Local recurrence after breast-conserving surgery and radiotherapy. Frequency, time course, and prognosis.

Mammary recurrences were studied in 1593 patients with Stage I and II breast cancer treated by macroscopically complete tumor excision followed by megavoltage radiotherapy, including a boost to the tumor bed (mean dose, 78 Gy). The actuarial freedom from mammary recurrence was 93% at 5, 86% at 10, 82% at 15, and 80% at 20 years. Seventy-nine percent of the recurrences were in the vicinity of the tumor bed, but with increasing time interval, an increasing percentage of recurrences was located elsewhere in the breast. A majority of recurrences after 10 years could be considered new tumors. Only ten of 181 patients with recurrence had prior or concomitant distant metastases, and 159 of 171 isolated mammary recurrences (93%) were operable. Uncorrected overall survival after operable recurrence was 69% at 5 and 57% at 10 years. Prognosis after late recurrence (after 5 years) was favorable (84% 5-year survival). Operable early recurrences retained a favorable prognosis if smaller than 2 cm and confined to the breast (74% 5-year survival). Disease-free interval and histologic grade also appeared to be important prognostic factors after early recurrence. Survival after recurrence did not depend upon the type of salvage operation. Locoregional control was 88% at 5 years after salvage mastectomy and 64% after breast-conserving salvage procedures. The role of adjuvant systemic therapy at time of local recurrence requires additional study. This experience illustrates the important differences between mammary failure and chest wall recurrence after mastectomy, in particular the protracted time course and more favorable prognosis associated with the former.

[Breast cancer: prognostic factors. Apropos of 1000 conservative treatments]. / Cancer du sein: facteurs pronostiques. A propos de 1000 traitements conservateurs.

Prognosis was analyzed as a function of histologic grade, axillary gland spread and hormonal receptors in a consecutive series of 1000 patients with breast cancer (stages I and II) treated by conservative tumorectomy and axillary curettage, combined with radiotherapy, and followed up for between 3 and 12 years. The three factors analyzed are of major importance in that they constituted a veritable tumoral identity card. Grade I tumors, the absence of glandular spread and the presence of hormonal receptors are correlated with cancer of good prognosis, whereas grade III tumors, major axillary spread and absence of hormonal receptors are related to a poor prognosis. Their interactions are studied by comparing associations of good and poor prognostic factors, allowing determination of populations at low and high risk of therapeutic failure.