RESUMO
Introducción: La leishmaniasis visceral (LV) es una enfermedad parasitaria emergente en Argentina. En Puerto Iguazú, frontera con Brasil y Paraguay, en 2010 se registró presencia del vector y casos caninos; y en 2014-2015 dos casos humanos. Objetivo: Este artículo tiene como objetivo analizar los cambios en el nivel micro escala después de dar a conocer a los convivientes el diagnóstico de LV canina (LVC), informándoles estrategias de manejo ambiental para reducir el contacto con el vector. Método: Es una investigación descriptiva, que indagó en dos momentos (2014 y 2016) una muestra no probabilística distribuida en base al criterio de mejor escenario para la presencia del vector (n = 55) en la que se seleccionaron, luego de un primer rastrillaje entomológico y de diagnóstico veterinario, puntos de muestreo con presencia de vectores y al menos un perro con LVC (n = 6/55). Resultados: Un único hogar implementó las modificaciones sugeridas. Esos cambios no resultaron suficientes para controlar la transmisión. La hipótesis es que las medidas de control requieren intervención a meso escala (el vecindario y no el domicilio), atendiendo al radio real de dispersión de vectores. Conclusiones: El riesgo de infección humana por LV se relaciona con el modo de vida, incluyendo las relaciones interespecie. Las relaciones humano-perro combinan especismo y poshumanismo, acotando la efectividad de la "tenencia responsable" como modelo de vínculo saludable.
Introduction: Visceral leishmaniasis (VL) is an emerging parasitic disease in Argentina. In Puerto Iguazú, border with Brazil and Paraguay, vector and canine cases were registered in 2010; and in 2014 and 2015 there were two human cases. Objective: The objective of this article is to analyze changes at the micro-scale level after informing the cohabitants of the diagnosis of canine LV (LVC), letting them know the environmental management strategies to reduce contact with the vector. Method: It is a descriptive researh, which investigated in two moments (2014 and 2016) a non-probabilistic sample distributed based on the criterion of the best scenario for the presence of the vector (n = 55). Sampling points with the presence of vectors and at least one dog with LVC (n = 6/55) were selected, after a first entomological and veterinary diagnosis raking. Results: A single household implemented the suggested modifications. The changes were not enough to control the transmission. The hypothesis is that the control measures require intervention at a meso-scale (the neighborhood instead of the home), taking into account the real radius of vector dispersion. Conclusions: The risk of human infection due to VL is related to the way of life, including interspecies relationships. The human-dog relationships combine speciesism and post-humanism, which limits the effectiveness of "responsible ownership" as model of a healthy bond.
RESUMO
A retrospective analytical method is presented, based on theoretical eco-epidemiology, applied on a subnational spatial scale. This method was used here to describe scenarios for the transmission of leishmaniasis in the Argentine province of Misiones- bordering Brazil and Paraguay-and formed the basis for recommendations for surveillance and control appropriate to the subnational scale. An exhaustive search of the literature on leishmaniasis in the province was carried out. Three scenarios for the transmission of cutaneous leishmaniasis (CL) and visceral leishmaniasis (VL) were found, corresponding to three periods: from 1920 to 1997, during which the transmission of CL distributed over time and space was confirmed; 1998 to 2005, during which there were focal outbreaks of CL; and 2006 to 2014, during which outbreaks were also reported and the geographical dispersion of VL was documented. To describe the risk scenarios and the anthropic processes that produce them, the results were summarized and integrated into the social, historical, and bio-ecological context of each period. Surveillance and control recommendations are based on the territory studied. They include establishing active surveillance to monitor possible rising trends in parasitic and vector circulation, conducting studies of any focal outbreak in order to confirm indigenous transmission and severity. Also, it should be a legal requirement for persons responsible for projects that alter the environment to adopt additional control measures, such as studies assessing transmission risk, risk mitigation, early detection, and timely case management.
Assuntos
Insetos Vetores , Leishmaniose Cutânea/transmissão , Leishmaniose Visceral/transmissão , Vigilância da População/métodos , Animais , Argentina/epidemiologia , Surtos de Doenças , Leishmaniose Cutânea/epidemiologia , Leishmaniose Visceral/epidemiologia , Psychodidae , Estudos Retrospectivos , Fatores de TempoRESUMO
Se presenta una metodología analítica retrospectiva, basada en el marco teórico de la eco-epidemiología, anclada en una escala espacial subnacional. Esta metodología, aplicada aquí a la caracterización de escenarios de transmisión de la leishmaniasis en la provincia argentina de Misiones —fronteriza con Brasil y Paraguay— permitió fundamentar recomendaciones de vigilancia y control apropiadas a dicha escala. Se realizó una búsqueda exhaustiva de la literatura sobre leishmaniasis en esa provincia y se determinaron tres escenarios de transmisión de leishmaniasis cutánea (LC) y visceral (LV), correspondientes a tres períodos: 1920-1997, en el que se constató la transmisión de LC, dispersa en el tiempo y el espacio; 1998-2005, en el que hubo brotes focales de LC; y 2006-2014 en el que, además, se registraron brotes y se documentó la dispersión geográfica de la LV. Para caracterizar los escenarios de riesgo y los procesos antrópicos que los producen, los resultados se sintetizaron e integraron en el contexto socio-histórico y bio-ecológico de cada período analizado. Se fundamentan recomendaciones de vigilancia y control en el territorio estudiado, entre ellas, establecer una vigilancia activa para monitorear posibles tendencias al incremento de la circulación parasitaria y vectorial y, ante la aparición de un foco, realizar estudios para verificar la transmisión autóctona y la intensidad del evento. Además, se debe establecer la obligación legal de tomar medidas adicionales de control por los responsables de los proyectos que impliquen modificación ambiental, como la realización de estudios de evaluación del riesgo de transmisión, y acciones de mitigación del riesgo, detección temprana y tratamiento oportuno de los casos.
A retrospective analytical method is presented, based on theoretical eco-epidemiology, applied on a subnational spatial scale. This method was used here to describe scenarios for the transmission of leishmaniasis in the Argentine province of Misiones—bordering Brazil and Paraguay—and formed the basis for recommendations for surveillance and control appropriate to the subnational scale. An exhaustive search of the literature on leishmaniasis in the province was carried out. Three scenarios for the transmission of cutaneous leishmaniasis (CL) and visceral leishmaniasis (VL) were found, corresponding to three periods: from 1920 to 1997, during which the transmission of CL distributed over time and space was confirmed; 1998 to 2005, during which there were focal outbreaks of CL; and 2006 to 2014, during which outbreaks were also reported and the geographical dispersion of VL was documented. To describe the risk scenarios and the anthropic processes that produce them, the results were summarized and integrated into the social, historical, and bio-ecological context of each period. Surveillance and control recommendations are based on the territory studied. They include establishing active surveillance to monitor possible rising trends in parasitic and vector circulation, conducting studies of any focal outbreak in order to confirm indigenous transmission and severity. Also, it should be a legal requirement for persons responsible for projects that alter the environment to adopt additional control measures, such as studies assessing transmission risk, risk mitigation, early detection, and timely case management.
Assuntos
Leishmaniose , Leishmaniose Cutânea , Leishmaniose Cutânea , Leishmaniose Visceral , Fenômenos Ecológicos e Ambientais , Argentina , Leishmaniose Visceral , Fenômenos Ecológicos e AmbientaisRESUMO
La leishmaniasis visceral urbana es una zoonosis emergente en Argentina. En América es producida por Leishmania infantum, con el perro como reservorio principal e insectos flebotomíneos como vectores. En este artículo se presenta el conocimiento acumulado a partir de su emergencia y dispersión en el país, por los referentes del Programa Nacional de Leishmaniasis, en el diagnóstico clínico y de laboratorio, tratamiento, biología de vectores, manejo de reservorio, y el conflicto generado con las acciones recomendadas en relación con los perros infectados. La detección temprana y el tratamiento precoz, con estrategias descentralizadas y horizontales, contribuirán a disminuir la morbimortalidad asociada a la leishmaniasis visceral. El control de su transmisión y dispersión requiere de un manejo ambiental integral y la tenencia responsable de perros. Se discuten los intereses y discursos en conflicto generados por la leishmaniasis visceral en el marco de la relación humano-perro, proponiendo la búsqueda de un discurso consensuado de riesgo.
Urban visceral leishmaniasis is an emerging zoonosis in Argentina. In the Americas the disease is produced by Leishmania infantum, with dogs as the primary reservoir and phlebotomine sandflies as the vectors. This article presents the experience acquired by professionals from the National Leishmaniasis Program in Argentina as visceral leishmaniasis has emerged and spread, especially in clinical and laboratory diagnosis, disease treatment, vector biology, reservoir management, and conflicts regarding recommendations for infected dogs. Early detection and treatment, along with decentralized and horizontal strategies, will contribute to the decrease in morbidity and mortality associated with visceral leishmaniasis. Control over the transmission and spread of the disease requires integral environmental management and responsible dog ownership. The interests and discourses put into conflict by visceral leishmaniasis are discussed in the framework of the human-dog relationship, and the search for a consensus-based risk discourse is proposed.
RESUMO
La leishmaniasis visceral urbana es una zoonosis emergente en Argentina. En América es producida por Leishmania infantum, con el perro como reservorio principal e insectos flebotomíneos como vectores. En este artículo se presenta el conocimiento acumulado a partir de su emergencia y dispersión en el país, por los referentes del Programa Nacional de Leishmaniasis, en el diagnóstico clínico y de laboratorio, tratamiento, biología de vectores, manejo de reservorio, y el conflicto generado con las acciones recomendadas en relación con los perros infectados. La detección temprana y el tratamiento precoz, con estrategias descentralizadas y horizontales, contribuirán a disminuir la morbimortalidad asociada a la leishmaniasis visceral. El control de su transmisión y dispersión requiere de un manejo ambiental integral y la tenencia responsable de perros. Se discuten los intereses y discursos en conflicto generados por la leishmaniasis visceral en el marco de la relación humano-perro, proponiendo la búsqueda de un discurso consensuado de riesgo.(AU)
Urban visceral leishmaniasis is an emerging zoonosis in Argentina. In the Americas the disease is produced by Leishmania infantum, with dogs as the primary reservoir and phlebotomine sandflies as the vectors. This article presents the experience acquired by professionals from the National Leishmaniasis Program in Argentina as visceral leishmaniasis has emerged and spread, especially in clinical and laboratory diagnosis, disease treatment, vector biology, reservoir management, and conflicts regarding recommendations for infected dogs. Early detection and treatment, along with decentralized and horizontal strategies, will contribute to the decrease in morbidity and mortality associated with visceral leishmaniasis. Control over the transmission and spread of the disease requires integral environmental management and responsible dog ownership. The interests and discourses put into conflict by visceral leishmaniasis are discussed in the framework of the human-dog relationship, and the search for a consensus-based risk discourse is proposed.(AU)
RESUMO
Vector-borne diseases closely associated with the environment, such as leishmaniases, have been a usual argument about the deleterious impact of climate change on public health. From the biological point of view interaction of different variables has different and even conflicting effects on the survival of vectors and the probability transmission of pathogens. The results on ecoepidemiology of leishmaniasis in Argentina related to climate variables at different scales of space and time are presented. These studies showed that the changes in transmission due to change or increase in frequency and intensity of climatic instability were expressed through changes in the probability of vector-human reservoir effective contacts. These changes of contact in turn are modulated by both direct effects on the biology and ecology of the organisms involved, as by perceptions and changes in the behavior of the human communities at risk. Therefore, from the perspective of public health and state policy, and taking into account the current nonlinear increased velocity of climate change, we concluded that discussing the uncertainties of large-scale models will have lower impact than to develop-validate mitigation strategies to be operative at local level, and compatibles with sustainable development, conservation biodiversity, and respect for cultural diversity.