The MMACHC variant c.158T>C: Mild clinical and biochemical phenotypes and marked hydroxocobalamin response in cblC patients.

Mutations in MMACHC cause cobalamin C disease (cblC, OMIM 277400), the commonest inborn error of vitamin B12 metabolism. In cblC, deficient activation of cobalamin results in methylcobalamin and adenosylcobalamin deficiency, elevating methylmalonic acid (MMA) and total plasma homocysteine (tHcy). We retrospectively reviewed the medical files of seven cblC patients: three compound heterozygotes for the MMACHC (NM_015506.3) missense variant c.158T>C p.(Leu53Pro) in trans with the common pathogenic mutation c.271dupA (p.(Arg91Lysfs*14), "compounds"), and four c.271dupA homozygotes ("homozygotes"). Compounds receiving hydroxocobalamin intramuscular injection monotherapy had age-appropriate psychomotor performance and normal ophthalmological examinations. In contrast, c.271dupA homozygotes showed marked psychomotor retardation, retinopathy and feeding problems despite penta-therapy (hydroxocobalamin, betaine, folinic acid, l-carnitine and acetylsalicylic acid). Pretreatment levels of plasma and urine MMA and tHcy were higher in c.271dupA homozygotes than in compounds. Under treatment, levels of the compounds approached or entered the reference range but not those of c.271dupA homozygotes (tHcy: compounds 9.8-32.9 µM, homozygotes 41.6-106.8 (normal (N) < 14); plasma MMA: compounds 0.14-0.81 µM, homozygotes, 10.4-61 (N < 0.4); urine MMA: compounds 1.75-48 mmol/mol creatinine, homozygotes 143-493 (N < 10)). Patient skin fibroblasts all had low cobalamin uptake, but this was milder in compound cells. Also, the distribution pattern of cobalamin species was qualitatively different between cells from compounds and from homozygotes. Compared to the classic cblC phenotype presented by c.271dupA homozygous patients, c.[158T>C];[271dupA] compounds had mild clinical and biochemical phenotypes and responded strikingly to hydroxocobalamin monotherapy.

Growth requirement for methionine in human melanoma-derived cell lines with different levels of MMACHC expression and methylation.

Methionine dependence, the inability to grow in culture when methionine in the medium is replaced by its metabolic precursor homocysteine, occurs in many tumor cell lines. In most affected lines, the cause of methionine dependence is not known. An exception is the melanoma-derived cell line MeWo-LC1, in which hypermethylation of the MMACHC gene is associated with decreased MMACHC expression. Decreased expression results in decreased provision of the methylcobalamin cofactor required for activity of methionine synthase and thus decreased conversion of homocysteine to methionine. Analysis of data in the Cancer Cell Line Encyclopedia Archive demonstrated that MMACHC hypermethylation and decreased MMACHC expression occurred more frequently in melanoma cell lines when compared to other tumor cell lines. We further investigated methionine dependence and aspects of MMACHC function in a panel of six melanoma lines, including both melanoma lines with known methionine dependence status (MeWo, which is methionine independent, and A375, which is methionine dependent). We found that the previously unclassified melanoma lines HMCB, Colo829 and SH-4 were methionine dependent, while SK-Mel-28 was methionine independent. However, despite varying levels of MMACHC methylation and expression, none of the tested lines had decreased methylcobalamin and adenosylcobalamin synthesis as seen in MeWo-LC1, and the functions of both cobalamin-dependent enzymes methionine synthase and methylmalonyl-CoA mutase were intact. Thus, while melanoma lines were characterized by relatively high levels of MMACHC methylation and low expression, the defect in metabolism observed in MeWo-LC1 was unique, and decreased MMACHC expression was not a cause of methionine dependence in the other melanoma lines.

Pulmonary lymphangiectasia in myotubular myopathy: a novel unrecognized association?

Chylothorax has been reported in rare cases of X-linked myotubular myopathy, but the pathophysiology of this association is not fully understood. We report a case of a neonate presenting prenatally with hydrops and chylothorax. The patient died at 17 days of life due to respiratory failure secondary to severe pulmonary hypertension. Comprehensive genetic testing identified a de novo hemizygous frameshift mutation in the MTM1 gene (c.142-143del, p.Glu48Serfs*12) with subsequent autopsy confirming the diagnosis of X-linked myotubular myopathy. Lung microscopy demonstrated primary pulmonary lymphangiectasia as the cause for the massive chylothorax. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first reported case of molecularly confirmed X-linked myotubular myopathy with pulmonary lymphangiectasia with prenatal findings of hydrops, chylothorax and postnatal severe pulmonary hypertension.

Epimutations in both the TESK2 and MMACHC promoters in the Epi-cblC inherited disorder of intracellular metabolism of vitamin B12.

BACKGROUND: epi-cblC is a recently discovered inherited disorder of intracellular vitamin B12 metabolism associating hematological, neurological, and cardiometabolic outcomes. It is produced by an epimutation at the promoter common to CCDC163P and MMACHC, which results from an aberrant antisense transcription due to splicing mutations in the antisense PRDX1 gene neighboring MMACHC. We studied whether the aberrant transcription produced a second epimutation by encompassing the CpG island of the TESK2 gene neighboring CCDC163P. METHODS: We unraveled the methylome architecture of the CCDC163P-MMACHC CpG island (CpG:33) and the TESK2 CpG island (CpG:51) of 17 epi-cblC cases. We performed an integrative analysis of the DNA methylome profiling, transcriptome reconstruction of RNA-sequencing (RNA-seq), chromatin immunoprecipitation sequencing (ChIP-Seq) of histone H3, and transcription expression of MMACHC and TESK2. RESULTS: The PRDX1 splice mutations and activation of numerous cryptic splice sites produced antisense readthrough transcripts encompassing the bidirectional MMACHC/CCDC163P promoter and the TESK2 promoter, resulting in the silencing of both the MMACHC and TESK2 genes through the deposition of SETD2-dependent H3K36me3 marks and the generation of epimutations in the CpG islands of the two promoters. CONCLUSIONS: The antisense readthrough transcription of the mutated PRDX1 produces an epigenetic silencing of MMACHC and TESK2. We propose using the term 'epi-digenism' to define this epigenetic disorder that affects two genes. Epi-cblC is an entity that differs from cblC. Indeed, the PRDX1 and TESK2 altered expressions are observed in epi-cblC but not in cblC, suggesting further evaluating the potential consequences on cancer risk and spermatogenesis.

Inherited defects of cobalamin metabolism.

Cobalamin (vitamin B12) is required for activity of the enzymes methylmalonyl-CoA mutase and methionine synthase in human cells. Inborn errors affecting cobalamin uptake or metabolism are characterized by accumulation of the substrates for these enzymes, methylmalonic acid and homocysteine, in blood and urine. Inborn errors affecting synthesis of the adenosylcobalamin coenzyme required by methylmalonyl-CoA mutase (cblA and cblB) result in isolated methylmalonic aciduria; inborn errors affecting synthesis of the methylcobalamin coenzyme required by methionine synthase (cblE and cblG) result in isolated homocystinuria. Combined methylmalonic aciduria and homocystinuria is seen in patients with impaired intestinal cobalamin absorption (intrinsic factor deficiency, Imerslund-Gräsbeck syndrome) and with defects affecting synthesis of both cobalamin coenzymes (cblC, cblD, cblF and cblJ). A series of disorders caused by pathogenic variant mutations affecting gene regulators (transcription factors) of the MMACHC gene have recently been described (HCFC1 [cblX disorder] and deficiencies of THAP11, and ZNF143 [the cblK disorder]).

Epimutation in inherited metabolic disorders: the influence of aberrant transcription in adjacent genes.

Epigenetic diseases can be produced by a stable alteration, called an epimutation, in DNA methylation, in which epigenome alterations are directly involved in the underlying molecular mechanisms of the disease. This review focuses on the epigenetics of two inherited metabolic diseases, epi-cblC, an inherited metabolic disorder of cobalamin (vitamin B12) metabolism, and alpha-thalassemia type α-ZF, an inherited disorder of α2-globin synthesis, with a particular interest in the role of aberrant antisense transcription of flanking genes in the generation of epimutations in CpG islands of gene promoters. In both disorders, the epimutation is triggered by an aberrant antisense transcription through the promoter, which produces an H3K36me3 histone mark involved in the recruitment of DNA methyltransferases. It results from diverse genetic alterations. In alpha-thalassemia type α-ZF, a deletion removes HBA1 and HBQ1 genes and juxtaposes the antisense LUC7L gene to the HBA2 gene. In epi-cblC, the epimutation in the MMACHC promoter is produced by mutations in the antisense flanking gene PRDX1, which induces a prolonged antisense transcription through the MMACHC promoter. The presence of the epimutation in sperm, its transgenerational inheritance via the mutated PRDX1, and the high expression of PRDX1 in spermatogonia but its nearly undetectable transcription in spermatids and spermatocytes, suggest that the epimutation could be maintained during germline reprogramming and despite removal of aberrant transcription. The epivariation seen in the MMACHC promoter (0.95 × 10-3) is highly frequent compared to epivariations affecting other genes of the Online Catalog of Human Genes and Genetic Disorders in an epigenome-wide dataset of 23,116 individuals. This and the comparison of epigrams of two monozygotic twins suggest that the aberrant transcription could also be influenced by post-zygotic environmental exposures.

Probing the functional consequence and clinical relevance of CD320 p.E88del, a variant in the transcobalamin receptor gene.

The biological and clinical significance of the p.E88del variant in the transcobalamin receptor, CD320, is unknown. This allele is annotated in ClinVar as likely benign, pathogenic, and of uncertain significance. To determine functional consequence and clinical relevance of this allele, we employed cell culture and genetic association studies. Fibroblasts from 16 CD320 p.E88del homozygotes exhibited reduced binding and uptake of cobalamin. Complete ascertainment of newborns with transiently elevated C3 (propionylcarnitine) in New York State demonstrated that homozygosity for CD320 p.E88del was over-represented (7/348, p < 6 × 10-5 ). Using population data, we estimate that ~85% of the p.E88del homozygotes born in the same period did not have elevated C3, suggesting that cobalamin metabolism in the majority of these infants with this genotype is unaffected. Clinical follow-up of 4/9 homozygous individuals uncovered neuropsychological findings, mostly in speech and language development. None of these nine individuals exhibited perturbation of cobalamin metabolism beyond the newborn stage even during periods of acute illness. Newborns homozygous for this allele in the absence of other factors are at low risk of requiring clinical intervention, although more studies are required to clarify the natural history of various CD320 variants across patient populations.

Mutations in Hcfc1 and Ronin result in an inborn error of cobalamin metabolism and ribosomopathy.

Combined methylmalonic acidemia and homocystinuria (cblC) is the most common inborn error of intracellular cobalamin metabolism and due to mutations in Methylmalonic Aciduria type C and Homocystinuria (MMACHC). Recently, mutations in the transcriptional regulators HCFC1 and RONIN (THAP11) were shown to result in cellular phenocopies of cblC. Since HCFC1/RONIN jointly regulate MMACHC, patients with mutations in these factors suffer from reduced MMACHC expression and exhibit a cblC-like disease. However, additional de-regulated genes and the resulting pathophysiology is unknown. Therefore, we have generated mouse models of this disease. In addition to exhibiting loss of Mmachc, metabolic perturbations, and developmental defects previously observed in cblC, we uncovered reduced expression of target genes that encode ribosome protein subunits. We also identified specific phenotypes that we ascribe to deregulation of ribosome biogenesis impacting normal translation during development. These findings identify HCFC1/RONIN as transcriptional regulators of ribosome biogenesis during development and their mutation results in complex syndromes exhibiting aspects of both cblC and ribosomopathies.

Methionine synthase deficiency: Variable clinical presentation and benefit of early diagnosis and treatment.

Methionine synthase deficiency (cblG complementation group) is a rare inborn error of metabolism affecting the homocysteine re-methylation pathway. It leads to a biochemical phenotype of hyperhomocysteinemia and hypomethioninemia. The clinical presentation of cblG is variable, ranging from seizures, encephalopathy, macrocytic anemia, hypotonia, and feeding difficulties in the neonatal period to onset of psychiatric symptoms or acute neurologic changes in adolescence or adulthood. Given the variable and nonspecific symptoms seen in cblG, the diagnosis of affected patients is often delayed. Medical management of cblG includes the use of hydroxocobalamin, betaine, folinic acid, and in some cases methionine supplementation. Treatment has been shown to lead to improvement in the biochemical profile of affected patients, with lowering of total homocysteine levels and increasing methionine levels. However, the published literature contains differing conclusions on whether treatment is effective in changing the natural history of the disease. Herein, we present five patients with cblG who have shown substantial clinical benefit from treatment with objective improvement in their neurologic outcomes. We demonstrate more favorable outcomes in our patients who were treated early in life, especially those who were treated before neurologic symptoms manifested. Given improved outcomes from treatment of presymptomatic patients, cblG warrants inclusion in newborn screening.

Methionine dependence in tumor cells: The potential role of cobalamin and MMACHC.

Methionine dependence of tumor cell lines, the inability to grow in tissue culture media lacking methionine but supplemented with homocysteine, has been known for decades, but an understanding of the mechanism underlying this phenomenon remains incomplete. Methionine dependence of certain glioma and melanoma cell lines has been linked to alterations in the metabolism of cobalamin (vitamin B12). In the MeWo LC1 melanoma line, complementation analysis demonstrated that the genetic defect affected the same locus mutated in the cblC inborn error of cobalamin metabolism; hypermethylation of the MMACHC promoter was subsequently demonstrated. Analysis of data in the Cancer Cell Line Encyclopedia showed increased MMACHC methylation levels in melanoma lines compared to other types of cancer. RNA sequencing data from isolated tumors, tabulated at the cBioPortal for Cancer Genomics website, showed decreased MMACHC expression compared to other tumors; and methylation data tabulated at the TGGA Wanderer website demonstrated increased MMACHC methylation. These data suggest that disruptions in cobalamin metabolism might play a more general role in methionine dependence, and potentially in the pathogenesis of melanoma cell lines and primary tumors.

Identification of Variants in Alpha-1-Antitrypsin by High Resolution Melting.

BACKGROUND: Alpha-1-antitrypsin deficiency (AATD) is one of the most common hereditary disorders occurring in populations of European origin and is due to variants in SERPINA1, which encodes a protease inhibitor of neutrophil elastase, limiting lung damage from this enzyme. The World Health Organization has recommended that individuals with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and asthma be tested for AATD. The development of inexpensive and simple genetic testing will help to meet this goal. METHODS: Primers and synthetic SERPINA1 gene fragments (gBlocks) were designed for 5 AATD-associated variants. PCR was run on a CFX96 Thermal Cycler with High Resolution Melting (HRM) capacity and data analyzed using the supplied HRM-analysis software. Genomic DNA from individuals (n = 86) genotyped for the S and Z variants were used for validation. HRM-analysis was performed on 3 additional samples with low alpha-1-antitrypsin levels inconsistent with the genotype determined in our clinical laboratory. RESULTS: Unique normalized melt curve and difference curve patterns were identified for the AAT variants Z, S, I, F, and MMalton using gBlocks. Similar curve shapes were seen when these primers were used to analyze the gDNA samples. HRM identified the genotypes of the gDNA correctly with 100% concordance. The curve shapes of some samples did not match the melting patterns of the targeted variant. Sequencing was used to identify the variants, including rare AATD variants c.1108_1115delinsAAAAACA (p.Glu370Lysfs*31) and c.1130dup (p.Leu377fs). CONCLUSION: We developed a rapid and inexpensive HRM-analysis method for genotyping of Z, S, MMalton, I, and F variants that was also capable of detecting other variants.

Correction: Genome and RNA sequencing in patients with methylmalonic aciduria of unknown cause.

An amendment to this paper has been published and can be accessed via a link at the top of the paper.

Immunodeficiency and inborn disorders of vitamin B12 and folate metabolism.

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: Immune dysfunction, including severe combined immunodeficiency, has been described in genetic disorders affecting the metabolism of the vitamins cobalamin (vitamin B12) and folate. We have reviewed reports of clinical findings in patients with a number of inborn errors of cobalamin or folate metabolism, specifically looking for immune problems. RECENT FINDINGS: There is little evidence that immune function is affected in most of the disorders. Exceptions are Imerslund-Gräsbeck syndrome and hereditary folate malabsorption (affecting intestinal absorption of cobalamin and folate, respectively), transcobalamin deficiency (affecting transport of cobalamin in blood and cellular cobalamin uptake), and methylenetetrahydrofolate dehydrogenase 1 deficiency (catalyzing cytoplasmic interconversion of reduced folate coenzyme derivatives). SUMMARY: Although some inborn errors of cobalamin or folate can be associated with immune dysfunction, the degree and type of immune dysfunction vary with no obvious pattern.

Biochemical analysis of patients with mutations in MTHFD1 and a diagnosis of methylenetetrahydrofolate dehydrogenase 1 deficiency.

MTHFD1 is a trifunctional protein containing 10-formyltetrahydrofolate synthetase, 5,10-methenyltetrahydrofolate cyclohydrolase and 5,10-methylenetetrahydrofolate dehydrogenase activities. It is encoded by MTHFD1 and functions in the cytoplasmic folate cycle where it is involved in de novo purine synthesis, synthesis of thymidylate and remethylation of homocysteine to methionine. Since the first reported case of severe combined immunodeficiency resulting from MTHFD1 mutations, seven additional patients ascertained through molecular analysis have been reported with variable phenotypes, including megaloblastic anemia, atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome, hyperhomocysteinemia, microangiopathy, infections and autoimmune diseases. We determined the level of MTHFD1 expression and dehydrogenase specific activity in cell extracts from cultured fibroblasts of three previously reported patients, as well as a patient with megaloblastic anemia and recurrent infections with compound heterozygous MTHFD1 variants that were predicted to be deleterious. MTHFD1 protein expression determined by Western blotting in fibroblast extracts from three of the patients was markedly decreased compared to expression in wild type cells (between 4.8 and 14.3% of mean control values). MTHFD1 expression in the fourth patient was approximately 44% of mean control values. There was no detectable methylenetetrahydrofolate dehydrogenase specific activity in extracts from any of the four patients. This is the first measurement of MTHFD1 function in MTHFD1 deficient patients and confirms the previous molecular diagnoses.

Analysis of fibroblasts from patients with cblC and cblG genetic defects of cobalamin metabolism reveals global dysregulation of alternative splicing.

Vitamin B12 or cobalamin (Cbl) metabolism can be affected by genetic defects leading to defective activity of either methylmalonyl-CoA mutase or methionine synthase or both enzymes. Patients usually present with a wide spectrum of pathologies suggesting that various cellular processes could be affected by modifications in gene expression. We have previously demonstrated that these genetic defects are associated with subcellular mislocalization of RNA-binding proteins (RBP) and subsequent altered nucleo-cytoplasmic shuttling of mRNAs. In order to characterize the possible changes of gene expression in these diseases, we have investigated global gene expression in fibroblasts from patients with cblC and cblG inherited disorders by RNA-seq. The most differentially expressed genes are strongly associated with developmental processes, neurological, ophthalmologic and cardiovascular diseases. These associations are consistent with the clinical presentation of cblC and cblG disorders. Multivariate analysis of transcript processing revaled splicing alterations that led to dramatic changes in cytoskeleton organization, response to stress, methylation of macromolecules and RNA binding. The RNA motifs associated with this differential splicing reflected a potential role of RBP such as HuR and HNRNPL. Proteomic analysis confirmed that mRNA processing was significantly disturbed. This study reports a dramatic alteration of gene expression in fibroblasts of patients with cblC and cblG disorders, which resulted partly from disturbed function of RBP. These data suggest to evaluate the rescue of the mislocalization of RBP as a potential strategy in the treatment of severe cases who are resistant to classical treatments with co-enzyme supplements.

Genome and RNA sequencing in patients with methylmalonic aciduria of unknown cause.

PURPOSE: Our laboratory has classified patients with methylmalonic aciduria using somatic cell studies for over four decades. We have accumulated 127 fibroblast lines from patients with persistent elevated methylmalonic acid (MMA) levels in which no genetic cause could be identified. Cultured fibroblasts from 26 of these patients had low [14C]propionate incorporation into macromolecules, possibly reflecting decreased methylmalonyl-CoA mutase function. METHODS: Genome sequencing (GS), copy-number variation (CNV) analysis, and RNA sequencing were performed on genomic DNA and complementary DNA (cDNA) from these 26 patients. RESULTS: No patient had two pathogenic variants in any gene associated with cobalamin metabolism. Nine patients had heterozygous variants of unknown significance previously identified by a next-generation sequencing (NGS) panel targeting cobalamin metabolic genes. Three patients had pathogenic changes in genes not associated with cobalamin metabolism (PCCA, EPCAM, and a 17q12 duplication) that explain parts of their phenotypes other than elevated MMA. CONCLUSION: Genome and RNA sequencing did not detect any additional putative causal genetic defects in known cobalamin genes following somatic cell studies and the use of a targeted NGS panel. They did detect pathogenic variants in other genes in three patients that explained some aspects of their clinical presentation.

Allosteric Regulation of Oligomerization by a B12 Trafficking G-Protein Is Corrupted in Methylmalonic Aciduria.

Allosteric regulation of methylmalonyl-CoA mutase (MCM) by the G-protein chaperone CblA is transduced via three "switch" elements that gate the movement of the B12 cofactor to and from MCM. Mutations in CblA and MCM cause hereditary methylmalonic aciduria. Unlike the bacterial orthologs used previously to model disease-causing mutations, human MCM and CblA exhibit a complex pattern of regulation that involves interconverting oligomers, which are differentially sensitive to the presence of GTP versus GDP. Patient mutations in the switch III region of CblA perturb the nucleotide-sensitive distribution of the oligomeric complexes with MCM, leading to loss of regulated movement of B12 to and/or from MCM and explain the molecular mechanism of the resulting disease.