A guide to troubleshooting metal sacrificial anodes for organic electrosynthesis.

The development of reductive electrosynthetic reactions is often enabled by the oxidation of a sacrificial metal anode, which charge-balances the reductive reaction of interest occurring at the cathode. The metal oxidation is frequently assumed to be straightforward and innocent relative to the chemistry of interest, but several processes can interfere with ideal sacrificial anode behavior, thereby limiting the success of reductive electrosynthetic reactions. These issues are compounded by a lack of reported observations and characterization of the anodes themselves, even when a failure at the anode is observed. Here, we weave lessons from electrochemistry, interfacial characterization, and organic synthesis to share strategies for overcoming issues related to sacrificial anodes in electrosynthesis. We highlight common but underexplored challenges with sacrificial anodes that cause reactions to fail, including detrimental side reactions between the anode or its cations and the components of the organic reaction, passivation of the anode surface by an insulating native surface film, accumulation of insulating byproducts at the anode surface during the reaction, and competitive reduction of sacrificial metal cations at the cathode. For each case, we propose experiments to diagnose and characterize the anode and explore troubleshooting strategies to overcome the challenge. We conclude by highlighting open questions in the field of sacrificial-anode-driven electrosynthesis and by indicating alternatives to traditional sacrificial anodes that could streamline reaction optimization.

Enabling Al sacrificial anodes in tetrahydrofuran electrolytes for reductive electrosynthesis.

Al0 is widely used as a sacrificial anode in organic electrosynthesis. However, there remains a notable knowledge gap in the understanding of Al anode interface chemistry under electrolysis conditions. We hypothesize that Al interfacial chemistry plays a pivotal role in the discernible bias observed in solvent selections for reductive electrosynthesis. The majority of existing methodologies that employ an Al sacrificial anode use N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF) as the preferred solvent, with only isolated examples of ethereal solvents such as tetrahydrofuran (THF). Given the crucial role of the solvent in determining the efficiency and selectivity of an organic reaction, limitations on solvent choice could significantly hinder substrate reactivity and impede the desired transformations. In this study, we aim to understand the Al metal interfaces and manipulate them to improve the performance of an Al sacrificial anode in THF-based electrolytes. We have discovered that the presence of halide ions (Cl-, Br-, I-) in the electrolyte is crucial for efficient Al stripping. By incorporating halide additive, we achieve bulk Al stripping in THF-based electrolytes and successfully improve the cell potentials of electrochemically driven reductive methodologies. This study will encourage the use of ethereal solvents in systems using Al sacrificial anodes and guide future endeavors in optimizing electrolytes for reductive electrosynthesis.

Three-Component Cross-Electrophile Coupling: Regioselective Electrochemical Dialkylation of Alkenes.

The cross-electrophile dialkylation of alkenes enables the formation of two C(sp3)-C(sp3) bonds from readily available starting materials in a single transformation, thereby providing a modular and expedient approach to building structural complexity in organic synthesis. Herein, we exploit the disparate electronic and steric properties of alkyl halides with varying degrees of substitution to accomplish their selective activation and addition to alkenes under electrochemical conditions. This method enables regioselective dialkylation of alkenes without the use of a transition-metal catalyst and provides access to a diverse range of synthetically useful compounds.

Improving the Mg Sacrificial Anode in Tetrahydrofuran for Synthetic Electrochemistry by Tailoring Electrolyte Composition.

Mg0 is commonly used as a sacrificial anode in reductive electrosynthesis. While numerous methodologies using a Mg sacrificial anode have been successfully developed, the optimization of the electrochemistry at the anode, i.e., Mg stripping, remains empirical. In practice, electrolytes and organic substrates often passivate the Mg electrode surface, which leads to high overall cell potential causing poor energy efficiency and limiting reaction scale-up. In this study, we seek to understand and manipulate the Mg metal interfaces for a more effective counter electrode in tetrahydrofuran. Our results suggest that the ionic interactions between the cation and the anion of a supporting electrolyte can influence the electrical double layer, which impacts the Mg stripping efficiency. We find halide salt additives can prevent passivation on the Mg electrode by influencing the composition of the solid electrolyte interphase. This study demonstrates that, by tailoring the electrolyte composition, we can modify the Mg stripping process and enable a streamlined optimization process for the development of new electrosynthetic methodologies.

Water Vapor Induced Superionic Conductivity in ZnPS3.

Next-generation batteries based on sustainable multivalent working ions, such as Mg2+, Ca2+, or Zn2+, have the potential to improve the performance, safety, and capacity of current battery systems. Development of such multivalent ion batteries is hindered by a lack of understanding of multivalent ionics in solids, which is crucial for many aspects of battery operation. For instance, multivalent ionic transport was assumed to be correlated with electronic transport; however, we have previously shown that Zn2+ can conduct in electronically insulating ZnPS3 with a low activation energy of 350 meV, albeit with low ionic conductivity. Here, we show that exposure of ZnPS3 to environments with water vapor at different relative humidities results in room-temperature conductivity increases of several orders of magnitude, reaching as high as 1.44 mS cm-1 without decomposition or structural changes. We utilize impedance spectroscopy with ion selective electrodes, ionic transference number measurements, and deposition and stripping of Zn metal, to confirm that both Zn2+ and H+ act as mobile ions. The contribution from Zn2+ to the ionic conductivity in water vapor exposed ZnPS3 is high, representing superionic Zn2+ conduction. The present study demonstrates that it is possible to enhance multivalent ion conduction of electronically insulating solids as a result of water adsorption and highlights the importance of ensuring that increased conductivity in water vapor exposed multivalent ion systems is in fact due to mobile multivalent ions and not solely H+.

Electrochemical Preparation of Sm(II) Reagent Facilitated by Weakly Coordinating Anions.

Samarium diiodide (SmI2 ) is widely used as a strong one-electron reducing agent and is often employed to form C-C bonds in complex systems. Despite their utility, SmI2 and related salts suffer from several drawbacks that render the use of Sm reducing agents in large-scale synthesis impractical. Here, we report factors influencing the electrochemical reduction of Sm(III) to Sm(II), towards the goal of electrocatalytic Sm(III) reduction. We probe the effect of supporting electrolyte, electrode material, and Sm precursor on Sm(II)/(III) redox and on the reducing power of the Sm species. We find that the coordination strength of the counteranion of the Sm salt affects the reversibility and redox potential of the Sm(II)/(III) couple and establish that the counteranion primarily determines the reducibility of Sm(III). Electrochemically generated SmI2 performs similarly to commercial SmI2 solutions in a proof-of-concept reaction. The results will provide fundamental insight to facilitate the development of Sm-electrocatalytic reactions.

Effect of Polysulfide Speciation on Mg Anode Passivation in Mg-S Batteries.

Mg-S batteries are a promising next-generation system for beyond conventional Li-ion chemistry. The Mg-S architecture pairs a Mg metal anode with an inexpensive, high-capacity S8 cathode. However, S8-based cathodes exhibit the "polysulfide shuttle" effect, wherein soluble partially reduced Sx2- species generated at the cathode diffuse to and react with the anode. While dissolved polysulfides may undergo reactions to form Li+-permeable layers in Li-S systems, the interfaces on Mg anodes are passivating. In this work, we probe the reactivity of various Mg polysulfide solutions at the Mg anode interface. Mg polysulfide solutions are prepared without any chelating agents to closely mimic conditions in a Mg-S cell. The polysulfides are synthesized by reacting Mg metal and S8 in electrolyte, and the speciation is controlled by varying the Mg:S precursor ratio. S-poor precursor ratios produce magnesium polysulfide solutions with a higher proportion of short-chain polysulfides that react at the Mg anode faster than the longer-chain analogues. Anode passivation can be slowed by shifting the polysulfide equilibria toward longer-chain polysulfides through addition of S8.

An Exploration of Sulfur Redox in Lithium Battery Cathodes.

Secondary Li-ion batteries have enabled a world of portable electronics and electrification of personal and commercial transportation. However, the charge storage capacity of conventional intercalation cathodes is reaching the theoretical limit set by the stoichiometry of Li in the fully lithiated structure. Increasing the Li:transition metal ratio and consequently involving structural anions in the charge compensation, a mechanism termed anion redox, is a viable method to improve storage capacities. Although anion redox has recently become the front-runner as a next-generation storage mechanism, the concept has been around for quite some time. In this perspective, we explore the contribution of anions in charge compensation mechanisms ranging from intercalation to conversion and the hybrid mechanisms between. We focus our attention on the redox of S because the voltage required to reach S redox lies within the electrolyte stability window, which removes the convoluting factors caused by the side reactions that plague the oxides. We highlight examples of S redox in cathode materials exhibiting varying degrees of anion involvement with a particular focus on the structural effects. We call attention to those with intermediate anion contribution to redox and the hybrid intercalation- and conversion-type structural mechanism at play that takes advantage of the positives of both mechanistic types to increase storage capacity while maintaining good reversibility. The hybrid mechanisms often invoke the formation of persulfides, and so a survey of binary and ternary materials containing persulfide moieties is presented to provide context for materials that show thermodynamically stable persulfide moieties.

Metal-Metal Bonding as an Electrode Design Principle in the Low-Strain Cluster Compound LiScMo3O8.

Electrode materials for Li+-ion batteries require optimization along several disparate axes related to cost, performance, and sustainability. One of the important performance axes is the ability to retain structural integrity though cycles of charge/discharge. Metal-metal bonding is a distinct feature of some refractory metal oxides that has been largely underutilized in electrochemical energy storage, but that could potentially impact structural integrity. Here LiScMo3O8, a compound containing triangular clusters of metal-metal bonded Mo atoms, is studied as a potential anode material in Li+-ion batteries. Electrons inserted though lithiation are localized across rigid Mo3 triangles (rather than on individual metal ions), resulting in minimal structural change as suggested by operando diffraction. The unusual chemical bonding allows this compound to be cycled with Mo atoms below a formally +4 valence state, resulting in an acceptable voltage regime that is appropriate for an anode material. Several characterization methods including potentiometric entropy measurements indicate two-phase regions, which are attributed through extensive first-principles modeling to Li+ ordering. This study of LiScMo3O8 provides valuable insights for design principles for structural motifs that stably and reversibly permit Li+ (de)insertion.

Electrochemically driven cross-electrophile coupling of alkyl halides.

Recent research in medicinal chemistry has suggested that there is a correlation between an increase in the fraction of sp3 carbons-those bonded to four other atoms-in drug candidates and their improved success rate in clinical trials1. As such, the development of robust and selective methods for the construction of carbon(sp3)-carbon(sp3) bonds remains a critical problem in modern organic chemistry2. Owing to the broad availability of alkyl halides, their direct cross-coupling-commonly known as cross-electrophile coupling-provides a promising route towards this objective3-5. Such transformations circumvent the preparation of carbon nucleophiles used in traditional cross-coupling reactions, as well as stability and functional-group-tolerance issues that are usually associated with these reagents. However, achieving high selectivity in carbon(sp3)-carbon(sp3) cross-electrophile coupling remains a largely unmet challenge. Here we use electrochemistry to achieve the differential activation of alkyl halides by exploiting their disparate electronic and steric properties. Specifically, the selective cathodic reduction of a more substituted alkyl halide gives rise to a carbanion, which undergoes preferential coupling with a less substituted alkyl halide via bimolecular nucleophilic substitution to forge a new carbon-carbon bond. This protocol enables efficient cross-electrophile coupling of a variety of functionalized and unactivated alkyl electrophiles in the absence of a transition metal catalyst, and shows improved chemoselectivity compared with existing methods.

Mg Anode Passivation Caused by the Reaction of Dissolved Sulfur in Mg-S Batteries.

As Li-ion battery optimization approaches theoretical limits, interest has grown in designing next-generation batteries from low-cost earth-abundant materials. Mg-S batteries are promising candidates, exhibiting widespread abundance of elemental precursors and a relatively large theoretical energy density albeit at lower cell voltage. However, Mg-S batteries exhibit poor reversibility, in part due to interactions between dissolved polysulfides and the Mg anode. Herein, we employ electrochemical experiments using Ag2S quasi-reference electrodes to probe the interactions between Mg anodes and dissolved polysulfides. We show that Mg2+ reduction (charging) is impeded in the presence of polysulfides, while Mg metal oxidation (discharging) remains facile. Large reduction overpotentials arise due to the formation of a passivation layer on the anode surface, likely composed primarily of MgS. The passivation layer is removed under oxidative conditions but quickly reforms during reduction. We discover that dissolved S8 influences the rate of MgS formation by shifting the polysulfide disproportionation equilibria. Shorter-chain polysulfides react more readily than longer-chain polysulfides at the Mg electrode, and thus, film formation is mediated by the electrochemical generation of shorter-chain polysulfide species.

Fluoride in the SEI Stabilizes the Li Metal Interface in Li-S Batteries with Solvate Electrolytes.

Lithium-sulfur (Li-S) batteries offer high theoretical gravimetric capacities at low cost relative to commercial lithium-ion batteries. However, the solubility of intermediate polysulfides in conventional electrolytes leads to irreversible capacity fade via the polysulfide shuttle effect. Highly concentrated solvate electrolytes reduce polysulfide solubility and improve the reductive stability of the electrolyte against Li metal anodes, but reactivity at the Li/solvate electrolyte interface has not been studied in detail. Here, reactivity between the Li metal anode and a solvate electrolyte (4.2 M LiTFSI in acetonitrile) is investigated as a function of temperature. Though reactivity at the Li/electrolyte interface is minimal at room temperature, we show that reactions between Li and the solvate electrolyte significantly impact the solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) impedance, cyclability, and capacity retention in Li-S cells at elevated temperatures. Addition of a fluoroether cosolvent to the solvate electrolyte results in more fluoride in the SEI which minimizes electrolyte decomposition, reduces SEI impedance, and improves cyclability. A 6 nm AlF3 surface coating is employed at the Li anode to further improve interfacial stability at elevated temperatures. The coating enables moderate cyclability in Li-S cells at elevated temperatures but does not protect against capacity fade over time.

Activating Magnesium Electrolytes through Chemical Generation of Free Chloride and Removal of Trace Water.

Mg batteries are attractive next-generation energy storage systems due to their high natural abundance, inexpensive cost, and high theoretical capacity compared to conventional Li-ion based systems. The high energy density is achieved by electrodeposition and stripping of a Mg metal anode and requires the development of effective electrolytes enabled by a mechanistic understanding of the charge-transfer mechanism. The magnesium aluminum chloride complex (MACC) electrolyte is a good model system to study the mechanism as the solution phase speciation is known. Previously, we reported that minor addition of Mg(HMDS)2 to the MACC electrolyte causes significant improvement in the Mg deposition and stripping voltammetry resulting in good Coulombic efficiency on cycle one and, therefore, negating the need for electrochemical conditioning. To determine the cause of the improved electrochemistry, here we probe the speciation of the electrolyte after Mg(HMDS)2 addition using Raman spectroscopy, 27Al nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, and 1H-29Si heteronuclear multiple bond correlation spectroscopy on MACC + Mg(HMDS)2 at various Mg(HMDS)2 concentrations. Mg(HMDS)2 scavenges trace H2O, but it also reacts with MACC complexes, namely, AlCl4-, to form free Cl-. We suggest that although both the removal of H2O and the formation of free Cl- improve electrochemistry by altering the speciation at the interface, the latter has a profound effect on electrodeposition and stripping of Mg.

A Super-Oxidized Radical Cationic Icosahedral Boron Cluster.

While the icosahedral closo-[B12H12]2- cluster does not display reversible electrochemical behavior, perfunctionalization of this species via substitution of all 12 B-H vertices with alkoxy or benzyloxy (OR) substituents engenders reversible redox chemistry, providing access to clusters in the dianionic, monoanionic, and neutral forms. Here, we evaluated the electrochemical behavior of the electron-rich B12(O-3-methylbutyl)12 (1) cluster and discovered that a new reversible redox event that gives rise to a fourth electronic state is accessible through one-electron oxidation of the neutral species. Chemical oxidation of 1 with [N(2,4-Br2C6H3)3]•+ afforded the isolable [1]•+ cluster, which is the first example of an open-shell cationic B12 cluster in which the unpaired electron is proposed to be delocalized throughout the boron cluster core. The oxidation of 1 is also chemically reversible, where treatment of [1]•+ with ferrocene resulted in its reduction back to 1. The identity of [1]•+ is supported by EPR, UV-vis, multinuclear NMR (1H, 11B), and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopic characterization.

Multielectron, Cation and Anion Redox in Lithium-Rich Iron Sulfide Cathodes.

Conventional Li-ion cathodes store charge by reversible intercalation of Li coupled to metal cation redox. There has been increasing interest in new materials capable of accommodating more than one Li per transition-metal center, thereby yielding higher charge storage capacities. We demonstrate here that the lithium-rich layered iron sulfide Li2FeS2 as well as a new structural analogue, LiNaFeS2, reversibly store ≥1.5 electrons per formula unit and support extended cycling. Ex situ and operando structural and spectroscopic data indicate that delithiation results in reversible oxidation of Fe2+ concurrent with an increase in the covalency of the Fe-S interactions, followed by reversible anion redox: 2 S2-/(S2)2-. S K-edge spectroscopy unequivocally proves the contribution of the anions to the redox processes. The structural response to the oxidation processes is found to be different in Li2FeS2 in contrast to that in LiNaFeS2, which we suggest is the cause for capacity fade in the early cycles of LiNaFeS2. The materials presented here have the added benefit of avoiding resource-sensitive transition metals such as Co and Ni. In contrast to Li-rich oxide materials that have been the subject of so much recent study and that suffer capacity fade and electrolyte degradation issues, the materials presented here operate within the stable potential window of the electrolyte, permitting a clearer understanding of the underlying processes.

Selective formation of pyridinic-type nitrogen-doped graphene and its application in lithium-ion battery anodes.

We report a high-yield single-step method for synthesizing nitrogen-doped graphene nanostripes (N-GNSPs) with an unprecedentedly high percentage of pyridinic-type doping (>86% of the nitrogen sites), and investigate the performance of the resulting N-GNSPs as a lithium-ion battery (LIB) anode material. The as-grown N-GNSPs are compared with undoped GNSPs using scanning electron microscopy (SEM), Raman spectroscopy, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), helium ion-beam microscopy (HIM), and electrochemical methods. As an anode material we find that pyridinic-type N-GNSPs perform similarly to undoped GNSPs, suggesting that pyridinic sites alone are not responsible for the enhanced performance of nitrogen-doped graphene observed in previous studies, which contradicts common conjectures. In addition, post-mortem XPS measurements of nitrogen-doped graphene cycled as a lithium-ion battery anode are conducted for the first time, which reveal direct evidence for irreversible chemical changes at the nitrogen sites during cycling. These findings therefore provide new insights into the mechanistic models of doped graphene as LIB anodes, which are important in improving the anode designs for better LIB performance.

Conditioning-Free Mg Electrolyte by the Minor Addition of Mg(HMDS)2.

Mg-based batteries are an attractive next-generation energy storage chemistry due to the high natural abundance and inexpensive cost of Mg, along with the high theoretical energy density compared to that of conventional Li-ion chemistry. The greater energy density is predicated on a Mg metal anode, and pathways to achieving reversible Mg electrodeposition and stripping are reliant on the development of Mg electrolytes. Although Mg electrolyte chemistry has advanced significantly from the reactive Grignards of the 1920s to the carboranes of this decade, there remains significant challenges in correlating the Mg metal anode electrochemistry with the composition of the electrolyte salts as a result of the complicated interface of Mg metal and the electrolyte. To probe the effect of the interface on Mg electrodeposition, we turn to an electrolyte with a known solution-phase composition: the magnesium aluminum chloride complex (MACC) electrolyte. The MACC electrolyte requires electrolytic conditioning to support reversible Mg electrodeposition and stripping. Here, we show that a small concentration (2-5 mM) of Mg(HMDS)2 with respect to the MACC electrolyte salts suppresses Al3+ deposition and promotes reversible Mg electrodeposition and stripping in the first cycle. The significant effect of a small concentration of additive is attributed to changes to the electrode interface. The impact of the Mg interface on the observed electrochemical performance is discussed.

Effect of the Electrolyte Solvent on Redox Processes in Mg-S Batteries.

Mg-S batteries are attractive for next-generation energy storage because of their high theoretical capacity and low cost. The foremost challenge in Mg-S batteries is designing electrolytes that support reversible electrochemistry at both electrodes. Here, we target a solution-mediated reduction pathway for the S8 cathode by tailoring the electrolyte solvent. Varying the solvent in Mg-based systems is complicated because of the active nature of the solvent in solvating Mg2+ and the complex dynamics of electrolyte-Mg interfaces. To understand the effect of the solvent on the S8 reduction processes in the Mg-S cell, the magnesium-aluminum chloride complex (MACC) electrolyte was prepared in different ethereal solvents. Reversible Mg electrodeposition is demonstrated in the MACC electrolyte in several solvent systems. The electrodeposition overpotentials and current densities are found to vary with the solvent, suggesting that the solvent plays a noninnocent role in the electrochemical processes at the Mg interface. Mg-S cells are prepared with the electrolytes to understand how the solvent affects the reduction of S8. A reductive wave is present in all linear-sweep voltammograms, and the peak potential varies with the solvent. The peak potential is approximately 0.8 V versus Mg/Mg2+, lower than the expected reduction potential of 1.7 V. We rule out passivation of the Mg anode as the cause for the low voltage peak potential, making processes at the S8 cathode the likely culprit. The ability to oxidize MgS with the MACC electrolyte is also examined, and we find that  the oxidation current can be attributed to side reactions at the C-electrolyte interface.

Effect of the Hydrofluoroether Cosolvent Structure in Acetonitrile-Based Solvate Electrolytes on the Li+ Solvation Structure and Li-S Battery Performance.

We evaluate hydrofluoroether (HFE) cosolvents with varying degrees of fluorination in the acetonitrile-based solvate electrolyte to determine the effect of the HFE structure on the electrochemical performance of the Li-S battery. Solvates or sparingly solvating electrolytes are an interesting electrolyte choice for the Li-S battery due to their low polysulfide solubility. The solvate electrolyte with a stoichiometric ratio of LiTFSI salt in acetonitrile, (MeCN)2-LiTFSI, exhibits limited polysulfide solubility due to the high concentration of LiTFSI. We demonstrate that the addition of highly fluorinated HFEs to the solvate yields better capacity retention compared to that of less fluorinated HFE cosolvents. Raman and NMR spectroscopy coupled with ab initio molecular dynamics simulations show that HFEs exhibiting a higher degree of fluorination coordinate to Li+ at the expense of MeCN coordination, resulting in higher free MeCN content in solution. However, the polysulfide solubility remains low, and no crossover of polysulfides from the S cathode to the Li anode is observed.

Effect of Concentration on the Electrochemistry and Speciation of the Magnesium Aluminum Chloride Complex Electrolyte Solution.

Magnesium batteries offer an opportunity to use naturally abundant Mg and achieve large volumetric capacities reaching over four times that of conventional Li-based intercalation anodes. High volumetric capacity is enabled by the use of a Mg metal anode in which charge is stored via electrodeposition and stripping processes, however, electrolytes that support efficient Mg electrodeposition and stripping are few and are often prepared from highly reactive compounds. One interesting electrolyte solution that supports Mg deposition and stripping without the use of highly reactive reagents is the magnesium aluminum chloride complex (MACC) electrolyte. The MACC exhibits high Coulombic efficiencies and low deposition overpotentials following an electrolytic conditioning protocol that stabilizes species necessary for such behavior. Here, we discuss the effect of the MgCl2 and AlCl3 concentrations on the deposition overpotential, current density, and the conditioning process. Higher concentrations of MACC exhibit enhanced Mg electrodeposition current density and much faster conditioning. An increase in the salt concentrations causes a shift in the complex equilibria involving both cations. The conditioning process is strongly dependent on the concentration suggesting that the electrolyte is activated through a change in speciation of electrolyte complexes and is not simply due to the annihilation of electrolyte impurities. Additionally, the presence of the [Mg2(µ-Cl)3·6THF]+ in the electrolyte solution is again confirmed through careful analysis of experimental Raman spectra coupled with simulation and direct observation of the complex in sonic spray ionization mass spectrometry. Importantly, we suggest that the ∼210 cm-1 mode commonly observed in the Raman spectra of many Mg electrolytes is indicative of the C3v symmetric [Mg2(µ-Cl)3·6THF]+. The 210 cm-1 mode is present in many electrolytes containing MgCl2, so its assignment is of broad interest to the Mg electrolyte community.