Field Trials of Plum Clones Transformed with the Plum pox virus Coat Protein (PPV-CP) Gene.

Transgenic clones C2, C3, C4, C5, C6, and PT-6, of plum (Prunus domestica L.) transformed with the coat protein (CP) gene of Plum pox virus (PPV), PT-23 transformed with marker genes only, and nontransgenic B70146 were evaluated for sharka resistance under high infection pressure in field trials in Poland and Spain. These sites differed in climatic conditions and virus isolates. Transgenic clone C5 showed high resistance to PPV at both sites. None of the C5 trees became naturally infected by aphids during seven (Spain) or eight (Poland) years of the test, although up to 100% of other plum trees (transgenic clones and nontransgenic control plants) grown in the same conditions showed disease symptoms and tested positively for PPV. Although highly resistant, C5 trees could be infected artificially by chip budding or via susceptible rootstock. Infected C5 trees showed only a few mild symptoms on single, isolated shoots, even up to 8 years post inoculation. These results clearly indicate the long-term nature and high level of resistance to PPV obtained through genetically engineered resistance.

Molecular studies of the synergistic interactions between plum pox virus HC-Pro protein and potato virus X.

Helper component proteinase (HC-Pro) is a multifunctional viral protein involved in vection and movement of potyvirus; suppression of host post-transcriptional gene silencing reaction; and synergism of potyvirus with other viruses, notably potexvirus. When the HC-Pro of plum pox potyvirus (PPV) was transiently expressed in N. benthamiana and N. clevelandii plants via potato virus X (PVX) vector, a highly synergistic response of leaf necrosis or plant death, was observed in PVXHC-infected plants. However, when mutations were introduced into the highly conserved "PTK" and "KITC" motifs of HC-Pro, known for their involvement in protein/protein interaction during aphid-mediated transmission of potyvirus, the resulting change of amino acid residue from lysine (K) to glutamic acid (E) in the "KITC" motif had no obvious influence.

Post-transcriptional gene silencing in plum pox virus resistant transgenic European plum containing the plum pox potyvirus coat protein gene.

Transgenic plums containing the plum pox potyvirus coat protein (PPV-CP) gene were inoculated with PPV. Infection was monitored by evaluating symptoms, ELISA, and IC-RT-PCR. Transgenic clone C5 was highly resistant to PPV during four years of testing and displayed characteristics typical of post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS), including a high level of transgene transcription in the nucleus, low levels of transgene mRNA in the cytoplasm, a complex multicopy transgene insertion with aberrant copies, and methylation of the silenced PPV-CP transgene. The PPV-CP transgene was also methylated in seedlings of C5 and these seedlings were resistant to PPV. Our results show, for the first time, that PTGS functions as a mechanism for virus resistance in a woody perennial species.

The use of transgenic fruit trees as a resistance strategy for virus epidemics: the plum pox (sharka) model.

Sharka or plum pox, caused by Plum pox virus (PPV: genus Potyvirus; Family Potyviridae), is the most serious disease of Prunus. Most cultivated Prunus species are highly susceptible and conventional breeding has not produced highly resistant and commercially acceptable varieties. Success in developing virus-resistant herbaceous crops through genetic engineering led us to investigate this approach for resistance to PPV. Our programme aims to develop a biotechnological approach to PPV control that is effective and shown to be environmentally safe. The programme began with the cloning of the PPV coat protein (CP) gene and the development of a transformation system for plum (Prunus domestica). The CP construct was first tested in Nicotiana benthamiana in which it proved effective in producing transgenic plants with varying levels of CP expression. Some of these plants, particularly low PPV CP expressers, were resistant to PPV, or recovered from initial infection. Based on these results plum was transformed using the Agrobacterium tumefaciens system and both low and high PPV CP-expressing transgenic plum lines were obtained. These were inoculated with PPV by bud grafts in the greenhouse. Line C-5 proved to be highly resistant. It contained multiple copies of the insert, produced low levels of PPV CP mRNA, no detectable CP and the insert appeared to be methylated. These characteristics all suggest that the resistance of the C-5 clone is based on post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS). Field tests of C-5 and other transgenic lines in Poland, Romania and Spain have demonstrated that such trees when inoculated by bud-grafts allow a low level of PPV multiplication, from which they rapidly recover. C-5 plants exposed to natural infection for 3 years did not become infected, whereas control trees were infected in the first year. Hybrid plums having the C-5 PPV CP insert inherited from C-5 are virus-resistant, demonstrating the usefulness of C-5 as a parent in developing new PPV-resistant plum varieties. Research is in progress on the biorisks of PPV CP transgenic plants. Gene constructs that either produce no CP or CP that cannot be transmitted by aphids have been developed, tested in N. benthamiana and transferred to plum. Studies have begun on the potential for synergistic interactions between the PPV CP gene and the other common viruses of Prunus spp. In the future we will be participating in investigating the toxicity or/and the allergenicity of transgenic fruit products and, more importantly, transgenic lines will be developed that express transgenes only in vegetative parts of the plant and not in the fruit.

Use of modified plum pox virus coat protein genes developed to limit heteroencapsidation-associated risks in transgenic plants.

Aphid transmission of a non-aphid-transmissible strain of zucchini yellow mosaic virus (ZYMV-NAT) occurs in transgenic plants expressing the plum pox potyvirus (PPV) coat protein (CP) gene. Heteroencapsidation has been shown to be responsible for this modification in the epidemiological characteristics of the infecting virus. In order to prevent this biological risk, several modified PPV CP constructs were produced that were designed to interfere with heteroencapsidation itself or to block aphid transmission of heteroencapsidated virions. These constructs were first expressed in Escherichia coli in order to check for the accumulation of pseudo-particles by electron microscopy. Virus-like particles (VLPs) were found with the full-length CP and with a PPV CP lacking the DAG amino acid triplet involved in aphid transmission. However, no VLPs were observed with CP lacking R220, Q221 or D264, amino acids known to be essential for the assembly of other potyvirus CPs. Transgenic Nicotiana benthamiana lines expressing the different PPV CP constructs were infected with ZYMV-NAT. Aphid transmission assays performed with these plants demonstrated that the strategies developed here provide an effective means of minimizing the biological risks associated with heteroencapsidation.

High resistance and control of biological risks in transgenic plants expressing modified plum pox virus coat protein.

Transgenic plums transformed with the plum pox virus coat protein (PPV CP) gene displayed a resistance to the sharka disease (Ravelonandro et al., 1997). However, the expression of PPV CP in transgenic plants may lead to complementation of deficient characteristic of an incoming potyvirus. Indeed, an aphid-intransmissible strain of zucchini yellow mosaic virus (ZYMV-NAT) could be transmitted when encapsidated by the engineered PPV CP (Lecoq et al., 1993). To control such a risk, new PPV CP constructs were designed and introduced into Nicotiana benthamiana genome. In the first construct, the DAG amino acid triplet involved in the potyvirus aphid-transmission was deleted. The second construct encoded a truncated PPV CP lacking its first 140 amino acids. In the last construct, the nucleotides encoding the charged amino-acids R220, Q221 and D264 localized in the core of the PPV CP were removed. A bacterial expression system was developed to show that these deletions prevent the assembly of the PPV CP subunits. For each construct, several transgenic lines were produced and first challenged with several strains of PPV. Two phenotypes of resistance were observed: recovery and immunity. Their biochemical characterization showed that the resistance was RNA-mediated and therefore can be classified as homology-dependent (Jacquet et al., 1998a). Resistant lines producing high level of wild type or modified PPV CP were then inoculated with ZYMV-NAT to perform an aphid-transmission assay. Results of these experiments demonstrated that the use of modified forms of PPV CP genes in transgenic plants provide a good way to control the biological risks associated with heteroencapsidation (Jacquet et al., 1998b).

Preliminary report on the apparent breaking of resistance of a transgenic plum by chip bud inoculation of plum pox virus PPV-S.

Five transgenic clones of Prunus domestica L. containing plum pox virus (PPV) coat protein (CP) gene and one non-transformed control clone were challenged with PPV-S in the field. Symptoms developed on C2, C3, C4, C6 and B70146 but not C5 trees inoculated by chip budding (CBI) (2/2, 2/2, 1/1, 2/2 and 2/2, positive/inoculated) in the first summer after inoculation. However, in the second year, symptoms appeared on CBI C5 trees. The presence of the virus in the plants was confirmed by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) amplification of a fragment of viral polymerase gene. During two years, symptoms of infection developed on 3 to 4 of 8 non-inoculated trees of clones C2, C3, C4, C6 and B70146. Eight non-inoculated C5 trees remained symptomless and ELISA-negative as of spring 1998, in spite of the presence of aphid vectors and inoculum sources.

Characterization of phenotype resistance to plum pox of transgenic plums expressing plum pox virus capsid gene.

Resistance to plum pox virus (PPV) infection can be obtained in transgenic plants that express the virus capsid gene. An Agrobacterium-mediated transformation was used to introduce the PPV capsid gene into Prunus domestica plants. Over 11 regenerated plants (clones) were observed for the development of the disease symptoms and analysed for the presence of PPV by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), Western blot analysis, and reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) through 4 dormancy cycles. The level of protection against PPV was determined in the transformed plants, non-transformed plants, and a control transgenic plant "transformed" with the plasmid vector alone. One clone, C-5, appeared fully protected, while PT-6 and C-4 clones accumulated a low concentration of virus and the rest of the clones was entirely susceptible. Little is known about the mechanisms of resistance to virus infection in transgenic woody plants. To investigate this aspect, comparative studies based on the characteristics of resistant and susceptible clones have been started. A question, whether the phenotype resistance of clone C-5 is similar to that observed in transgenic herbaceous plants or not, has been addressed. Recent progress in this investigation is presented.

Resistance of Transgenic Prunus domestica to Plum Pox Virus Infection.

Transgenic plum trees (Prunus domestica) containing the plum pox potyvirus coat protein (PPV-CP) gene were inoculated with PPV by aphid feeding or chip budding. Infection was monitored by evaluation of virus symptoms, DAS-ELISA, and immunoblot assays. Based on observations and analyses over 3 years including two dormancy cycles, one out of five transgenic clones (C-5), was found to be resistant to infection whether inoculated by aphids or by chip budding. PPV could not be detected in any inoculated plants of the C-5 clone by immunoblot or immunocap-ture-reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction assays. To our knowledge, this is the first P. domestica clone resistant to PPV infection produced by genetic engineering.

Transgenic plums (Prunus domestica L.) express the plum pox virus coat protein gene.

Plum hypocotyl slices were transformed with the coat protein (CP) gene of plum pox virus (PPV-CP) following cocultivation with Agrobacterium tumefaciens containing the plasmid pGA482GG/PPVCP-33. This binary vector carries the PPV-CP gene construct, as well as the chimeric neomycin phosphotransferase and ß-glucuronidase genes. Integration and expression of the transferred genes into regenerated plum plants was verified through kan resistance, GUS assays, and PCR amplification of the PPV-CP gene. Twenty-two transgenic clones were identified from approximately 1800 hypocotyl slices. DNA, mRNA, and protein analyses of five transgenic plants confirmed the integration of the engineered CP gene, the accumulation of CP mRNA and of PPV-CP-immunoreactive protein. CP mRNA levels ranged from high to undetectable levels, apparently correlated with gene structure, as indicated by DNA blot analysis. Western analysis showed that transgenic plants produced amounts of CP which generally correlated with amounts of detected mRNA.

Immunodetection of the plum pox virus helper component in infected plants and expression of its gene in transgenic plants.

Tobacco plants (Nicotiana tabacum cv. Xanthi) have been transformed via Agrobacterium tumefaciens vectors, with cDNAs corresponding to the plum pox virus (PPV) cistron 2 encoding helper component (HC-Pro) and with the first two and half cistrons of the PPV genome. Presence of the HC-Pro in PPV-infected plants and transgenic plants transformed with the gene coding for this protein was investigated using specific polyclonal antibodies produced against the PPV HC-Pro. The results suggest that two proteases are involved in the processing of the PPV N-terminal polyprotein to yield a protein of 48 k (HC-Pro). HC-Pro autolytically cleaves at its carboxyl-terminus and a proteolytic activity, probably associated with the protein (P1) encoded by the cistron 1, is required for the cleavage in planta between the proteins derived from cistrons 1 and 2.

Construction of a chimeric viral gene expressing plum pox virus coat protein.

The capsid-encoding gene of plum pox virus (PPV) was fused with the leader sequence of the coat protein mRNA (cp) of tobacco mosaic virus by a novel mutagenesis technique which involves reverse transcription of minus-strand RNA [synthesized by in vitro transcription of a double-stranded (ds) cDNA clone], using an ad hoc synthetic oligodeoxynucleotide as primer. The resulting cDNA was rendered ds and cloned into the plasmid, pBluescribe M13+. Transcription of this chimeric construction produced RNA molecules of 1250 nucleotides in length, which were used as messengers in the in vitro protein-synthesizing systems. The major product of this transcript consists of a 36-kDa polypeptide and was identified as the PPV coat protein (CP) by molecular weight estimation and by immunoprecipitation with a polyclonal antiserum to PPV. Transfer of this cDNA via Agrobacterium tumefaciens into plants was successfully performed. Transgenic Nicotiana plants producing the PPV CP were subsequently obtained.

A highly sensitive immunocapture polymerase chain reaction method for plum pox potyvirus detection.

A highly sensitive assay, based on polymerase chain reaction amplification of cDNA synthesized from the viral RNA of antibody-captured viral particles, has been developed for plum pox potyvirus (PPV) detection. The reaction, called immunocapture/PCR (IC/PCR), yields a specific 243-bp product. The immunocapture step, by allowing the use of large sample volumes and by the viral particle prepurification it achieves, dramatically increases the sensitivity of the assay. As few as 8000 target viral particles per ml of plant extract could be detected by IC/PCR. When compared to direct PCR (Wetzel et al., 1991), molecular hybridization using 32P-labeled cRNA probes and ELISA, this result corresponds to a 250-fold, 625-fold and 5000-fold increased sensitivity, respectively. The high sensitivity of IC/PCR was confirmed during an indexing trial with field samples collected from naturally infected trees. This very powerful technique should have wide ranging applications for the detection of a number of other viruses and pathogens for which specific antisera and sequence data are available.

A polymerase chain reaction assay adapted to plum pox potyvirus detection.

A sensitive, polyvalent assay based on the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was developed for plum pox potyvirus (PPV) detection. This technique was adapted for a single tube, the chemical denaturation and reverse transcription of the viral RNA followed by the PCR reaction yielding a 243-base-pair product. As few as 10 fg of purified viral RNA, corresponding to approximately 2000 viral particles, were detected in plant extracts. All PPV isolates tested were amplified, and the amplified fragments were analysed by restriction endonuclease digestion. An RsaI restriction site polymorphism in the amplified fragments allowed the discrimination of two groups of isolates. In a field indexing trial, the PCR assay proved to be more sensitive than molecular hybridization using 32P-labelled RNA probes for PPV detection.

Nucleotide sequence of the 3'-terminal region of the RNA of the El Amar strain of plum pox potyvirus.

The nucleotide sequence of the 3'-terminal 4773 nucleotides of the RNA of a widely divergent, aphid-transmissible strain of plum pox potyvirus isolated from Egypt (PPV-El Amar) was determined. The sequenced region covers the carboxy terminus of the cylindrical inclusion (CI) gene, and the putative 6K protein, the NIa protease, the NIb RNA polymerase and the coat protein genes, linked together as one large open reading frame (ORF) in a fashion similar to the canonical genomic organization of other potyviruses. The large ORF encoding the polyprotein is followed by a 217 nucleotide non-coding region and a poly(A) tail. However, whereas the three PPV strains previously sequenced show levels of identity in excess of 98%, PPV-El Amar shows levels of heterogeneity of 20% in the nucleotide sequence and 10% in the amino acid sequence, when compared with these previously sequenced strains. The N-terminal region of the capsid protein, postulated to be involved in the aphid transmission mechanism of the virus, was found to be the region which differed most between PPV-El Amar and the other strains.

Dot hybridization detection of plum pox virus using 32P-labeled RNA probes representing non-structural viral protein genes.

A cDNA library covering the complete genome of plum pox virus strain D (PPV D) has been obtained, and an endonuclease restriction map derived from it. This map was superposed on the PPV genomic organisation map, established for a nonaphid transmissible strain of PPV (Maiss et al., 1989). This allowed us to select seven probes, corresponding to different regions on the PPV genome. These probes were tested in a dot-blot hybridization assay for the detection of PPV. Probes of various lengths (0.25 to 1.5 kb) were tested and those measuring at least 0.8 kb (4 of the 7 probes selected) proved to be the most sensitive. The detection limit was of about 5 pg of purified virus per assay. Probes representing non-structural viral protein genes were equally sensitive in detecting both serotypes D and M of PPV. The previously described probe pBPPV1 (Varveri et al., 1988), covering the coat protein gene of strain D, was less sensitive, when compared to the above probes, in detecting heterologous strains of PPV. The polyvalence of probes transcribed from non-structural viral protein genes was confirmed by screening isolates of PPV, collected in infected orchards in several Mediterranean countries.

The nucleotide sequence of satellite RNA in grapevine fanleaf virus, strain F13.

The nucleotide sequence of cDNA copies of grapevine fanleaf virus (strain F13) satellite RNA has been determined. The primary structure obtained was 1114 nucleotides in length, excluding the poly(A) tail, and contained only one long open reading frame encoding a 341 residue, highly hydrophilic polypeptide of Mr37275. The coding sequence was bordered by a leader of 14 nucleotides and a 3'-terminal non-coding region of 74 nucleotides. No homology has been found with small satellite RNAs associated with other nepoviruses. Two limited homologies of eight nucleotides have been detected between the satellite RNA in grapevine fanleaf virus and those in tomato black ring virus, and a consensus sequence U.G/UGAAAAU/AU/AU/A at the 5' end of nepovirus RNAs is reported. A less extended consensus exists in this region in comovirus and picornavirus RNA.

Cap accessibility correlates with the initiation efficiency of alfalfa mosaic virus RNAs.

The rate of cap removal from the alfalfa mosaic virus (A1MV) RNAs with tobacco acid pyrophosphatase (TAP) depends on the RNA species. At 37 degrees C and in the absence of divalent cation, RNA 3 reacts more slowly than the other three, which are decapped at similar rates. In the presence of magnesium, at 25 degrees C, TAP also discriminates against RNA 1. Thus the order of reactivity with TAP largely mimics the hierarchy of initiation efficiencies of the A1MV RNAs (Godefroy-Colburn et al., preceding paper in this journal). Our interpretation of these findings is that cap accessibility is what limits the rate of reaction with initiation factors as well as with TAP. In this hypothesis, translational discrimination between naturally capped messages would be related to the rate of 'breathing' of their 5' ends.