Impact of Synergy Partner Cel7B on Cel7A Binding Rates: Insights from Single-Molecule Data.

Enzymatic degradation of cellulosic biomass is a well-established route for the sustainable production of biofuels, chemicals, and materials. A strategy employed by nature and industry to achieve an efficient degradation of cellulose is that cellobiohydrolases (or exocellulases), such as Cel7A, work synergistically with endoglucanases, such as Cel7B, to achieve the complete degradation of cellulose. However, a complete mechanistic understanding of this exo-endo synergy is still lacking. Here, we used single-molecule fluorescence microscopy to quantify the binding kinetics of Cel7A on cellulose when it is acting alone on the cellulose fibrils and in the presence of its synergy partner, the endoglucanase Cel7B. To this end, we used a fluorescently tagged Cel7A and studied its binding in the presence of the unlabeled Cel7B. This provided the single-molecule data necessary for the estimation of the rate constants of association kON and dissociation kOFF of Cel7A for the substrate. We show that the presence of Cel7B does not impact the dissociation rate constant, kOFF. But, the association rate of Cel7A decreases by a factor of 2 when Cel7B is present at a molar proportion of 10:1. This ratio has previously been shown to lead to synergy. This decrease in association rate is observed in a wide range of total enzyme concentrations, from sub nM to µM concentrations. This decrease in kON is consistent with the formation of cellulase clusters recently observed by others using atomic force microscopy.

A comparative biochemical investigation of the impeding effect of C1-oxidizing LPMOs on cellobiohydrolases.

Lytic polysaccharide monooxygenases (LPMOs) are known to act synergistically with glycoside hydrolases in industrial cellulolytic cocktails. However, a few studies have reported severe impeding effects of C1-oxidizing LPMOs on the activity of reducing-end cellobiohydrolases. The mechanism for this effect remains unknown, but it may have important implications as reducing-end cellobiohydrolases make up a significant part of such cocktails. To elucidate whether the impeding effect is general for different reducing-end cellobiohydrolases and study the underlying mechanism, we conducted a comparative biochemical investigation of the cooperation between a C1-oxidizing LPMO from Thielavia terrestris and three reducing-end cellobiohydrolases; Trichoderma reesei (TrCel7A), T. terrestris (TtCel7A), and Myceliophthora heterothallica (MhCel7A). The enzymes were heterologously expressed in the same organism and thoroughly characterized biochemically. The data showed distinct differences in synergistic effects between the LPMO and the cellobiohydrolases; TrCel7A was severely impeded, TtCel7A was moderately impeded, while MhCel7A was slightly boosted by the LPMO. We investigated effects of C1-oxidations on cellulose chains on the activity of the cellobiohydrolases and found reduced activity against oxidized cellulose in steady-state and pre-steady-state experiments. The oxidations led to reduced maximal velocity of the cellobiohydrolases and reduced rates of substrate complexation. The extent of these effects differed for the cellobiohydrolases and scaled with the extent of the impeding effect observed in the synergy experiments. Based on these results, we suggest that C1-oxidized chain ends are poor attack sites for reducing-end cellobiohydrolases. The severity of the impeding effects varied considerably among the cellobiohydrolases, which may be relevant to consider for optimization of industrial cocktails.

Removal of N-linked glycans in cellobiohydrolase Cel7A from Trichoderma reesei reveals higher activity and binding affinity on crystalline cellulose.

BACKGROUND: Cellobiohydrolase from glycoside hydrolase family 7 is a major component of commercial enzymatic mixtures for lignocellulosic biomass degradation. For many years, Trichoderma reesei Cel7A (TrCel7A) has served as a model to understand structure-function relationships of processive cellobiohydrolases. The architecture of TrCel7A includes an N-glycosylated catalytic domain, which is connected to a carbohydrate-binding module through a flexible, O-glycosylated linker. Depending on the fungal expression host, glycosylation can vary not only in glycoforms, but also in site occupancy, leading to a complex pattern of glycans, which can affect the enzyme's stability and kinetics. RESULTS: Two expression hosts, Aspergillus oryzae and Trichoderma reesei, were utilized to successfully express wild-types TrCel7A (WT Ao and WT Tr ) and the triple N-glycosylation site deficient mutants TrCel7A N45Q, N270Q, N384Q (ΔN-glyc Ao and ΔN-glyc Tr ). Also, we expressed single N-glycosylation site deficient mutants TrCel7A (N45Q Ao , N270Q Ao , N384Q Ao ). The TrCel7A enzymes were studied by steady-state kinetics under both substrate- and enzyme-saturating conditions using different cellulosic substrates. The Michaelis constant (K M ) was consistently found to be lowered for the variants with reduced N-glycosylation content, and for the triple deficient mutants, it was less than half of the WTs' value on some substrates. The ability of the enzyme to combine productively with sites on the cellulose surface followed a similar pattern on all tested substrates. Thus, site density (number of sites per gram cellulose) was 30-60% higher for the single deficient variants compared to the WT, and about twofold larger for the triple deficient enzyme. Molecular dynamic simulation of the N-glycan mutants TrCel7A revealed higher number of contacts between CD and cellulose crystal upon removal of glycans at position N45 and N384. CONCLUSIONS: The kinetic changes of TrCel7A imposed by removal of N-linked glycans reflected modifications of substrate accessibility. The presence of N-glycans with extended structures increased K M and decreased attack site density of TrCel7A likely due to steric hindrance effect and distance between the enzyme and the cellulose surface, preventing the enzyme from achieving optimal conformation. This knowledge could be applied to modify enzyme glycosylation to engineer enzyme with higher activity on the insoluble substrates.

A steady-state approach for inhibition of heterogeneous enzyme reactions.

The kinetic theory of enzymes that modify insoluble substrates is still underdeveloped, despite the prevalence of this type of reaction both in vivo and industrial applications. Here, we present a steady-state kinetic approach to investigate inhibition occurring at the solid-liquid interface. We propose to conduct experiments under enzyme excess (E0 ≫ S0), i.e. the opposite limit compared with the conventional Michaelis-Menten framework. This inverse condition is practical for insoluble substrates and elucidates how the inhibitor reduces enzyme activity through binding to the substrate. We claim that this type of inhibition is common for interfacial enzyme reactions because substrate accessibility is low, and we show that it can be analyzed by experiments and rate equations that are analogous to the conventional approach, except that the roles of enzyme and substrate have been swapped. To illustrate the approach, we investigated the major cellulases from Trichoderma reesei (Cel6A and Cel7A) acting on insoluble cellulose. As model inhibitors, we used catalytically inactive variants of Cel6A and Cel7A. We made so-called inverse Michaelis-Menten curves at different concentrations of inhibitors and found that a new rate equation accounted well for the data. In most cases, we found a mixed type of surface-site inhibition mechanism, and this probably reflected that the inhibitor both competed with the enzyme for the productive binding-sites (competitive inhibition) and hampered the processive movement on the surface (uncompetitive inhibition). These results give new insights into the complex interplay of Cel7A and Cel6A on cellulose and the approach may be applicable to other heterogeneous enzyme reactions.

Substrate binding in the processive cellulase Cel7A: Transition state of complexation and roles of conserved tryptophan residues.

Cellobiohydrolases effectively degrade cellulose and are of biotechnological interest because they can convert lignocellulosic biomass to fermentable sugars. Here, we implemented a fluorescence-based method for real-time measurements of complexation and decomplexation of the processive cellulase Cel7A and its insoluble substrate, cellulose. The method enabled detailed kinetic and thermodynamic analyses of ligand binding in a heterogeneous system. We studied WT Cel7A and several variants in which one or two of four highly conserved Trp residues in the binding tunnel had been replaced with Ala. WT Cel7A had on/off-rate constants of 1 × 105 m-1 s-1 and 5 × 10-3 s-1, respectively, reflecting the slow dynamics of a solid, polymeric ligand. Especially the off-rate constant was many orders of magnitude lower than typical values for small, soluble ligands. Binding rate and strength both were typically lower for the Trp variants, but effects of the substitutions were moderate and sometimes negligible. Hence, we propose that lowering the activation barrier for complexation is not a major driving force for the high conservation of the Trp residues. Using so-called Φ-factor analysis, we analyzed the kinetic and thermodynamic results for the variants. The results of this analysis suggested a transition state for complexation and decomplexation in which the reducing end of the ligand is close to the tunnel entrance (near Trp-40), whereas the rest of the binding tunnel is empty. We propose that this structure defines the highest free-energy barrier of the overall catalytic cycle and hence governs the turnover rate of this industrially important enzyme.

Structural and biochemical characterization of a family 7 highly thermostable endoglucanase from the fungus Rasamsonia emersonii.

Thermostable cellulases from glycoside hydrolase family 7 (GH7) are the main components of enzymatic mixtures for industrial saccharification of lignocellulose. Activity improvement of these enzymes via rational design is a promising strategy to alleviate the industrial costs, but it requires detailed structural knowledge. While substantial biochemical and structural data are available for GH7 cellobiohydrolases, endoglucanases are more elusive and only few structures have been solved so far. Here, we report a new crystal structure and biochemical characterization of a thermostable endoglucanase from the thermophilic ascomycete Rasamsonia emersonii, ReCel7B. The enzyme was compared with the homologous endoglucanase from the mesophilic model ascomycete Trichoderma reesei (TrCel7B), which unlike ReCel7B possesses an additional carbohydrate-binding module (CBM). With a temperature optimum of 80 °C, ReCel7B displayed a number of differences in activity and ability to synergize with cellobiohydrolases compared to TrCel7B. We improved both binding and kinetics in a chimeric variant of ReCel7B and a CBM, while we observe the opposite effect when the CBM was removed in TrCel7B. The crystal structure of ReCel7B was determined at 2.48 Å resolution, with Rwork and Rfree factors of 0.182 and 0.206, respectively. Structural analyses revealed that ReCel7B has increased rigidity in a number of peripheral loops compared to TrCel7B and fewer aromatics in the substrate-binding cleft. An increased number of glycosylations were identified in ReCel7B, and we propose a stabilizing mechanism for one of the glycans. Global structure-function interpretations of ReCel7B highlight the differences in temperature stability, turnover, binding, and cellulose accessibility in GH7 endoglucanases. DATABASE: Structural data are available in RCSB Protein Data Bank database under the accession number 6SU8. ENZYMES: ReCel7B, endoglucanase (EC3.2.1.4) from Rasamsonia emersonii; ReCel7A, cellobiohydrolase (EC3.2.1.176) from Rasamsonia emersonii; TrCel7B, endoglucanase (EC3.2.1.4) from Trichoderma reesei; TrCel7A, cellobiohydrolase (EC3.2.1.176) from Trichoderma reesei.

Systematic deletions in the cellobiohydrolase (CBH) Cel7A from the fungus Trichoderma reesei reveal flexible loops critical for CBH activity.

Glycoside hydrolase family 7 (GH7) cellulases are some of the most efficient degraders of cellulose, making them particularly relevant for industries seeking to produce renewable fuels from lignocellulosic biomass. The secretome of the cellulolytic model fungus Trichoderma reesei contains two GH7s, termed TrCel7A and TrCel7B. Despite having high structural and sequence similarities, the two enzymes are functionally quite different. TrCel7A is an exolytic, processive cellobiohydrolase (CBH), with high activity on crystalline cellulose, whereas TrCel7B is an endoglucanase (EG) with a preference for more amorphous cellulose. At the structural level, these functional differences are usually ascribed to the flexible loops that cover the substrate-binding areas. TrCel7A has an extensive tunnel created by eight peripheral loops, and the absence of four of these loops in TrCel7B makes its catalytic domain a more open cleft. To investigate the structure-function relationships of these loops, here we produced and kinetically characterized several variants in which four loops unique to TrCel7A were individually deleted to resemble the arrangement in the TrCel7B structure. Analysis of a range of kinetic parameters consistently indicated that the B2 loop, covering the substrate-binding subsites -3 and -4 in TrCel7A, was a key determinant for the difference in CBH- or EG-like behavior between TrCel7A and TrCel7B. Conversely, the B3 and B4 loops, located closer to the catalytic site in TrCel7A, were less important for these activities. We surmise that these results could be useful both in further mechanistic investigations and for guiding engineering efforts of this industrially important enzyme family.

The influence of different linker modifications on the catalytic activity and cellulose affinity of cellobiohydrolase Cel7A from Hypocrea jecorina.

Various cellulases consist of a catalytic domain connected to a carbohydrate-binding module (CBM) by a flexible linker peptide. The linker if often strongly O-glycosylated and typically has a length of 20-50 amino acid residues. Functional roles, other than connecting the two folded domains, of the linker and its glycans, have been widely discussed, but experimental evidence remains sparse. One of the most studied cellulose degrading enzymes is the multi-domain cellobiohydrolase Cel7A from Hypocrea jecorina. Here, we designed variants of Cel7A with mutations in the linker region to elucidate the role of the linker. We found that moderate modification of the linker could result in significant changes in substrate affinity and catalytic efficacy. These changes were quite different for different linker variants. Thus, deletion of six residues near the catalytic domain had essentially no effects on enzyme function. Conversely, a substitution of four glycosylation sites near the middle of the linker reduced substrate affinity and increased maximal turnover. The observation of weaker binding provides some support of recent suggestions that linker glycans may be directly involved in substrate interactions. However, a variant with several inserted glycosylation sites near the CBM also showed lower affinity for the substrate compared to the wild-type, and we suggest that substrate interactions of the glycans depend on their exact location as well as other factors such as changes in structure and dynamics of the linker peptide.

Loop variants of the thermophile Rasamsonia emersonii Cel7A with improved activity against cellulose.

Cel7A cellobiohydrolases perform processive hydrolysis on one strand of cellulose, which is threaded through the enzyme's substrate binding tunnel. The tunnel structure results from a groove in the catalytic domain, which is covered by a number of loops. These loops have been identified as potential targets for engineering of this industrially important enzyme family, but only few systematic studies on this have been made. Here we show that two asparagine residues (N194 and N197) positioned in the loop covering the glucopyranose subsite -4 (recently denoted B2 loop) of the thermostable Cel7A from Rasamsonia emersonii had profound effects on both substrate interactions and catalytic efficacy. At room temperature the double mutant N194A/N197A showed strongly reduced substrate affinity with a water-cellulose partitioning coefficient threefold lower than the wild type. Yet, this variant was catalytically efficient with a maximal turnover about twice as high as the wild type. Analogous but smaller changes were found for the single mutants. Analysis of these changes in affinity and kinetics as a function of temperature, led to the conclusion that replacement of N194 and particularly N197 with alanine leads to faster enzyme-substrate dissociation. Conversely, these residues appeared to have little or no effect on the rate of association. We suggest that the controlled adjustment of the enzyme-substrate dissociation prompts faster cellulolytic enzymes. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2017;114: 53-62. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Free Energy Diagram for the Heterogeneous Enzymatic Hydrolysis of Glycosidic Bonds in Cellulose.

Kinetic and thermodynamic data have been analyzed according to transition state theory and a simplified reaction scheme for the enzymatic hydrolysis of insoluble cellulose. For the cellobiohydrolase Cel7A from Hypocrea jecorina (Trichoderma reesei), we were able to measure or collect relevant values for all stable and activated complexes defined by the reaction scheme and hence propose a free energy diagram for the full heterogeneous process. For other Cel7A enzymes, including variants with and without carbohydrate binding module (CBM), we obtained activation parameters for the association and dissociation of the enzyme-substrate complex. The results showed that the kinetics of enzyme-substrate association (i.e. formation of the Michaelis complex) was almost entirely entropy-controlled and that the activation entropy corresponded approximately to the loss of translational and rotational degrees of freedom of the dissolved enzyme. This implied that the transition state occurred early in the path where the enzyme has lost these degrees of freedom but not yet established extensive contact interactions in the binding tunnel. For dissociation, a similar analysis suggested that the transition state was late in the path where most enzyme-substrate contacts were broken. Activation enthalpies revealed that the rate of dissociation was far more temperature-sensitive than the rates of both association and the inner catalytic cycle. Comparisons of one- and two-domain variants showed that the CBM had no influence on the transition state for association but increased the free energy barrier for dissociation. Hence, the CBM appeared to promote the stability of the complex by delaying dissociation rather than accelerating association.

Temperature Effects on Kinetic Parameters and Substrate Affinity of Cel7A Cellobiohydrolases.

We measured hydrolytic rates of four purified cellulases in small increments of temperature (10-50 °C) and substrate loads (0-100 g/liter) and analyzed the data by a steady state kinetic model that accounts for the processive mechanism. We used wild type cellobiohydrolases (Cel7A) from mesophilic Hypocrea jecorina and thermophilic Rasamsonia emersonii and two variants of these enzymes designed to elucidate the role of the carbohydrate binding module (CBM). We consistently found that the maximal rate increased strongly with temperature, whereas the affinity for the insoluble substrate decreased, and as a result, the effect of temperature depended strongly on the substrate load. Thus, temperature had little or no effect on the hydrolytic rate in dilute substrate suspensions, whereas strong temperature activation (Q10 values up to 2.6) was observed at saturating substrate loads. The CBM had a dual effect on the activity. On one hand, it diminished the tendency of heat-induced desorption, but on the other hand, it had a pronounced negative effect on the maximal rate, which was 2-fold larger in variants without CBM throughout the investigated temperature range. We conclude that although the CBM is beneficial for affinity it slows down the catalytic process. Cel7A from the thermophilic organism was moderately more activated by temperature than the mesophilic analog. This is in accord with general theories on enzyme temperature adaptation and possibly relevant information for the selection of technical cellulases.

A pyranose dehydrogenase-based biosensor for kinetic analysis of enzymatic hydrolysis of cellulose by cellulases.

A novel electrochemical enzyme biosensor was developed for real-time detection of cellulase activity when acting on their natural insoluble substrate, cellulose. The enzyme biosensor was constructed with pyranose dehydrongease (PDH) from Agaricus meleagris that was immobilized on the surface of a carbon paste electrode, which contained the mediator 2,6-dichlorophenolindophenol (DCIP). An oxidation current of the reduced form of DCIP, DCIPH2, produced by the PDH-catalyzed reaction with either glucose or cellobiose, was recorded under constant-potential amperometry at +0.25V (vs. Ag/AgCl). The PDH-biosensor was shown to be anomer unspecific and it can therefore be used in kinetic studies over broad time-scales of both retaining- and inverting cellulases (in addition to enzyme cocktails). The biosensor was used for real-time measurements of the activity of the inverting cellobiohydrolase Cel6A from Hypocrea jecorina (HjCel6A) on cellulosic substrates with different morphology (bacterial microcrystalline cellulose (BMCC) and Avicel). The steady-state rate of hydrolysis increased towards a saturation plateau with increasing loads of substrate. The experimental results were rationalized using a steady-state rate equation for processive cellulases, and it was found that the turnover for HjCel6A at saturating substrate concentration (i.e. maximal apparent specific activity) was similar (0.39-0.40s(-1)) for the two substrates. Conversely, the substrate load at half-saturation was much lower for BMCC compared to Avicel. Biosensors covered with a polycarbonate membrane showed high operational stability of several weeks with daily use.