Insights into Nitrogenase Bioelectrocatalysis for Green Ammonia Production.

There is a growing interest in using ammonia as a liquid carrier of hydrogen for energy applications. Currently, ammonia is produced industrially by the Haber-Bosch process, which requires high temperature and high pressure. In contrast, bacteria have naturally evolved an enzyme known as nitrogenase, that is capable of producing ammonia and hydrogen at ambient temperature and pressure. Therefore, nitrogenases are attractive as a potentially more efficient means to produce ammonia via harnessing the unique properties of this enzyme. In recent years, exciting progress has been made in bioelectrocatalysis using nitrogenases to produce ammonia. Here, the prospects for developing biological ammonia production are outlined, key advances in bioelectrocatalysis by nitrogenases are highlighted, and possible solutions to the obstacles faced in realising this goal are discussed.

Engineering a solid-state metalloprotein hydrogen evolution catalyst.

Hydrogen has the potential to play an important role in decarbonising our energy systems. Crucial to achieving this is the ability to produce clean sources of hydrogen using renewable energy sources. Currently platinum is commonly used as a hydrogen evolution catalyst, however, the scarcity and expense of platinum is driving the need to develop non-platinum-based catalysts. Here we report a protein-based hydrogen evolution catalyst based on a recombinant silk protein from honeybees and a metal macrocycle, cobalt protoporphyrin (CoPPIX). We enhanced the hydrogen evolution activity three fold compared to the unmodified silk protein by varying the coordinating ligands to the metal centre. Finally, to demonstrate the use of our biological catalyst, we built a proton exchange membrane (PEM) water electrolysis cell using CoPPIX-silk as the hydrogen evolution catalyst that is able to produce hydrogen with a 98% Faradaic efficiency. This represents an exciting advance towards allowing protein-based catalysts to be used in electrolysis cells.

Enhancement of metallomacrocycle-based oxygen reduction catalysis through immobilization in a tunable silk-protein scaffold.

Fuel cells convert chemical energy into electrical current with the use of an oxidant such as oxygen and have the potential to reduce our reliance on fossil fuels. To overcome the slow kinetics of the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR), platinum is often used as the catalyst. However, the scarcity and expense of platinum limits the wide-spread use of fuel cells. In the search for non-platinum oxygen reduction catalysts, metallomacrocycles have attracted significant attention. While progress has been made in understanding how metallomacrocycle-based molecules can catalyze the ORR, their low stability, remains an on-going challenge. Here we report an immobilization strategy whereby hemin (iron protoporphyrin IX, heme b) is converted into an oxygen reduction catalyst which could be operated for over 96 h, with turnover numbers >107. This represents a 3 orders of magnitude improvement over the best reported iron porphyrin ORR catalyst to date. The basis for this improvement in turnover is specific binding of the heme within a recombinant silk protein, which allows for separation of the porphyrin active sites. Use of the silk protein provides a scaffold that can be engineered to improve selectivity and efficiency. Through rational design of the heme binding site, a > 95% selectivity for a four-electron reduction of oxygen to water was obtained, equal to the selectivity obtained using platinum-based catalysts. This work represents an important advance in the field, demonstrating that metallomacrocycle-based ORR catalysts are viable for use in fuel cells.

Biocompatibility and immunogenic response to recombinant honeybee silk material.

If tolerated in biological environments, recombinant structural proteins offer the advantage that biological cues dictating cell attachment and material degradation can be modified as required for clinical application using genetic engineering. In this study, we investigate the biological response to materials generated from the recombinant honeybee silk protein, AmelF3, a structural protein that can be produced at high levels by fermentation in Escherichia coli. The protein can be readily purified from E. coli host cell proteins after transgenic production and fabricated into various material formats. When implanted subcutaneously according to International Standard ISO 10993 tests, materials generated from the purified recombinant protein were found to be noncytotoxic, inducing a transient weak immunogenic response and a chronic inflammatory response that resolved over time. While preliminary, this study supports the ongoing development of materials generated from this protein for biomedical applications. © 2019 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Biomed Mater Res Part A: 107A: 1763-1770, 2019.

Did aculeate silk evolve as an antifouling material?

Many of the challenges we currently face as an advanced society have been solved in unique ways by biological systems. One such challenge is developing strategies to avoid microbial infection. Social aculeates (wasps, bees and ants) mitigate the risk of infection to their colonies using a wide range of adaptations and mechanisms. These adaptations and mechanisms are reliant on intricate social structures and are energetically costly for the colony. It seems likely that these species must have had alternative and simpler mechanisms in place to ensure the maintenance of hygienic domicile conditions prior to the evolution of these complex behaviours. Features of the aculeate coiled-coil silk proteins are reminiscent of those of naturally occurring α-helical antimicrobial peptides (AMPs). In this study, we demonstrate that peptides derived from the aculeate silk proteins have antimicrobial activity. We reconstruct the predicted ancestral silk sequences of an aculeate ancestor that pre-dates the evolution of sociality and demonstrate that these ancestral sequences also contained peptides with antimicrobial properties. It is possible that the silks evolved as an antifouling material and facilitated the evolution of sociality. These materials serve as model materials for consideration in future biomaterial development.

Confirmation of Bioinformatics Predictions of the Structural Domains in Honeybee Silk.

Honeybee larvae produce a silk made up of proteins in predominantly a coiled coil molecular structure. These proteins can be produced in recombinant systems, making them desirable templates for the design of advanced materials. However, the atomic level structure of these proteins is proving difficult to determine: firstly, because coiled coils are difficult to crystalize; and secondly, fibrous proteins crystalize as fibres rather than as discrete protein units. In this study, we synthesised peptides from the central structural domain, as well as the N- and C-terminal domains, of the honeybee silk. We used circular dichroism spectroscopy, infrared spectroscopy, and molecular dynamics to investigate the folding behaviour of the central domain peptides. We found that they folded as predicted by bioinformatics analysis, giving the protein engineer confidence in bioinformatics predictions to guide the design of new functionality into these protein templates. These results, along with the infrared structural analysis of the N- and C-terminal domain peptides and the comparison of peptide film properties with those of the full-length AmelF3 protein, provided significant insight into the structural elements required for honeybee silk protein to form into stable materials.

Rational design of new materials using recombinant structural proteins: Current state and future challenges.

Sequence-definable polymers are seen as a prerequisite for design of future materials, with many polymer scientists regarding such polymers as the holy grail of polymer science. Recombinant proteins are sequence-defined polymers. Proteins are dictated by DNA templates and therefore the sequence of amino acids in a protein is defined, and molecular biology provides tools that allow redesign of the DNA as required. Despite this advantage, proteins are underrepresented in materials science. In this publication we investigate the advantages and limitations of using proteins as templates for rational design of new materials.

Silk provides a new avenue for third generation biosensors: Sensitive, selective and stable electrochemical detection of nitric oxide.

Using heme entrapped in recombinant silk films, we have produced 3rd generation biosensors, which allow direct electron transfer from the heme center to an electrode avoiding the need for electron mediators. Here, we demonstrate the use of these heme-silk films for the detection of nitric oxide (NO) at nanomolar levels in the presence and absence of oxygen. The sensor was prepared by drop-casting a silk solution on a glassy carbon electrode modified with multiwalled carbon nanotubes (MWCNT) followed by infusion with heme. The sensor was characterized by cyclic voltammetry and showed well defined and reversible Fe+/ Fe3+ redox couple activity, with NO detection by oxidation at potentials above +0.45V or reduction at potentials below - 0.7V. Evaluation of the effect of pH on the sensor response to NO reduction indicated a maximum response at pH 3. The sensor showed good linearity in the concentration range from 19 to 190nM (R2 = 0.99) with a detection limit of 2nM. The sensor had excellent selectivity towards NO with no or negligible interference from oxygen, nitrite, nitrate, dopamine and ascorbic acid and retained 86% of response after 2 months of operation and storage at room temperature.

Design of silk proteins with increased heme binding capacity and fabrication of silk-heme materials.

In our previous studies, heme was bound into honeybee silk to generate materials that could function as nitric oxide sensors or as recoverable heterogeneous biocatalysts. In this study, we sought to increase the heme-binding capacity of the silk protein by firstly redesigning the heme binding site to contain histidine as the coordinating residue and secondly, by adding multiple histidine residues within the core of the coiled coil core region of the modified silk protein. We used detergent and a protein denaturant to confirm the importance of the helical structure of the silk for heme coordination. Aqueous methanol treatment, which was used to stabilize the materials, transformed the low-spin, six-coordinate heme to a five-coordinate high-spin complex, thus providing a vacant site for ligand binding. The optimal aqueous methanol treatment time that simultaneously maintains the helical protein structure and stabilizes the silk material without substantial leaching of heme from the system was determined.

Recombinant Structural Proteins and Their Use in Future Materials.

Recombinant proteins are polymers that offer the materials engineer absolute control over chain length and composition: key attributes required for design of advanced polymeric materials. Through this control, these polymers can be encoded to contain information that enables them to respond as the environment changes. However, despite their promise, protein-based materials are under-represented in materials science. In this chapter we investigate why this is and describe recent efforts to address this. We discuss constraints limiting rational design of structural proteins for advanced materials; advantages and disadvantages of different recombinant expression platforms; and, methods to fabricate proteins into solid-state materials. Finally, we describe the silk proteins used in our laboratory as templates for information-containing polymers.

Modification of Honeybee Silk by the Addition of Antimicrobial Agents.

Honeybee silk proteins can be produced at high levels in recombinant systems, fabricated into materials, and are tolerant of amino acid modifications: properties that make them exciting templates for designing new functional materials. Here, we explore the properties of materials either made from silk-antimicrobial peptide (AMP) fusion proteins or silk containing entrapped AMPs or silver nanoparticles. Inclusion of AMP within the silk protein sequence did not affect our ability to express the proteins or process them into films. When AMP-silk proteins and Escherichia coli cells were coincubated in solution, a reduction in cell numbers was observed after degradation of the chimeric protein to release a truncated version of the AMP. In films, the AMP was retained in the silk with leaching rates of <1% per day. Films containing silver nanoparticles were antimicrobial, with the silk preventing aggregation of nanoparticles and slowing the rate of dissolution of the particles.

Solid-State Metalloproteins-An Alternative to Immobilisation.

This commentary outlines a protein engineering approach as an alternative to immobilisation developed in our laboratory. We use a recombinant silk protein into which metal active sites can be incorporated to produce solid-state metalloprotein materials. The silk protein directly coordinates to the metal centres providing control over their reactivity akin to that seen in naturally occurring metalloproteins. These solid-state materials are remarkably stable at a range of temperatures and different solvent conditions. I discuss the genesis of this approach and highlight areas where such solid-state materials could find application.

De Novo Engineering of Solid-State Metalloproteins Using Recombinant Coiled-Coil Silk.

To achieve the sophisticated chemistry required for life, nature uses metal containing proteins (metalloproteins). However, despite intensive research efforts, very few of these metalloproteins have been exploited for biotechnological applications. One major limiting factor is the poor stability of these proteins when they are removed from their cellular environment. To produce stable metalloproteins, we have developed an engineering strategy that uses structural proteins which can be fabricated into a number of different solid-state materials. Here we demonstrate that a recombinant silk protein (AmelF3 - Apis mellifera Fibroin 3) binds heme and other metal macrocycles in a manner reminiscent of naturally occurring metalloproteins, whereby an amino acid coordinates directly to the metal center. Our strategy affords design at four different levels: the metal center, the organic macrocycle, the protein scaffold, and the material format structure. The solid-state metalloproteins produced remained functional when stored at room temperature for over one year.

Micromolar biosensing of nitric oxide using myoglobin immobilized in a synthetic silk film.

In this work we investigate the use of coiled-coil silk proteins, produced in recombinant Escherichia coli, as a new material for immobilizing biosensors. Myoglobin was embedded in transparent honeybee silk protein films. Immobilized myoglobin maintained a high affinity for nitric oxide (KD NO=52 µM) and good sensitivity with a limit of detection of 5 µM. The immobilized myoglobin-silk protein film was stable and could be stored as a dry film at room temperature for at least 60 days. The effect of immobilization on the structure of myoglobin was fully investigated using UV/visible, Fourier Transform Infrared and Raman spectroscopy, which indicated a weakening in the strength of the iron-histidine bond. This study demonstrates that recombinant coiled-coil silk proteins provide a safe and environmentally friendly alternative to sol-gels for stabilizing heme proteins for use as optical biosensors.

Short circuiting a sulfite oxidising enzyme with direct electrochemistry: active site substitutions and their effect on catalysis and electron transfer.

Sulfite dehydrogenase (SDH) from Starkeya novella is a heterodimeric enzyme comprising a Mo active site and a heme c electron relay, which mediates electron transfer from the Mo cofactor to cytochrome c following sulfite oxidation. Studies on the wild type enzyme (SDH(WT)) and its variants have identified key amino acids at the active site, specifically Arg-55 and His-57. We report the Mo(VI/V), Mo(V/IV) and Fe(III/II) (heme) redox potentials of the variants SDH(R55K), SDH(R55M), SDH(R55Q) and SDH(H57A) in comparison with those of SDH(WT). For SDH(R55M), SDH(R55Q) and SDH(H57A) the heme potentials are lowered from ca. 240mV in SDH(WT) to ca. 200mV, while the heme potential in SDH(R55K) remains unchanged and the Mo redox potentials are not affected significantly in any of these variants. Protein film voltammetry reveals a pH dependence of the electrochemical catalytic half-wave potential (E(cat)) of -59mV/pH in SDH(WT) and SDH(R55K) which tracks the pH dependence of the Mo(VI/V) redox potential. By contrast, the catalytic potentials for SDH(R55M) and SDH(H57A) are pH-independent and follow the potential of the heme cofactor. These results highlight a switch in the pathway of electron exchange as a function of applied potential that is revealed by protein film voltammetry where an actuation of rate limiting intramolecular electron transfer (IET, Mo to heme) at high potential attenuates the catalytic current relative to faster, direct electron transfer (Mo to electrode) at lower potential. The same change in electron transfer pathway is linked to an unusual peak-shaped profile of the ideally sigmoidal steady state voltammogram in SDH(WT) alone, which has been associated with a potential dependent change in the orientation of the enzyme on the electrode surface. All other variants show purely sigmoidal voltammetry due to their inherently slower turnover numbers which are always lower than IET rates.

Pulsed EPR investigations of the Mo(V) centers of the R55Q and R55M variants of sulfite dehydrogenase from Starkeya novella.

Continuous-wave and pulsed electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy have been used to characterize two variants of bacterial sulfite dehydrogenase (SDH) from Starkeya novella in which the conserved active-site arginine residue (R55) is replaced by a neutral amino acid residue. Substitution by the hydrophobic methionine residue (SDH(R55M)) has essentially no effect on the pH dependence of the EPR properties of the Mo(V) center, even though the X-ray structure of this variant shows that the methionine residue is rotated away from the Mo center and a sulfate anion is present in the active-site pocket (Bailey et al. in J Biol Chem 284:2053-2063, 2009). For SDH(R55M) only the high-pH form is observed, and samples prepared in H(2)(17)O-enriched buffer show essentially the same (17)O hyperfine interaction and nuclear quadrupole interaction parameters as SDH(WT) enzyme. However, the pH dependence of the EPR spectra of SDH(R55Q), in which the positively charged arginine is replaced by the neutral hydrophilic glutamine, differs significantly from that of SDH(WT). For SDH(R55Q) the blocked form with bound sulfate is generated at low pH, as verified by (33)S couplings observed upon reduction with (33)S-labeled sulfite. This observation of bound sulfate for SDH(R55Q) supports our previous hypothesis that sulfite-oxidizing enzymes can exhibit multiple pathways for electron transfer and product release (Emesh et al. in Biochemistry 48:2156-2163, 2009). At pH > or = 8 the high-pH form dominates for SDH(R55Q).

Intramolecular electron transfer in sulfite-oxidizing enzymes: elucidating the role of a conserved active site arginine.

All reported sulfite-oxidizing enzymes have a conserved arginine in their active site which hydrogen bonds to the equatorial oxygen ligand on the Mo atom. Previous studies on the pathogenic R160Q mutant of human sulfite oxidase (HSO) have shown that Mo-heme intramolecular electron transfer (IET) is dramatically slowed when positive charge is lost at this position. To improve our understanding of the function that this conserved positively charged residue plays in IET, we have studied the equivalent uncharged substitutions R55Q and R55M as well as the positively charged substitution R55K in bacterial sulfite dehydrogenase (SDH). The heme and molybdenum cofactor (Moco) subunits are tightly associated in SDH, which makes it an ideal system for improving our understanding of residue function in IET without the added complexity of the interdomain movement that occurs in HSO. Unexpectedly, the uncharged SDH variants (R55Q and R55M) exhibited increased IET rate constants relative to that of the wild type (3-4-fold) when studied by laser flash photolysis. The gain in function observed in SDH(R55Q) and SDH(R55M) suggests that the reduction in the level of IET seen in HSO(R160Q) is not due to a required role of this residue in the IET pathway itself, but to the fact that it plays an important role in heme orientation during the interdomain movement necessary for IET in HSO (as seen in viscosity experiments). The pH profiles of SDH(WT), SDH(R55M), and SDH(R55Q) show that the arginine substitution also alters the behavior of the Mo-heme IET equilibrium (K(eq)) and rate constants (k(et)) of both variants with respect to the SDH(WT) enzyme. SDH(WT) has a k(et) that is independent of pH and a K(eq) that increases as pH decreases; on the other hand, both SDH(R55M) and SDH(R55Q) have a k(et) that increases as pH decreases, and SDH(R55M) has a K(eq) that is pH-independent. IET in the SDH(R55Q) variant is inhibited by sulfate in laser flash photolysis experiments, a behavior that differs from that of SDH(WT), but which also occurs in HSO. IET in SDH(R55K) is slower than in SDH(WT). A new analysis of the possible mechanistic pathways for sulfite-oxidizing enzymes is presented and related to available kinetic and EPR results for these enzymes.

Direct catalytic electrochemistry of sulfite dehydrogenase: mechanistic insights and contrasts with related Mo enzymes.

Under hydrodynamic electrochemical conditions with slow cyclic voltammetry sweep rates we have been able to probe catalytic events at the molybdenum active site of sulfite dehydrogenase (SDH) from Starkeya novella adsorbed on an edge plane graphite electrode within a polylysine film. The electrochemically driven catalytic behaviour of SDH mirrors that seen in solution assays suggesting that the adsorbed enzyme retains its native activity. However, at high sulfite concentrations, the voltammetric waveform transforms from the expected sigmoidal profile to a peak-shaped response, similar to that reported for the molybdenum enzymes DMSO reductase and nitrate reductase (NarGHI and NapAB) where a redox reaction at the active site has been associated with a switch to lower activity at high overpotentials. This is the first time a similar phenomenon has been observed in a Mo-containing oxidase/dehydrogenase, which raises a number of interesting mechanistic problems. The potential at which the activity of SDH becomes attenuated only emerges at saturating substrate conditions and occurs at a potential (ca. + 320mV vs NHE) well removed from any known redox couple in the enzyme. These results cannot be explained by the same mechanism adopted for DMSO reductase and nitrate reductase catalysis.