A guide to conducting systematic reviews of clinical laboratory tests.

Clinical laboratory professionals have an instrumental role in supporting clinical decision making with the optimal use of laboratory testing for screening, risk stratification, diagnostic, prognostic, treatment selection and monitoring of different states of health and disease. Delivering evidence-based laboratory medicine relies on review of available data and literature. The information derived, supports many national policies to improve patient care through clinical practice guidelines or best practice recommendations. The quality, validity and bias of this literature is variable. Hence, there is a need to collate similar studies and data and analyse them critically. Systematic review, thus, becomes the most important source of evidence. A systematic review, unlike a scoping or narrative review, involves a thorough understanding of the procedure involved and a stepwise methodology. There are nuances that need some consideration for laboratory medicine systematic reviews. The purpose of this article is to describe the process of performing a systematic review in the field of laboratory medicine, describing the available methodologies, tools and software packages that can be used to facilitate this process.

Analytical Concordance of Diverse Point-of-Care and Central Laboratory Troponin I Assays.

BACKGROUND: Cardiac troponin I (cTnI) 99th percentile cutoffs, used in the diagnosis of acute myocardial infarction, are not standardized across cTnI assays. We compared 3 point-of-care (POC) and 1 central laboratory contemporary cTnI assays against the Abbott high-sensitivity (hs) cTnI to evaluate the analytical concordance and the feasibility of using a single cutoff value for all assays. METHODS: Fresh blood samples collected from 102 inpatients in the coronary care unit were measured on central laboratory instruments (Beckman Coulter DxI AccuTnI+3 TnI, Abbott Architect hs-TnI) and cTnI POC analyzers (Alere Triage Troponin I, Radiometer AQT90, Abbott i-STAT). Agreement and correlation between the contemporary cTnI assays and hs-cTnI assay were assessed using regression analysis. Proportional bias was assessed using Bland-Altman plots. Concordance between the contemporary cTnI and hs-cTnI assays was determined by diagnostic contingency tables at specific cutoffs. RESULTS: Most POC cTnI assays had excellent correlation with the Abbott hs-cTnI method (r 2 = 0.955-0.970) except for Alere Triage (r 2 = 0.617), while proportional bias is evident between all cTnI assays. Overall concordance between POC contemporary cTnI assays and hs-cTnI assay was 80% to 90% at their respective 99th percentile cutoffs. The concordance increased to 90% to 95% when a fixed cutoff of 0.03 to 0.05 ng/mL was used across the assays. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrates poor analytical concordance between cTnI assays at the 99th percentile and supports the notion of a single clinical decision limit for cTnI and consequently standardization of diagnostic protocols despite the analytical differences among these assays.

Analytical sensitivity and diagnostic performance of serum protein electrophoresis on the HYDRAGEL 30 PROTEIN(E) ß1-ß2 Sebia Hydrasys system.

BACKGROUND: Serum protein electrophoresis (SPE) and immunofixation electrophoresis (IFE) are used in the diagnosis and monitoring of plasma cell dyscrasias. IFE is considered the most sensitive method for the detection of monoclonal proteins (M-proteins), but it is not quantitative. The goal of this study was to establish the analytical sensitivity and diagnostic performance of SPE on the Sebia Hydrasys using HYDRAGEL 30 PROTEIN(E) ß1-ß2. METHODOLOGY: Patient sera with a previously identified M-protein (IgG, IgA or IgM) were serially diluted with a normal serum pool and electrophoresed on the Sebia Hydrasys using HYDRAGEL 30 PROTEIN(E) ß1-ß2. The SPE gels were individually interpreted by five independent observers and IFE was performed on selected samples. Limit of detection was determined as the lowest concentration of M-protein band visible on the gel. SPE diagnostic performance was evaluated against the "gold standard" IFE according CLSI EP12-A2 guidelines. RESULTS: Detection limit was comparable among all M-proteins migrating in the gamma region, IgG-κ (0.18±0.08g/L; n=6), IgG-λ (0.36±0.25g/L; n=8), IgA-κ (0.40±0.13g/L; n=7), IgA-λ (0.37±0.23g/L; n=4), IgM-κ (0.47±0.20g/L; n=13) and IgM-λ (0.29±0.24g/L; n=6). Percentage agreement with IFE for IgG and IgA in the gamma region ranged from 65% to 100%, whereas IgM migrating in the gamma region and immunoglobulins co-migrating with alpha or beta globulins, showed poor (0-38%) agreement. CONCLUSIONS: This study evaluates the analytical sensitivity and diagnostic performance of SPE on the Sebia Hydrasys using HYDRAGEL 30 PROTEIN(E) ß1-ß2. There was acceptable agreement between SPE and IFE for IgG-κ/λ and IgA-κ/λ migrating in the gamma region, suggesting that repeating IFE for samples with these isotypes, when the previous IFE and second SPE are both negative, may not be necessary.

Candidate recommendations for protein electrophoresis reporting from the Canadian Society of Clinical Chemists Monoclonal Gammopathy Working Group.

Protein electrophoresis is commonly used as an aid in the diagnosis of monoclonal gammopathies and is performed in many laboratories in Canada and throughout the world. However, unlike many other diagnostic tests, there is limited guidance for standardization and neither guidance nor specific recommendations for clinical reporting of serum (SPE) or urine (UPE) protein electrophoresis and immunotyping available in the literature. Therefore, a Canadian effort was undertaken to recommend standards that cover all aspects of clinical reporting with an ultimate goal towards reporting standardization. The Canadian Society of Clinical Chemists (CSCC) Monoclonal Gammopathy Interest Group (MGIG), which is composed of CSCC members with an interest in protein electrophoresis, has formed a Monoclonal Gammopathy Working Group (MGWG) to take initial steps towards standardization of SPE, UPE and immunotyping. Candidate standardization recommendations were developed, discussed and voted upon by the MGWG. Candidate recommendations that achieved 90% agreement are presented as consensus recommendations. Recommendations that did not achieve 90% consensus remain candidate recommendations and are presented with accompanying MGWG discussion. Eleven consensus recommendations along with candidate recommendations for nomenclature, protein fraction reporting, test utilization, interference handling and interpretive reporting options are presented.

The use of fructosamine in cystic fibrosis-related diabetes (CFRD) screening.

OBJECTIVE: To determine whether serum fructosamine correlates with glycemic control and clinical outcomes in patients being screened for cystic fibrosis-related diabetes (CFRD). METHODS: Fructosamine and percent predicted forced expiratory volume in 1s (FEV1) were measured in patients undergoing a 2h oral glucose tolerance test (OGTT) for CFRD screening. Fractional serum fructosamine (FSF) was calculated as fructosamine/total protein. RESULTS: FSF exhibited a positive correlation with 2h OGTT results (r2=0.3201, p=0.009), and ROC curve analysis suggested that FSF can identify patients with an abnormal OGTT (AUC=0.840, p=0.0002). FSF also exhibited a negative correlation with FEV1 (r2=0.3732, p=0.035). Patients with FSF≥3.70µmol/g had significantly lower FEV1 (median 47%) compared to those with FSF<3.70µmol/g (median 90%; p=0.015). CONCLUSIONS: FSF correlated with both OGTT results and FEV1, and reliably identified patients with abnormal OGTT results. This simple blood test shows potential as an effective tool in CFRD screening.

Point-of-care testing (POCT) and evidence-based laboratory medicine (EBLM) - does it leverage any advantage in clinical decision making?

Point-of-care testing (POCT) is the analysis of patient specimens outside the clinical laboratory, near or at the site of patient care, usually performed by clinical staff without laboratory training, although it also encompasses patient self-monitoring. It is able to provide a rapid result near the patient and which can be acted upon immediately. The key driver is the concept that clinical decision making may be delayed when samples are sent to the clinical laboratory. Balanced against this are considerations of increased costs for purchase and maintenance of equipment, staff training, connectivity to the laboratory information system (LIS), quality control (QC) and external quality assurance (EQA) procedures, all required for accreditation under ISO 22870. The justification for POCT depends upon being able to demonstrate that a more timely result (shorter turnaround times (TATs)) is able to leverage a clinically important advantage in decision making compared with the central laboratory (CL). In the four decades since POCT was adapted for the self-monitoring of blood glucose levels by subjects with diabetes, numerous new POCT methodologies have become available, enabling the clinician to receive results and initiate treatment more rapidly. However, these instruments are often operated by staff not trained in laboratory medicine and hence are prone to errors in the analytical phase (as opposed to laboratory testing where the analytical phase has the least errors). In some environments, particularly remote rural settings, the CL may be at a considerable distance and timely availability of cardiac troponins and other analytes can triage referrals to the main centers, thus avoiding expensive unnecessary patient transportation costs. However, in the Emergency Department, availability of more rapid results with POCT does not always translate into shorter stays due to other barriers to implementation of care. In this review, we apply the principles of evidence-based laboratory medicine (EBLM) looking for high quality systematic reviews and meta-analyses, ideally underpinned by randomized controlled trials (RCTs), looking for evidence of whether POCT confers any advantage in clinical decision making in different scenarios.

Evaluation of thyroid test utilization through analysis of population-level data.

BACKGROUND: Inappropriate laboratory test utilization can result in unnecessary patient testing and increased healthcare costs. While several thyroid function tests are available, thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) is recommended as the first-line test for investigating and monitoring thyroid dysfunction. We evaluate thyroid test utilization in Northern Alberta in terms of testing patterns, frequencies, and reflex cutpoints. METHODS: This retrospective study analyzed thyroid test requests from January to December 2014. Each request was designated as appropriate or potentially inappropriate as per clinical practice guidelines and Choosing Wisely recommendations, and the frequencies of each testing pattern were calculated. Sub-analysis was performed to categorize testing patterns based on physician specialty. The number of test requests per patient was determined to assess the appropriateness of testing frequency. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves were generated to define optimal TSH cutpoints for automatic reflex to FT4 testing. RESULTS: Of 752,217 test requests, approximately 10% were potentially inappropriate in terms of testing patterns. Free thyroxine (FT4) and free triiodothyronine (FT3) requested with TSH accounted for 59% of all potentially inappropriate test requests, and 49% of requests from endocrinologists (ENDO) were potentially inappropriate, occurring most frequently among those with less experience. Excessive testing frequencies were observed in 869 patients, accounting for 9382 test requests. Adjustment of our TSH reflex cutpoint would significantly increase specificity for identifying a low FT4 without compromising sensitivity. CONCLUSIONS: This study suggests that questionable testing patterns, excessive testing frequencies, and suboptimal reflexive testing cutpoints contribute to inappropriate thyroid test utilization.

Erroneous HbA1c results in a patient with elevated HbC and HbF.

BACKGROUND: HbA1c is used in the diagnosis and monitoring of diabetes mellitus (DM). Interference from hemoglobin variants is a well-described phenomenon, particularly with HPLC-based methods. While immunoassays may generate more reliable HbA1c results in the presence of some variants, these methods are susceptible to negative interference from high concentrations of HbF. We report a case where an accurate HbA1c result could not be obtained by any available method due to the presence of a compound hemoglobinopathy. METHODS: HbA1c was measured by HPLC, immunoassay, and capillary electrophoresis. Hemoglobinopathy investigation consisted of a CBC, hemoglobin fractionation by HPLC and electrophoresis, and molecular analysis. RESULTS: HbA1c analysis by HPLC and capillary electrophoresis gave no result. Analysis by immunoassay yielded HbA1c results of 5.9% (Siemens DCA 2000+) and 5.1% (Roche Integra), which were inconsistent with other markers of glycemic control. Hemoglobinopathy investigation showed HbC with the hereditary persistence of fetal hemoglobin-2 Ghana deletion. CONCLUSION: Reliable HbA1c results may be unobtainable in the presence of some hemoglobinopathies. HPLC and capillary electrophoresis alerted the laboratory to the presence of an unusual hemoglobinopathy. Immunoassays generated falsely low results without warning, which could lead to missed diagnoses and under treatment of patients with DM.

Stability of specific IgE antibodies to common food and inhalant allergens.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the optimum storage temperature for serum allergen specific IgE antibodies (sIgE) to common food and inhalant allergens. METHODS: Patient sera with sIgE concentrations ≥0.7kIUA/l were pooled accordingly: pool 1-peanut and hazelnut, pool 2-egg white, cow's milk and cod fish, pool 3-soy, wheat and shrimp and pool 4-dust mite Dermatophagoides farinae, dog dander, cat dander, Timothy grass pollen, and silver birch pollen. Aliquots stored frozen, refrigerated and at room temperature were tested in duplicate (Phadia ImmunoCAP® 250) over two weeks. The relative difference was calculated for each sIgE as a percentage of the initial value and compared to the analytical reference change value. RESULTS: Minimal effects on specimen stability were noted for all sIgE analyzed under the three storage conditions tested in this study. All changes observed in sIgE concentrations were related to the assay variability and not to sample deterioration. CONCLUSION: Serum allergen specific IgE concentrations are stable at all temperatures studied for up to 17days.

Hemoglobin Hirose: A rare beta chain variant causing falsely low HbA1c by HPLC.

OBJECTIVES: To investigate the underlying cause of unexpectedly low HbA1c results (3.3-3.5%) obtained by HPLC in three siblings undergoing routine screening for type 2 diabetes mellitus. DESIGN AND METHODS: HbA1c was measured using an alternate method based on a different analytical principle (the Siemens DCA 2000+ immunoassay). Hemoglobin fractionation was performed by HPLC on the BioRad Variant II, gel electrophoresis at acid and alkaline pH on the Sebia Hydrasys 2, and capillary electrophoresis on the Sebia Capillarys 2. Sequencing of the beta globin gene was also conducted. RESULTS: HbA1c analysis by immunoassay gave significantly higher results, ranging from 5.2-5.5%. Hemoglobin fractionation by HPLC showed an abnormal peak comprising approximately 43% of total hemoglobin, suggesting the presence of a beta chain hemoglobin variant. Gel electrophoresis at alkaline pH revealed a very unusual pattern, with 3 abnormal bands migrating with Hb F, between Hb F and Hb S, and slightly cathodal to Hb S. A single band in the Hb A position was seen on gel electrophoresis at acid pH. Capillary electrophoresis revealed two abnormal peaks, comprising 42% and 5% of total hemoglobin. Sequencing of the beta globin gene showed heterozygosity for Hb Hirose (beta 37(C3) Trp>Ser), an extremely rare variant with a substitution at the α1ß2 interface. CONCLUSIONS: We describe the chromatographic and electrophoretic properties of Hb Hirose, and demonstrate that this rare variant causes falsely low HbA1c results on the BioRad variant II Turbo 2.0. Recognition of this interference is crucial in order to prevent reporting erroneous results.

Identification of Hb Wayne and its effects on HbA1c measurement by 5 methods.

BACKGROUND: The World Health Organization and the American and Canadian Diabetes Associations approved HbA1c >6.5% as diagnostic for type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM). Hb variants and/or their chemically modified species can interfere with HbA1c measurements. We recently described a patient with Hb Wayne trait who was misdiagnosed with T2DM based on falsely elevated HbA1c. Hb Wayne is a clinically silent variant that exists as two isoforms: Hb Wayne I (Asn 139) and Hb Wayne II (Asp 139). METHODS: Hemoglobinopathy investigation was performed by HPLC (Bio-Rad VARIANT-II), alkaline and acid electrophoresis (Sebia Hydrasis2), capillary zone electrophoresis (Sebia CAPILLARYS2™) and DNA sequencing. HbA1c was measured by five methods. RESULTS: Hb Wayne eluted as two small fractions with retention times of 1.0 and 1.46min on the HPLC (Bio-Rad VARIANT-II). Alkaline gel and capillary electrophoresis showed two small bands migrating faster than HbA. Hb Wayne generated spuriously high results on the Bio-Rad VARIANT-II Turbo 2.0, no results on the Tosoh G8, and did not interfere with either the Sebia CAPILLARYS2™ or immunoassays from Roche (tinaquant) and Siemens (Bayer DCA2000+). Based on the Hb Wayne HPLC profile of 3 patients, an algorithm was developed to facilitate its detection, which identified 9 additional patients with Hb Wayne trait. CONCLUSIONS: We characterize Hb Wayne by chromatographic and electrophoretic techniques and show the effect of Hb Wayne on five common HbA1c methodologies. We developed a quality assurance tool to assist in detecting Hb Wayne trait during HbA1c analysis on the Bio-Rad VARIANT-II™ Turbo 2.0.

A novel double heterozygous Hb Fontainebleau/HbD Punjab hemoglobinopathy.

OBJECTIVES: To report the finding of a novel double heterozygous hemoglobinopathy, the coinheritance of Hb Fontainebleau (α-chain variant) with HbD-Punjab (ß-chain variant) discovered upon investigation of unexplained microcytosis in an infant. DESIGN AND METHODS: Hemoglobinopathy investigation was performed by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) using the ß-thalassemia Short Program on the Bio-Rad Variant II(TM) followed by gel electrophoresis at alkaline and acid pH (Sebia Hydrasys 2 Electrophoresis System) and molecular diagnostic testing. This study complied with our institutional board ethics requirements. RESULTS: HPLC and electrophoresis suggested a complex α- and ß-chain hemoglobinopathy with presumptive identification of the beta Hb variant as Hb D-Punjab. DNA sequencing analysis revealed the presence of a double heterozygous status for Hb Fontainebleau/Hb D-Punjab. CONCLUSIONS: In this paper we report the coinheritance of Hb Fontainebleau with Hb D-Punjab.

Hemoglobin Constant Spring exhibits prolonged ex vivo stability when assessed by HPLC.

OBJECTIVES: 1) To investigate the presence of hemoglobin Constant Spring (HbCS) in a patientwith severe microcytic anemia who had previously been diagnosed with alpha thalassemia minor. 2) To assess the stability of HbCS post blood collection by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). DESIGN AND METHODS: Hemoglobin fractionation was performed by HPLC immediately after specimen collection using the ß-thalassemia Short Program on the BioRad Variant II. To assess HbCS stability, the patient's specimen was re-analyzed over a 17 day period. RESULTS: HPLC analysis showed a low abundance peak with chromatographic properties consistent with HbCS. Presence of this hemoglobin variant was confirmed by electrophoresis and gene sequencing. HbCS remained detectable by HPLC for 17 days after specimen collection, with minimal degradation. CONCLUSIONS: Our results suggest that HbCS is stable many days after blood collection. Consequently, it is not necessary to analyze specimens immediately after collection when assessing the potential presence of this hemoglobin variant.

Incidence of hemoglobinopathies and thalassemias in Northern Alberta. Establishment of reference intervals for HbF and HbA2.

OBJECTIVES: The aims of this study were to identify the incidence of hemoglobinopathies and thalassemias in Northern Alberta and calculate the reference intervals (RI) for hemoglobin (Hb) HbF and HbA2. METHODS: A retrospective ad-hoc analysis of the structural Hb variants and thalassemias identified on patients who had a hemoglobinopathy/thalassemia investigation performed between February 1 to December 31, 2013. Results were extracted from the Laboratory Information System. Statistical analysis was performed using MedCalc® version 11.4.2.0 for Windows software. RESULTS: 6616 hemoglobinopathy/thalassemia investigations and HbS screens were physician requested and 602 Hb variants were fortuitously found during HbA1c analysis. 3438 were interpreted as "normal" and 532 were classified as iron deficient. 3306 individuals, with age ranging from 3 to 92 years were included in the RI calculation. HbA2 RI was 2.3% to 3.4% and HbF 0.0% to 1.8%. 524 and 423 α and ß thalassemia traits respectively were identified. Additionally ten 뫧 thalassemia traits and twelve cases of HbH disease were identified. Regarding hemoglobinopathies, 7% were classified as α-chain variants and 93% as ß-chain variants with HbS (46%), HbE (16%), HbD Punjab (8%) and HbC (7%) traits being the most prevalent. We also documented 20 homozygous hemoglobinopathies and 36 compound/double heterozygous hemoglobinopathies. CONCLUSION: A wide diversity of hemoglobinopathies is found in the Northern Alberta population, 80% of the hemoglobinopathies were found as a reflex to HbA1c testing. Reference intervals for HbF and HbA2 were established.

Analytical evaluation of the Diazyme glycated serum protein assay on the siemens ADVIA 1800: comparison of results against HbA1c for diagnosis and management of diabetes.

Hemoglobin A1c (HbA1c) is considered the gold standard for assessment of glycemic control in diabetic patients. HbA1c is inadequate in individuals homozygous or compound heterozygous for hemoglobin variants or in conditions with an altered red blood cell turnover. In these cases glycated albumin (GA) is proposed as an alternative assay. We aimed to evaluate the analytical performance of the Diazyme glycated serum protein (GSP) assay on an automated analyzer, to establish a reference interval (RI), and to compare from a clinical perspective, GSP/GA with glycated Hb (glyHb) results. Validation studies followed the CLSI guidelines and included precision, linearity, interferences, concordance of results with glyHb, and RI calculation. GSP was analyzed on representative samples with previously ordered HbA1c and albumin from the Dyna LIFE : DX laboratory. Samples from patients with bisalbuminemia, hemoglobinopathies, and multiple myeloma were also included. Within-run and total imprecision was <3.0% at both levels of control, analytical sensitivity was 5.31 µmol/L, and linearity was verified from 10 to 1150 µmol/L (total allowable error of 5%). Clinical concordance between %GA and glyHb was substantial (n = 175, R2 = .91, kappa = .78, P = .167). GSP RI was 160 to 340 µmol/L or if expressed as %GA 10.5 to 17.5%. Analytical performance of the Diazyme GSP assay on the Siemens ADVIA 1800 is acceptable for clinical use. The RI obtained was higher than that suggested by the manufacturer.

Evaluation of a commercially available carbohydrate deficient transferrin kit to detect beta-2-transferrin in cerebrospinal fluid using capillary electrophoresis.

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to evaluate the CEofix™ CDT Capillary Electrophoresis (CE) kit for the detection of ß-2-tranferrin (ß-2-Tf) in cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). DESIGN AND METHOD: Evaluation was performed according to CLSI EP5-A and EP12-A guidelines. RESULTS: The method resolved ß-2-Tf from other Tf isoforms. The C50 for ß-Tf was determined to be 0.46 mg/L. Neither hemoglobin nor bilirubin co-migrated with ß-2-Tf. CONCLUSIONS: The CDT kit can be used for detecting ß-2-Tf in CSF by CE.

Assessment of a four hour delay for urine samples stored without preservatives at room temperature for urinalysis.

OBJECTIVES: To determine whether urine storage at room temperature for up to 2h versus 4h changes urinalysis results. DESIGN AND METHODS: We compared the rejection rate at eight different hospital laboratories and concordance of urinalysis results (n=83; two laboratories) between urines analyzed within 2h and 4h after collection. RESULTS: The rejection rate at the two hour cutoff was significantly higher as compared to the four hour cutoff. The concordance between urinalysis results was 97-100% between the two and four hour analyses. CONCLUSION: Urine may be stored for up to 4h at room temperature without significant changes to the urinalysis results.