Different responses to K-10 and CIDI suggest that complex structured psychiatric interviews underestimate rates of mental disorder in old people.

BACKGROUND: Epidemiological surveys based on complex diagnostic interviews, such as the Composite International Diagnostic Interview (CIDI), report very low rates of anxiety and depressive disorders in older age groups. Mental health checklists show much less change over the lifespan. This paper explores the possibility that complex interviews present a special challenge to older respondents and thereby exaggerate the decline in mental disorder with age. METHOD: Analysis of data from an Australian national mental health survey with 10,641 community-resident adult respondents. Measures of interest included ICD-10 anxiety and depression diagnoses, scores on the Kessler Psychological Distress Scale (K-10), agreement between K-10 and CIDI anxiety and depressive questions, and changes in agreement with age. RESULTS: Levels of inconsistency between simple and complex questions about anxiety and depression rose with age. CONCLUSIONS: Older people may have difficulty attending to and processing lengthy, complex questionnaires. When in doubt, their preferred response may be to deny having experienced symptoms, thus deflating rates of diagnosed mental disorder. We recommend that simple mental health scales be included in epidemiological studies involving older age groups.

Depression among newly admitted Australian nursing home residents.

BACKGROUND: This research concerns the prevalence and course of depression in newly admitted nursing home residents. We attempted to recruit consecutive admissions into the study, irrespective of cognitive status, enabling a comparison of the prevalence and course of depression experienced by cognitively intact residents and those exhibiting all levels of cognitive impairment. METHOD: Depression was assessed at one month, three months and six months post-admission. The assessment of mood in this study entailed the conduct of a semi-structured clinical interview, which encompassed DSM-IV criteria and Cornell Scale for Depression in Dementia (CSDD) items. RESULTS: Recruitment difficulties resulted in a sample of 51 newly admitted residents, drawn from six nursing homes located in Victoria, Australia. Of particular interest, throughout the duration of the study, only the cognitively impaired were diagnosed with major depression (MD). One month post-admission, 24% of the sample were diagnosed with MD, and a further 20% evidenced a non-major depressive disorder. At the second and third assessments, MD was observed in 14% and 15% of residents, respectively. For residents who completed all three assessments, there was no appreciable change in the proportion diagnosed with a depressive disorder, nor was there a change in the levels of depressive symptomatology. CONCLUSION: Although subject to limitations, the current study indicated that clinical depression in nursing home facilities most often occurs in residents who also exhibit pronounced cognitive impairment. These depressions are unlikely to remit spontaneously. Accordingly, care staff and general practitioners must be trained in the identification of depression in dementia, and any interventions implemented in these facilities should be tailored to meet the unique needs of this group.

A comparison of the efficacy and safety of olanzapine and risperidone in the treatment of elderly patients with schizophrenia: an open study of six months duration.

BACKGROUND: Following an earlier study in which elderly patients with schizophrenia had their typical antipsychotic medication changed to olanzapine or risperidone, the 61 patients were followed for up to a further six months to see if either treatment was superior in terms of efficacy or side effects. AIMS: To determine whether either olanzapine or risperidone was superior in terms of efficacy or side effects when treating schizophrenia in late life. METHODS: Psychiatric symptoms, side effects and quality of life were rated every six weeks for 24 weeks of open label comparative treatment using standard measures. Group differences were examined using analysis of covariance and within-group changes over time were assessed using paired t-tests. RESULTS: There were 34 olanzapine and 32 risperidone patients who entered the study, but intention to treat data was only available for 61 of the 66 patients. There were no clinical or demographic differences between the groups. Parkinsonism, positive and negative symptoms of schizophrenia improved in both groups both from baseline switch to olanzapine or risperidone and during the six month follow-up after completion of crossover. No significant differences were seen between groups on most measures. However, patients treated with olanzapine showed a significantly greater improvement in quality of life from baseline compared to risperidone patients. CONCLUSIONS: Both drugs were well tolerated and their use was associated with fewer symptoms of schizophrenia and less adverse effects than were seen when the patients were taking a typical antipsychotic at baseline. Olanzapine appears to have particular benefit with regard to quality of life.

The impact upon extra-pyramidal side effects, clinical symptoms and quality of life of a switch from conventional to atypical antipsychotics (risperidone or olanzapine) in elderly patients with schizophrenia.

BACKGROUND: Atypical antipsychotics are commonly used in the management of schizophrenia in late life with evidence suggesting they induce lower rates of motor disturbance, but have similar efficacy to conventional antipsychotics. Trials in the elderly have been either retrospective, small, of short duration or of a single-arm design. AIMS: To demonstrate the effects upon motor side-effects, efficacy, safety and quality of life (QOL) of switching elderly patients with schizophrenia from conventional antipsychotics to olanzapine or risperidone. METHODS: Elderly patients with schizophrenia were randomly allocated to olanzapine or risperidone and followed through an open-label crossover period. Between and within group intention to treat analyses were conducted. RESULTS: 66 patients were randomised (mean age 69.6 [SD +/- 6.2]). Four (11.8%) patients on olanzapine and 8 (26.7%) patients on risperidone failed to complete the crossover because of treatment failure [Odds Ratio (OR) = 2.73[0.73-10.2] p = 0.14]. The mean doses upon completion of switching in each arm were 9.9 mg (SD = 4.2) and 1.7 mg (SD = 1.2) for olanzapine and risperidone respectively. In both arms there was improvement in Parkinsonism, though only olanzapine was associated with a reduction in dyskinetic symptoms. The Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale, Scale for the assessment of Negative Symptoms and Montgomery and Asberg Depression Rating Scale scores all improved through the crossover period in both arms with no between group differences. Treatment with olanzapine was associated with a better response over risperidone on the psychological domain of the World Health Organisation-Quality Of Life [Brief] (WHO-QOL-BREF) scale ( p = 0.02). Patients in the olanzapine arm also demonstrated improvement from baseline in the WHO-QOL-BREF physical, psychological and health satisfaction domains, but risperidone had no effect on any Quality of Life (QOL) measure. CONCLUSIONS: After switching from a conventional antipsychotic, olanzapine and risperidone were associated with improvement in core symptoms of schizophrenia and motor side effects. Subjects switched to olanzapine were more likely to complete the switching process and show an improvement in psychological QOL.

Depression in primary care. 1: elderly patients' disclosure of depressive symptoms to their doctors.

BACKGROUND: This article examines some of the factors responsible for older patients' decision to report current depressive symptoms to their general medical practitioner. A companion article considers factors contributing to general practitioners' (GPs') recognition of major depressive episode when it was present. METHODS: A survey was conducted of a stratified sample of 1,021 patients aged 70+ years of 30 GPs in Melbourne, Australia, to gauge the prevalence of depressive symptoms, the frequency with which patients had informed GPs of their symptoms, and GPs' recognition of major depressive episodes. Patients and informants were questioned using the Canberra Interview for the Elderly, which generates rigorous ICD-10 research diagnoses. RESULTS: Logistic regression analysis showed that symptom disclosure was associated in descending order of importance with higher depressive scores, previous contact with a psychiatrist, and female gender. Even so, 48% of persons with ICD-10 moderate or severe depressive episode had not reported any current complaints to their doctor at the time of interview. CONCLUSION: Older patients often do not report depressive symptoms to their medical practitioner. Men and patients lacking "psychological mindedness" may be at special risk.

Depression in primary care. 2: general practitioners' recognition of major depression in elderly patients.

BACKGROUND: It is important that serious depressive illness be recognized and treated appropriately by primary care practitioners. This and the preceding article in this issue examine (a) factors responsible for older patients' decision to report depressive symptoms to their doctor and (b) general practitioners' (GPs') recognition of depression when it was present. METHODS: A survey was conducted of a stratified sample of 1,021 patients aged 70+ years of 30 GPs in Melbourne, Australia, using the Canberra Interview for the Elderly, which generates rigorous ICD-10 research diagnoses. RESULTS: GPs' ratings of depression were best predicted in descending order of importance by patients' past contact with a psychiatrist, the doctor's view that a patient did not have dementia, the number of current depressive symptoms, patients' disclosure of these symptoms, and current physical pain. Physicians' assessments of patients' mood concurred with research diagnoses in 23 of 35 (66%) cases of ICD-10 mild depressive episode and 23 of 26 (88%) cases of moderate or severe depressive episode. GPs were unaware, however, of many depressive symptoms and often rated patients as being depressed when they were not. CONCLUSION: The use of a simple checklist of depressive symptoms would lead to a dramatic improvement in doctors' knowledge of patients' current psychiatric status.

Population norms for the MMSE in the very old: estimates based on longitudinal data. Mini-Mental State Examination.

OBJECTIVE: To report the percentile distribution of Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE) scores in older people by age, sex, and education level, estimated from longitudinal data, after correcting for loss due to dropout. METHODS: The Cambridge City over 75 Cohort is a population-based study of a cohort of 2106 subjects age 75 years and older at study entry followed up over 9 years. At each of the four waves, cognitive function was assessed using MMSE. Based on these data, the relationship between age and MMSE score was modeled. Percentile distributions by age, sex, and education level were provided using inverse probability weighting to correct for dropouts. RESULTS: Performance on MMSE was related to age in men and women. In women, at age 75, MMSE score ranged from 21 (10th percentile) to 29 (90th percentile). At age 95, the range was 10 (10th percentile) to 27 (90th percentile). The upper end of MMSE distribution was slightly modified with age, whereas the lower end of the distribution was very sensitive to age effect. A similar pattern was observed in both sexes. CONCLUSION: These findings provide norms for MMSE scores in subjects age 75 years and older from longitudinal population-based data. Such norms can be used as reference values to determine where an individual's score lies in relation to his or her age, sex, and education level.

Estimating the true extent of cognitive decline in the old old.

OBJECTIVE: To measure cognitive change using a brief measure over a period of 9 years and to adjust for attrition in the sample. DESIGN: The Cambridge City over 75 Cohort (CC75C), a complete sample of the 75 years and older age group from five group general practices in the city of Cambridge with a systematic one-third of a further practice, all followed on four occasions. SETTING: Cambridge city, UK, the respondents' place of residence. PARTICIPANTS: A total of 2106 subjects were included at study entry. MEASUREMENTS: A brief interview, administered by a trained interviewer, containing a short cognitive scale and the Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE) at baseline, 2.4 years, 6 years, and 9 years. RESULTS: Decline in MMSE scores occurred across the population and was greater in the oldest age groups. Attrition at later stages of the follow-up was associated with greater decline at earlier stages. Adjusting the results for loss to the sample leads to considerably higher estimates of decline, with the older age groups declining faster from lower levels. CONCLUSIONS: To date, cognitive decline in the very old has been considerably underestimated by longitudinal studies. If studies of population samples are to reflect the health and social needs of this frail group accurately, adjustments for the effect of attrition must be included before true decline can be estimated.

How is psychiatry taught to Australian and New Zealand medical students?

OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to describe the amount, format and content of psychiatry teaching programs in all 12 Australian and New Zealand medical schools. METHOD: A structured questionnaire which included definitions and coding instructions was completed by class coordinators for the years of 1995 or 1996. Missing and inconsistent data were checked by coordinators and results were confirmed by heads of department. RESULTS: Most departments of psychiatry taught throughout the undergraduate course. Only three made no contribution to pre-clinical teaching. The time devoted to clinical tuition ranged from 279 to 454 h per university with a mean of 353 h. Clinical attachments occupied most time (mean = 70%), followed by small group teaching (mean = 19%) and lectures (mean = 11%). Medical schools varied greatly in the attention given to history taking and mental state examination, psychological therapies and the sub-specialties of child and aged psychiatry. Clinical attachments were mostly to adult inpatient units. Private psychiatric hospitals and clinics were used infrequently as were consultation-liaison psychiatry services and primary care. CONCLUSION: There is a need to broaden the clinical experience of students to better equip them for future medical practice. There appears to be a serious mis-match between the settings in which most students are taught and the settings in which most will work later as non-psychiatric practitioners. It was disappointing that psychological therapies received so little attention given the central place of counselling in modern medical practice.

The efficacy of psychosocial approaches to behaviour disorders in dementia: a systematic literature review.

OBJECTIVE: This paper provides a systematic review of research findings published between 1989 and 1998 concerning non-pharmacological strategies to alleviate behavioural disturbances in elderly persons with dementia. METHOD: Data collection strategies included computer literature searches, manual searches of selected journals and checks of references listed in previous reviews. To warrant inclusion, studies were required to include some measure of behaviour before and after the introduction of an intervention. Papers were appraised in the following domains: design, sampling technique, setting, behaviours studied, measurement tools, data collection methods, type of interventions and feasibility. An overall validity rating was assigned to each article using predetermined rules. RESULTS: Forty-three studies met criteria for inclusion including five randomised controlled trials. Validity ratings were as follows: one strong, 15 moderate, and 27 weak. Areas of scientific weakness included small numbers of subjects, inadequate descriptions of study participants, imprecise data collection methods, high attrition rates and insufficient statistical analysis. Despite this, there is evidence to support the efficacy of activity programs, music, behaviour therapy, light therapy, carer education and changes to the physical environment. The evidence in favour of multidisciplinary teams, massage and aromatherapy is inconclusive. CONCLUSIONS: It was easier to interpret the results of rigorously designed studies that focused on a single behaviour or single intervention tailored to the needs of individuals and carers. Future studies should seek to replicate the findings outlined here, improving methodologies where necessary and including outcome measures that encompass the interests of people with dementia, family caregivers and health professionals.

Vascular risks and incident dementia: results from a cohort study of the very old.

The contribution of vascular pathology to the manifestation of dementia and the importance of vascular risk to measures of cognitive function is being increasingly recognized. In particular, confirmation of this risk points towards approaches for prevention in large sections of the population. Information on determinants of incident dementia is increasing, but still relatively few studies of risk have been based on incident cases of dementia in very elderly populations. In this study based on incident cases of dementia in a population aged 75 and over, vascular risks were obtained from informants of the respondents with incident dementia. When compared with controls the factors associated with incident dementia were history of heart attack (odds ratio 2.9), transient ischaemic attacks (4.8), cerebrovascular accidents (3.4), family history of first-degree relatives with dementia (4.0), and occupational exposure to vibrating instruments (1.4). If only Alzheimer's disease, clinically diagnosed, was included, diabetes (1.4) and a history of dementia in first-degree relatives (6.6) emerged. Thus, vascular risk continues to be of importance in the oldest age groups.

Changes in self-rated health, disability and contact with services in a very elderly cohort: a 6-year follow-up study.

OBJECTIVES: To study the relationships between global self-rated health, reported physical symptoms and depressive symptoms and the receipt of community services by very elderly people, and to examine changes in these variables over time. DESIGN: Three-wave study with follow-up at 2.4 and 6 years after first interview. Structured interview, incorporating cognitive examination (Mini-Mental State Examination) and enquiring specifically about overall self-rated health, physical symptoms and depressive symptoms. SETTING: Community setting in city of Cambridge, UK. PARTICIPANTS: 2609 were initially recruited: all patients aged 75 years and over from lists of six general practices (and one in three from a seventh practice). At 2.4 years, 1173 individuals re-examined and at 6 years 628 individuals. MEASUREMENTS: General health self-rated in comparison to others of similar age and individual physical and depressive symptoms self-rated as present or absent. Symptoms were added to produce physical health and depressive symptom scores. Data presented from cross-sectional analysis of 6-year sample; also examined longitudinal data from all three waves of study for ageing and cohort effects. Finally the effect of health variables on the receipt of services was examined. Statistics used included chi(2) and non-parametric statistics for continuous data, also odds ratios for likelihood of receiving services. RESULTS: At 6 years, 70% rated their overall health as good or very good. Overall self-rated health showed both ageing and cohort effects, improving with increasing age and especially with more recent cohort. Reported physical symptoms increased with ageing. Depression scores also increased with ageing but the relationship between depressive symptoms and ageing was less clear-cut. Receipt of services was associated with poor self-rated health and reported physical symptoms as well as with ageing. Higher depression scores at 2.4 years were associated with increased service receipt at 6 years, indicating a lag between the symptoms and the service response. Individuals in the more recent cohort were less likely to receive services, but those who did so received more frequent contact. CONCLUSIONS: Although very elderly people have a high prevalence of reported physical symptoms, they often rate their overall health as good. There was a stronger relationship between ageing and physical symptoms than with depressive symptoms. Symptoms of both kinds influenced the likelihood of receiving services, although there was a lag between depressive symptoms and service response. Cohort effects on service receipt may reflect changes in public service policy.

Cognitive impairment: a challenge for community care. A comparison of the domiciliary service receipt of cognitively impaired and equally dependent physically impaired elderly women.

OBJECTIVES: to compare the domiciliary service receipt of cognitively impaired and equally dependent physically impaired elderly women prior to the passing of the UK Community Care Act. METHODS: secondary analysis of a population survey conducted in 1986 in the city of Cambridge. The analysis used data on 1585 women aged 75 and over living in the community. The effect of type of impairment on the receipt of domiciliary services (meals-on-wheels, home help and community nursing) is measured using a multivariate model which allows for adjustment for dependency level and other potential confounding factors. RESULTS: the odds of an elderly woman getting help from any of the domiciliary services whilst not being significantly affected by cognitive impairment (odds ratio 0.7, 95% CI 0.5-1.2) are increased by physical impairment (odds ratio 1.8, 95% CI 1.2-2.5). Similar results were found for the home help service. The differences were exaggerated in the case of the community nursing service, whilst receipt of meals-on-wheels was similar for women of with all types of impairment. CONCLUSIONS: in the late 1980s, cognitively impaired elderly women received less help from the domiciliary services than equally dependent physically frail women who lived in similar household circumstances. The development of specialist services appropriate to the needs of cognitively impaired elderly people presents a challenge to community care policy, especially since this group are at high risk of institutionalization.

Cross-national interrater reliability of dementia diagnosis in the elderly and factors associated with disagreement.

Thirteen researchers from five centers in Australia, Germany, the Netherlands, United Kingdom, and United States applied DSM-III-R and Clinical Dementia Rating (CDR) syndrome-level dementia criteria to written vignettes of 100 elderly people identified in clinics or community surveys. Subjects ranged in type from cognitively intact to severely demented and many were also frail, partially sighted, or deaf. This paper concerns reliability within and between centers, and the relationship between reliability and factors such as diagnostic criteria, dementia severity, and respondents' clinical characteristics. Within-center interrater reliability was high, more so for "yes-no" DSM-III-R diagnoses than the multi-level CDR. Between-center rates were lower but still moderate to good. Concordance was lower for intermediate dementia levels than for no dementia and severe dementia. Physical disability made an additional contribution to uncertainty but deafness, poor vision, anxiety, and depression had no discernible effects. Reliability levels are likely to be lower in representative aged populations than in carefully selected clinical groups.

Apolipoprotein E genotype in the prediction of cognitive decline and dementia in a prospectively studied elderly population.

An increased apolipoprotein E (ApoE) type epsilon 4 allele frequency is associated with both sporadic and familial late-onset Alzheimer's disease (AD). The age of onset of disease in patients homozygous for the epsilon 4 allele appears to be decreased by approximately 15 years compared with E2/3 individuals. In order to assess the influence of this allele on both dementia and cognitive decline in the elderly we have determined the ApoE genotype of 150 individuals over the age of 75 years who have taken part in a longitudinal study. Homozygosity for the epsilon 4 allele was rare. Of the 2 homozygotes, 1 was severely demented but the other did not receive a clinical diagnosis of dementia. The latter individual did demonstrate marked cognitive decline over a 28-month period. There was a consistent association between the presence of an epsilon 4 allele and both the clinical diagnosis of dementia and cognitive decline. These findings confirm a genetic heterogeneity in late-onset sporadic AD and prompt caution in the use of ApoE genotype to predict an elderly individual's susceptibility to either dementia or cognitive decline.

The relationship between clinical dementia and neuropathological staging (Braak) in a very elderly community sample.

The neuropathological staging model proposed by Braak and Braak (1991) implies that the evolution of neurofibrillary pathology follows a predictable sequence and can be ordered in a regular regional hierarchy. A total of 42 cases of an elderly population sample, which had been prospectively clinically assessed, were examined. Clinical diagnosis was made according to the CAMDEX criteria, and the sample reported here did not include cases were vascular dementia according to the criteria proposed by Chui et al. (1991). The neuropathological staging procedure was applied as originally proposed by Braak and Braak (1991). In addition, in all cortical laminae and regions which are essential for the staging model neurofibrillary tangles were quantified. Demented cases had significantly more areas involved and more advanced neuropathological stages. Cases with stages 1-3 tended to be non-demented, and cases with stages 4-6 tended to be demented. However, there was a considerable degree of overlap and no clear-cut threshold could be established. This brings into question the diagnostic value of the staging model.

Predictors of hospital contact by very elderly people: a pilot study from a cohort of people aged 75 years and over.

We wished to test the hypothesis that elderly people with impaired cognitive function were heavier users of both outpatient and inpatient hospital services. In a retrospective cohort study, 144 elderly people aged 75-97 years (50 men and 94 women) identified from a prevalence survey of dementia were traced over an average period of 4 years. They were categorized into three groups: cognitively impaired, physically frail and physically healthy. Elderly people with impaired cognitive function had fewer contacts with outpatient services (p = 0.0003) but did not differ in inpatient service use from subjects with normal cognitive function. Cognitively impaired people who lived alone had longer hospital stays (p = 0.002) and a higher admission rate to geriatric wards (p = 0,009). Negative self-rated health was an important factor predicting more contacts for men with inpatient services and geriatric outpatient services (both p = 0.002). Use of surgical outpatient services was associated with use of surgical inpatient services by the physically healthy group only (p = 0.0003). After adjusting for age, sex and physical health, cognitively impaired subjects were nearly twice as likely to die within four years as the other two groups (RR = 1.89).

Incidence of clinically diagnosed subtypes of dementia in an elderly population. Cambridge Project for Later Life.

BACKGROUND: In developed countries, most dementia appears to be due to Alzheimer's disease and vascular dementia. We report rates for incidence of subtypes of dementia based on clinical diagnosis. METHOD: This study was a 2.4-year (s.d. 2.6 months) follow-up of a cohort aged 75 years and over, seen initially in a prevalence study of dementia. A screening interview in 1173 survivors was followed in a subsample of 461 respondents by a diagnostic interview 1.8 months after screening (s.d. 1.5 months). This comprised a standardised interview with respondent and informant, with venepuncture where possible. Clinical diagnoses of subtypes were made by specified criteria. RESULTS: The incidence of Alzheimer's disease of mild and greater severity was 2.7/1000 person-years at risk (1.6-4.4); in men 1.5 (0.8-2.7) and in women 3.3 (1.8-5.9). The incidence of vascular dementia was 1.2/100 person-years at risk (0.7-1.9); in men 1.1 (0.4-2.8) and in women 1.2 (0.7-2.0). Alzheimer's disease, but not vascular dementia, showed a marked increase with age, particularly in women. Rates for minimal dementia of different subtypes showed similar age and sex effects, but were much higher for Alzheimer's disease than vascular dementia. CONCLUSIONS: The striking rise in incidence rates of dementia in the very old appear to be due to Alzheimer's disease, while rates for vascular dementia remain relatively constant. These trends are particularly marked for minimal dementia, but emphasise the importance of Alzheimer's disease in the community as a cause of cognitive decline of all degrees.

Cognitive decline in an elderly population--a two wave study of change.

A sample of 1111 survivors from a population aged 75 years and over completed the Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE) twice, separated by 28 months on average. There was a mean decline of 1.3 points in MMSE score. With increasing age, mean drop in score also increased. The proportion at each age identified as newly cognitively impaired according to any standard cut-point on MMSE rose markedly. Mean decline was greater in women than men even after adjustment for age. Cognitive change on the MMSE was approximately unimodally and normally distributed. This distribution was a marked contrast to the distribution of MMSE scores themselves, which was skewed due to truncation of scores at the maximum. The decline was not due to the inclusion of individuals with physical impairment. These findings indicate that cognitive decline, like dementia, becomes increasingly common with advancing age, and suggest that dementia may be regarded as one extreme of the continuum of cognitive decline.