Value in Acute Care Surgery, Part 3: Defining Value in Acute Surgical Care - It Depends on the Perspective.

ABSTRACT: The prior articles in this series have focused on measuring cost and quality in acute care surgery. This third article in the series explains the current ways of defining value in acute care surgery, based on different stakeholders in the healthcare system - the patient, the healthcare organization, the payer and society. The heterogenous valuations of the different stakeholders require that the framework for determining high-value care in acute care surgery incorporates all viewpoints.

A Case of Delayed Cecal Perforation After Abdominal (Seat Belt) Injury.

Seatbelts have reduced the number of fatal head, facial, and chest injuries. They have, however, introduced a set of injuries comprising abdominal wall bruising, Intra-abdominal injuries, and lumbar spine fractures collectively termed the seat belt syndrome. Surgical repair is the treatment for encountered bowel injuries. We present a case of delayed bowel perforation following presentation with signs of seat belt trauma identifying a decisional dilemma in the surgical management of serosal tears with no apparent signs of perforation.

Value in acute care surgery, Part 1: Methods of quantifying cost.

BACKGROUND: With health care expenditures continuing to increase rapidly, the need to understand and provide value has become more important than ever. In order to determine the value of care, the ability to accurately measure cost is essential. The acute care surgeon leader is an integral part of driving improvement by engaging in value increasing discussions. Different approaches to quantifying cost exist depending on the purpose of the analysis and available resources. Cost analysis methods range from detailed microcosting and time-driven activity-based costing to less complex gross and expenditure-based approaches. An overview of these methods and a practical approach to costing based on the needs of the acute care surgeon leader is presented.

The economic footprint of acute care surgery in the United States: Implications for systems development.

BACKGROUND: Acute care surgery (ACS) comprises trauma, surgical critical care, and emergency general surgery (EGS), encompassing both operative and nonoperative conditions. While the burden of EGS and trauma has been separately considered, the global footprint of ACS has not been fully characterized. We sought to characterize the costs and scope of influence of ACS-related conditions. We hypothesized that ACS patients comprise a substantial portion of the US inpatient population. We further hypothesized that ACS patients differ from other surgical and non-surgical patients across patient characteristics. METHODS: We queried the National Inpatient Sample 2014, a nationally representative database for inpatient hospitalizations. To capture all adult ACS patients, we included adult admissions with any International Classification of Diseases-9th Rev.-Clinical Modification diagnosis of trauma or an International Classification of Diseases-9th Rev.-Clinical Modification diagnosis for one of the 16 AAST-defined EGS conditions. Weighted patient data were presented to provide national estimates. RESULTS: Of the 29.2 million adult patients admitted to US hospitals, approximately 5.9 million (20%) patients had an ACS diagnosis. ACS patients accounted for US $85.8 billion, or 25% of total US inpatient costs (US $341 billion). When comparing ACS to non-ACS inpatient populations, ACS patients had higher rates of health care utilization with longer lengths of stay (5.9 days vs. 4.5 days, p < 0.001), and higher mean costs (US $14,466 vs. US $10,951, p < 0.001. Of all inpatients undergoing an operative procedure, 27% were patients with an ACS diagnosis. Overall, 3,186 (70%) of US hospitals cared for both trauma and EGS patients. CONCLUSION: Acute care surgery patients comprise 20% of the inpatient population, but 25% of total inpatient costs in the United States. In addition to being costly, they overall have higher health care utilization and worse outcomes. This suggests that there is an opportunity to improve clinical trajectory for ACS patients that in turn, can affect the overall US health care costs. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Epidemiologic, level III.

Promoting use of booster seats in rural areas through community sports programs.

BACKGROUND: Booster seats reduce mortality and morbidity for young children in car crashes, but use is low, particularly in rural areas. This study targeted rural communities in 4 states using a community sports-based approach. OBJECTIVE: The Strike Out Child Passenger Injury (Strike Out) intervention incorporated education about booster seat use in children ages 4-7 years within instructional baseball programs. We tested the effectiveness of Strike Out in increasing correct restraint use among participating children. METHODS: Twenty communities with similar demographics from 4 states participated in a nonrandomized, controlled trial. Surveys of restraint use were conducted before and after baseball season. Intervention communities received tailored education and parents had direct consultation on booster seat use. Control communities received only brochures. RESULTS: One thousand fourteen preintervention observation surveys for children ages 4-7 years (Intervention Group [I]: N = 511, Control [C]: N = 503) and 761 postintervention surveys (I: N = 409, C: N = 352) were obtained. For 3 of 4 states, the intervention resulted in increases in recommended child restraint use (Alabama +15.5%, Arkansas +16.1%, Illinois +11.0%). Communities in 1 state (Indiana) did not have a positive response (-9.2%). Overall, unadjusted restraint use increased 10.2% in intervention and 1.7% in control communities (P = .02). After adjustment for each state in the study, booster seat use was increased in intervention communities (Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel odds ratio 1.56, 95% confidence interval [1.16-2.10]). CONCLUSIONS: A tailored intervention using baseball programs increased appropriate restraint use among targeted rural children overall and in 3 of 4 states studied. Such interventions hold promise for expansion into other sports and populations.

The utility of computed tomography as a screening tool for the evaluation of pediatric blunt chest trauma.

BACKGROUND: There is a growing concern that computed tomography (CT) is being unnecessarily overused for the evaluation of pediatric patients. The purpose of this study was to analyze the trends and utility of chest CT use compared with chest X-ray (CXR) for the evaluation of children with blunt chest trauma. METHODS: A 4-year retrospective review was performed for pediatric patients who underwent chest CT within 24 hours of sustaining blunt trauma at a Level-I trauma center. Trends in the use of CT and CXR were documented, and results of radiology reports were analyzed and compared with clinical outcomes. RESULTS: Three hundred thirty-three children, mean age 11 years, had chest CTs, increasing from 5.5% in 2001-2002 to 10.5% in 2004-2005 (p < 0.001). Conversely, in those children who underwent chest CT, the rate of initial CXR use decreased from 84% to 56% during the same period (p < 0.001). Twenty percent of chest CTs had significant positive findings. Six patients underwent emergency surgery for cardiac or arterial injuries, and all demonstrated abnormal findings on CXR or CT scout imaging. When compared with the CT, only 5% of initial CXRs falsely reported normal findings that may have altered management. CONCLUSIONS: CT use in children has increased rapidly for the initial evaluation of chest trauma, whereas CXR use has decreased. Despite this trend, CXR remains an acceptable screening tool to analyze which patients may require CT evaluation. A multidisciplinary approach is warranted to develop guidelines that standardize the use of CT and thereby decreases unnecessary radiation exposure to pediatric patients.

Analysis of nonfatal dog bites in children.

BACKGROUND: Dog bites are a significant public health problem among children. The purpose of this study was to examine the hospital incidence, hospital charges, and characteristics of dog bite injuries among children by age group and hospitalization status who were treated at our health care system to guide prevention programs and policies. METHODS: An electronic hospital database identified all patients younger than 18 years who were treated for dog bites from 1999 to 2006. Demographics, injury information, hospital admission status, length of stay, hospital charges, and payer source were collected. A further review of the narrative part of the inpatient electronic database was examined to identify owner of the dog, type of dog, and circumstances surrounding the incident. RESULTS: During 8 years, 1,347 children younger than 18 years were treated for dog bites. The majority were treated and released from the emergency department (91%). Of the 66 children (4.9%) requiring inpatient admission, the median length of stay was 2 days. Victims were frequently male (56.9%) and <8 years (55.2%). Children younger than 5 years represented 34% of all dog bite victims, but 50% of all children requiring hospitalization. Thirty-seven percent of all children admitted to the hospital were bitten by a family dog. The cost of direct medical care during the study was $2.15 million. CONCLUSION: Dog bite visits comprised 1.5% of all pediatric injuries treated in our hospital system during the study period. The majority (91%) of all dog bite visits were treated and released from the emergency department. Injuries to the head/neck region increased the odds of requiring 23 hour observation (OR, 1.95) and age less than 5 years increased the odds of being admitted as an inpatient (OR, 3.3).

Steroids and poor nutrition are associated with infectious wound complications in children undergoing first stage procedures for ulcerative colitis.

BACKGROUND: Risk factors for postoperative infections have not been evaluated in pediatric patients with ulcerative colitis (UC). This review was undertaken to evaluate the effects of immunosuppressive therapy and other preoperative factors on infectious wound complications in children undergoing first stage surgical therapy for UC. METHODS: A 10-year retrospective review of children under 18 years of age receiving first stage surgical therapy for UC at a major children's hospital was performed. Preoperative clinical and treatment variables were identified and correlated with postoperative wound complications. RESULTS: A total of 51 children were identified: 19 underwent colectomy with ileo-anal-pouch anastomosis and 32 underwent total abdominal colectomy with Hartmann's pouch. A total of 20 infectious complications were identified in 18 patients. Preoperative steroid use was associated with a greater postoperative wound infection rate. Preoperative hemoglobin less than 10 g/dL (P < .05) and albumin less than 3 g/dL (P = 0.1) were associated with greater rates of postoperative infection. Preoperative body mass index and other immunosuppressive agents did not influence postoperative infectious morbidity. CONCLUSIONS: The majority of pediatric patients who require operative intervention for UC are debilitated from their disease and medication use. Children with normal serum albumin and hemoglobin who are not on steroid therapy have a low risk of postoperative infectious complications.

Pediatric blunt abdominal injury: age is irrelevant and delayed operation is not detrimental.

BACKGROUND: During the past 40 years, management of solid organ injury in pediatric trauma patients has shifted to highly successful nonoperative management. Our purpose was to characterize children requiring operative intervention. We hypothesized that older children would be more likely to require operative intervention. In particular, we wanted to examine potential outcome disparities between children who were operated upon immediately and those in whom attempted nonoperative management failed. Additionally, we asked whether attempted nonoperative management, when failed, put children at higher risk for mortality or morbidities such as increased blood product transfusions or lengths of stays. METHODS: Retrospective cohorts from seven Level I pediatric trauma centers were identified. Blunt splenic, hepatic, renal, or pancreatic injuries were documented in 2,944 children <1 to 19 years of age from January 1993 to December 2002. Data collected included demographics, hemodynamics, blood transfusions, Glasgow Coma Scale score, Injury Severity Score, hospital length of stay (LOS), intensive care unit (ICU) LOS, and mortality. Analysis involved 140 (4.8%) of 2,944 patients requiring operation. Two cohorts were characterized: (1) immediate operation (IO), defined as laparotomy 3 hours after arrival (n = 59; 42%). RESULTS: Comparing the two cohorts, no age differences were found. Compared with F-NOM, IO had significantly worse hemodynamics, Injury Severity Score, and Glasgow Coma Scale score and was associated with liver injuries. Pancreatic injuries were significantly associated with F-NOM. While controlling for injury severity to compare IO versus F-NOM, linear regression revealed equivalent blood transfusions, ICU LOS, hospital LOS, and mortality rates. CONCLUSION: IO and F-NOM are rare events and independent of age. When operated upon for appropriate physiology, the timing of operation in pediatric solid organ injury is irrelevant and not detrimental with respect to blood transfusion, mortality, ICU and hospital LOS, and resource utilization.

Incidence of abdominal wall defects is related to surface water atrazine and nitrate levels.

BACKGROUND: Gastroschisis and omphalocele are congenital abdominal wall defects (AWD). Atrazine and nitrates are common agricultural fertilizers. METHODS: The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention natality data set was used to collect data for patients with AWD born between January 1990 and December 2002. Similar data were obtained from the Indiana State Department of Health. An estimated date of conception was calculated by birth date and gestational age. Surface water nitrate and atrazine levels for Indiana were collected from US Geological Survey data. Midwest was defined as Indiana, Illinois, Iowa, Ohio, and Nebraska. Statistical analysis was performed by chi2 test and Pearson correlation for P < or = .05. RESULTS: The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention identified 9871 children with AWD in 1990 and in 1995-2001 of 35,876,519 live births (rate 2.75/10(5)). In Indiana, 358 children from 1990-2001 had AWD of 1,013,286 live births (rate 3.53/10(5)). The AWD rate in Indiana was significantly higher than the national rate in 1996 (P = .0377), 1998 (P = .0005), and 2001 (P = .0365) and significantly higher than the Midwest rate in 1998 (P = .0104). Monthly comparison demonstrated a positive correlation of AWD rate and mean atrazine levels (P = .0125). CONCLUSION: Indiana has significantly higher rates of AWD compared with national rates. Increased atrazine levels correlate with increased incidence of AWD.

Incidence of persistent left superior vena cava in esophageal atresia.

PURPOSE: Esophageal atresia is known to be associated with a variety of additional congenital anomalies in multiple organ systems. Emphasis on cardiovascular anomalies has been focused on aortic arch and intrinsic cardiac malformations. Persistent left superior vena cava (PLSVC) is the most common venous thoracic anomaly in the general population and creates a problem when central venous access is required. This review was undertaken to define the incidence of PLSVC in infants with esophageal atresia and to determine if any subgroup of associated anomalies poses additional risk. METHODS: A retrospective, institutional review board-approved review of all children treated for esophageal atresia from 1993 to 2002 at Riley Hospital for Children was undertaken. Of 118 children, 89 had sufficient data for inclusion. Charts were reviewed for gestational age, weight, type of atresia, echocardiogram, and associated anomalies. Statistical analysis was performed using the Fisher's Exact test. RESULTS: Of 89 children, 8 (9.9%; confidence interval, 4%-17%) had PLSVC compared with the reported incidence of 0.3% in the general population. Presence of additional organ system anomalies did not significantly increase relative risk for PLSVC. CONCLUSION: The incidence of PLSVC is significantly increased in children with esophageal atresia when compared with the general population. This increased incidence of PLSVC is not influenced by the presence of cardiac or other associated anomalies. This finding should be kept in mind when central venous access is required in this patient population.

Long-term outcomes in patients with stage IV neuroblastoma.

AIM OF STUDY: Long-term outcome studies in survivors with stage IV neuroblastoma (NB) are sparse. This review evaluates late complications and long-term outcomes in stage IV NB survivors. METHODS: A retrospective review of stage IV NB survivors was performed to analyze outcomes, including long-term morbidity, recurrence, and survival. MAIN RESULTS: Of 153 patients with stage IV NB, 52 (34%) survived (male-female, 26:26). Age at diagnosis was 29.1 +/- 31.7 months in survivors. Eighteen were 1 year or younger and 34 were older than 1 year compared with 10 nonsurvivors 1 year or younger and 91 older than 1 year (P = .0003, Fisher's Exact test). Primary tumor sites were adrenal (35), retroperitoneal (11), mediastinal (3), pelvic (2), and no primary with tumor metastases identified (1). Ten survivors had favorable and 16 had unfavorable histology compared with 1 favorable and 18 unfavorable in nonsurvivors (P = .01). Four survivors had MYCN amplification (> or = 10 copies) and 2 deletions of 1p and 11q. Sites of metastasis in survivors and nonsurvivors were similar. Treatment in survivors included surgery in 51 (75% [39/51] complete tumor resection [CTR]); chemotherapy, 50; radiation, 17; stem cell transplantation, 20; and bone marrow transplant, 1. In nonsurvivors, 13 (25%) of 53 (P < < .0001) had CTR, 18 stem cell transplantation, and 12 bone marrow transplant. Six patients had tumor recurrence but survived (mean, 9.3 +/- 8.3 years; range, 6 months-24 years). Recurrence was local (1), distant (2), and both (3) and was treated by resection, chemotherapy, and radiation. The mean age of survivors was 12.4 +/- 8.3 years (range, 2-34 years). In all stage IV cases, event-free survival was 30% and overall survival was 34%. Long-term complications occurred in 23 (44%) survivors, including endocrine disturbances (7), orthopedic (5), cataracts (2), adhesive bowel obstruction (2), hypertension (1), bronchiolitis (1), blindness (1), peripheral neuropathy (1), nonfunctioning kidney (1), cholelithiasis (1), and thyroid nodule (1). CONCLUSION: Only 34% of patients with stage IV NB survived despite aggressive multimodal therapy. Age of younger than 1 year, favorable pathology, CTR, and no recurrence were the only statistically significant factors that favored survival. Forty-four percent of survivors experienced late morbidity, and tumor recurred in 6 (11.5%) of 52. Patients should be monitored for tumor recurrence and long-term sequelae. New methods of treatment are required to achieve better outcomes.

Surgical considerations in cystic fibrosis: a 32-year evaluation of outcomes.

BACKGROUND: Information concerning long-term operative outcomes in patients with cystic fibrosis (CF) is relatively sparse in the operative literature. METHODS: A retrospective review of CF patients with operative conditions was performed (1972-2004) at a tertiary children's hospital to analyze outcomes including long-term morbidity and survival. RESULTS: A total of 226 patients with CF presented with an operative diagnosis (113 men, 113 women). A total of 422 operations were performed in 213 patients (94%). The mean age at operation was 4.1 +/- 6.2 years (range, 1 d to 26 y) and 109 were neonates. Fifteen of 42 (36%) babies with simple meconium ileus (MI) were treated nonoperatively with hypertonic enemas, 27 of 42 and all 45 patients with complicated MI required operation, including 15 with jejunoileal atresia (17%). Seventeen of 27 (63%) patients with meconium ileus equivalent had MI as neonates; 7 of 27 (26%) required operation. Eight of 9 (89%) with fibrosing colonopathy required operation. Organ transplantation was required in 21 patients. Follow-up evaluation was possible in 204 of 213 (96%) patients. The duration of follow-up evaluation was 14.9 +/- 8.5 years (range, 2 mo to 35 y). Operative morbidity was 11% at 1 year, 2% at 2 to 4 years, 1% at 5 to 10 years, and less than 1% at more than 10 years. There were 24 deaths (11%); 22 followed CF-related pulmonary complications and included 8 of 16 (50%) children with pneumothorax. CONCLUSIONS: Long-term survival in CF patients has improved significantly (89%), with many surviving into the fourth decade. MI may predispose to late complications including meconium ileus equivalent and fibrosing colonopathy. Pneumothorax in CF patients is an ominous predictor of mortality. Children with CF are living longer and are good candidates for operation, but require long-term follow-up evaluation because of ongoing exocrine dysfunction.

Long-term outcomes in total colonic aganglionosis: a 32-year experience.

BACKGROUND/METHODS: A 32-year retrospective review from 1972 to 2004 analyzed complications and long-term outcomes in children with total colonic aganglionosis (TCA) as they relate to the procedure performed. RESULTS: Thirty-six patients (27 boys, 9 girls) had TCA. The level of aganglionosis was distal ileum (26), mid-small bowel (8), midjejunum (1), and entire bowel (1). Enterostomy was performed in 35 of 36. Eight developed short bowel syndrome. Twenty-nine (81%) had a pull-through at 15 +/- 6 months (modified Duhamel 20, Martin long Duhamel 4, and Soave 5). Six had a Kimura patch. Postoperative complications (including enterocolitis) were more common after long Duhamel and Soave procedures. Seven (19%; 2 with Down's syndrome) died (3 early, 4 late) from pulmonary emboli (1), sepsis (1), fluid overload (1), viral illness (1), liver failure (1), arrhythmia (1), and total bowel aganglionosis (1). Mean follow-up was 11 +/- 9 years (range, 6 months-29 years). Twenty-four (83%) of 29 patients exhibited growth by weight of 25% or more, 21 (91%) of 23 older than toddler age had 4 to 6 bowel movements per day, and 17 (81%) of 21 were continent. In 5 of 6, the Kimura patch provided functional benefit with proximal disease. CONCLUSION: Long-term survival was 81%. The highest morbidity occurred with long Duhamel or Soave procedures. The modified Duhamel is our procedure of choice in TCA. Bowel transplantation is an option for TCA with unadapted short bowel syndrome.

Supraumbilical pyloromyotomy: a unique indication for antimicrobial prophylaxis.

BACKGROUND: The umbilical fold incision for infantile hypertrophic pyloric stenosis provides a convenient exposure and cosmetically appealing scar. This study investigates the possible difference in infection rates between traditional and supraumbilical approaches for pyloromyotomy. METHODS: All patients who underwent pyloromyotomy for infantile hypertrophic pyloric stenosis at a tertiary pediatric hospital were reviewed. Baseline wound infection rate was determined through review of patients with right upper quadrant incisions (group 1). A nonrandomized comparison was performed between patients with a supraumbilical approach (group 2) and those undergoing supraumbilical incisions after prophylactic antibiotic administration (group 3). RESULTS: Complete records were reviewed on 384 patients over a 6-year period. Demographics and preoperative factors were similar among groups. The rate of infection in group 1 (n = 258) was 2.3%. With introduction of the supraumbilical approach, there was a statistically significant increase in wound infection rate to 7.0% (chi 2 ; group 1 vs group 2, P < .05). The use of prophylactic antibiotics with a supraumbilical approach reduced this rate of infection back to 2.3% (chi 2 ; group 1 vs group 3, P < 1.0 and group 2 [n = 85] vs group 3 [n = 42], P < .3). CONCLUSIONS: The risk of wound infection by classic pyloromyotomy of 2.3% is significantly increased with an open supraumbilical approach. The use of prophylactic antibiotics reduces this risk of wound infection.

Appendicitis in childhood hematologic malignancies: analysis and comparison with typhilitis.

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE: Recognition of appendicitis in the child with hematologic malignancy may be difficult particularly in the setting of neutropenia and multiple medications causing an altered inflammatory response. Typhilitis may produce a similar constellation of clinical findings causing further diagnostic confusion. This review compares the relative frequency of these two conditions in children with hematologic malignancy with a focus on the clinical presentation, distinguishing features, surgical management, and outcome for patients with appendicitis. METHODS: This institutional review board-approved retrospective study evaluated 464 pediatric patients treated for hematologic malignancy at our institution from 1997 to 2003. From this cohort, we identified all children with a diagnosis of appendicitis or typhilitis. Data include demographics, clinical presentation, laboratory studies, and computed tomography (CT) scan findings. Groups were compared using the Fisher exact test. Significance was defined as P < .05. RESULTS: Eight (1.7%) of 464 children were diagnosed with typhilitis and 7 (1.5%) with appendicitis. There were no demographic differences between patients with appendicitis and typhilitis. Distinguishing clinical features in children with typhilitis included presence of fever and diarrhea. Clinical presentation in children with appendicitis was atypical in 5 of 7 cases yielding an incorrect preoperative diagnosis in all 5. Radiographic evaluation by CT scan accurately defined typhilitis, but not appendicitis. An operation was performed on all 7 children with appendicitis with no operative morbidity or mortality. CONCLUSIONS: Appendicitis and typhilitis occur with similar frequency in children with leukemia and lymphoma. Typhilitis is accurately diagnosed with clinical findings of fever, diarrhea, abdominal pain, and typical CT scan findings. Appendicitis tends to present with atypical findings, but can be successfully managed with standard surgical care.

Postoperative outcomes of extremely low birth-weight infants with necrotizing enterocolitis or isolated intestinal perforation: a prospective cohort study by the NICHD Neonatal Research Network.

OBJECTIVE: Purposes of this study were: 1) to compare mortality and postoperative morbidities (intra-abdominal abscess, wound dehiscence, and intestinal stricture) in extremely low birth weight (ELBW) infants who underwent initial laparotomy or drainage for necrotizing enterocolitis (NEC) or isolated intestinal perforation (IP); 2) to determine the ability to distinguish NEC from IP preoperatively and the importance of this distinction on outcome measures; and 3) to evaluate the association between extent of intestinal disease determined at operation and outcome measures. BACKGROUND: ELBW infants who undergo operation for NEC or IP have a postoperative, in-hospital mortality rate of approximately 50%. Whether to perform laparotomy or drainage initially is controversial. Also unknown is the importance of distinguishing NEC from IP and the current ability to make this distinction based on objective data available prior to operation. METHODS: A prospective, multicenter cohort study of 156 ELBW infants at 16 neonatal intensive care units (NICU) within the NICHD Neonatal Research Network. RESULTS: Among the 156 enrolled infants, 80 underwent initial peritoneal drainage and 76 initial laparotomy. Mortality rate was 49% (76 of 156). Ninety-six patients had a preoperative diagnosis of NEC and 60 had presumed IP. There was a high level of agreement between the presumed preoperative diagnosis and intraoperative diagnosis in patients undergoing initial laparotomy (kappa = 0.85). The relative risk for death with a preoperative diagnosis of NEC (versus IP) was 1.4 (95% confidence interval, 0.99-2.1, P = 0.052). The overall incidence of postoperative intestinal stricture was 10.3%, wound dehiscence 4.4%, and intra-abdominal abscess 5.8%, and did not significantly differ between groups undergoing initial laparotomy versus initial drainage. CONCLUSIONS: Survival to hospital discharge after operation for NEC or IP in ELBW neonates remains poor (51%). Patients with a preoperative diagnosis of NEC have a relative risk for death of 1.4 compared with those with a preoperative diagnosis of IP. A distinction can be made preoperatively between NEC and IP based on abdominal radiographic findings and the patient's age at operation. Future randomized trials that compare laparotomy versus drainage would likely benefit from stratification of treatment assignment based on preoperative diagnosis.

The failure of nonoperative management in pediatric solid organ injury: a multi-institutional experience.

BACKGROUND: Nonoperative management (NOM) is the accepted treatment of most pediatric solid organ injuries (SOI) and, is typically successful. We sought to elucidate predictors of, and the time course to, failure in the subset of children suffering SOI who required operative intervention. METHODS: A retrospective analysis was performed from January 1997 through December 2002 of all pediatric patients (age 0-20 years) with a SOI (liver, spleen, kidney, pancreas) from the trauma registries of seven designated, level I pediatric trauma centers. Failure of NOM was defined as the need for intra-abdominal operative intervention. Data reviewed included demographics, injury mechanism, injury severity (ISS, AIS, SOI grade, and GCS), and outcome. For the failures of NOM, time to operation and relevant clinical variables were also abstracted. A summary AIS (sAIS) was calculated for each patient by summing the AIS values for each SOI, to account for multiple SOI in the same patient. Univariate and multivariate analyses were employed, and significance was set at p < 0.05. RESULTS: A total of 1,880 children were identified. Of these, 62 sustained nonsurvivable head injuries that precluded assessment of NOM outcome and were thus excluded. The remaining 1,818 patients comprised the overall study population. There were 1,729 successful NOM patients (controls -- C) and 89 failures (F), for an overall NOM failure rate of 5%. For isolated organ injuries, the failure rates were: kidney 3%, liver 3%, spleen 4%, and pancreas 18%. There were 14 deaths in the failure group from nonsalvageable injuries (mean ISS = 54 +/- 15). The two groups did not differ with respect to mean age or gender. An MVC was the most common injury mechanism in both groups. Only bicycle crashes were associated with a significantly increased risk of failing NOM (RR = 1.76, 95% CI = 1.02-3.04, p < 0.05). Injury severity and organ specific injuries were associated with NOM failure. When controlling for ISS and GCS, multivariate regression analysis confirmed that a sAIS > or = 4, isolated pancreatic injury, and >1 organ injured were significantly associated with NOM failure (p < 0.01). The median time to failure was 3 hours (range, 0.5-144 hours) with 38% having failed by 2 hours, 59% by 4 hours, and 76% by 12 hours. CONCLUSIONS: Failure of NOM is un common (5%) and typically occurs within the first 12 hours after injury. Failure is associated with injury severity and multiplicity, as well as isolated pancreatic injuries.