New insights into the mechanism of electrotransfer of small nucleic acids.

RNA interference (RNAi) is a powerful and rapidly developing technology that enables precise silencing of genes of interest. However, the clinical development of RNAi is hampered by the limited cellular uptake and stability of the transferred molecules. Electroporation (EP) is an efficient and versatile technique for the transfer of both RNA and DNA. Although the mechanism of electrotransfer of small nucleic acids has been studied previously, too little is known about the potential effects of significantly larger pDNA on this process. Here we present a fundamental study of the mechanism of electrotransfer of oligonucleotides and siRNA that occur independently and simultaneously with pDNA by employing confocal fluorescence microscopy. In contrast to the conditional understanding of the mechanism, we have shown that the electrotransfer of oligonucleotides and siRNA is driven by both electrophoretic forces and diffusion after EP, followed by subsequent entry into the nucleus within 5 min after treatment. The study also revealed that the efficiency of siRNA electrotransfer decreases in response to an increase in pDNA concentration. Overall, the study provides new insights into the mechanism of electrotransfer of small nucleic acids which may have broader implications for the future application of RNAi-based strategies.

The comparison of the dynamics of Ca2+ and bleomycin intracellular delivery after cell sonoporation and electroporation in vitro.

Ca2+, in combination with SP or EP, induces cell cytotoxicity much faster compared to BLM. The application of BLM in combination with, SP or EP, reaches the level of cell death, induced by similar combination with Ca2+, only after 72 h. The methods of SP and EP were calibrated according to the level of differential cytotoxicity, determined after 6 days (using cell clonogenic assay). The combination of Ca2+ SP induces cell death faster than Ca2+ EP - after Ca2+ SP it increases to a maximum level after 15 min and remains constant for up to 6 days, while the cytotoxic efficiency after Ca2+ EP increases to the level of Ca2+ SP only after 72 h. The combination of BLM SP shows a very similar dynamics to BLM EP - both reach maximal level of cytotoxicity after 48-72 h. Ca2+ and BLM in combination with SP have shown similar levels of cytotoxicity at higher acoustic pressures (≥250 kPa); therefore, Ca2+ SP can be used to induce immediate and maximal level of cytotoxic effect. The faster cytotoxic efficiency of Ca2+ in combination with SP than EP was determined to be due to the involvement of microbubble inertial cavitation.

The Assessment of Calcium and Bleomycin Cytotoxic Efficiency in Relation to Cavitation Dosimetry.

Microbubble (MB)- and ultrasound (US)-facilitated intracellular Ca2+ delivery, known as sonoporation (SP), is a promising anticancer treatment modality, since it allows a spatio-temporally controllable and side-effect-free alternative to conventional chemotherapy. The current study provides extensive evidence that a 5 mM concentration of Ca2+ in combination with US alone or US and Sonovue MBs can be an alternative to the conventional 20 nM concentration of the anticancer drug bleomycin (BLM). Ca2+ application together with SP induces a similar level of death in Chinese hamster ovary cells to the combination of BLM and SP but does not cause systemic toxicity, as is inherent to conventional anticancer drugs. In addition, Ca2+ delivery via SP alters three vital characteristics essential for viable cells: membrane permeability, metabolic activity and proliferation ability. Most importantly, Ca2+ delivery via SP elicits sudden cell death-occurring within 15 min-which remains similar during 24-72 h and 6 d periods. The extensive study of US waves side-scattered by MBs led to the quantification of the cavitation dose (CD) separately for subharmonics, ultraharmonics, harmonics and broadband noise (up to 4 MHz). The CD was suitable for the prognostication of the cytotoxic efficiency of both anticancer agents, Ca2+ and BLM, as was indicated by an overall high (R2 ≥ 0.8) correlation (22 pairs in total). These extensive analytical data imply that a broad range of frequencies are applicable for the feedback-loop control of the process of US-mediated Ca2+ or BLM delivery, successively leading to the eventual standardization of the protocols for the sonotransfer of anticancer agents as well as the establishment of a universal cavitation dosimetry model.

Dosimetric assessment of antitumor treatment by enhanced bleomycin delivery via electroporation and sonoporation.

Targeted and controlled techniques of intratumoral delivery of chemotherapeutic agents are under extensive development, since they diminish detrimental side-effects of conventional anticancer drugs. We investigated the effectiveness of chemotherapy using bleomycin (1 mg/ml) and Sonovue microbubbles combined with: electroporation (EP), mainly designed for subcutaneous tumor therapy, and sonoporation (SP) - for deeper localized tumors. Research was performed on hepatoma MH-22A tumors in murine models, exposed to EP or SP and combined (EP + SP) treatment. Animal survival time and the rate/ speed of tumor growth reduction were examined. Study demonstrated that both EP or SP and their combination (EP + SP) were able to induce the reduction of tumor volume from the 3rd day after treatment. The employment of EP before SP allowed to significantly reduce the values of inertial cavitation dose (ICD), necessary to induce complete tumor reduction and prolong animal survival. The analysis of ultrasound (US) side-scattered signals and B-scan imaging indicated the occurrence of inertial cavitation at our experimental conditions. Strong (R2 = 0.88; p < 0.0001) correlation of ICD with the survival time of corresponding unrecovered mice indicates the option for the dosimetric control and standardization of cavitation activities for in vivo practice.

Ca2+ roles in electroporation-induced changes of cancer cell physiology: From membrane repair to cell death.

The combination of Ca2+ ions and electroporation has gained attention as potential alternative to electrochemotherapy. Ca2+ is an important component of the cell membrane repair system and its presence directly influences the dynamics of the pore cycle after electroporation which can be exploited for cancer therapies. Here, the influence of Ca2+ concentration is investigated on small molecule electrotransfer and release of Calcein from 4T1, MX-1, B16F10, U87 cancer cells after cell exposure to microsecond electric pulses. Moreover, we investigated simultaneous molecule electrotransfer and intracellular calcium ion influx when media was supplemented with different Ca2+ concentrations. Results show that increased concentrations of calcium ions reduce the electrotransfer of small molecules to different lines of cancer cells as well as the release of Calcein. These effects are related with an enhanced membrane repair mechanism. Overall, we show that the efficiency of molecular electrotransfer can be controlled by regulating Ca2+ concentration in the electroporation medium. For the first time, the cause of cancer cell death in vitro from 1 mM CaCl2 concentrations is related to the irreversible loss of Ca2+ homeostasis after cell electroporation. Our findings provide fundamental insight on the mechanisms of Ca2+ electroporation that might lead to improved therapeutic outcomes.

Sudden Cell Death Induced by Ca2+ Delivery via Microbubble Cavitation.

Intracellular calcium ion delivery via sonoporation has been validated to be a substitute for classical chemotherapy. However, the mechanism behind calcium sonoporation remains unclear to this day. To elucidate the role of calcium in the process of sonoporation, we aimed to investigate the influence of different calcium concentration on cell membrane permeabilization and cell viability after sonoporation. In this study, we present experimental evidence that extracellular calcium plays a major role in cell membrane molecular transport after applying ultrasound pulses. Ultrasound-microbubble cavitation in the presence of different calcium concentration affects fundamental cell bio-physio-chemical conditions: cell membrane integrity, metabolic activity, and colony formation. Corresponding vital characteristics were evaluated using three independent viability tests: propidium iodide assay (20 min-3 h), MTT assay (48 h), and cell clonogenic assay (6 d). The results indicate instant cell death, as the level of cell viability was determined to be similar within a 20 min-48 h-6 d period. Inertial cavitation activities have been determined to be directly involved in calcium delivery via sonoporation according to high correlation (R2 > 0.85, p < 0.01) of inertial cavitation dose with change in either cell membrane permeabilization, metabolic activity, and colony formation efficiency. In general, calcium delivery via sonoporation induces rapid cell death, occurring within 20 min after treatment, that is the result of ultrasound mediated microbubble cavitation.

Extracellular-Ca2+-Induced Decrease in Small Molecule Electrotransfer Efficiency: Comparison between Microsecond and Nanosecond Electric Pulses.

Electroporation-a transient electric-field-induced increase in cell membrane permeability-can be used to facilitate the delivery of anticancer drugs for antitumour electrochemotherapy. In recent years, Ca2+ electroporation has emerged as an alternative modality to electrochemotherapy. The antitumor effect of calcium electroporation is achieved as a result of the introduction of supraphysiological calcium doses. However, calcium is also known to play a key role in membrane resealing, potentially altering the pore dynamics and molecular delivery during electroporation. To elucidate the role of calcium for the electrotransfer of small charged molecule into cell we have performed experiments using nano- and micro-second electric pulses. The results demonstrate that extracellular calcium ions inhibit the electrotransfer of small charged molecules. Experiments revealed that this effect is related to an increased rate of membrane resealing. We also employed mathematical modelling methods in order to explain the differences between the CaCl2 effects after the application of nano- and micro-second duration electric pulses. Simulation showed that these differences occur due to the changes in transmembrane voltage generation in response to the increase in specific conductivity when CaCl2 concentration is increased.

The relation of Bleomycin Delivery Efficiency to Microbubble Sonodestruction and Cavitation Spectral Characteristics.

The concurrent assessment of principal sonoporation factors has been accomplished in a single systemic study. Microbubble sonodestruction dynamics and cavitation spectral characteristics, ultrasound scattering and attenuation, were examined in relation to the intracellular delivery of anticancer drug, bleomycin. Experiments were conducted on Chinese hamster ovary cells coadministered with Sonovue microbubbles. Detailed analysis of the scattering and attenuation temporal functions culminated in quantification of metrics, inertial cavitation dose and attenuation rate, suitable for cavitation control. The exponents, representing microbubble sonodestruction kinetics were exploited to derive dosimetric, microbubble sonodestruction rate. High intracorrelation between empirically-attained metrics defines the relations which indicate deep physical interdependencies within inherent phenomena. Subsequently each quantified metric was validated to be well-applicable to prognosticate the efficacy of bleomycin delivery and cell viability, as indicated by strong overall correlation (R2 > 0.85). Presented results draw valuable insights in sonoporation dosimetry and contribute towards the development of universal sonoporation dosimetry model. Both bleomycin delivery and cell viability reach their respective plateau levels by the time, required to attain total microbubble sonodestruction, which accord with scattering and attenuation decrease to background levels. This suggests a well-defined criterion, feasible through signal-registration, universally employable to set optimal duration of exposure for efficient sonoporation outcome.

Calcein Release from Cells In Vitro via Reversible and Irreversible Electroporation.

The aim of this study was to investigate the dependence of calcein extraction and cell viability on the parameters of pulsed electric field (PEF). Two different approaches concerning PEF parameters were investigated: (1) extraction efficiency and cell viability dependence on pulse number, exploiting 1200 V/cm 100 µs duration high voltage (HV) electric pulses and (2) extraction efficiency and cell viability dependence on the pulses with different duration (44-400 µs) and electric field strength (600-1800 V/cm) that result in the same amount of electric field energy delivered to Chinese hamster ovary cells. Extraction efficiency was evaluated as a percentage ratio of calcein fluorescence intensity prior and after PEF treatment. Cell viability was evaluated using PI test and cell clonogenic assay. Moreover, calcein release dynamics from cells after 600 V/cm 400 µs, 1200 V/cm 100 µs, and 1800 V/cm 44 µs was evaluated. Our results show that HV pulses induce instant calcein extraction due to reversible electroporation; however, subsequent calcein leakage over time was only observed when 9 HV pulses of 1800 V/cm 44 µs were used. The increased number of pulses resulted in more efficient total calcein extraction. With the same total energy delivered via electric pulses, the increase of calcein extraction efficiency was more dependent on pulse strength rather than pulse duration. The highest calcein extraction efficiency (84.5 ± 7.4%) was obtained using 9 electric field pulses of 1800 V/cm, 44 µs at 1 Hz. Furthermore, the extraction efficiency can be significantly enhanced if external mechanical stress (pipetting) is applied to cells. Cell viability was determined to be dependent on different PEF exposure parameters. It varied from 96.8 ± 4.8 to 31.2 ± 8.9%, implying the possibility to adjust PEF parameter combinations to maintain high cell viability.

Physical Methods for Drug and Gene Delivery Through the Cell Plasma Membrane.

The cell membrane represents a major barrier for efficient delivery of exogenous molecules, either pharmaceuticals or genetic material, under both in vitro and in vivo conditions. The number of methods employed to attempt safe, efficient, and local drug and gene delivery has increased during the recent years. One method for membrane permeabilization, electroporation, has already been translated to clinical practice for localized anticancer drug delivery and is termed "electrochemotherapy". Clinical trials for gene delivery using electroporation as well as drug delivery using another cell permeabilization method, sonoporation, are also underway. This review focuses on these two methods, including their fundamental principles and state-of-the-art applications. Other techniques, such as microinjection, magnetoporation, photoporation, electrospray, and hydrodynamic and ballistic gene delivery, are also discussed.

Investigation of Microbubble Cavitation-Induced Calcein Release from Cells In Vitro.

In the present study, microbubble (MB) cavitation signal analysis was performed together with calcein release evaluation in both pressure and exposure duration domains of the acoustic field. A passive cavitation detection system was used to simultaneously measure MB scattering and attenuation signals for subsequent extraction efficiency relative to MB cavitation activity. The results indicate that the decrease in the efficiency of extraction of calcein molecules from Chinese hamster ovary cells, as well as cell viability, is associated with MB cavitation activity and can be accurately predicted using inertial cavitation doses up to 0.18 V × s (R2 > 0.9, p < 0.0001). No decrease in additional calcein release or cell viability was observed after complete MB sonodestruction was achieved. This indicates that the optimal exposure duration within which maximal sono-extraction efficiency is obtained coincides with the time necessary to achieve complete MB destruction. These results illustrate the importance of MB inertial cavitation in the sono-extraction process. To our knowledge, this study is the first to (i) investigate small molecule extraction from cells via sonoporation and (ii) relate the extraction process to the quantitative characteristics of MB cavitation acoustic spectra.

Analysis of Metrics for Molecular Sonotransfer in Vitro.

Ultrasound induced microbubble (MB) cavitation is used to significantly enhance cell membrane permeabilization, thereby allowing delivery of various therapeutic agents into cells. In order to monitor and quantitatively control the extent of cavitation the uniform dosimetry model is needed. In present study we have simultaneously performed quantitative evaluation of three main sonoporation factors: (1) MB concentration, (2) MB cavitation extent, and (3) doxorubicin (DOX) sonotransfer into Chinese hamster ovary cells. MB concentration measurement results and passively recorded MB cavitation signals were used for MB sonodestruction rate and spectral root-mean-square (RMS) calculations, respectively. Subsequently, time to maximum value of RMS and inertial cavitation dose (ICD) quantifications were performed for every acoustic pressure value. This comprehensive research has led not only to explanation of relation of ICD and MB sonodestruction rate but also to the development of a new sonoporation metric: the inverse of time to maximum value of RMS (1/time to maximum value of RMS). ICD and MB sonodestruction rate intercorrelation and correlation with DOX sonotransfer suggest inertial cavitation to be the key mechanism for cell sonoporation. All these metrics were successfully used for doxorubicin sonotransfer prediction (R(2) > 0.9, p < 0.01) and therefore shows feasibility to be applied for future dosimetric applications for ultrasound-mediated drug and gene delivery.