A bird´s-eye view of chromosomes during meiotic prophase I / Una vista panorámica de los cromosomas en la profase I de la meiosis

ABSTRACT The present review aims to summarize the research carried out in relation to meiosis in birds, especially by observing the protein axes of the chromosomes in prophase I of meiosis. This line of research, initially developed in Argentina, has provided key data in the study of the evolution of sex chromosomes and the mechanisms involved in the frequency and distribution of crossing over in birds, among other topics. Some of these contributions, in addition to those made by other authors, are described also providing the general theoretical framework or the hypotheses that support them.

RESUMEN La presente revisión tiene por objetivo resumir las investigaciones realizadas en relación a la meiosis de las aves, especialmente mediante la observación de los ejes proteicos de los cromosomas en la profase I de la meiosis. Esta línea de investigación, desarrollada inicialmente en Argentina, ha aportado datos clave dentro del estudio de la evolución de los cromosomas sexuales y los mecanismos involucrados en la frecuencia y distribución del crossing over en las aves, entre otros temas. Algunas de estas contribuciones, además de las realizadas por otros autores, se describen proporcionando también el marco teórico general o las hipótesis que las sustentan.

Meiotic recombination analysis in female ducks (Anas platyrhynchos).

Meiotic recombination in female ducks was directly studied by immunolocalization of MLH1 protein, a mismatch repair protein of mature recombination nodules. In total, 6820 crossovers were scored along the autosomal synaptonemal complexes in 122 meiotic nuclei. From this analysis we predict that the female map length of the duck is 2845 cM, with a genome wide recombination rate of 2 cM/Mb. MLH1-focus mapping along the six largest bivalents shows regional variations of recombination frequencies that can be linked to differences in chromosome morphology. From this MLH1 mapping it can be inferred that distally located markers will appear more separated in genetic maps than physically equidistant markers located near the centromeres on bivalents 1 and 2. Instead, markers at interstitial positions on the acrocentric bivalents 3-6 will appear more tightly linked than expected on the basis of their physical distance because recombination is comparatively lower at the mid region of these chromosomes. The present results provide useful information to complement linkage mapping in ducks and extend previous knowledge about the variation of recombination rates among domestic Galloanserae.

Chromosomal axis formation and meiotic progression in chicken oocytes: a quantitative analysis.

The assembly and disassembly of the synaptonemal complexes (SCs) correlate with the progression of meiotic prophase I. Using immunostaining of the cohesin component SMC3, which is present in the axial elements of the SC, we characterized the synaptic process in chicken oocytes and quantified the frequency of the different prophase stages at hatching and at 3 different ages after hatching. The analysis provides detailed quantitative data regarding the meiotic stages in the chicken ovary showing that the maximum amount of pachytene oocytes is found around hatching and that oocytes reach the diplotene stage 5 days after entering into meiosis. We confirmed the asynchrony of the meiotic development in the female chicken gonad showing that the ovary has a composite population of cells at different stages from day 17 before hatching and for several days after hatching. The significance of these results is discussed in relationship to functional experimental procedures that involve avian oocytes.

Sex chromosome evolution in cotton stainers of the genus Dysdercus (Heteroptera: Pyrrhocoridae).

The neo-X and neo-Y sex chromosomes of Dysdercus albofasciatus represent a unique model for the study of early stages of sex chromosome evolution since they retained the ability to pair and recombine, in contrast to sex chromosomes in most Heteroptera. Here we examined structure, molecular differentiation, and meiotic behaviour of the D. albofasciatus neo-sex chromosomes. Two related species with the ancestral X0 system, D. chaquensis and D. ruficollis, were used for a comparison. In D. albofasciatus, 2 nucleolar organizer regions (NORs) were identified on the neo-X chromosome using fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) with an rDNA probe, whereas a single NOR was found on an autosomal pair in the other 2 species. Genomic in situ hybridization (GISH) differentiated a part of the original X in the neo-X chromosome but not the neo-Y chromosome. The same segment of the neo-X chromosome was identified by Zoo-FISH with a chromosome painting probe derived from the X chromosome of D. ruficollis, indicating that this part is conserved between the species. Immunostaining against the cohesin subunit SMC3 revealed that only terminal regions of the D. albofasciatus neo-Xneo-Y bivalent pair and form a synaptonemal complex, which is in keeping with the occurrence of terminal chiasmata, whereas the interstitial region forms a large loop indicating the absence of homology. These results support the hypothesis that the neo-X chromosome evolved by insertion of the original X chromosome into 1 NOR-bearing autosome in an ancestor carrying the X0 system. As a consequence, the homologue of this NOR-autosome became the neo-Y chromosome. A subsequent inversion followed by transposition of the NOR located on the neo-Y onto the neo-X chromosome resulted in the present neo-sex chromosome system in D. albofasciatus.

Localization of single-copy sequences on chicken synaptonemal complex spreads using fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH).

Synaptonemal complex (SC) spreads from bird oocytes and spermatocytes show the complete chromosome complement and can be observed at the light microscope using immunostaining of the proteins that compose the lateral elements. To investigate the use of avian SC spreads as substrates for fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) in combination with immunostaining, we applied two single-copy sequences to chicken oocyte spreads. Signals for both target sequences were consistently observed on the short arm of bivalent 1 in a large number of nuclei. Based on previous data about the size of chromosome 1 and from measurements on probed SC spreads, an estimate of the physical distance in Mb between each sequence and the telomere was calculated. The crossover frequencies along SC 1 obtained by immunolocalization of MLH1 foci during pachytene were used to calculate the distances in cM to the target sequences and to compare this cytogenetic SC map with the consensus linkage map for GGA1. The combination of SC-FISH and immunostaining could be generally applied to obtain high-resolution mapping of single-copy sequences in birds and, coupled with MLH1 crossover maps, it could be a reliable approach to obtain genetic distances between markers to test the genetic linkage maps generated from molecular markers.

MLH1-focus mapping in birds shows equal recombination between sexes and diversity of crossover patterns.

Using immunolocalization of the mismatch-repair protein MLH1 in oocytes and spermatocytes of the Japanese quail and the zebra finch, we estimated the average amount of recombination in each sex of both species. In each case the number of MLH1 foci is statistically equivalent in males and females and the resulting sex-averaged map lengths are 2800 cM in the Japanese quail and 2275 cM in the zebra finch. In the Japanese quail the MLH1 foci are regularly distributed along the macrobivalents and recombination rates per Mb pair are somewhat lower compared to the chicken. In the zebra finch the MLH1 foci on the macrobivalents are substantially reduced in number relative to the Japanese quail and they show remarkable localization in both sexes. It is proposed that the lack of sex-dependent differences in recombination might be an extended feature among birds and that the different recombination patterns observed here reflect different controls of crossing over in spite of similarities regarding karyotypic asymmetry and DNA content. We discussed possible causes of the differences between birds and mammals, which show sex-dependent recombination differences.

An azoospermic man with a double-strand DNA break-processing deficiency in the spermatocyte nuclei: case report.

BACKGROUND: The mechanisms of meiotic arrest in human spermatogenesis are poorly known. METHODS AND RESULTS: A testicular biopsy from an azoospermic male showed complete spermatogenesis arrest at the spermatocyte stage, asynapsis, lack of formation of the XY body, partial reversion to a mitotic-like division and cell degeneration both at the prophase and at the abnormal cell divisions. Synaptonemal complex analysis showed minor segments of synapsis and mainly single axes. Fluorescent immunolocalization of meiotic proteins showed normal SYCP3, scarcity of SYCP1, null MLH1 foci, about 10 patches of gamma-H2AX, abnormal presence of BRCA1 among autosomal axes, absence of RAD51 in early and advanced spermatocytes and permanence of gamma-H2AX labelling up to the abnormal spermatocyte divisions that are the most advanced stage reached. There are at least six dominions of evenly packed chromatin resembling that of the normal XY body, but no true XY body. CONCLUSIONS: The protein phenotype and the fine structure of the nuclei are compatible with a deficiency of the processing of double-strand DNA breaks in the zygotene-like spermatocytes, but the features of this defect do not agree with Spo11, Sycp1, Atm and Dmc1 null mutations, which give absence of XY body, synapsis disturbances and spermatocyte apoptosis in mice.

Chromosomal localization of the telomeric (TTAGGG)n sequence in four species of Armadillo (Dasypodidae) from Argentina: an approach to explaining karyotype evolution in the Xenarthra.

The distribution of the vertebrate telomeric sequence (TTAGGG)(n) in four species of armadillos (Dasypodidae, Xenarthra), i.e. Chaetophractus villosus (2n = 60), Chaetophractus vellerosus (2n = 62), Dasypus hybridus (2n = 64) and Zaedyus pichiy (2n = 62) was examined by FISH with a peptide nucleic acid (PNA) probe. Besides the expected telomeric hybridization, interstitial (centromeric) locations of the (TTAGGG)n sequence were observed in one chromosome pair of Chaetophractus vellerosus and Zaedyus pichiy, suggesting chromosome fusion of ancestral chromosomes occurring during the evolution of Dasypodidae. In addition, all the species analysed showed one to four apparently telocentric chromosomes, exhibiting only two telomeric signals. However, the immunodetection study of kinetochore proteins on synaptonemal complex spreads from C. villosus showed that the apparently telocentric chromosomes have a tiny short arm that can be resolved only in the more elongated pachytene bivalents. This finding suggests that none of the species of armadillos possess true telocentric chromosomes. Our present results support a reduction in the diploid number by fusion of acrocentrics with loss of chromosome material as a tendency in Dasypodidae.

The germ-line-restricted chromosome in the zebra finch: recombination in females and elimination in males.

In the zebra finch (Taeniopygia guttata), there is a germ-line-restricted chromosome regularly present in males and females. A reexamination of male and female meiosis in the zebra finch showed that this element forms a euchromatic bivalent in oocytes, but it is always a single, heterochromatic element in spermatocytes. Immunostaining with anti-MLH1 showed that the bivalent in oocytes has two or three foci with a localized pattern, indicating the regular occurrence of recombination. In male meiosis, the single restricted chromosome forms an axis that contains the cohesin subunit SMC3, and the associated chromatin is densely packed until late pachytene. Electron microscopy of thin-sectioned seminiferous tubules shows that the restricted chromosome is eliminated in postmeiotic stages in the form of packed chromatin inside a micronucleus, visible in the cytoplasm of young spermatids. The selective condensation of the restricted chromosome during early meiotic prophase in males is interpreted as a strategy to avoid the triggering of asynaptic checkpoints, but this condensation is reversed prior to the final condensation that leads to its (ulterior) elimination. Recombination during female meiosis may prevent the genetic attrition of the restricted chromosome and, along with the elimination in male germ cells, ensures its regular transmission through females.

Changes in crossover distribution along a quadrivalent in a man carrier of a reciprocal translocation t(11;14).

A testicular biopsy from an infertile man carrying a heterozygous chromosome translocation t(11;14) was studied with synaptonemal complex analysis and immunolocalization of the protein MLH1 for crossover detection. A full blockage of spermatogenesis at the spermatocyte stage was related to the presence of the translocation quadrivalents at pachytene. Only 2% of the quadrivalents showed full synapsis. Most of the spermatocytes showed asynaptic free ends that frequently mingled with the XY pair. The average number of crossovers per cell was diminished from a mean of 52.7 in controls to a mean of 48 in the patient. The difference between the number of crossovers in the quadrivalent and the normal bivalents was highly significant. The distribution of crossovers over the segment of the quadrivalent corresponding to bivalent #14 was also very different from that of the control. It is concluded that in this translocation, the pattern of crossovers is changed, mainly due to a synaptic hindrance in the quadrivalent, and that the spermatogenesis arrest is mainly due to the quadrivalents that interact with the XY pair.

Changes in crossover distribution along a quadrivalent in aman carrier of a reciprocal translocation t(11; 14)

A testicu1ar biopsy from an infertile man carrying a heterozygous chromosome translocation t(ll; 14) was studied with synaptonemal complex analysis and immunolocalization of the protein MLH 1 for crossover detection. A full blockage of spermatogenesis at the spermatocyte stage was related to the presence of the translocation quadrivalents at pachytene. Only 2% of the quadrivalents showed full synapsis. Most of the spermatocytes showed asynaptic free ends that frequently mingled with the XY pair. The average number of crossovers per cell was diminished from a mean of 52.7 in controls to a mean of 48 in the patient. The difference between the number of crossovers in the quadrivalent and the normal bivalents was highly significant. The distribution of crossovers over the segment of the quadrivalent corresponding to bivalent #14 was also very different from that ofthe control. It is concluded that in this translocation, the pattern of crossovers is changed, mainly due to a synaptic hindrance in the quadrivalent, and that the spermatogenesis arrest is mainly due to the quadrivalents that interact with the XY pair

Changes in crossover distribution along a quadrivalent in aman carrier of a reciprocal translocation t(11; 14)

A testicu1ar biopsy from an infertile man carrying a heterozygous chromosome translocation t(ll; 14) was studied with synaptonemal complex analysis and immunolocalization of the protein MLH 1 for crossover detection. A full blockage of spermatogenesis at the spermatocyte stage was related to the presence of the translocation quadrivalents at pachytene. Only 2% of the quadrivalents showed full synapsis. Most of the spermatocytes showed asynaptic free ends that frequently mingled with the XY pair. The average number of crossovers per cell was diminished from a mean of 52.7 in controls to a mean of 48 in the patient. The difference between the number of crossovers in the quadrivalent and the normal bivalents was highly significant. The distribution of crossovers over the segment of the quadrivalent corresponding to bivalent #14 was also very different from that ofthe control. It is concluded that in this translocation, the pattern of crossovers is changed, mainly due to a synaptic hindrance in the quadrivalent, and that the spermatogenesis arrest is mainly due to the quadrivalents that interact with the XY pair

Meiotic recombination in the ZW pair of a tinamid bird shows a differential pattern compared with neognaths.

The tinamid bird Nothura maculosa, along with other species of the order Tinamiformes and all of the existent ratites, form the infraclass Paleognathae, the most primitive living birds. Previous work has shown that in all studied Neognathae, the ZW pair shows strictly localized recombination in a very short pseudoautosomal region, while in paleognath birds, the ZW pairs have mostly free recombination. The present observations show that the ZW pair of N. maculosa has a recombination pattern departing from both neognaths and other Paleognath birds, as there is a single crossover but occurring at random points along a significant part of the long arm of the W chromosome. This recombination pattern agrees with the presence of intercalary and terminal heterochromatin in the W chromosome, suggesting an exceptional, additional step of recombination suppression.

Changes in crossover distribution along a quadrivalent in a man carrier of a reciprocal translocation t(11;14).

A testicular biopsy from an infertile man carrying a heterozygous chromosome translocation t(11;14) was studied with synaptonemal complex analysis and immunolocalization of the protein MLH1 for crossover detection. A full blockage of spermatogenesis at the spermatocyte stage was related to the presence of the translocation quadrivalents at pachytene. Only 2

of the quadrivalents showed full synapsis. Most of the spermatocytes showed asynaptic free ends that frequently mingled with the XY pair. The average number of crossovers per cell was diminished from a mean of 52.7 in controls to a mean of 48 in the patient. The difference between the number of crossovers in the quadrivalent and the normal bivalents was highly significant. The distribution of crossovers over the segment of the quadrivalent corresponding to bivalent #14 was also very different from that of the control. It is concluded that in this translocation, the pattern of crossovers is changed, mainly due to a synaptic hindrance in the quadrivalent, and that the spermatogenesis arrest is mainly due to the quadrivalents that interact with the XY pair.

Differential immunolocalization of a putative Rec8p in meiotic autosomes and sex chromosomes of triatomine bugs.

Hemipteran chromosomes are holocentric and show regular, special behavior at meiosis. While the autosomes pair at pachytene, have synaptonemal complexes (SCs) and recombination nodules (RNs) and segregate at anaphase I, the sex chromosomes do not form an SC or RNs, divide equationally at anaphase I, and their chromatids segregate at anaphase II. Here we show that this behavior is shared by the X and Y chromosomes of Triatoma infestans and the X(1)X(2)Y chromosomes of Triatoma pallidipennis. As Rec8p is a widely occurring component of meiotic cohesin, involved in meiotic homolog segregation, we used an antibody against Rec8p of Caenorhabditis elegans for immunolocalization in these triatomines. We show that while Rec8p is colocalized with SCs in the autosomes, no Rec8p can be found by immunolabeling in the sex chromosomes at any stage of meiosis. Furthermore, Rec8p labeling is lost from autosomal bivalents prior to metaphase I. In both triatomine species the sex chromosomes conjoin with each other during prophase I, and lack any SC, but they form "fuzzy cores", which are observed with silver staining and with light and electron microscopy during pachytene. Thin, serial sectioning and electron microscopy of spermatocytes at metaphases I and II reveals differential behavior of the sex chromosomes. At metaphase I the sex chromosomes form separate entities, each surrounded by a membranous sheath. On the other hand, at metaphase II the sex chromatids are closely tied and surrounded by a shared membranous sheath. The peculiar features of meiosis in these hemipterans suggest that they depart from the standard meiotic mechanisms proposed for other organisms.

Meiotic recombination and spermatogenic impairment in Mus musculus domesticus carrying multiple simple Robertsonian translocations.

We quantitatively analyzed the spermatogenic process, including evaluation of seminiferous tubules with defective cycles, rates of germ cell death and sperm morphology, in adult male mice with standard telocentric chromosomes (2n = 40, CD1 strain), homozygous (2n = 24, Mil II population) and heterozygous (2n = 24 x 40) for Robertsonian (Rb) rearrangements. The animals were analyzed at three different ages: three, five and seven months after birth. The number and position of crossover events were also determined by chiasmata counting and immunostaining with an antibody against mouse MLH1 protein. Our analysis of spermatogenesis confirms the impairment of the spermatogenic process in multiple simple heterozygotes due to both germ cell and abnormal sperm morphology. The detrimental effects exerted by Rb heterozygosities were found to be at least partially buffered with time: the frequency of defective tubules was lower and germ cell survival and sperm morphology better in 7-month-old animals than in the 3- and 5-month-old mice. While there are previously published data on germ cell death in multiple simple heterozygotes, this is the first report of a partial rescue of spermatogenesis with time. The mean frequency of MLH1 foci was lower in Rb homozygous and heterozygous mice than in mice carrying all telocentric chromosomes. The lower number of foci in Rb mice can be ascribed to a decrease in the number of multiple chiasmata and the maintenance of single chiasmata preferentially located in the terminal region of both the telocentric and metacentric chromosomes.

Distribution of MLH1 foci on the synaptonemal complexes of chicken oocytes.

The frequency and distribution of the mismatch repair protein MLH1 was analyzed on synaptonemal complex spreads of chicken oocytes using indirect immunofluorescence. MLH1 foci appeared in late zygotene and their number remains constant throughout pachytene. The average number of foci on autosomal synaptonemal complexes (65.02 +/- 4.02) is in agreement with the number of chiasmata estimated from lampbrush chromosomes. The distribution of foci along the synaptonemal complexes is shown to be nonrandom and nonuniform in terms of the distances between them. It is concluded that MLH1 foci are good markers of crossing over in bird (chicken) meiocytes.

The ZW pairs of two paleognath birds from two orders show transitional stages of sex chromosome differentiation.

Pachytene oocytes from the two presumably most primitive orders (Paleognathae) among living birds were used to study the pairing behaviour and location of recombination nodules (RNs) in the sex pair. In the ratite Pterocnemia pennata (Rheiformes), the 42 analyzed ZW pairs show an average of 2.2 RNs distributed along 80% of the synaptonemal complex (SC) that covers the long arm of the acrocentric Z and W chromosomes in this homomorphic sex pair. In the tinamid Rynchotus rufescens (Tinamiformes), the 60 analyzed ZW pairs show an average of 1.35 RNs distributed along 66% of the SC covering most of the long arms of this visibly heteromorphic ZW pair. RNs are non-randomly distributed and show interference in both species, but in the tinamou they are restricted to a significantly smaller stretch. The discovery of an intermediate degree in the restriction of RN location, between the extremes of free recombination along most of the W in ratites and strict localization of a single RN in Neognath birds, suggests its relationship with the mechanism of sex chromosome differentiation among Aves.

Origin and evolution of the sex chromosomes in birds

A scheme is proposed to explain the process of sex chromosome differentiation in the class Aves. It is based on the restriction of recombination in an ancestral homomorphic ZW pair and the subsequent degeneration of the non-recombining region of the W chromosome leading to the highly heteromorphic sex chromosomes of carinate birds. The model presented here and Ohno's model of sex chromosome differentiation in Ophidia are the only integral models of sex chromosome evolution based on cytological evidences. The co-existence among living birds of mostly homomorphic (Ratites) and highly heteromorphic ZW pairs (carinates) provides a unique ground to study the mechanisms of sex chromosome differentiation in vertebrates