Modifications in a Reference Freeze-Dried Direct Agglutination Test to Improve Visceral Leishmaniasis Detection.

Currently, a significantly lower temperature (35°C) than initially established (56°C) is indicated as the maximum temperature storage for the commercial reference visceral leishmaniasis (VL) freeze-dried direct agglutination test (FD-DAT). Despite an approximately 50% loss in the number of promastigotes in an FD-DAT batch that expired 7 years earlier, the promastigotes maintained a similar morphology to the equivalent valid batch implying most likely that auto-agglutination, rather than aging, is the main reason for expiry. The substitution of normal saline which was initially recommended for reconstitution, by citrate-saline/formaldehyde (CSF) as an anti-clumping/preservative agent resulted in restoration of validity comparable with that of the freeze-dried original or the liquid direct agglutination test (LQ-DAT) version (Friedman ANOVA test = 1.0588; P = 0.5890). Following a similar reconstitution procedure as for the 7-year expired antigen, using significantly lower promastigote concentration (1.4 × 107/mL) than in the non-expired (9.0 × 107/mL), good reliability for VL detection and stability at 4°C (> 12 months) were achieved. In comparison with the original version using normal saline ($32.0/vial), the cost-effectiveness of the FD-DAT was appreciably improved by the CSF incorporation and lowering of promastigote concentration per unit suspension medium ($12.8/vial). With diagnostic reliability comparable with the full-out titration used, FD-DAT procedure based on single sample dilution at the VL cutoff (1:3,200) permitted the use of significantly smaller antigen volumes (0.1 mL vs. > 1.5 mL), therefore contributing to a further reduction in the application cost. The successful replacement of ß-mercaptoethanol (ß-ME) by urea (T = 21.00; P = 0.0868) provided the required safety for the test procedure similar to the widely applied LQ-DAT.

Are We Now Well Prepared for Another Major Visceral Leishmaniasis Epidemic in Sudan?

To minimize the chance for future visceral leishmaniasis (VL) epidemics such as the 1988-1991 epidemic in Sudan, several VL detection tools have been introduced. There are many VL diagnostics with excellent sensitivities, specificities, and ease of use reported. However, additional test characteristics should be considered for use in the detection of future VL epidemics. The potential for local production or uninterrupted availability, low production and application costs, and stability at ≥45°C are of the utmost importance. Of the antibody-, antigen-, or DNA-based methods introduced, only a liquid direct agglutination test (LQ-DAT) remains in routine use. The LQ-DAT test may be the ideal diagnostic for detection of VL epidemics due to its low cost ($0.50/patient), stability under frequent and long-duration electric failures, and high level of reproducibility. The improved reliability for VL detection achieved locally through incorporating autochthonous L. donovani strains in antigen processing and precluding toxicants in test execution provides optimal sensitivity and safety for routine and mass application.

rKLO8, a novel Leishmania donovani - derived recombinant immunodominant protein for sensitive detection of visceral leishmaniasis in Sudan.

BACKGROUND: For effective control of visceral leishmaniasis (VL) in East Africa, new rapid diagnostic tests are required to replace current tests with low sensitivity. The aim of this study is to improve diagnosis of VL in East Africa by testing a new antigen from an autochthonous L. donovani strain in Sudan. METHODOLOGY AND PRINCIPLE FINDINGS: We cloned, expressed and purified a novel recombinant protein antigen of L. donovani from Sudan, designated rKLO8, that contains putative conserved domains with significant similarity to the immunodominant kinesin proteins of Leishmania. rKLO8 exhibited 93% and 88% amino acid identity with cloned kinesin proteins of L. infantum (synonymous L. chagasi) (K39) and L. donovani (KE16), respectively. We evaluated the diagnostic efficiency of the recombinant protein in ELISA for specific detection of VL patients from Sudan. Data were compared with a rK39 ELISA and two commercial kits, the rK39 strip test and the direct agglutination test (DAT). Of 106 parasitologically confirmed VL sera, 104 (98.1%) were tested positive by rKLO8 as compared to 102 (96.2%) by rK39. Importantly, the patients' sera showed increased reactivity with rKLO8 than rK39. Specificity was 96.1% and 94.8% for rKLO8- and rK39 ELISAs, respectively. DAT showed 100% specificity and 94.3% sensitivity while rK39 strip test performed with 81.1% sensitivity and 98.7% specificity. CONCLUSION: The increased reactivity of Sudanese VL sera with the rKLO8 makes this antigen a potential candidate for diagnosis of visceral leishmaniasis in Sudan. However, the suitability at the field level will depend on its performance in a rapid test format.

Successful substitution of fetal calf serum by human plasma for bulk cultivation of Leishmania donovani promastigotes.

The potential of human plasma (HP) or serum (HS) as a replacement for fetal calf serum (FCS) was evaluated in a liver infusion tryptose (LIT) medium for bulk cultivation of Leishmania donovani promastigotes. The promastigote yield with the LIT-FCS standard medium was 0.4-1.8×10(7) ml(-1), and yields of 0.5-3.4×10(7) (P = 0.527) and 0.4-2.4×10(7) (P = 0.062) were recorded for two LIT medium variants containing HP or HS as supplement instead of FCS. Significantly, higher promastigote yields of 1.3-4.9×10(7) ml(-1) were demonstrated when LIT medium was supplemented with HP of blood group O but not A, B, AB or equally pooled ABO (P = 0.007-0.020). Matching (P = 0.56) strong positive (1 : 10 2400 to ≥1 : 262 144 00) and weak negative (1 : 5-1 : 160) direct agglutination test (DAT) titres, respectively, were demonstrated in 24 visceral leishmaniasis (VL) and 45 non-VL sera for both standard LIT-FCS and alternative LIT-HP derived antigens. Our findings indicate strong potential for sustainable production of promastigotes for important diagnostic procedures such as DAT in the VL affected areas.

Validation of a ß-ME ELISA for detection of anti Leishmania donovani antibodies in Eastern Sudan.

BACKGROUND: A ß-mercaptoethnol (ß-ME)-treated promastigote antigen of L. donovani was successfully employed in direct agglutination test (DAT) for the diagnosis of visceral leishmaniasis (VL). OBJECTIVE: The ß-ME-treated antigen was further incorporated into an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay set-up (ß-ME ELISA) and evaluated for VL diagnosis against outcome of reference freeze-dried DAT (FD-DAT) and rK39 strip test (RKT) commercial kits. METHODS: Two-hundred and ninety-two sera from patients with high VL suspicion of whom 105 had confirmed L. donovani infection were tested. RESULTS: Relatively higher sensitivities of 93.3% (95% CI: 88.4-98.2) and 92.4% (95% CI: 87.3-97.5) were determined for ß-ME ELISA and FD-DAT as compared to 83.8% (95% CI: 76.7-90.8) for RKT. Of 73 VL sera that scored maximum absorbance values (>0.81) in ß-ME ELISA, 66 (90.4%) tested at the highest agglutination titres (>1:51200) in FD-DAT as did 56 (76.7%) also at comparable reaction intensities (3 + colour intensity) in RKT. Compared with FD-DAT (94.7%, 95% CI: 91.5-97.9) or RKT (93.0%, 95% CI: 89.3-96.6), lower specificity was estimated for ß-ME ELISA (90.4%, 95% CI: 86.1-94.6). Based both on positive and negative microscopy for L. donovani in organ aspirates of all VL suspects enrolled (292), significantly higher correlation (p<0.01, 0.919) was established between ß-ME ELISA and FD-DAT than between ß-ME ELISA and RKT (p<0.01, 0.824). Taking into calculation the combined estimates of sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values, higher agreement (94.8%) was determined between total performance of ß-ME ELISA and FD-DAT than between that of ß-ME ELISA and RKT (90.7%). CONCLUSION: Based on results and merits discussed, we recommend application of this ß-ME ELISA both for diagnosis of VL at laboratory level and confirmation of results obtained with DAT or RKT in the field.

Qualitative and semi-quantitative comparison of an rK39 strip test and direct agglutination test for detection of anti-Leishmania donovani antibodies in the Sudan.

BACKGROUND: Until now, the comparison of the rK39 strip test (RKT) and direct agglutination test (DAT) for detection of visceral leishmaniasis (VL) is exclusively based on either positive or negative qualification of the reaction outcome. OBJECTIVE: In this study, we compared the diagnostic performance of RKT and DAT for VL both qualitatively and semi-quantitatively. METHODS: For comparison based on semi-quantitative grounds, the execution of RKT and DAT was according to the standard procedures. For comparison on semi-qualitative grounds with DAT, the RKT was applied to aliquots from positive samples that were two-fold serially diluted in saline to determine, as for the DAT, the end-point reaction in RKT. RESULTS: While qualitatively both RKT and DAT demonstrated comparable reliability for VL detection (sensitivity = 96% and specificity = 98.7% or 99.3%), no significant correlation (r = 0.13) could be established between intensities of their positive reactions in 25 cases studied. A negative correlation was further determined in those 25 VL cases between the positive intensities of the RKT and antibody levels measured semi-quantitatively with the same procedure (r = -0.36) or the DAT (r = -0.30). Irrespective of the low, moderate or high antibody levels measured with RKT (< or = 1:8 and 1:16-1:32 > or = 1:256) or DAT (< or = 1:25,600 and 1:51,200- 1:409,600 > or = 1:3,276,800) in patients with confirmed or unconfirmed VL infection, exclusively strong positive intensities were obtained with RKT. CONCLUSION: For further optimizing diagnosis and simultaneously assessing magnitude of immune response to L. donovani infection in Sudanese patients, the combined application of RKT and DAT is recommended.

Use of a newly developed beta-mercaptoethanol enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay to diagnose visceral leishmaniasis in patients in eastern Sudan.

Corroboration of serology results is essential for restricting the risk of inappropriate antileishmanial prescription. A direct agglutination test (DAT) and a recently developed beta-mercaptoethanol-modified enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (beta-ME ELISA) based on the use of antigen prepared as described for the DAT were applied to 416 sera from two Sudanese populations with and without clinical evidence of visceral leishmaniasis (VL). Of 285 sera with the lowest antileishmanial DAT titers (/=1:25,600), 86 (73.5%) scored maximum (0.81 to >/=1.35) and 30 (25.6%) medium (0.27 to 0.80) beta-ME ELISA absorbance values. VL diagnosis was established for 142 (44.1%) patients in the VL-symptomatic group (n = 322), based on positive microscopy for Leishmania donovani in lymph node aspirates or positive DAT (titer, >/=1:3,200). Of the 125 sera from the symptomatic patients for whom microscopy was positive for VL, 111 (88.8%) had comparable positive DAT and beta-ME ELISA readings. In all 17 sera from the symptomatic DAT-positive patients for whom leishmaniasis was not established by microscopy but who responded favorably to antileishmanial therapy, absorbance values (>/=0.27) indicative of VL were obtained by beta-ME ELISA. Of 197 symptomatic patients for whom microscopy was negative for VL, 172 (87.3%) tested negative in beta-ME ELISA and 180 (91.4%) in DAT. Based on the high reliability demonstrated here for VL detection, beta-ME ELISA fulfills the requirement of confirming DAT results in patients manifesting suspected VL.

Evaluation of a glycerol-preserved antigen in the direct agglutination test for diagnosis of visceral leishmaniasis at rural level in eastern Sudan.

Three-hundred and eight patients with suspected visceral leishmaniasis (VL) were received at Doka Hospital (eastern Sudan) during the period September 2004 to October 2005. The sensitivity and specificity of a glycerol-preserved (GP) antigen for VL diagnosis was assessed against the results of repeated lymph node aspiration and readings from a direct agglutination test (DAT) employing standard formaldehyde-fixed (FF) or freeze-dried (FD) antigen. Despite 13 months of storage at ambient temperature (28-47 degrees C), the GP antigen mean titres obtained from these 308 patients were no different from those that were FD (P=0.945) and stored under similar conditions, but were significantly different (P=0.019) from those that were FF and kept continuously at the optimum temperature for storage (4-8 degrees C). Taking the parasitological result as the gold standard and using a pre-established titre of 1 : 3200 as the DAT cut-off, the GP antigen revealed a sensitivity (91/105, 86.7 %) and specificity (187/203, 92.1 %) comparable to that of FD antigen (92/105, 87.6 %, and 188/203, 92.6 %, respectively) and FF antigen (94/105, 89.5 %, and 188/203, 92.6 %, respectively). At a titre range of 1 : 400-1 : 800, statistically determined as the optimum cut-off for the three antigens, sensitivities of 92.4, 90.5 and 96.2 % and specificities of 90.6, 90.1 and 88.7 % were achieved for the GP, FD and FF antigens, respectively, at a peripheral hospital. Regardless of the antigen preparation used, DAT results obtained in the peripheral hospital were highly reproducible in the central laboratory in Omdurman (weighted kappa: GP=0.957, FD=0.979 and FF=0.936). With a diagnostic reliability comparable to formaldehyde fixation and stability under ambient conditions similar to freeze drying, glycerol preservation, by virtue of its high potential for reproduction, meets the requirements for the management of VL in developing countries.

Beta-mercaptoethanol-modified ELISA for diagnosis of visceral leishmaniasis.

Following antigen preparation procedures similar to those of the direct agglutination test (DAT), an IgG ELISA employing intact beta-mercaptoethanol (beta-ME)-treated Leishmania donovani promastigotes was developed. The performance of the beta-ME ELISA thus developed was assessed in patients with confirmed visceral leishmaniasis (VL), revealing slightly lower sensitivity (39/40=97.5%) than that of the DAT (40/40=100%). When challenged with sera of individuals with non-VL conditions, including leukaemia and African trypanosomiasis, the specificity of the beta-ME ELISA was 100% (158/158), compared to 98.8% (156/158) for DAT. In an endemic population (n=145) manifesting a clinical suspicion of VL, results obtained with the beta-ME ELISA were highly concordant with those of DAT, both in the seropositive (65/68=95.6%) and seronegative (77/80=96.3%) groups. Furthermore, the incorporated intact antigen demonstrated higher sensitivity in ELISA (16/18=88.9%) than the water-soluble equivalent (13/18=72.2%). The stability of the formaldehyde-fixed antigen (2 months at 4 degrees C) in beta-ME ELISA, as well as the option for direct testing of whole-blood samples and visual reading of results (within 2 h, compared to 18 h for DAT), advocate the simultaneous application of the technique with DAT for confirmation of VL in laboratories with limited facilities.

Use of glycerol as an alternative to freeze-drying for long-term preservation of antigen for the direct agglutination test.

The potential of glycerol for long-term preservation of the direct agglutination test (DAT) antigen was evaluated at a fluctuating laboratory temperature of 25-37 degrees C and at constant temperatures of 37 and 45 degrees C for a period of 222 days. DAT titres recorded for the three antigen aliquots preserved in 50% (v/v) glycerol and stored at 25-37, 37 or 45 degrees C at 11 time intervals were within the same range of the control antigen kept at 4 degrees C. Performance of the glycerol-preserved antigen stored at 45 degrees C was compared with that of a freeze-dried version on 24 visceral leishmaniasis (VL) and 54 non-VL patients. For all non-VL patients, a maximum DAT titre of 1/800 was recorded for either of the two antigens. For all VL patients, in comparison with the freeze-dried, the glycerol-preserved antigen always had equal or higher titre; in 16 of the 24 VL sera tested, the latter antigen scored three- to sixfold higher titres. As this glycerol preservation method is economical and easy to perform, it has better potential for wider-scale application than freeze-drying.