Optical spectroscopy as a tool for studying the solution chemistry of neodymium(III).

In nature, the elements of the inorganic part of the periodic table are found in three forms: metals, ions in salts & minerals, and ions in solution. The ions may be coordinated to simple or complicated ligands. They may form purely electrostatic or partially covalent bonds. A common trend is that the more covalent bonds an element form, the more we know of its physicochemical properties. The rare earths form purely electrostatic bonds, thus, our understanding of the solution chemistry of these elements is limited-yet important. Most rare earth elements used today pass through hydrometallurgical processes that rely on the solution chemistry of these elements, even through the critical applications are in alloys and functional materials. Through developments in optical spectroscopy, total X-ray scattering, and quantum chemical methods we are posed to remedy this situation: we are ready to create predictive structure-property relationships in the field of lanthanide solution chemistry. The scope of this review is to summarise the state-of-the-art for neodymium(III), to go through the structure-property relationships that are in use. In the form of NdFeB magnets, neodymium plays a crucial role in green energy production and electric propulsion. As a 4f3 ion in solution it is also one of the simpler rare earth ions, and the Nd(III) ion has characteristic optical properties that can be exploited as a handle in physicochemical studies. Here, we start with a critical review of the current concepts used to relate structure and electronic energy levels. We follow with our suggested approach of using the methodology from molecular photophysics to relate optical properties and structure, and conclude with selected literature examples.

Electronic Structure of Neodymium(III) and Europium(III) Resolved in Solution Using High-Resolution Optical Spectroscopy and Population Analysis.

Solution chemistry of the lanthanide(III) ions is unexplored and relevant: extraction and recycling processes exclusively operate in solution, MRI is a solution-phase method, and bioassays are done in solution. However, the molecular structure of the lanthanide(III) ions in solution is poorly described, especially for the near-IR (NIR)-emitting lanthanides, as these are difficult to investigate using optical tools, which has limited the availability of experimental data. Here we report a custom-built spectrometer dedicated to investigation of lanthanide(III) luminescence in the NIR region. Absorption, luminescence excitation, and luminescence spectra of five complexes of europium(III) and neodymium(III) were acquired. The obtained spectra display high spectral resolution and high signal-to-noise ratios. Using the high-quality data, a method for determining the electronic structure for the thermal ground states and emitting states is proposed. It combines Boltzmann distributions with population analysis and uses the experimentally determined relative transition probabilities from both excitation and emission data. The method was tested on the five europium(III) complexes and was used to resolve the electronic structures of the ground state and the emitting state of neodymium(III) in five different solution complexes. This is the first step toward correlating optical spectra with chemical structure in solution for NIR-emitting lanthanide complexes.

Electronic Energy Levels and Optical Transitions in Samarium(III) Solvates.

Lanthanide luminescence fascinates with a complicated electronic structure and "forbidden" transitions. By studying the photophysics of lanthanide(III) solvates, a close to ideal average coordination geometry can be used to map both electronic energy levels and transition probabilities. Some lanthanide(III) ions are simpler to study than others, and samarium(III) belongs to the more difficult ones. The 4f5 system has numerous absorption and emission lines in the visible and infrared parts of the spectrum and in this work, the energy levels giving rise to these transitions were mapped, the transition probability between them was calculated, and it was shown that the electronic structures of the samarium(III) solvates in DMSO, MeOH, and water are different.

A high-sensitivity rapid acquisition spectrometer for lanthanide(III) luminescence.

Detecting luminescence beyond 750-800 nm becomes problematic as most conventional detectors are less sensitive in this range, and as simple corrections stops being accurate. Lanthanide luminescence occurs in narrow bands across the spectrum from 350-2000 nm. The most emissive lanthanide(III) ions have bands from 450 nm to 850 nm, some with additional bands in the NIR. Investigating NIR bands are hard, but the difficulties already start at 700 nm. In general, the photon flux from lanthanide(III) emitters is not great, and the bands beyond 700 nm are very weak, we therefore decided to build a spectrometer based on cameras for microscopy with single-photon detection capabilities. This was found to allieviate all limitations and to allow for fast and efficient recording of luminescence spectra in the range from 450 to 950 nm. The spectrometer characteristics were investigated and the performance was benchmarked against two commercial spectrometers. We conclude that this spectrometer is ideal for investigating lanthanide luminescence, and all other emitters with emission in the target range.

A europium(III)-based nanooptode for bicarbonate sensing - a multicomponent approach to sensor materials.

Lanthanide luminescence contains detailed chemical information and can be used to report on several chemical analytes. This has been exploited through elaborate synthesis of responsive lanthanide complexes. Here, we report on a less elaborate approach and assemble four different nanooptodes. Europium(III) is used to sense the bicarbonate concentration. The signal from the optode was enhanced 100 times using antenna chromophore and the response was modulated by the addition of lipophilic cations.

Revisiting the assignment of innocent and non-innocent counterions in lanthanide(III) solution chemistry.

Lanthanides are found in critical applications from display technology to renewable energy. Often, these rare earth elements are used as alloys or functional materials, yet access to them is through solution processes. In aqueous solutions, the rare earths are found predominantly as trivalent ions and charge balance dictates that counterions are present. The fast ligand exchange and lack of directional bonding in lanthanide complexes have led to questions regarding the speciation of Ln3+ solvates in the presence of various counterions and the distinction between innocent = non-coordinating and non-innocent = coordinating counterions. There is limited agreement as to which group counterions belong to, which led to this report. By using Eu3+ luminescence, it was possible to clearly distinguish between coordinating and non-coordinating ions. To interpret the results, it was required to bridge the descriptions of ion pairing and coordination. The data-in the form of Eu3+ luminescence spectra and luminescence lifetimes from solutions with varying concentrations of acetate, chloride, nitrate, sulfate, perchlorate and triflate-was contrasted to those obtained with ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA4-), which allowed for the distinction between three Ln3+-anion interaction types. It was possible to conclude which counterions are truly innocent (e.g. ClO4- and OTf-) and which clearly coordinate (e.g. NO3- and AcO-). Finally, a considerable amount of data from systems studied under similar conditions allowed the minimum perturbation arising from the inner sphere or outer sphere coordination in Eu3+ complexes to be identified.

Arel: Investigating [Eu(H2O)9]3+ Photophysics and Creating a Method to Bypass Luminescence Quantum Yield Determinations.

Lanthanide luminescence has been treated separate from molecular photophysics, although the underlying phenomena are the same. As the optical transitions observed in the trivalent lanthanide ions are forbidden, they do belong to the group that molecular photophysics has yet to conquer, yet the experimental descriptors remain valid. Herein, the luminescence quantum yields (ϕlum), luminescence lifetimes (τobs), oscillator strengths (f), and the rates of nonradiative (knr) and radiative (kr ≡ A) deactivation of [Eu(H2O)9]3+ were determined. Further, it was shown that instead of a full photophysical characterization, it is possible to relate changes in transition probabilities to the relative parameter Arel, which does not require reference data. While Arel does not afford comparisons between experiments, it resolves emission intensity changes due to emitter properties from intensity changes due to environmental effects and differences in the number of photons absorbed. When working with fluorescence this may seem trivial; when working with lanthanide luminescence it is not.

Accessing lanthanide-based, in situ illuminated optical turn-on probes by modulation of the antenna triplet state energy.

Luminescent lanthanides possess ideal properties for biological imaging, including long luminescent lifetimes and emission within the optical window. Here, we report a novel approach to responsive luminescent Tb(iii) probes that involves direct modulation of the antenna excited triplet state energy. If the triplet energy lies too close to the 5D4 Tb(iii) excited state (20 500 cm-1), energy transfer to 5D4 competes with back energy transfer processes and limits lanthanide-based emission. To validate this approach, a series of pyridyl-functionalized, macrocyclic lanthanide complexes were designed, and the corresponding lowest energy triplet states were calculated using density functional theory (DFT). Subsequently, three novel constructs L3 (nitro-pyridyl), L4 (amino-pyridyl) and L5 (fluoro-pyridyl) were synthesized. Photophysical characterization of the corresponding Gd(iii) complexes revealed antenna triplet energies between 25 800 and 30 400 cm-1 and a 500-fold increase in quantum yield upon conversion of Tb(L3) to Tb(L4) using the biologically relevant analyte H2S. The corresponding turn-on reaction can be monitored using conventional, small-animal optical imaging equipment in presence of a Cherenkov radiation emitting isotope as an in situ excitation source, demonstrating that antenna triplet state energy modulation represents a viable approach to biocompatible, Tb-based optical turn-on probes.

Electronic Structure of Ytterbium(III) Solvates-a Combined Spectroscopic and Theoretical Study.

The wide range of optical and magnetic properties of lanthanide(III) ions is associated with their intricate electronic structures which, in contrast to lighter elements, is characterized by strong relativistic effects and spin-orbit coupling. Nevertheless, computational methods are now capable of describing the ladder of electronic energy levels of the simpler trivalent lanthanide ions, as well as the lowest energy term of most of the series. The electronic energy levels result from electron configurations that are first split by spin-orbit coupling into groups of energy levels denoted by the corresponding Russell-Saunders terms. Each of these groups are then split by the ligand field into the actual electronic energy levels known as microstates or sometimes mJ levels. The ligand-field splitting directly informs on the coordination geometry and is a valuable tool for determining the structure and thus correlating the structure and properties of metal complexes in solution. The issue with lanthanide complexes is that the determination of complex structures from ligand-field splitting remains a very challenging task. In this paper, the optical spectra-absorption, luminescence excitation, and luminescence emission-of ytterbium(III) solvates were recorded in water, methanol, dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), and N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF). The electronic energy levels, that is, the microstates, were resolved experimentally. Subsequently, density functional theory calculations were used to model the structures of the solvates, and ab initio relativistic complete active space self-consistent field calculations (CASSCF) were employed to obtain the microstates of the possible structures of each solvate. By comparing the experimental and theoretical data, it was possible to determine both the coordination number and solution structure of each solvate. In water, methanol, and N,N-dimethylformamide, the solvates were found to be eight-coordinated and have a square antiprismatic coordination geometry. In DMSO, the speciation was found to be more complicated. The robust methodology developed for comparing experimental spectra and computational results allows the solution structures of homoleptic lanthanide complexes to be determined.

The effect of weighted averages when determining the speciation and structure-property relationships of europium(iii) dipicolinate complexes.

Lanthanide(iii) coordination chemistry in solution is inherently complicated by the lack of directional interactions and rapid ligand exchange. The latter can be eliminated in kinetically inert complexes, but remains a challenge in complexes between lanthanide(iii) ions and smaller ligands. As multiple conformations and partial decomplexation is an issue even with multidentate ligands, it will influence the observed solution properties of complexes of smaller ligands common in the field of f-elements coordination chemistry such as acetylacetonates and dipicolinates. Here, europium(iii) complexes with one, two and three dipicolinates were investigated in a series of 13 samples, where the composition was varied from 0 to 3 equivalents of dipicolinate. While the results did show the formation of three distinct europium(iii) dipicolinate complexes confirming the literature data on the system, clear discrepancies in speciation related properties were evident when comparing the results from absorption and luminescence spectroscopy. It was concluded that the difference is due to the difference in time constant of the two experiments. Furthermore, it is shown that the information obtained from luminescence arises from a weigthed average, and with discepancies between the observed and actual concentration exceeding 25%, it is advised that the weighted averages are taken into consideration when reporting on solution properties of lanthanide(iii) complexes. From the resolved optical spectra of [Eu(H2O)9]3+, [Eu(DPA)(H2O)6]+, [Eu(DPA)2(H2O)3]-, and [Eu(DPA)3]3-, the excited energy levels and transition probabilities are determined, and it was concluded that both transition probabilities and ligand field effects on the microstates are different in all four species.

Solution Structure, Electronic Energy Levels, and Photophysical Properties of [Eu(MeOH)n-2m(NO3)m]3-m+ Complexes.

The structure of lanthanide(III) ions in solutions high in nitrate has been debated since the early days of lanthanide coordination chemistry. The structure and properties of lanthanides in these solutions are essential in industrial rare-earth separation, as well as in the fundamental solution chemistry of these elements. Pending decades of debate, it was established that nitrate is bidentate and coordinates in the inner sphere, and complexes have been observed with as many as four nitrates coordinated to a single lanthanide(III) center in nonaqueous solutions. We revisit the interactions between nitrate and europium(III) in methanol using optical spectroscopy, X-ray total scattering, and the current understanding of europium(III) photophysics. By a combination of direct and indirect methods to probe the structure, it was found that four distinct species from Eu(MeOH)93+ to [Eu(MeOH)3(NO3)3] are present in solutions containing from 0 to 2 M NO3- ions. It was shown that the changes in transition probabilities together with high-resolution spectra can provide information on speciation and how the minute changes in ligand field affect the microstates. By a comparison to total X-ray scattering, it was concluded that the optical spectra alone allow the constitution and symmetry of the europium(III) species to be determined. Most notably, the minute changes in the all oxygen atom coordination imply significant changes in the optical properties of the europium(III) center.

Using Polarized Spectroscopy to Investigate Order in Thin-Films of Ionic Self-Assembled Materials Based on Azo-Dyes.

Three series of ionic self-assembled materials based on anionic azo-dyes and cationic benzalkonium surfactants were synthesized and thin films were prepared by spin-casting. These thin films appear isotropic when investigated with polarized optical microscopy, although they are highly anisotropic. Here, three series of homologous materials were studied to rationalize this observation. Investigating thin films of ordered molecular materials relies to a large extent on advanced experimental methods and large research infrastructure. A statement that in particular is true for thin films with nanoscopic order, where X-ray reflectometry, X-ray and neutron scattering, electron microscopy and atom force microscopy (AFM) has to be used to elucidate film morphology and the underlying molecular structure. Here, the thin films were investigated using AFM, optical microscopy and polarized absorption spectroscopy. It was shown that by using numerical method for treating the polarized absorption spectroscopy data, the molecular structure can be elucidated. Further, it was shown that polarized optical spectroscopy is a general tool that allows determination of the molecular order in thin films. Finally, it was found that full control of thermal history and rigorous control of the ionic self-assembly conditions are required to reproducibly make these materials of high nanoscopic order. Similarly, the conditions for spin-casting are shown to be determining for the overall thin film morphology, while molecular order is maintained.