Evaluation of the ESMO-Magnitude of Clinical Benefit Scale version 1.1 (ESMO-MCBS v1.1) for adjuvant radiotherapy in breast cancer.

BACKGROUND: The European Society of Medical Oncology (ESMO) has suggested using the ESMO-Magnitude of Clinical Benefit Scale (MCBS) to grade the magnitude of clinical benefit of cancer therapies. This approach has not been applied to radiation therapy (RT) yet. We applied the ESMO-MCBS to experiences describing the use of RT to assess (1) the 'scoreability' of the data, (2) evaluate the reasonableness of the grades for clinical benefit and (3) identify potential shortcomings in the current version of the ESMO-MCBS in its applicability to RT. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We applied the ESMO-MCBS v1.1 to a selection of studies in radiotherapy that had been identified as references in the development of American Society for Radiation Oncology (ASTRO) evidence-based guidelines on whole breast radiation. Of the 112 cited references, we identified a subset of 16 studies that are amenable to grading using the ESMO-MCBS. RESULTS: Of the 16 studies reviewed, 3/16 were scoreable with the ESMO tool. Six of 16 studies could not be scored because of shortcomings in the ESMO-MCBS v1.1: (1) in 'non-inferiority studies', there is no credit for improved patient convenience, reduced patient burden or improved cosmesis; (2) in 'superiority studies' evaluating local control as a primary endpoint, there is no credit for the clinical benefit such as reduced need for further interventions. In 7/16 studies, methodological deficiencies in the conduct and reporting were identified. CONCLUSIONS: This study represents a first step in determining the utility of the ESMO-MCBS in the evaluation of clinical benefit in radiotherapy. Important shortcomings were identified that would need to be addressed in developing a version of the ESMO-MCBS that can be robustly applied to radiotherapy treatments. Optimization of the ESMO-MCBS instrument will proceed to enable assessment of value in radiotherapy.

A methodology for selecting the beam arrangement to reduce the intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) dose to the SPECT-defined functioning lung.

Macroaggregated albumin single-photon emission computed tomography (MAA-SPECT) provides a map of the spatial distribution of lung perfusion. Our previous work developed a methodology to use SPECT guidance to reduce the dose to the functional lung in IMRT planning. This study aims to investigate the role of beam arrangement on both low and high doses in the functional lung. In our previous work, nine-beam IMRT plans were generated with and without SPECT guidance and compared for five patients. For the current study, the dose-function histogram (DFH) contribution for each of the nine beams for each patient was calculated. Four beams were chosen based on orientation and DFH contributions to create a SPECT-guided plan that spared the functional lung and maintained target coverage. Four-beam SPECT-guided IMRT plans reduced the F(20) and F(30) values by (16.5 +/- 6.8)% and (6.1 +/- 9.2)%, respectively, when compared to nine-beam conventional IMRT plans. Moreover, the SPECT-4F Plan reduces F(5) and F(13) for all patients by (11.0 +/- 8.2)% and (6.1 +/- 3.6)%, respectively, compared to the SPECT Plan. Using fewer beams in IMRT planning may reduce the amount of functional lung that receives 5 and 13 Gy, a factor that has recently been associated with radiation pneumonitis.

The impact of pre-radiotherapy surgery on radiation-induced lung injury.

AIMS: The use of postoperative radiation therapy (PORT) is predicated by an assessment of the potential benefits and risks, including radiation-induced lung injury. In this study, the risk of radiation-induced lung injury is assessed in patients who received PORT, and compared with a group of patients who received radiation without prior surgery, to determine if surgery increases the risk of radiation pneumonitis. MATERIALS AND METHODS: From 1991 to 2003, 251 patients with lung cancer were enrolled into a prospective study to assess radiation-induced lung injury. All patients received three-dimensional-planned, external-beam radiotherapy. One hundred and seventy-seven patients with over 6-months follow-up were eligible. For the current analysis, 49 patients (28%) had surgical intervention before radiotherapy. The rates of Grade 2 symptomatic pneumonitis in subgroups, based on the type of pre-radiation surgery, were computed and compared using Fisher's Exact Test. To consider the confounding factor of irradiated lung volume, patient subgroups were further defined on the basis of the mean lung dose. RESULTS: Surgical procedures included pneumonectomy (n=9), lobectomy (n=16), wedge resection (n=8) and exploration without resection (n=16). Radiation-induced lung injury occurred in 33 out of 177 (19%) patients, including 18% of the surgical group and 19% of the non-surgical group. Additionally, no statistically significant difference was found in the rate of radiation-induced lung injury based on the extent of resection. CONCLUSIONS: The incidence of pneumonitis is similar in the surgical and non-surgical groups. Thus, PORT may be safely given to selected patients after surgical exploration or resection.

Feasibility of optimizing the dose distribution in lung tumors using fluorine-18-fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission tomography and single photon emission computed tomography guided dose prescriptions.

The information provided by functional images may be used to guide radiotherapy planning by identifying regions that require higher radiation dose. In this work we investigate the dosimetric feasibility of delivering dose to lung tumors in proportion to the fluorine-18-fluorodeoxyglucose activity distribution from positron emission tomography (FDG-PET). The rationale for delivering dose in proportion to the tumor FDG-PET activity distribution is based on studies showing that FDG uptake is correlated to tumor cell proliferation rate, which is shown to imply that this dose delivery strategy is theoretically capable of providing the same duration of local control at all voxels in tumor. Target dose delivery was constrained by single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) maps of normal lung perfusion, which restricted irradiation of highly perfused lung and imposed dose-function constraints. Dose-volume constraints were imposed on all other critical structures. All dose-volume/function constraints were considered to be soft, i.e., critical structure doses corresponding to volume/function constraint levels were minimized while satisfying the target prescription, thus permitting critical structure doses to minimally exceed dose constraint levels. An intensity modulation optimization methodology was developed to deliver this radiation, and applied to two lung cancer patients. Dosimetric feasibility was assessed by comparing spatially normalized dose-volume histograms from the nonuniform dose prescription (FDG-PET proportional) to those from a uniform dose prescription with equivalent tumor integral dose. In both patients, the optimization was capable of delivering the nonuniform target prescription with the same ease as the uniform target prescription, despite SPECT restrictions that effectively diverted dose from high to low perfused normal lung. In one patient, both prescriptions incurred similar critical structure dosages, below dose-volume/function limits. However, in the other patient, critical structure dosage from the nonuniform dose prescription exceeded dose-volume/function limits, and greatly exceeded that from the uniform dose prescription. Strict compliance to dose-volume/ function limits would entail reducing dose proportionality to the FDG-PET activity distribution, thereby theoretically reducing the duration of local control. Thus, even though it appears feasible to tailor lung tumor dose to the FDG-PET activity distribution, despite SPECT restrictions, strict adherence to dose-volume/function limits could compromise the effectiveness of functional image guided radiotherapy.

Radiation-induced pulmonary toxicity: a dose-volume histogram analysis in 201 patients with lung cancer.

PURPOSE: To relate lung dose-volume histogram-based factors to symptomatic radiation pneumonitis (RP) in patients with lung cancer undergoing 3-dimensional (3D) radiotherapy planning. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Between 1991 and 1999, 318 patients with lung cancer received external beam radiotherapy (RT) with 3D planning tools at Duke University Medical Center. One hundred seventeen patients were not evaluated for RP because of <6 months of follow-up, development of progressive intrathoracic disease making scoring of pulmonary symptoms difficult, or unretrievable 3D dosimetry data. Thus, 201 patients were analyzed for RP. Univariate and multivariate analyses were performed to test the association between RP and dosimetric factors (i.e., mean lung dose, volume of lung receiving >or=30 Gy, and normal tissue complication probability derived from the Lyman and Kutcher models) and clinical factors, including tobacco use, age, sex, chemotherapy exposure, tumor site, pre-RT forced expiratory volume in 1 s, weight loss, and performance status. RESULTS: Thirty-nine patients (19%) developed RP. In the univariate analysis, all dosimetric factors (i.e., mean lung dose, volume of lung receiving >or=30 Gy, and normal tissue complication probability) were associated with RP (p range 0.006-0.003). Of the clinical factors, ongoing tobacco use at the time of referral for RT was associated with fewer cases of RP (p = 0.05). These factors were also independently associated with RP according to the multivariate analysis (p = 0.001). Models predictive for RP based on dosimetric factors only, or on a combination with the influence of tobacco use, had a concordance of 64% and 68%, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Dosimetric factors were the best predictors of symptomatic RP after external beam RT for lung cancer. Multivariate models that also include clinical variables were slightly more predictive.

Using plasma transforming growth factor beta-1 during radiotherapy to select patients for dose escalation.

PURPOSE: The ability to prescribe treatment based on relative risks for normal tissue injury has important implications for oncologists. In non-small-cell lung cancer, increasing the dose of radiation may improve local control and survival. Changes in plasma transforming growth factor beta (TGFbeta) levels during radiotherapy (RT) may identify patients at low risk for complications in whom higher doses of radiation could be safely delivered. PATIENT AND METHODS: Patients with locally advanced or medically inoperable non-small-cell lung cancer received three-dimensional conformal RT to the primary tumor and radiographically involved nodes to a dose of 73.6 Gy (1.6 Gy twice daily). If the plasma TGFbeta level was normal after 73.6 Gy, additional twice daily RT was delivered to successively higher total doses. The maximum-tolerated dose was defined as the highest radiation dose at which < or = one grade 4 (life-threatening) late toxicity and < or = two grade 3 to 4 (severe life-threatening) late toxicities occurred. RESULTS: Thirty-eight patients were enrolled. Median follow-up was 16 months. Twenty-four patients were not eligible for radiation dose escalation beyond 73.6 Gy because of persistently abnormal TGFbeta levels. Fourteen patients whose TGFbeta levels were normal after 73.6 Gy were escalated to 80 Gy (n = 8) and 86.4 Gy (n = 6). In the 86.4-Gy group, dose-limiting toxicity was reached because there were two (33%) grade 3 late toxicities. CONCLUSION: It is feasible to use plasma TGFbeta levels to select patients for RT dose escalation for non-small-cell lung cancer. The maximum-tolerated dose using this approach is 86.4 Gy.

Relating radiation-induced regional lung injury to changes in pulmonary function tests.

PURPOSE: To determine whether the sum of radiotherapy (RT)-induced reductions in regional lung perfusion is quantitatively related to changes in global lung function as assessed by reductions in pulmonary function tests (PFTs). METHODS AND MATERIALS: Two hundred seven patients (70% with lung cancer) who received incidental partial lung irradiation underwent PFTs (forced expiratory volume in 1 s and diffusion capacity for carbon monoxide) before and repeatedly after RT as part of a prospective clinical study. Regional lung function was serially assessed before and after RT by single photon emission computed tomography perfusion scans. Of these, 53 patients had 105 post-RT evaluations of changes in both regional perfusion and PFTs, were without evidence of intrathoracic disease recurrence that might influence regional perfusion and PFT findings, and were not taking steroids. The summation of the regional functional perfusion changes were compared with changes in PFTs using linear regression analysis. RESULTS: Follow-up ranged from 3 to 86 months (median 19). Overall, a significant correlation was found between the sum of changes in regional perfusion and the changes in the PFTs (p = 0.002-0.24, depending on the particular PFT index). However, the correlation coefficients were small (r = 0.16-0.41). CONCLUSIONS: A statistically significant correlation was found between RT-induced changes in regional function (i.e., perfusion) and global function (i.e., PFTs). However, the correlation coefficients are low, making it difficult to relate changes in perfusion to changes in the PFT results. Thus, with our current techniques, the prediction of changes in perfusion alone does not appear to be sufficient to predict the changes in PFTs accurately. Additional studies to clarify the relationship between regional and global lung injury are needed.

Predicting the risk of symptomatic radiation-induced lung injury using both the physical and biologic parameters V(30) and transforming growth factor beta.

PURPOSE: To correlate the volume of lung irradiated with changes in plasma levels of the fibrogenic cytokine transforming growth factor beta (TGFbeta) during radiotherapy (RT), such that this information might be used to predict the development of symptomatic radiation-induced lung injury (SRILI). METHODS AND MATERIALS: The records of all patients with lung cancer treated with RT with curative intent from 1991 to 1997 on a series of prospective normal tissue injury studies were reviewed. A total of 103 patients were identified who met the following inclusion criteria: (1) newly diagnosed lung cancer of any histology treated with RT +/- chemotherapy with curative intent; (2) no evidence of distant metastases or malignant pleural effusion; (3) no thoracic surgery after lung RT; (4) no endobronchial brachytherapy; (5) follow-up time more than 6 months; (6) plasma TGFbeta1 measurements obtained before and at the end of RT. The concentration of plasma TGFbeta1 was measured by an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. Seventy-eight of the 103 patients were treated with computed tomography based 3-dimensional planning and had dose-volume histogram data available. The endpoint of the study was the development of SRILI (modified NCI [National Cancer Institute] common toxicity criteria). RESULTS: The 1-year and 2-year actuarial incidence of SRILI for all 103 patients was 17% and 21%, respectively. In those patients whose TGFbeta level at the end of RT was higher than the pre-RT baseline, SRILI occurred more frequently (2-year incidence = 39%) than in patients whose TGFbeta1 level at the end of RT was less than the baseline value (2-year incidence = 11%, p = 0.007). On multivariate analysis, a persistent elevation of plasma TGFbeta1 above the baseline concentration at the end of RT was an independent risk factor for the occurrence of SRILI (p = 0.004). The subgroup of 78 patients treated with 3-dimensional conformal radiotherapy, who consequently had dose-volume histogram data, were divided into groups according to their TGFbeta1 kinetics and whether their V(30) level was above or below the median of 30%. Group I (n = 29), with both a TGFbeta1 level at the end of RT that was below the pre-RT baseline and V(30) < 30%; Group II (n = 35), with a TGFbeta1 level at the end of irradiation that was below the baseline but a V(30) > or = 30% or with a TGFbeta1 level at the end of RT that was above the pre-RT baseline but V(30) < 30%; Group III (n = 14), with both a TGFbeta1 level at the end of RT that was above the baseline and V(30) > or = 30%. A significant difference was found in the incidence of SRILI among these three groups (6.9%, 22.8%, 42.9%, respectively, p = 0.02). CONCLUSIONS: (1) An elevated plasma TGFbeta1 level at the end of RT is an independent risk factor for SRILI; (2) The combination of plasma TGFbeta1 level and V(30) appears to facilitate stratification of patients into low, intermediate, and high risk groups. Thus, combining both physical and biologic risk factors may allow for better identification of patients at risk for the development of symptomatic radiation-induced lung injury.

A practical and easy method to locate the first three internal mammary lymph node-bearing areas.

PURPOSE: To assess the distance from a clinically recognized anatomic landmark to the different costocondral interspaces in female patients to facilitate the design of radiation fields intended to include specific internal mammary nodal areas. METHODS AND MATERIALS: The distance from the suprasternal notch (SSN) to the caudal portion of the first through fourth interspace was measured on a computer display of the chest skeleton of 65 female patients with left-sided breast cancer. The relationship between these distances and bone size (sternal length and standing height) was assessed via linear regression. In 21 of the 65 patients where myocardial perfusion imaging of the heart was available, the relationship between the location of the 3rd costochondral interspace and the left ventricle was assessed. RESULTS: In 90% of patients (59/65), the first, second, third, and fourth interspace were within 5, 8.5, 11, and 14 cm of the SSN, respectively. The SSN-interspace distances did not correlate well with sternal length (r = 0.28) or standing height (r = 0.31). In 20 of 21 patients (95%), the third interspace "shadowed" the cephalad aspect of the left heart ventricle. Median "shadowing" was 3 cm (range 0.5-6 cm). CONCLUSION: The caudal portion of the third costochondral interspace is < or = 11 cm caudal to the SSN in 90% of patients. These measurements can be used to clinically design radiation therapy fields intended to treat the upper three interspaces. The distance from the SSN to the 1st through 4th interspaces is not related to sternal length or to standing height. In patients with left-sided breast cancer, radiation treatment fields designed to include the internal mammary lymph nodes in the upper three interspaces may incidentally include a portion of the heart.

Cardiac perfusion changes in patients treated for breast cancer with radiation therapy and doxorubicin: preliminary results.

PURPOSE: To determine the incidence and dose dependence of regional cardiac perfusion abnormalities in patients with left-sided breast cancer treated with radiation therapy (RT) with and without doxorubicin (Dox). METHODS: Twenty patients with left-sided breast cancer underwent cardiac perfusion imaging using single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) prechemotherapy, pre-RT, and 6 months post-RT. SPECT perfusion images were registered onto 3-dimensional (3D) RT dose distributions. The volume of heart in the RT field was quantified, and the regional RT dose was calculated. A decrease in regional cardiac perfusion was assessed subjectively by visual inspection and objectively using image fusion software. Ten patients received Dox-based chemotherapy (total dose 120-300 mg/m(2)), and 10 patients had no chemotherapy. RT was delivered by tangent beams in all patients to a total dose of 46-50 Gy. RESULTS: Overall, 60% of the patients had new visible perfusion defects 6 months post-RT. A dose-dependent perfusion defect was seen at 6 months with minimal defect appreciated at 0-10 Gy, and a 20% decrease in regional perfusion at 41-50 Gy. One of 20 patients had a decrease in left ventricle ejection fraction (LVEF) of greater than 10% at 6 months; 2/20 patients had developed transient pericarditis. No instances of myocardial infarction or congestive heart failure (CHF) have occurred. CONCLUSIONS: RT causes cardiac perfusion defects 6 months post-RT in most patients. Long-term follow-up is needed to assess whether these perfusion changes are transient or permanent and to determine if these findings are associated with changes in overall cardiac function and clinical outcome.

73.6 Gy and beyond: hyperfractionated, accelerated radiotherapy for non-small-cell lung cancer.

PURPOSE: To assess results with twice-daily high-dose radiotherapy (RT) for non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC). PATIENTS AND METHODS: Between 1991 and 1998, 94 patients with unresectable NSCLC were prescribed > or = 73.6 Gy via accelerated fractionation. Fifty were on a phase II protocol (P group); 44 were similarly treated off-protocol (NP group). The clinical target volume received 45 Gy at 1.25 Gy bid (6-hour interval). The gross target volume received 1.6 Gy bid to 73.6 to 80 Gy over 4.5 to 5 weeks using a concurrent boost technique. Overall survival (OS) and local progression-free survival (LPFS) were calculated by the Kaplan-Meier method. Median follow-up durations for surviving P and NP patients were 67 and 16 months, respectively. RESULTS: Total doses received were > or = 72 Gy in 97% of patients. The median OS by stage was 34, 13, and 12 months for stages I/II, IIIa, and IIIb, respectively. LPFS was significantly longer for patients with T1 lesions (median, 43 months) versus T2-4 (median, 7 to 10 months; P =.01). Results were similar in the P and NP groups. Acute grade > or = 3 toxicity included esophagus (14 patients; 15%), lung (three patients; 3% [one grade 5]), and skin (four patients; 4%). Grade > or = 3 late toxicity in 86 assessable patients included esophagus (three patients; 3%), lung (15 patients; 17% [three grade 5]), skin (five patients; 6%), heart (two patients; 2%), and nerve (one patient; 1%). CONCLUSION: This regimen yielded favorable survival results, particularly for T1 lesions. Acute grade > or = 3 toxicity seems greater than for conventional RT, though most patients recovered. Late grade > or = 3 pulmonary toxicity occurred in 17%. Because of continued locoregional recurrences, we are currently using doses > or = 86 Gy.

Carboplatin/paclitaxel or carboplatin/vinorelbine followed by accelerated hyperfractionated conformal radiation therapy: a preliminary report of a phase I dose escalation trial from the Carolina Conformal Therapy Consortium.

The maximum tolerated dose of conformal radiation therapy delivered at 1.6 Gy bid is being assessed in patients with unresectable stage IIB-IIIB non-small cell lung cancer who have been treated with induction regimens consisting of carboplatin plus paclitaxel or carboplatin plus vinorelbine. Data from the early stages of this parallel phase I study show that the two induction regimens are similar in toxicity and that both induce partial responses in 45% of patients. Both regimens can be followed by conformal radiotherapy using an accelerated hyperfractionated schedule to a dose of at least 80 Gy without experiencing unacceptable toxicity. Key morbidity observed thus far has involved the esophagus. Further cohorts of patients will receive higher doses of conformal radiotherapy (in 6.4 Gy increments) until the maximum tolerated dose is reached.

Can we predict radiation-induced changes in pulmonary function based on the sum of predicted regional dysfunction?

PURPOSE: To determine whether changes in whole-lung pulmonary function test (PFT) values are related to the sum of predicted radiation therapy (RT)-induced changes in regional lung perfusion. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Between 1991 and 1998, 96 patients (61% with lung cancer) who were receiving incidental partial lung irradiation were studied prospectively. The patients were assessed with pre- and post-RT PFTs (forced expiratory volume in one second [FEV1] and diffusion capacity for carbon monoxide [DLCO]) for at least a 6-month follow-up period, and patients were excluded if it was determined that intrathoracic recurrence had an impact on lung function. The maximal declines in PFT values were noted. A dose-response model based on RT-induced reduction in regional perfusion (function) was used to predict regional dysfunction. The predicted decline in pulmonary function was calculated as the weighted sum of the predicted regional injuries: equation [see text] where Vd is the volume of lung irradiated to dose d, and Rd is the reduction in regional perfusion anticipated at dose d. RESULTS: The relationship between the predicted and measured reduction in PFT values was significant for uncorrected DLCO (P = .005) and borderline significant for DLCO (P = .06) and FEV1 (P = .08). However, the correlation coefficients were small (range,.18 to.30). In patients with lung cancer, the correlation coefficients improved as the number of follow-up evaluations increased (range,.43 to.60), especially when patients with hypoperfusion in the lung adjacent to a central mediastinal/hilar thoracic mass were excluded (range,.59 to.91). CONCLUSION: The sum of predicted RT-induced changes in regional perfusion is related to RT-induced changes in pulmonary function. In many patients, however, the percentage of variation explained is small, which renders accurate predictions difficult.

Functional imaging of normal tissues with nuclear medicine: applications in radiotherapy.

Functional imaging techniques are gaining significant interest from radiation oncologists. Many now claim the need for physical and physiological information during both treatment planning and in the study of normal tissue injury. Toward this goal, the nuclear medicine functional imaging modalities, single-photon emission computed tomography and positron-emission computed tomography, have been used. This article reviews the studies performed in radiotherapy that used these modalities, and attempts to stimulate further interest in this topic.

The physical parameters and molecular events associated with radiation-induced lung toxicity.

Radiation therapy (RT) is frequently used to treat patients with tumors in and around the thorax. Clinical radiation pneumonitis is a common side effect, occurring in 5% to 20% of patients. Efforts to identify patients at risk for pneumonitis have focused on physical factors, such as dose and volume. Recently, the underlying molecular biological mechanisms behind RT-induced lung injury have come under study. Improved knowledge of the molecular events associated with RT-induced lung injury may translate into a better ability to individualized therapy. This review discusses our current understanding of the physical and molecular factors contributing to RT-induced pulmonary injury.

Routine 3D treatment planning: opportunities, challenges, and hazards.

Three-dimensional (3D) treatment planning refers to the use of software and hardware tools to design and implement more accurate and conformal radiation therapy. This is a major advance in oncology that should lead to the reduction of treatment-associated morbidity and facilitate safe dose escalation for many tumor sites. This technology affords the incorporation of physiologic and anatomic information into the treatment planning process, further enhancing our ability to improve the therapeutic ratio. However, as with any new technology, care must be taken when applying it in the clinic. The introduction of 3D planning presents new challenges to existing quality assurance systems. These need to be addressed to maintain patient safety. Based on our experience with over 1,500 patients treated at Duke University, the benefits, challenges, and hazards of routine 3D treatment planning are discussed.

A new three-dimensional dose distribution reduction scheme for tubular organs.

In tubular structures, spatial aspects of the dose distribution may be important in determining the normal tissue response. Conventional dose-volume-histograms (DVHs) and dose-surface-histograms (DSHs) lack spatial information and may not be adequate to represent the three-dimensional (3D) dose data. A new 3D dose distribution data reduction scheme which preserves its longitudinal and circumferential character is presented. Dose distributions were generated at each axial level for esophagus or rectum in 123 patients with lung cancer or prostate cancer. Dose distribution histograms at each axial level were independently analyzed along the esophageal or rectal circumference to generate dose-circumference-histogram (DCH) sheets. Two types of plots were then generated from the DCH sheet. The first considered the percentage of the circumference at each axial level receiving various doses. The second considered the minimum dose delivered to any percentage of the circumference at each axial level. The DCH as a treatment planning tool can be easily implemented in a 3D planing system and is potentially useful for the study of the relationship between the complication risk and the longitudinal and circumferential dose distributions.

Variability of the depth of supraclavicular and axillary lymph nodes in patients with breast cancer: is a posterior axillary boost field necessary?

PURPOSE: To determine the variability of the depth of supraclavicular (SC) and axillary (AX) lymph nodes in patients undergoing radiation therapy for breast cancer and to relate this variability with the patient's anterior/posterior (A/P) diameter. The dosimetric consequences of the variability in depth are explored and related to the need for a posterior axillary boost field. METHOD AND MATERIALS: In 49 patients undergoing treatment-planning computed tomography (CT) scanning in the treatment position, the maximum depth of the SC and AX lymph nodes was measured on CT images. The A/P diameter was measured at the location of the SC and AX, respectively. The relationship between the SC/AX lymph node depth and patient diameter was determined using linear regression. For an anterior SC and AX field, the relative dose to the SC and AX lymph nodes were calculated for a 6 MV photon beam. RESULTS: The maximum depth of the SC lymph nodes ranged from 2.4 to 9.5 cm (median, 4.3 cm). The depth was less than 3 cm in 4 patients, 3-6 cm in 39 (80%), and greater than 6 cm in 6 patients. There was a linear relationship between the SC lymph node depth and the A/P diameter. The depth of the SC lymph nodes in cm equals approximately one-half of the A/P diameter minus 3.5 (r(2) = 0.69). In 94% (46 of 49) of patients, the SC lymph node depth was between one-fifth and one-half of the A/P diameter. The depth of the axillary lymph nodes ranged from 1.4 to 8 cm (median, 4.3 cm). The depth was less than 3 cm in 8 patients, 3-6 cm in 32 (65%), and greater than 6 cm in 9 patients. The AX lymph node depth in cm equals approximately one-half of the A/P diameter minus 3 (r(2) = 0.81). In all patients, the AX lymph nodes were shallower than mid-depth. The depth of the SC and AX lymph nodes was within +/- 1 cm in 53% (26 of 49) of patients. The AX lymph nodes were located at >/= 1 cm shallower or greater depth than the SC in 24.5% (12 of 49) and 22.5% (11 of 49) of patients, respectively. If an anterior 6-MV beam only is used to treat the SC and AX lymph nodes in these 49 patients, the dose to the AX is within +/- 5% of the SC dose in 53% (26 of 49) patients and is 90% or more of the dose delivered in the SC in 90% (44 of 49) of patients. CONCLUSION: The maximum depth of the SC and AX lymph nodes varies widely and is related to the patient's size represented by the A/P diameter. In most patients, the AX lymph nodes lie at approximately the same depth or shallower than the SC. Therefore, the rationale for a posterior axillary boost field needs to be further assessed. When the AX and SC lymph nodes are deep, opposed supraclavicular and axillary fields and/or the use of a higher energy beam might be reasonable.

Radiation-induced pulmonary injury: symptomatic versus subclinical endpoints.

PURPOSE: To assess the relationship between radiation (RT)-induced pulmonary symptoms and subclinical changes in pulmonary functions tests (PFT) and radiographs. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A total of 184 patients irradiated between 1992 and 1998 were prospectively evaluated for RT-induced pulmonary symptoms, changes in computed tomography (CT) density, reductions in single photon emission CT (SPECT) perfusion, and changes in pulmonary functions tests (forced expiratory volume in 1 s [FEV1] and diffusion capacity to carbon monoxide [DLCO]). Comparisons between the evaluable patients with (N=34) and without (N=106) RT-induced pulmonary symptoms were made. RESULTS: Within 6 months of RT, 80% of the RT-induced symptoms were noted. There was no association between the presence or absence of RT-induced pulmonary symptoms and the frequency of RT-induced radiographic changes (p=0.53), or in the dose-response curve for RT-induced reductions in regional perfusion. Overall, RT-induced changes in SPECT images were more commonly seen than increased density changes on CT (p<0.001). Most patients with pulmonary symptoms had relatively low pre-RT PFTs and experienced further declines following RT. CONCLUSIONS: Regional radiographic changes in CT-defined tissue density or SPECT-defined tissue perfusion are similar in patients with and without RT-induced pulmonary symptoms because these endpoints do not consider the volume of lung affected. RT-induced pulmonary symptoms are better related to post-RT PFT because they are an assessment of whole lung function. Additional studies are necessary to better define models that can predict the degree of radiation-induced changes in whole lung function.