Toward a high-throughput screening platform for directed evolution of enzymes that activate genotoxic prodrugs.

Engineering of enzymes to more efficiently activate genotoxic prodrugs holds great potential for improving anticancer gene or antibody therapies. We report the development of a new, GFP-based, high-throughput screening platform to enable engineering of prodrug-activating enzymes by directed evolution. By fusing an inducible SOS promoter to an engineered GFP reporter gene, we were able to measure levels of DNA damage in intact Escherichia coli and separate cell populations by fluorescence activating cell sorting (FACS). In two FACS iterations, we were able to achieve a 90,000-fold enrichment of a functional prodrug-activating nitroreductase from a null library background.

Targeted mutagenesis of the Vibrio fischeri flavin reductase FRase I to improve activation of the anticancer prodrug CB1954.

Phase I/II cancer gene therapy trials of the Escherichia coli nitroreductase NfsB in partnership with the prodrug CB1954 [5-(aziridin-1-yl)-2,4-dinitrobenzamide] have indicated that CB1954 toxicity is dose-limiting at concentrations far below the enzyme K(M). Here we report that the flavin reductase FRase I from Vibrio fischeri is also a CB1954 nitroreductase, which has a substantially lower apparent K(M) than E. coli NfsB. To enhance the activity of FRase I with CB1954 we used targeted mutagenesis and an E. coli SOS reporter strain to engineer single- and multi-residue variants that possess a substantially reduced apparent K(M) and an increased k(cat)/K(M) relative to the wild type enzyme. In a bacteria-delivered model for enzyme prodrug therapy, the engineered FRase I variants were able to kill human colon carcinoma (HCT-116) cells at significantly lower CB1954 concentrations than wild type FRase I or E. coli NfsB.

uvrB gene deletion enhances SOS chromotest sensitivity for nitroreductases that preferentially generate the 4-hydroxylamine metabolite of the anti-cancer prodrug CB1954.

CB1954 is an anti-cancer prodrug that can be reduced at either of two nitro groups to form cytotoxic metabolites. We describe here two efficient and previously uncharacterized nitroreductases, YfkO from Bacillus subtilis which reduces CB1954 exclusively at the 4-NO(2) position, and NfsA from Klebsiella pneumoniae which preferentially reduces the 2-NO(2) group. Utilizing these novel enzymes, together with three previously characterized nitroreductases, we demonstrate that the Escherichia coli SOS-chromotest assay can differentially detect the 4-nitro versus 2-nitro reduction products of CB1954 following deletion of the nucleotide excision repair gene uvrB, but not mismatch repair (mutS) or methyltransferase (ada/ogt) genes. These findings may hold significance for identification and selection of nitroreductases for CB1954-mediated gene therapy, particularly when targeting tumors that are deficient in nucleotide excision repair. Moreover, we demonstrate that comparative SOS chromotest analysis in wild type and uvrB mutant strains can be used to determine whether or not nucleotide excision repair plays a significant role in processing DNA damage resulting from activation of different nitroaromatic prodrugs.

Discovery and evaluation of Escherichia coli nitroreductases that activate the anti-cancer prodrug CB1954.

Gene-directed enzyme prodrug therapy (GDEPT) aims to achieve highly selective tumor-cell killing through the use of tumor-tropic gene delivery vectors coupled with systemic administration of otherwise inert prodrugs. Nitroaromatic prodrugs such as CB1954 hold promise for GDEPT as they are readily reduced to potent DNA alkylating agents by bacterial nitroreductase enzymes (NTRs). Transfection with the nfsB gene from Escherichia coli can increase the sensitivity of tumor cells to CB1954 by greater than 1000-fold. However, poor catalytic efficiency limits the activation of CB1954 by NfsB at clinically relevant doses. A lack of flexible, high-throughput screening technology has hindered efforts to discover superior NTR candidates. Here we demonstrate how the SOS chromotest and complementary screening technologies can be used to evaluate novel enzymes that activate CB1954 and other bioreductive and/or genotoxic prodrugs. We identify the major E. coli NTR, NfsA, as 10-fold more efficient than NfsB in activating CB1954 as purified protein (k(cat)/K(m)) and when over-expressed in an E. coli nfsA(-)/nfsB(-) gene deleted strain. NfsA also confers sensitivity to CB1954 when expressed in HCT-116 human colon carcinoma cells, with similar efficiency to NfsB. In addition, we identify two novel E. coli NTRs, AzoR and NemA, that have not previously been characterized in the context of nitroaromatic prodrug activation.

The nitroreductase prodrug SN 28343 enhances the potency of systemically administered armed oncolytic adenovirus ONYX-411(NTR).

Conditionally replicating adenoviruses (CRAd) 'armed' with prodrug-activating genes have the potential to augment the efficacy of virotherapy. An Escherichia coli nitroreductase (NTR) gene (nfsB) was introduced into the E3B region of the systemically active CRAd ONYX-411, to produce ONYX-411(NTR), which had single agent oncolytic activity equivalent to unarmed virus in vitro and in vivo. A fluorogenic probe (SN 29884) developed to monitor NTR expression revealed robust, durable NTR expression in ONYX-411(NTR) infected neoplastic but not primary human cell lines. NTR expression occurred >24 h post-infection in parallel with fiber and was sensitive to ara-C indicating transcriptional linkage to viral replication. A novel NTR prodrug, the 3,5-dinitrobenzamide-2-bromomustard SN 27686, was shown to be more dose potent and selective than CB 1954 and provided a superior bystander effect in 3D multicellular layer cultures. Its water-soluble phosphate ester SN 28343 was substantially more active than CB 1954 against xenografts containing a minority of stable NTR-expressing cells. A single intravenous dose of ONYX-411(NTR) (10(8) PFU) to nude mice bearing large H1299 xenografts (>350 mm(3)) resulted in tumor-specific NTR expression which increased over time. Despite extensive viral spread by day 14, this conservative virus dose and schedule was unable to control such well-established tumors. However, subsequent administration of SN 28343 resulted in the majority of mice (62.5%) being tumor-free on day 120.

Cytotoxicity of the bioreductive agent RH1 and its lack of interaction with radiation.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: RH1 is a new bioreductive agent that was developed as a cytotoxic agent with selectivity for tumour cells expressing high levels of the enzyme DT-diaphorase (DTD). The aim of the present study was to investigate the cytotoxicity of RH1 in relation to cellular levels of reducing enzymes and any interaction of RH1 with ionizing radiation under oxic and hypoxic conditions. PATIENTS AND METHODS: The MB-MDA231 human breast cancer cell line (WT) and WT cells transfected with the NQO1 gene encoding DTD (the D7 cell line) were used to examine the dependency of RH1's cytotoxicity on cellular DTD activity. The role of the 1-electron reducing enzyme P450 reductase was also studied using a P450 reductase-transfected isogenic cell line (R4). A clonogenic assay was used to investigate the cytotoxicity of RH1 with and without irradiation in air and in nitrogen. In all cases drug exposure was for 3 h. RESULTS: DTD levels were around 300-fold higher in D7 compared to WT and R4 cells. RH1 was cytotoxic at nanomolar concentrations to all the cell lines, and was 2-3 times more toxic in the D7 cells with high DTD than in the other two cell lines. Doses of RH1 was around 2-fold more effective in hypoxic than in oxic WT cells, but not by as much in D7 cells. RH1 did not radiosensitise the cells but showed an additive effect when combined with irradiation under oxic and hypoxic conditions. CONCLUSIONS: RH1 shows high clonogenic cytotoxicity to MDA231 cells with high DTD activity but its selectivity based on the presence of DTD is much less than as shown in previous reports. RH1 showed an additive cell killing effect when combined with irradiation under both oxic and hypoxic conditions.

The importance of DT-diaphorase and hypoxia in the cytotoxicity of RH1 in human breast and non-small cell lung cancer cell lines.

The diaziridiny/benzoquinone RH1 is shortly to enter a phase I clinical trial. The drug was originally designed as a substrate for the enzyme DT-diaphorase (DTD) such that metabolic activation of the drug would lead to toxicity. To evaluate this, we have measured the toxicity of RH1 in a pair of non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) cell lines of widely differing levels of DTD and in MDA231 breast cancer cells which have been engineered to overexpress DTD. In addition, we have explored the importance of the putative one-electron reductase, P450 reductase, by assessing the toxicity of RH1 in MDA231 cells engineered to overexpress the enzyme. All drug exposures were carried out under hypoxic and aerobic conditions. Those cells with the highest levels of DTD, i.e. D7 versus MDA231 wt and H460 versus H596, are substantially more sensitive to RH1 than the cell lines expressing low DTD activity. Those cells with the lowest levels of DTD activity, i.e. MDA231 wt, R4 and H596, show much greater sensitivity to RH1 under hypoxic conditions compared to aerobic conditions. Finally, overexpression of P450 reductase, i.e. comparing MDA231 wt with R4, has little, if any, impact on the toxicity of RH1 under hypoxic or aerobic conditions. In summary, RH1 can be effective in killing cells containing high levels of DTD and may be useful in treating tumors expressing this enzyme.

2-Amino metabolites are key mediators of CB 1954 and SN 23862 bystander effects in nitroreductase GDEPT.

An important feature of gene-directed enzyme-prodrug therapy is that prodrug activation can provide diffusible cytotoxic metabolites capable of generating a local bystander effect in tumours. Activation of the aziridinyl dinitrobenzamide CB 1954 by E. coli nitroreductase (NTR) provides a bystander effect assumed to be due to the potently cytotoxic 4-hydroxylamine metabolite. We show that there are four cytotoxic extracellular metabolites of CB 1954 in cultures of NTR-expressing tumour cells (the 2- and 4-hydroxylamines and their corresponding amines). The 4-hydroxylamine is the most cytotoxic in DNA crosslink repair defective cells, but the 2-amino derivative (CB 10-236) is of similar potency to the 4-hydroxylamine in human tumour cell lines. Importantly, CB 10-236 has much superior diffusion properties to the 4-hydroxylamine in multicellular layers grown from the SiHa human cervical carcinoma cell line. These results suggest that the 2-amine, not the 4-hydroxylamine, is the major bystander metabolite when CB 1954 is activated by NTR in tumours. The corresponding dinitrobenzamide nitrogen mustard SN 23862 is reduced by NTR to form a single extracellular metabolite (also the 2-amine), which has superior cytotoxic potency and diffusion properties to the CB 1954 metabolites. These results are consistent with the reported high bystander efficiency of SN 23862 as an NTR prodrug in multicellular layers and tumour xenografts.

Novel chimeric gene promoters responsive to hypoxia and ionizing radiation.

Despite being an adverse prognostic factor in radiotherapy, hypoxia represents a physiological difference that can be exploited for selective cancer gene therapy. In this study gene therapy vectors responsive to both hypoxia and ionizing radiation (IR) were developed. Gene expression was regulated by novel, synthetic promoters containing hypoxia responsive elements (HREs) from the erythropoietin (Epo), the phosphoglycerate kinase 1 (PGK1) and the vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) genes, and IR-responsive CArG elements from the early growth response (Egr) 1 gene. All chimeric promoters could be activated by hypoxia and/or IR-treatment, and selectively control marker gene expression in human T24 bladder carcinoma and MCF-7 mammary carcinoma cells. Importantly, enhancers containing combinations of HREs and CArG elements were able to respond to both triggering treatments, with the Epo HRE/CArG combination proving to be the most responsive and robust. The Epo HRE/CArG enhancer could effectively control a suicide gene therapy strategy by selectively sensitizing hypoxic and/or irradiated cells expressing the enzyme horseradish peroxidase (HRP) to the prodrug indole-3-acetic acid (IAA). These data indicate that the use of such chimeric promoters may effectively regulate therapeutic gene expression within the tumor microenvironment in gene therapy strategies aimed at addressing the problem of hypoxia in radiotherapy.

Oxygen-sensitive enzyme-prodrug gene therapy for the eradication of radiation-resistant solid tumours.

Overwhelming clinical and experimental data demonstrate that tumour hypoxia is associated with aggressive disease and poor treatment outcome as hypoxic cells are refractive to radiotherapy and some forms of chemotherapy. However, hypoxia is rare in physiologically normal tissues representing a tumour-specific condition. To selectively target this therapeutically refractive cell population, we have combined bioreductive chemotherapy with hypoxia-directed gene therapy. We have transfected the human fibrosarcoma cell line, HT1080, with a hypoxia-regulated expression vector encoding the human flavoprotein cytochrome c P450 reductase (HRE-P450R). This conferred hypoxia-dependent sensitivity to the alkylating nitroimidazole prodrug RSU1069 in vitro, with a greater than 30-fold increase in oxic/hypoxic cytotoxicity ratio compared with controls. Xenografts of both the HRE-P450R and empty vector transfectants had comparable hypoxic fractions and were refractive to single dose radiotherapy of up to 15 Gy. However, combining a prodrug of RSU1069 with a reduced radiotherapy dose of 10 Gy represents a curative regimen (50% tumour-free survival; day 100) in the HRE-P450R xenografts. In complete contrast, 100% mortality was apparent by day 44 in the empty vector control xenografts treated in the same way. Thus, an oxygen-sensitive gene-directed enzyme prodrug therapy approach may have utility when incorporated into conventional radiotherapy and/or chemotherapy protocols for loco-regional disease in any tissue where hypoxia is a contra-indication to treatment success. doi:10.1038/sj.gt.3301702

Induction of thymidine phosphorylase as a pharmacodynamic end-point in patients with advanced carcinoma treated with 5-fluorouracil, folinic acid and interferon alpha.

Thymidine phosphorylase (TP) is an essential enzyme for the biochemical activation of 5-fluorouracil (5-FU). Interferon upregulates TP in vivo, although the dose and schedule of interferon for optimal biomodulation of 5-FU is not known. In this study, TP activity was measured in peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBLs) from patients with advanced carcinoma receiving treatment with 5-FU and folinic acid. Cohorts of patients were treated with interferon alpha (IFNalpha), immediately prior to 5-FU/folinic acid, at doses of 3 MIU m(-2), 9 MIU m(-2) and 18 MIUm(-2). IFNalpha was administered on day 0 cycle two, day-1 and day 0 cycle three and day-2, day-1 and day 0 cycle four. A fourth cohort was treated with IFNalpha 9 MIU m(-2) three times per week from cycle 2 onwards. Twenty-one patients were entered into the study with 19 evaluable for response. Six patients (32%) had stable disease and 13 (68%) progressive disease. There were no grade-IV toxicities. TP activity was detected in PBLs from all patients with wide interpatient variability in constitutive TP activity prior to chemotherapy, and in response to IFNalpha. 5-FU/folinic acid alone did not induce TP activity but a single dose of IFNalpha led to upregulation of TP within 2 h of administration with a further increase by 24 h (signed rank test, P = 0.006). TP activity remained elevated for at least 13 days (signed rank test, P= 0.02). There were no significant differences in TP activity between schedules or with additional doses of IFNalpha. A single dose of IFNalpha as low as 3 MIU m(-2) can cause sustained elevation of PBL TP activity in vivo indicating that biochemical markers are important pharmacodynamic endpoints for developing optimal schedules of IFNalpha for biomodulation of 5-FU.

NADPH:cytochrome c (P450) reductase activates tirapazamine (SR4233) to restore hypoxic and oxic cytotoxicity in an aerobic resistant derivative of the A549 lung cancer cell line.

Tirapazamine (TPZ, SR4233, WIN 59075) is a bioreductive drug that is activated in regions of low oxygen tension to a cytotoxic radical intermediate. This labile metabolite shows high selective toxicity towards hypoxic cells, such as those found in solid tumours. Under aerobic conditions, redox cycling occurs with subsequent generation of superoxide radicals, which are also cytotoxic. NADPH:cytochrome c (P450) reductase (P450R) is a one-electron reducing enzyme that efficiently activates TPZ. Recently a derivative of the A549 non-small cell lung cancer cell line (A549c50) was generated that showed substantially reduced P450R activity compared to its parental line (Elwell et al (1997) Biochem Pharmacol 54: 249-257). Here, it is demonstrated that the A549c50 cells are markedly more resistant to TPZ under both aerobic and hypoxic conditions. In addition, these cells have a dramatically impaired ability to metabolize TPZ to its two-electron reduction product, SR4317, under hypoxic conditions when compared to wild-type cells. P450R activity in the A549c50 cells was reintroduced to similar levels as that seen in the parental A549 cells by transfection of the full-length cDNA for human P450R. These P450R over-expressing cells exhibit restored sensitivity to TPZ under both aerobic and hypoxic conditions, comparable to that found in the original parental A549 cells. Further, the ability of the transfected cells to metabolize TPZ to SR4317 under hypoxic conditions is also shown to be restored. This provides further evidence that P450R can play an important role in the activation, metabolism and toxicity of this lead bioreductive drug.

The relative importance of NADPH: cytochrome c (P450) reductase for determining the sensitivity of human tumour cells to the indolequinone EO9 and related analogues lacking functionality at the C-2 and C-3 positions.

Analogues of EO9 (3-hydroxymethyl-5-aziridinyl-1-methyl-2[1H-indole-4-7-dione]prop-2-e n-1-ol) which lack functionality at either the C-2 or C-3 position were synthesised. The aim was to establish the importance of each group towards toxicity and to give an indication as to whether substitution at either position altered activation and toxicity after metabolism by cellular NADPH: cytochrome c (P450) reductase (P450R). MDA231 breast cancer cells were transfected with the cDNA for human P450R and stable clones were isolated. These high P450R-expressing clones were used to determine the aerobic and hypoxic toxicity of EO9 and the two analogues that lacked functionality at either C-2 or C-3. The results showed that P450R was strongly implicated in the bioactivation of EO9 and its analogues under both of these conditions. This data also showed that the C-3 functionality was primarily implicated in hypoxic toxicity.

Does reductive metabolism predict response to tirapazamine (SR 4233) in human non-small-cell lung cancer cell lines?

The bioreductive drug tirapazamine (TPZ, SR 4233, WIN 59075) is a lead compound in a series of potent cytotoxins that selectively kill hypoxic rodent and human solid tumour cells in vitro and in vivo. Phases II and III trials have demonstrated its efficacy in combination with both fractionated radiotherapy and some chemotherapy. We have evaluated the generality of an enzyme-directed approach to TPZ toxicity by examining the importance of the one-electron reducing enzyme NADPH:cytochrome P450 reductase (P450R) in the metabolism and toxicity of this lead prodrug in a panel of seven human non-small-cell lung cancer cell lines. We relate our findings on TPZ sensitivity in these lung lines with our previously published results on TPZ sensitivity in six human breast cancer cell lines (Patterson et al (1995) Br J Cancer 72: 1144-1150) and with the sensitivity of all these cell types to eight unrelated cancer chemotherapeutic agents with diverse modes of action. Our results demonstrate that P450R plays a significant role in the activation of TPZ in this panel of lung lines, which is consistent with previous observations in a panel of breast cancer cell lines (Patterson et al (1995) Br J Cancer 72: 1144-1150; Patterson et al (1997) Br J Cancer 76: 1338-1347). However, in the lung lines it is likely that it is the inherent ability of these cells to respond to multiple forms of DNA damage, including that arising from P450R-dependent TPZ metabolism, that underlies the ultimate expression of toxicity.

Enzymology of tirapazamine metabolism: a review.

The enzymology of triapazamine (TPZ, SR 4233, WIN 59075, 3-amino-1,2,4-benzotriazene 1,4-dioxide, Tirazone) has been extensively studied in rodents and to a lesser extent in human systems. While it is clear that the initial reductive step in TPZ activation is enzyme-mediated, there is limited consensus in the published literature as to the relative contributions of the cellular reductases involved. Moreover, not only is the importance of subcellular localization for these putative activating reductase(s) far from clear, but their activity profiles in vivo are poorly defined. The same might also be said of the potential detoxifying enzymes. This review will attempt to establish what common ground exists regarding the enzymology of TPZ metabolism, and will relate the available evidence to the enzyme profiles found in human cell lines in vitro, as well as in xenograft models and human solid tumours.

Thymidine phosphorylase moderates thymidine-dependent rescue after exposure to the thymidylate synthase inhibitor ZD1694 (Tomudex) in vitro.

The inhibition of de novo thymidine (dThd) synthesis by the novel folate-based thymidylate synthase (TS) inhibitor ZD1694 (Tomudex) can achieve tumor cell-specific cytotoxicity in vivo. However, nucleosides in the surrounding microenvironment of tumors may be used by the salvage pathway to regenerate any depleted pools, thus providing an efficient mechanism through which to circumvent the ZD1694-dependent toxicity. Anabolism of dThd to dTMP by dThd kinase (TK) is the first committed step in the dThd salvage pathway. However, dThd phosphorylase (dThdPase) can compete with TK by catalyzing the reversible phosphorolytic cleavage of dThd to thymine and deoxyribose 1-phosphate and rendering the salvaged dThd metabolically unavailable. Both TK and dThdPase are up-regulated in some tumors, and their relative importance is not fully defined. We have studied the influence of dThdPase expression on the capacity of exogenous dThd to reverse ZD1694-dependent growth inhibition and have shown that both intra- and extracellular dThdPase activity can effectively moderate dThd-rescue. This suggests that tumor levels of dThdPase may be an important factor in the outcome of ZD1694 therapy.

Targeting gene expression to hypoxic tumor cells.

Solid tumors with areas of low oxygen tension (hypoxia) have a poor prognosis, as cells in this environment often survive radiation and chemotherapy. In this report we describe how this hypoxic environment can be used to activate heterologous gene expression driven by a hypoxia-responsive element (HRE), which interacts with the transcriptional complex hypoxia-inducible factor-1 (HIF-1). Our results demonstrate that the HIF-1/HRE system of gene regulation is active in hypoxic tumor cells and show the potential of exploiting tumor-specific conditions for the targeted expression of diagnostic or therapeutic genes in cancer therapy.

Overexpression of human NADPH:cytochrome c (P450) reductase confers enhanced sensitivity to both tirapazamine (SR 4233) and RSU 1069.

P450 reductase (NADPH: cytochrome c (P450) reductase, EC 1.6.2.4) plays an important role in the reductive activation of the bioreductive drug tirapazamine (SR4233). Thus, in a panel of human breast cancer cell lines, expression of P450 reductase correlated with both the hypoxic toxicity and the metabolism of tirapazamine [Patterson et al (1995) Br J Cancer 72: 1144-1150]. To examine this dependence in more detail, the MDA231 cell line, which has the lowest activity of P450 reductase in our breast cell line panel, was transfected with the human P450 reductase cDNA. Isolated clones expressed a 78-kDa protein, which was detected with anti-P450 reductase antibody, and were shown to have up to a 53-fold increase in activity of the enzyme. Using six stable transfected clones covering the 53-fold range of activity of P450 reductase, it was shown that the enzyme activity correlated directly with both hypoxic and aerobic toxicity of tirapazamine, and metabolism of the drug under hypoxic conditions. No metabolism was detected under aerobic conditions. For RSU1069, toxicity was also correlated with P450 reductase activity, but only under hypoxic conditions. Measurable activity of P450 reductase was found in a selection of 14 primary human breast tumours. Activity covered an 18-fold range, which was generally higher than that seen in cell lines but within the range of activity measured in the transfected clones. These results suggest that if breast tumours have significant areas of low oxygen tension, then they are likely to be highly sensitive to the cytotoxic action of tirapazamine and RSU 1069.

Importance of P450 reductase activity in determining sensitivity of breast tumour cells to the bioreductive drug, tirapazamine (SR 4233).

P450 reductase (NADPH:cytochrome P450 reductase, EC 1.6.2.4) is known to be important in the reductive activation of the benzotriazene-di-N-oxide tirapazamine (SR 4233). Using a panel of six human breast adenocarcinoma cell lines we have examined the relationship between P450 reductase activity and sensitivity to tirapazamine. The toxicity of tirapazamine was found to correlate strongly with P450 reductase activity following an acute (3 h) exposure under hypoxic conditions, the drug being most toxic in the cell lines with the highest P450 reductase activity. A similar correlation was also observed following a chronic (96 h) exposure to the drug in air but not following acute (3 h) exposure in air. We have also determined the ability of lysates prepared from the cell lines to metabolise tirapazamine to its two-electron reduced product, SR 4317, under hypoxic conditions using NADPH as an electron donor. The rate of SR 4317 formation was found to correlate both with P450 reductase activity and with sensitivity to tirapazamine, the highest rates of SR 4317 formation being associated with the highest levels of P450 reductase activity and the greatest sensitivity to the drug. These findings indicate a major role for P450 reductase in determining the hypoxic toxicity of tirapazamine in breast tumour cell lines.