Lessons Learned from Catalysis to Qubits: General Strategies to Build Accessible and Accurate First-Principles Models of Point Defects.

Defects and dopants play critical roles in defining the properties of a material. Achieving a mechanistic understanding of how such properties arise is challenging with current experimental methods, and computational approaches suffer from significant modeling limitations that frequently require a posteriori fitting. Consequently, the pace of dopant discovery as a means of tuning material properties for a particular application has been slow. However, recent advances in computation have enabled researchers to move away from semiempirical schemes to reposition density functional theory as a predictive tool and improve the accessibility of highly accurate first-principles methods to all researchers. This Perspective discusses some of these recent achievements that provide more accurate first-principles geometric, thermodynamic, optical, and electronic properties simultaneously. Advancements related to supercells, basis sets, functionals, and optimization protocols, as well as suggestions for evaluating the quality of a computational model through comparison to experimental data, are discussed. Moreover, recent computational results in the fields of energy materials, heterogeneous catalysis, and quantum informatics are reviewed along with an evaluation of current frontiers and opportunities in the field of computational materials chemistry.

Controlling product selectivity in oxidative desulfurization using an electrodeposited iron oxide film.

Sulfur-containing compounds must be removed from raw fuel oils before use and recently, there has been an effort to identify and optimize a more energy efficient method of oil processing. One promising route is electrochemical oxidative desulfurization (ODS), and in this work, we investigate an electrodeposited iron oxide film (FeOx(OH)y) as a working electrode to catalyze the oxidation of dibenzothiophene (DBT). The FeOx(OH)y film displays unexpected selectivity for the DBT sulfoxide (DBTO)-departing from the catalytic behavior of gold, which favors the dimerization of DBT. In addition, we observe a morphological change within our FeOx(OH)y film from γ-FeOOH to γ-Fe2O3. This change provides insight to the activity of each structure for ODS as the rate of oxidation increases after the incorporation of γ-Fe2O3. Our experimental observations are corroborated with DFT calculations, which suggest that the adsorption energy of DBT on Au is significantly greater than on the FeOx(OH)y, favoring the formation of dimeric and oligomeric products. Calculations also demonstrate that DBT binds preferably in a monodentate configuration but that oxidation occurs via DBT bound via a bidentate configuration. Monodentate binding on γ-FeOOH is significantly stronger than binding on γ-Fe2O, resulting in easier conversation to bidentate binding on γ-Fe2O3.

Elucidation of complex triplet excited state dynamics in Pd(II) biladiene tetrapyrroles.

Pd(II) biladienes have been developed over the last five years as non-aromatic oligotetrapyrrole complexes that support a rich triplet photochemistry. In this work, we have undertaken the first detailed photophysical interrogation of three homologous Pd(II) biladienes bearing different combinations of methyl- and phenyl-substituents on the frameworks' sp3-hybridized meso-carbon (i.e., the 10-position of the biladiene framework). These experiments have revealed unexpected excited-state dynamics that are dependent on the wavelength of light used to excite the biladiene. More specifically, transient absorption spectroscopy revealed that higher-energy excitation (λexc ∼ 350-500 nm) led to an additional lifetime (i.e., an extra photophysical process) compared to experiments carried out following excitation into the lowest-energy excited states (λexc = 550 nm). Each Pd(II) biladiene complex displayed an intersystem crossing lifetime on the order of tens of ps and a triplet lifetime of ∼20 µs, regardless of the excitation wavelength. However, when higher-energy light is used to excite the complexes, a new lifetime on the order of hundreds of ps is observed. The origin of the 'extra' lifetime observed upon higher energy excitation was revealed using density functional theory (DFT) and time-dependent DFT (TDDFT). These efforts demonstrated that excitation into higher-energy metal-mixed-charge-transfer excited states with high spin-orbit coupling to higher energy metal-mixed-charge-transfer triplet states leads to the additional excitation deactivation pathway. The results of this work demonstrate that Pd(II) biladienes support a unique triplet photochemistry that may be exploited for development of new photochemical schemes and applications.

Atomic-Layer-Deposited Aluminum Oxide Thin Films Probed with X-ray Scattering and Compared to Molecular Dynamics and Density Functional Theory Models.

A better understanding of amorphous aluminum oxide's structure and electronic properties is obtained through combined experimental and computational approaches. Grazing incidence X-ray scattering measurements were carried out on aluminum oxide thin films grown using thermal atomic layer deposition. The corresponding pair distribution functions (PDFs) showed structures similar to previously reported PDFs of solid-state amorphous alumina and molten alumina. Structural models based on crystalline alumina polymorphs (PDFgui) and amorphous alumina (molecular dynamics, MD) were examined for structural comparisons to the experimental PDF data. Smaller MD models were optimized and verified against larger models to allow for quantum chemical electronic structure calculations. The electronic structure of the amorphous alumina models yields additional insight into the band structure and electronic defects present in amorphous alumina that are not present in crystalline samples.

Parameter space exploration reveals interesting Mn-doped SrTiO3 structures.

The rich chemistry of the SrTiO3 is often modified, intentionally or unintentionally, through the inclusion of defects and dopants. Much computational effort using periodic boundary DFT has been dedicated towards understanding how these observed properties arise from the disordered perovskite structure, but the range of possible defect chemistries arising from different computational modeling choices has not been thoroughly explored. In this study, we calculate the geometric and electronic properties for a systematic range of supercells, from approximately 40 atoms to approximately 320 atoms, with each atomic vacancy and doped with Mn ions to isolate the contribution of supercell size to predicted properties. Our thorough analysis of the electronic and geometric structure of each defected supercell shows high variability, illustrating the need to map the parameter space in order to achieve a comprehensive model of disordered perovskites. Our results additionally reveal fundamental insights into dopant chemistry in SrTiO3, and we report new potential geometric and electronic structures for Mn dopants that can be used to justify and guide additional experimental investigation into this complex material.

Proton-controlled non-exponential photoluminescence in a pyridylamidine-substituted Re(I) complex.

Chemical intuition and well-known design principles can typically be used to create ligand environments in transition metal complexes to deliberately tune reactivity for desired applications. However, intelligent ligand design does not always result in the expected outcomes. Herein we report the synthesis and characterization of a tricarbonyl rhenium (2,2'-bipyridine) 4-pyridylamidine, Re(4-Pam), complex with unexpected photophysical properties. Photoluminescence kinetics of Re(4-Pam) undergoes non-exponential decay, which can be deconvolved into two emission lifetimes. However, upon protonation of the amidine functionality of the 4-pyridylamidine to form Re(4-PamH), a single exponential decay is observed. To understand and rationalize these experimental observations, density functional theory (DFT) and time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) are employed. The symmetry or asymmetry of the protonated or deprotonated 4-pyridylamidine ligand, respectively, is the key factor in switching between one and two photoluminescence lifetimes. Specifically, rotation of the dihedral angle formed between the bipyridine and 4-Pam ligand leads to two rotamers of Re(4-Pam) with degenerate triplet- to ground-state transitions.