education, and applicable to individuals with different degrees of disability. It is recommended that health professionals be instructed in their use to avoid biases in the interpretation of the results (AU)

Description and clinical application of comprehensive geriatric assessment scales: A rapid systematic review of reviews.

OBJECTIVE: This work aims to describe the main scales used in comprehensive geriatric assessment through a narrative analysis detailing their clinical application in relation to their advantages and disadvantages in terms of their psychometric properties (mental assessment) and biases in their application. The scales selected were: Barthel Index, Katz Index, Lawton and Brody Scale, Mini-Mental State Examination, Clock Test, Geriatric Depression Scale, and the Social Resources Scale. METHODS: We conducted a rapid systematic review of reviews in MEDLINE (PubMed) up to January 2021, reporting findings using PRISMA, 2020. MeSH language, keywords, and the Boolean operators AND and OR were used to construct the reproducible search strategy. RESULTS: Thirty-one works were selected that met the eligibility criteria: 18 systematic reviews, 12 literature reviews, and one scoping review. Multiple versions were found for some of the scales and biases in their interpretation were observed. Short, easy-to-administer questionnaires are recommended and cut-off points should be defined by formal education. CONCLUSION: Comprehensive geriatric assessment scales are inexpensive, effective, and useful instruments for identifying problems and potential problems in the elderly. They should be easy to apply, not extensive, valid for multiple cultures and different levels of formal education, and applicable to individuals with different degrees of disability. It is recommended that health professionals be instructed in their use to avoid biases in the interpretation of the results.

Evaluation of the mini-nutritional assessment short-form (MNA-SF)among institutionalized older patients in Spain / Evaluación del test corto de valoración nutricional (MNA-SF) en ancianos institucionalizados en España

Introduction: In the present study, we evaluated a short form version of MNA test in a multicenter study and the relationship of different biochemical markers with MNASF scores. Material and methods: This was a cross-sectional survey covering a sample of representative of the older institutionalized Spanish population aged above 65 years (n = 873). A Mini nutritional assessment short form test (MNA-SF) was used. Results: The number of patients classified as well nouri shed (42.1%) was larger in the 65-74 (52.6%) range than in the 75-84 (40.2%), 85-94 (43.8%) and > 95 (24%) age ranges. Risk of undernutrition occurred in a total of 506 patients (57.9%), risk of undernutrition was larger in > 95 (76%) range than in 65-74 (47.4%), 75-84 (59.8%) and 85-94 range (56.2%). No differences were detected between males and females at risk of undernutrition (odds ratio: 0.85 CI 95%: 0.64-1.12). Conclusion: In this multicenter study, institutionalized patients have a high prevalence of at risk of malnutrition assessed by MNA-SF test (AU)

Introducción: En el presente estudio, se evaluó una versión corta del test MNA en un estudio multicéntrico y se valoro la relación de los marcadores bioquímicos con el test MNA-SF. Material y métodos: Se realizó un estudio transversal de una muestra representativa de la población anciana institucionalizada española de más de 65 años (n = 873). Se utilizó en todos los pacientes el test de valoración nutricional en su versión corta (MNA-SF). Resultados: El número de pacientes clasificados como bien nutridos (42,1%) fue mayor en los ancianos de 65-74 años (52,6%) que en el rango de edad entre 75 a 84 (40,2%), 85-94 años (43,8%) y > 95 años (24%). La situación de riesgo de desnutrición se produjo en un total de 506 pacientes (57,9%), este riesgo de desnutrición fue mayor en los ancianos mayores de 95 años (76%) que en el rango de edad de 65 a 74 años (47,4%), de 75 a 84 años (59,8%) y de 85-94 años (56,2%). No se detectaron diferencias entre hombres y mujeres en riesgo de desnutrición (OR: 0,85 IC 95% : 0.64-1.12). Conclusión: En este estudio multicéntrico, los pacientes ancianos institucionalizados tienen una alta prevalencia de riesgo de desnutrición evaluada por el test MNA-SF (AU)

Nutritional status in a multicenter study among institutionalized patients in Spain.

INTRODUCTION: The aim of our study was to investigate and evaluate, in a multicenter study, the prevalence of malnutrition as well as the relationship between different anthropometric and biochemical markers with Mininutritional assessment (MNA) scores. SUBJECTS AND METHODS: A representative sample of the institutionalized Spanish population aged 65 and older (stricly speaking, born in 1942 or earlier), is covered in this cross-sectional survey. Anthropometric variables, MNA test and biochemical evaluation were performed by Geriatrics Units specialists. RESULTS: The percentage of patients classified as well nourished (27.8%) was larger in the 85-94 (39.4%) range than in the 65-74 (26.2%), 75-84 (24%) and > 95 (14.8%) age ranges. A population of 254 patients (49.6%) were at risk of undernutrition, a number which was larger in 75-84 (52%), 65-74 (53.8%) and > 95 (53.7%) than in the 85-94 (44.1%) ones. On the other hand, undernourishment (22.5%) was larger in those of 95 and older (31.5%) than in 85-94 (16.5%), 75-84 (24%) and 65-74 (20%) patients. According to our investigation females are worse nourished (Odd's Ratio 0.51 CI 95%: 0.33-0.79) and, consequently, more undernourished (Odd's Ratio 2.36 CI 95%: 1.48-3.74) than males. No significant differences in the "at risk of undernutrition category" (Odd's Ratio 0.76 CI 95%: 0.52-1.10) were observed but, in transferrin, iron, haemoglobin and total cholesterol, statistical differences among MNA classification were detected. MNA scores were correlated with iron, total cholesterol, albumin, transferrin, age and haemoglobin. CONCLUSION: In this multicenter study, institutionalized patients have a high prevalence of undernutrition or are at-risk, as well as females are more undernourished than males.

Evaluation of the mini-nutritional assessment short-form (MNA-SF) among institutionalized older patients in Spain.

INTRODUCTION: In the present study, we evaluated a short form version of MNA test in a multicenter study and the relationship of different biochemical markers with MNASF scores. MATERIAL AND METHODS: This was a cross-sectional survey covering a sample of representative of the older institutionalized Spanish population aged above 65 years (n = 873). A Mini nutritional assessment short form test (MNA-SF) was used. RESULTS: The number of patients classified as well nourished (42.1%) was larger in the 65-74 (52.6%) range than in the 75-84 (40.2%), 85-94 (43.8%) and > 95 (24%) age ranges. Risk of undernutrition occurred in a total of 506 patients (57.9%), risk of undernutrition was larger in > 95 (76%) range than in 65-74 (47.4%), 75-84 (59.8%) and 85-94 range (56.2%). No differences were detected between males and females at risk of undernutrition (odds ratio: 0.85 CI 95%: 0.64-1.12). CONCLUSION: In this multicenter study, institutionalized patients have a high prevalence of at risk of malnutrition assessed by MNA-SF test.

Prevalence of metabolic syndrome with International Diabetes Federation Criteria and ATP III Program in patients 65 years of age or older.

BACKGROUND: The relationship between cardiovascular factors and death can vary with age, very few studies have examined metabolic syndrome in the elderly. OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study is to assess the prevalence of the MS in a sample of elderly institutionalized patients (> 65 years) using ATPIII and IDF definitions. DESIGN: This was a cross-sectional survey covering a sample of representative of the institutionalized Spanish population aged above 65 years. The final sample study consisted of 862 patients, 556 females and 306 males. ATPIII and IDF definitions were used to classify the patients. RESULTS: Prevalence of MS was different according to the two definitions used. When the IDF definition was applied, total prevalence was 48.91% (CI 95%:43.47-50.25), while prevalence according to ATPIII criteria was 46.80% (CI = 43.47-50.25). a higher prevalence of MS was found in females as compared to males. Using IDF criteria, odds ratio was 1.9 (CI 95%:1.4-2.6) and 1.7 (CI 95%:1.2-2.2) according to ATPIII criteria. a steady decrease is seen in MS prevalence as the age of patients increases (the last two groups (85-94 ys and > 95 ys), both for the ATP III and the IDF definitions. CONCLUSION: A higher prevalence of MS in this elderly population as compared to general population was observed. A decrease of this prevalence above 95 years was detected.

Evaluación de la patología neoplásica y su repercusión en el estado funcional del anciano institucionalizado / Evaluation of the neoplastic condition and its impact on the functional status of the institutionalized elderly patient

Este estudio pretende conocer la prevalencía de patología neoplásica en la Residencia "Cardenal Marcelo", las características de esta enfermedad en los ancianos que la padecen (síntomas, evolución, tratamiento... etc.) y como repercute la patología neoplásica en el estado funcional del paciente. Para ello se llevó a cabo una revisión de las historias médicas de todos los residentes ingresados en dicha residencia en el momento de inicio del estudio, con el fin de determinar quién padecía patología neoplásica. Posteriormente se llevó a cabo un protocolo que incluía datos referentes a dicha patología y los test que miden la valoración funcional. Una vez recogidos y analizados todos estos datos se realiza un estudio descriptivo observacional transversal. Una de las conclusiones de dicho estudio es afirmar nuevamente: "Los ancianos son marginados de la oncología". Otro dato de interés es la falta de correlación entre la existencia de patología neoplásica y el grado de dependencia funcional (AU)