[Comment about the policy statement of the MDS. A position statement of the assessment group of the University Witten/Herdecke with regard to nursing documentation]. / Kommentar zur Grundsatzstellungnahme "Pflegeprozess und Dokumentation" des MDS. Positionspapier der Assessmentgruppe, Universität Witten/Herdecke, zur Pflegedokumentation.

In 2005 the Medical Advisory Service of Social Health Insurance (MDS) in Germany published a policy statement with regard to the nursing process and documentation. According to the intention of the association, this statement should be considered as recommendations which are able to improve nursing practice and to contribute to streamlining of bureaucracy in nursing care. Recognising the broad impact of this publication on nursing institutions, a working group on nursing assessment of the University Witten/Herdecke conducted a critical review of the statement. Significant criteria for evaluation were the primary role of nursing documentation, quality requirements for the documentation as well as recent scientific results concerning the implementation of nursing process and assessment-based nursing diagnoses. The review revealed that the statement lacks of a clear rationale and its content appears to be merely research-based. Therefore it has to be questioned if the publication will accomplish the claimed effects. In fact, future quality criteria for health care are to be developed independently on the basis of scientific results and in consideration of the experiences of all concerned social groups.

[Position statement of the National Nursing Assessment Group of Germany: regarding the basic "nutrition and fluid requirements" policy of the elderly by the MDS (Medical Service of the Central Associations of the Health Insurance Companies), July 2003]. / Positionspapier der Nationalen Pflegeassessmentgruppe Deutschland: zur Grundsatzstellungnahme "Ernährung und Flüssigkeitsversorgung älterer Menschen", Abschlussbericht Projektgruppe P 39 des Medizinischen Dienstes der Spitzenverbände der Krankenkassen (MDS), Juli 2003.

Assessing the nutritional state of old and dependent people demands a distinctive consideration of all aspects which might influence the individual's nutritional habits. An isolated consideration of the body mass index (BMI) does not serve the needs of elderly, because the BMI seems not to be a valid indicator for their nutrtional state. In order to prove the risk of malnutrition, also the individual life conditions as well as social, religious, cultural and economic circumstances besides the amount of energy and nu triments are to be taken into account.