Tandem mass spectrometry of protein-protein complexes: cytochrome c-cytochrome b5.

An improved method to interpret triple quadrupole MS/MS experiments of complexes of large ions is presented and applied to a study of the complex formed by the proteins cytochrome c and cytochrome b5. Modeling of the activation and dissociation process shows that most of the reaction occurs near the collision cell exit where ions have the highest internal energies. Experiments at different collision cell pressures or with different collision gases (Ne, Ar, Kr) are interpreted with a previously proposed collision model (Chen et al., Rapid Commun. Mass Spectrom. 1998, 12, 1003-1010) to calculate the internal energy added to ions to cause dissociation. Small but systematic differences under different experimental conditions are attributed to different times available for reaction. A method to correct for this is presented. Ne, Ar, and Kr are found to have similar energy transfer efficiencies. Complexes of cytochrome c and cytochrome b5 are detected in ESI mass spectra but with abundances less than expected from the solution equilibrium. Dissociation of the cytochrome c-cytochrome b5 complexes with charge k gives as the most abundant fragments, cytochrome b5(+3) and cytochrome c+(k-3). Adding charges to the complex destabilizes it. A series of cytochrome c variants with Lys residues thought to be involved in solution binding replaced by Ala showed no differences in the energy required to induce dissociation of the gas phase complex. The implications for the binding of the gas phase ions are inconclusive.

N epsilon,N epsilon-dimethyl-lysine cytochrome c as an NMR probe for lysine involvement in protein-protein complex formation.

The reductively dimethylated derivatives of horse and yeast iso-1-ferricytochromes c have been prepared and characterized for use as NMR probes of the complexes formed by cytochrome c with bovine liver cytochrome b5 and yeast cytochrome c peroxidase. The electrostatic properties and structures of the derivatized cytochromes are not significantly perturbed by the modifications; neither are the electrostatics of protein-protein complex formation or rates of interprotein electron transfer. Two-dimensional 1H-13C NMR spectroscopy of the complexes formed by the derivatized cytochromes with cytochrome b5 and cytochrome c peroxidase has been used to investigate the number and identity of lysine residues of cytochrome c that are involved in interprotein interactions of cytochrome c. The NMR data are incompatible with simple static models proposed previously for the complexes formed by these proteins, but are consistent with the presence of multiple, interconverting complexes of comparable stability, consistent with studies employing Brownian dynamics to model the complexes. The NMR characteristics of the Nepsilon,Nepsilon-dimethyl-lysine groups, their chemical shift dispersion, oxidation state and temperature dependences and the possibility of chemical exchange phenomena are discussed with relevance to the utility of Nepsilon, Nepsilon-dimethyl-lysine's being a generally useful derivative for characterizing protein-protein complexes.

pH-linked binding of Mn(II) to manganese peroxidase.

The stability of Mn(II) binding to manganese peroxidase (MnP) has been studied as a function of pH by spectrophotometric and potentiometric titrations. The sensitivity of the potentiometric titrations allows collection of data that are consistent with a high-affinity and a low-affinity Mn(II) binding site on the peroxidase. The two sites differ in affinity by 4 to 900-fold between pH 4 and 6.5. The stability of Mn(II) binding to the high-affinity site increases with increasing pH, while the stability of Mn(II) binding to the low-affinity site decreases with increasing pH. Interestingly, at pH values above 5.0, the high-affinity site appears to be partially unavailable for binding Mn(II). A pH-dependent structural change in the Mn(II) binding site is proposed to account for this partial inactivation at elevated pH.

Charge compensated binding of divalent metals to bacterioferritin: H+ release associated with cobalt(II) and zinc(II) binding at dinuclear metal sites.

Divalent metal ion binding to the bacterial iron-storage protein, bacterioferritin (BFR), which contains a dinuclear metal binding site within each of its 24 subunits, was investigated by potentiometric and spectrophotometric methods. Cobalt(II) and zinc(II) were found to bind at both high- and low-affinity sites. Cobalt(II) binding at the high-affinity site was observed at a level of two per subunit with the release of approximately 1.6 protons per metal ion, thus confirming the dinuclear metal centre as the high-affinity site. Zinc(II) binding at the dinuclear centre (high-affinity site) resulted in the release of approximately 2 protons per metal ion, but exhibited a binding stoichiometry which indicated that not all dinuclear centres were capable of binding two zinc(II) ions. Competition data showed that binding affinities for the dinuclear centre were in the order zinc(II) > cobalt(II), and also confirmed the unexpected stoichiometry of zinc(II) binding. This work emphasises the importance of charge neutrality at the dinuclear centre.

Experimental and theoretical analysis of the interaction between cytochrome c and cytochrome b5.

Experimental and theoretical investigation of the interaction of cytochrome c and cytochrome b5 performed over nearly twenty years has produced considerable insight into the manner in which these proteins recognize and bind to each other. The results of these studies and the experimental and theoretical strategies that have been developed to achieve these results have significant implications for understanding the behavior of similar complexes formed by more complex and less-well characterized electron transfer proteins. The current review provides a comprehensive summary and critical evaluation of the literature on which the current status of our understanding of the interaction of cytochrome c and cytochrome b5 is based. The general issues related to the study of electron transfer complexes of this type are discussed and some new directions for future investigation of such systems are considered.

Proton linkage in formation of the cytochrome c-cytochrome c peroxidase complex: electrostatic properties of the high- and low-affinity cytochrome binding sites on the peroxidase.

The electrostatic character of cytochrome c-cytochrome c peroxidase complex formation has been studied by potentiometric titration between pH 5.5 and 7.75. Potentiometric data obtained at ionic strength > or = 100 mM were adequately analyzed in terms of 1:1 complex formation while the simplest model capable of fitting similar data obtained at lower ionic strength involves the assumption of two inequivalent binding sites for the cytochrome on the peroxidase. The stability of cytochrome c binding at the high-affinity site is ca. three orders of magnitude greater than that observed for the low-affinity site and is optimal between pH 6.75 and 7. The electrostatic properties of the two binding sites are distinctly different because, at most values of pH, binding of cytochrome c to the high-affinity site results in proton release while binding of the cytochrome to the low-affinity site results in proton uptake. Furthermore, binding of the cytochrome to the low-affinity site appears to be least stable in the pH range where binding to the high-affinity site is optimal. Interestingly, the binding parameters derived from these measurements were independent of temperature, consistent with a substantial entropic contribution to complex stability. Ferricytochrome c binds to the peroxidase with a slightly greater affinity than does ferrocytochrome c, and no evidence for specific anion effects on complex stability was observed. At low ionic strength (< or = 50 mM) and high pH (7.75), the interaction of the two proteins is more complex and cannot be adequately analyzed in terms of the two-site model.

Recombinant human erythrocyte cytochrome b5.

The gene encoding the human erythrocyte form of cytochrome b5 (97 residues in length) has been prepared by mutagenesis of an expression vector encoding lipase-solubilized bovine liver microsomal cytochrome b5 (93 residues in length) (Funk et al., 1990). Efficient expression of this gene in Escherichia coli has provided the first opportunity to obtain this protein in quantities sufficient for physical and functional characterization. Comparison of the erythrocytic cytochrome with the trypsin-solubilized bovine liver cytochrome b5 by potentiometric titration indicates that the principal electrostatic difference between the two proteins results from two additional His residues present in the human erythrocytic protein. The midpoint reduction potential of this protein determined by direct electrochemistry is -9 +/- 2 mV vs SHE at pH 7.0 (mu = 0.10 M, 25.0 degrees C), and this value varies with pH in a fashion that is consistent with the presence of a single ionizable group that changes pKa from 6.0 +/- 0.1 in the ferricytochrome to 6.3 +/- 0.1 in the ferrocytochrome with delta H degrees = -3.2 +/- 0.1 kcal/mol and delta S degrees = -11.5 +/- 0.3 eu (pH 7.0, mu = 0.10). The 1D 1H NMR spectrum of the erythrocytic ferricytochrome indicates that 90% of the protein binds heme in the "major" orientation and 10% of the protein binds heme in the "minor" orientation (pH 7.0, 25 degrees C) with delta H degrees = -2.9 +/- 0.3 kcal/mol and delta S degrees = -5.4 +/- 0.9 eu for this equilibrium.

Laser flash photolysis studies of electron transfer to the cytochrome b5-cytochrome c complex.

Rate constants for electron transfer in the complex between recombinant rat mitochondrial outer membrane cytochrome b5 or the tryptic fragment of bovine liver cytochrome b5 and horse mitochondrial cytochrome c were measured by laser flash photolysis of 5-deazariboflavin-EDTA solutions. When an excess of cytochrome b5 was titrated with increasing amounts of cytochrome c at low ionic strength and electron transfer was initiated by a laser flash, both proteins were rapidly reduced by deazariboflavin semiquinone. The initial photoreduction was followed by a slower second-order reduction of b5 complexed oxidized cytochrome c by free reduced cytochrome b5. At an 8:1 ratio of cytochromes b5 to c, the pseudo-first-order rate constant for reduction of complexed cytochrome c increased 3-5-fold between ionic strengths of 5 and 40 mM, and then dropped precipitously at higher ionic strengths. The ionic strength dependent increase in rate constant is likely to be due to relief of steric hindrance via rearrangement of cytochrome c in the complex. The reaction rate showed no sign of saturation at any ionic strength, indicating a first-order rate constant greater than 10(4) s-1 within a transient ternary protein complex; i.e., interprotein electron transfer approaches the largest values previously reported for the stable binary protein complex (approximately 4 x 10(5) s-1). Our results emphasize the flexibility of electron-transfer protein complexes, which had previously been modeled in a single conformation with specific salt bridges. It appears that a variety of orientations can exist within such protein-protein complexes and that the population of conformations changes with ionic strength.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Proton linkage of complex formation between cytochrome c and cytochrome b5: electrostatic consequences of protein-protein interactions.

Two potentiometric methods have been used to study the pH-dependent changes in proton binding that accompany complex formation between cytochrome c and cytochrome b5. With one method, the number of protons bound or released upon addition of one cytochrome to the other has been measured as a function of pH. The results from these studies are correlated with the complexation-induced difference titration curve calculated from the titration curves of the preformed complex and of the individual proteins. Both methods demonstrate that complex formation at acid pH is accompanied by proton release, that complex formation at basic pH is accompanied by proton uptake, and that the change in proton binding at neutral pH, where stability of complex formation is maximal, is relatively small. Under all conditions studied, the stoichiometry of cytochrome c-cytochrome b5 complex formation is 1:1 with no evidence of higher order complex formation. Although the dependence of complex formation on pH for interaction between different species of cytochrome c and cytochrome b5 are qualitatively similar, they are quantitatively different. In particular, complex formation between yeast iso-1-cytochrome c and lipase-solubilized bovine cytochrome b5 occurs with a stability constant that is 10-fold greater than observed for the other two pairs of proteins under all conditions studied. Interaction between these two proteins is also significantly less dependent on ionic strength than observed for complexes formed by horse heart cytochrome c with either form of cytochrome b5.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Proton titration curve of yeast iso-1-ferricytochrome c. Electrostatic and conformational effects of point mutations.

The proton titration curves of yeast iso-1-ferricytochrome c and selected point mutants of this protein have been determined between pH 3 and 11 at 10 and 25 degrees C with a computer-controlled titration system. Initial titration of the wild-type protein to acidic pH followed by subsequent titrations to alkaline and then acidic pH demonstrates hysteresis, with one more group (28.7) titrating between pH 11 and 3 than originally titrated (27.7) between pH 3 and 11. Initial titration to alkaline pH, however, resulted in observation of the same number of groups in both directions of titration (28.7 vs 28.6). At 10 degrees C, 7.5 fewer groups were found to titrate over the same range of pH. Titration curves obtained for six cytochrome c mutants modified at Arg-38, Phe-82, Tyr-48, and Tyr-67 were analyzed by subtraction of the corresponding titration curve for the wild-type protein to produce difference titration curves. In most cases, the effects of these mutations as revealed in the difference titration curves could be accounted for as either the result of introduction of an additional group titrating within this pH range, the result of a change in the pK of a titrating residue, and/or the result of a change in the pK for either the first acidic or the first alkaline protein conformational transition. In addition to demonstration of the electrostatic consequences of the mutations in cytochrome c studied here, this study establishes the general usefulness of precise proton titration curve analysis in the characterization of variant proteins produced through recombinant genetic techniques.

Mutagenic, electrochemical, and crystallographic investigation of the cytochrome b5 oxidation-reduction equilibrium: involvement of asparagine-57, serine-64, and heme propionate-7.

A gene coding for lipase-solubilized bovine liver microsomal cytochrome b5 has been synthesized, expressed in Escherichia coli, and mutated at functionally critical residues. Characterization of the recombinant protein revealed that it has a reduction potential that is approximately 17 mV lower than that of authentic wild-type protein at pH 7 (25 degrees C). Structural studies determined that the recombinant protein differed in sequence from authentic wild-type cytochrome b5 owing to three errors in amidation status in the published sequence for the protein on which the gene synthesis was based. The structural origin of the lower reduction potential exhibited by the triple mutant has been investigated through X-ray crystallographic determination of the three-dimensional structure of this protein and is attributed to the presence of Asp-57 within 3.3 A of heme vinyl-4 in the mutant. In addition, the model developed by Argos and Mathews [Argos, P., & Mathews, F.S. (1975) J. Biol. Chem. 250, 747] for the change in cytochrome b5 oxidation state has been studied through mutation of Ser-64 to Ala. In this model, Ser-64 is postulated to stabilize the oxidized protein through H-bonding interactions with heme propionate-7 that orients this propionate group 6.2 A from the heme iron. Spectroelectrochemical studies of a mutant in which Ser-64 has been changed to an alanyl residue demonstrate that this protein has a reduction potential that is 7 mV lower than that of the wild-type protein; moreover, conversion of the heme propionate groups to the corresponding methyl esters increases the potential by 67 mV.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

NMR characterization of surface interactions in the cytochrome b5-cytochrome c complex.

The complex formed in solution by native and chemically modified cytochrome c with cytochrome b5 has been studied by 1H and 13C nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (NMR). Contrary to predictions of recent theoretical analysis, 1H NMR spectroscopy indicates that there is no major movement of cytochrome c residue Phe82 on binding to cytochrome b5. The greater resolution provided by 13C NMR spectroscopy permits detection of small perturbations in the environments of cytochrome c residues Ile75 and Ile85 on binding with cytochrome b5, a result that is in agreement with earlier model-building experiments. As individual cytochrome c lysyl residues are resolved in the 1H NMR spectrum of N-acetimidylated cytochrome c, the interaction of this modified protein with cytochrome b5 has been studied to evaluate the number of cytochrome c lysyl residues involved in binding to cytochrome b5. The results of this experiment indicate that at least six lysyl residues are involved, two more than predicted by static model building, which indicates that cytochrome c and cytochrome b5 form two or more structurally similar 1:1 complexes in solution.

Crosslinking of cytochrome c and cytochrome b5 with a water-soluble carbodiimide. Reaction conditions, product analysis and critique of the technique.

A water soluble carbodiimide, 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl)carbodiimide (EDC), has been used to crosslink horse heart cytochrome c and trypsin-solubilized bovine liver microsomal cytochrome b5. The reaction was conducted under a variety of solution conditions, and the products were purified by a combination of gel filtration and ion-exchange chromatography. Under all conditions of pH, ionic strength, EDC/protein ratio and reaction time that were studied, multiple 1:1 crosslinked complexes were observed with no evidence of a single, dominant species. Acetate, which is often used as a quencher of such reactions, was found to increase the complexity of the reaction products, presumably through EDC-promoted coupling to cytochrome c. Hydroxylamine treatment of the crosslinked complexes, a procedure frequently used to reverse EDC modification of tyrosyl residues, did not reduce the number of crosslinked components observed. The cytochrome b5 heme group was readily extracted from each of the 1:1 crosslinked complexes by standard techniques, so the crosslinking of heme propionate 7 with Lys79 of cytochrome c that might have been anticipated on the basis of molecular graphics modeling [Salemme, F.R. (1976) J. Mol. Biol. 102, 563-568] was not evident from this analysis. Analysis of HPLC tryptic peptide maps produced from crosslinked complexes revealed reduced specificity of trypsin in hydrolysis of EDC-crosslinked protein-protein complexes and unsatisfactory resolution of crosslinked or branched peptides. Nevertheless, it was possible to demonstrate that residues 52-72 of cytochrome b5, a region predicted to be critical to interaction with cytochrome b5 [Salemme, F.R. (1976) J. Mol. Biol. 102, 563-568] was absent from all peptide maps of 1:1 cytochrome c.cytochrome b5 complexes. Based on these results and a review of the literature involving EDC crosslinking of electron transfer proteins, we conclude that the techniques available for specific protein hydrolysis and separation of crosslinked peptides are not adequate to permit routine unambiguous identification of crosslinking sites in carbodiimide-crosslinked complexes.

NMR study of the interaction between cytochrome b5 and cytochrome c. Observation of a ternary complex formed by the two proteins and [Cr(en)3]3+.

The interaction between horse cytochrome c and the tryptic fragment of bovine liver microsomal cytochrome b5 in the absence and presence of [Cr(ethylenediamine)3]Cl3 was studied by 1H NMR spectroscopy. The protein-protein interaction region on cytochrome b5 was found to be different from the [Cr(en)3]3+-binding region. The solvent-exposed propionate-bearing edge of the haem of cytochrome b5 is accessible to [Cr(en)3]3+ in the interprotein complex.

Electrostatic analysis of the interaction of cytochrome c with native and dimethyl ester heme substituted cytochrome b5.

The stability of the complex formed between cytochrome c and dimethyl ester heme substituted cytochrome b5 (DME-cytochrome b5) has been determined under a variety of experimental conditions to evaluate the role of the cytochrome b5 heme propionate groups in the interaction of the two native proteins. Interaction between cytochrome c and the modified cytochrome b5 was found to produce a difference spectrum in the visible range that is very similar to that generated by the interaction of the native proteins and that can be used to monitor complex formation between the two proteins. At pH 8 [25 degrees C (HEPPS), I = 5 mM], DME-cytochrome b5 and cytochrome c form a 1:1 complex with an association constant KA of 3 (1) X 10(6) M-1. This pH is the optimal pH for complex formation between these two proteins and is significantly higher than that observed for the interaction between the two native proteins. The stability of the complex formed between DME-cytochrome b5 and cytochrome c is strongly dependent on ionic strength with KA ranging from 2.4 X 10(7) M-1 at I = 1 mM to 8.2 X 10(4) M-1 at I = 13 mM [pH 8.0 (HEPPS), 25 degrees C]. Calculations for the native, trypsin-solubilized form of cytochrome b5 and cytochrome c confirm that the intermolecular complex proposed by Salemme [Salemme, F. R. (1976) J. Mol. Biol. 102, 563] describes the protein-protein orientation that is electrostatically favored at neutral pH.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Conversion of oxyhaemoglobin into methaemoglobin by ferricytochrome b5.

Ferricytochrome b5 was found to convert oxyhaemoglobin into methaemoglobin under conditions previously found to be optimal for complex-formation between ferricytochrome b5 and methaemoglobin [Mauk & Mauk (1982) Biochemistry 21, 4730-4734]. As this reaction is completely inhibited by CO, it is proposed that oxyhaemoglobin is oxidized after O2 dissociation, as has been suggested for the oxidation of oxyhaemoglobin by inorganic complexes. From the present analysis, ferricytochrome b5 seems unlikely to contribute significantly to methaemoglobin formation in vivo. Nevertheless, this observation provides a relatively convenient means of investigating the mechanism by which these two proteins interact.

Interaction between cytochrome b5 and human methemoglobin.

Complex formation between purified human methemoglobin and the tryptic fragment of bovine liver cytochrome b5 has been demonstrated by the observation of a difference spectrum produced on mixing the two proteins. The intensity of this difference spectrum has been used to determine the stoichiometry of the complex formed and its stability under a variety of conditions. At pH 6.2 [25 degrees C (cacodylate buffer), mu = 2 mM], the complex has a stoichiometry of 1:1 (heme: heme) with a stability constant, KA, of (3 +/- 2) X 10(5) M(-1). This stability constant is dependent on ionic strength, decreasing to a value of (9 +/- 3) X 10(3) M(-1) at mu = 12 mM [pH 6.2 (cacodylate buffer), 25 degrees C]. Analysis of this dependence by fitting the data to a form of the Debye-Hückel equation produces a charge product of -64 +/- 14 which is in reasonable agreement with the value anticipated on the basis of the amino acid sequences of the two proteins. Determination of the pH dependence of KA revealed that the complex is most stable at slightly acidic pH (pH 6.0-6.2) or, in other words, at a pH that is approximately midway between the isoelectric pH values of cytochrome b5 and methemoglobin. The variation of KA with temperature is consistent with delta H degree = -10 +/- 3 kcal/mol and delta S degree = -12 +/- 10 eu [pH 6.2 (cacodylate buffer), mu = 5 mM]. Together, these results generate a model for cytochrome b5-methemoglobin interaction in which each hemoglobin subunit binds one cytochrome b5 by means of complementary charge interactions between oppositely charged groups on the two proteins. The probable sites of cytochrome b5 binding on hemoglobin are discussed.

Spectrophotometric analysis of the interaction between cytochrome b5 and cytochrome c.

The interaction between cytochrome c and the tryptic fragment of cytochrome b5 has been found to produce a difference spectrum in the Soret region with a maximum absorbance at 416 nm. The intensity of this difference has been used to determine the stoichiometry of complex formation and the stability of the complex formed. At pH 7.0 [25 degrees C (phosphate), mu = 0.01 M], the two proteins were found to form a 1:1 complex with an association constant, KA, of 8(3) x 10(4) M-1. The stability of the complex was found to be strongly dependent on ionic strength with KA increasing to 4(3) x 10(6) M-1 at mu = 0.001 M [25 degrees C, pH 7.0 (phosphate)]. Analysis of the dependence of KA on pH from pH 6.5 to 8 demonstrated that this complex is maximally stable between pH 7 and 8 or about midway between the isoelectric points of the two proteins. Analysis of the temperature dependence of KA revealed that formation of the complex between the two proteins is largely entropic in origin with delta Ho = 1 +/- 3 kcal/mol and delta So = 33 +/- 11 eu [pH 7.0 (phosphate), mu = 0.001 M]. This result may be explained either by the model of Clothia and Janin [Clothia, C., & Janin, J. (1975) Nature (London) 256, 705] in terms of extensive solvent reorganization upon complexation or by the model of Ross and Subramanian [Ross, P. D., & Subramanian, S. (1981) Biochemistry 20, 3096] in which the negative enthalpic and entropic contributions of short-range protein-protein interactions are offset by proton release.