Cathepsin K inhibitors prevent matrix-derived growth factor degradation by human osteoclasts.

The coupling between bone formation and resorption creates a therapeutic impasse in osteoporosis: antiresorptive therapy halts bone loss, but also inhibits bone formation, and therefore does not cure the condition. Surprisingly, recent preliminary reports suggest that inhibition of resorption by cathepsin K (CathK) inhibitors augments bone formation. Uniquely amongst resorption-inhibitors, CathK-inhibitors suppress degradation of the organic matrix of bone while allowing demineralization. We hypothesized that these unique characteristics might explain a capacity of CathK inhibitors to enhance bone formation: the inhibitors might prevent degradation not only of collagen, but also other proteins, including growth factors embedded in matrix. We tested this hypothesis using osteocalcin and insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I) as examples of matrix-embedded proteins, and found that CathK-inhibitors, unlike other resorption-inhibitors, dramatically increased the concentrations of these matrix-derived proteins in supernatants of osteoclasts on bone, most likely through protection against intracellular degradation. We found that protons are both necessary and sufficient for the release of IGF-I from bone matrix, and that recombinant CathK can degrade both marker proteins. In the presence of a CathK-inhibitor, the amount of IGF-I released from matrix substantially exceeded the amount secreted by osteoclasts. CathK-inhibition similarly augmented bone morphogenetic protein (BMP)-2 release. Lastly, MC3T3-E1 numbers were greater after co-culture with osteoclasts on bone with versus without CathK-inhibitor, showing that, in the presence of CathK-inhibitor, osteoclasts release biologically-significant quantities of biologically-active matrix-derived growth factors. These results support a model in which osteoclastic secretion of protons demineralizes bone, causing release of growth factors from bone matrix. Normally these are largely degraded, with collagen, in the resorptive hemivacuole and during transcytosis to the basal surface of the osteoclast, but in the presence of CathK inhibitor they are released intact, and so might augment bone formation.

A novel assay for analysis of the regulation of the function of human osteoclasts.

BACKGROUND: Very little is known of the regulation of the function of human osteoclasts, largely due to the virtual impossibility of obtaining human osteoclasts ex vivo. It has recently become possible to generate human osteoclasts in vitro, by incubation of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) in macrophage colony-stimulating factor (M-CSF) and receptor activator of nuclear factor-kappaB ligand (RANKL). However, the assays at present available do not distinguish clearly between the distinct effects of agents on differentiation and function. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We developed a novel assay for resorptive function of human osteoclasts that minimizes inter-assay variability by using each culture as its own baseline, and that minimizes the confounding effects of agents on differentiation by assessing resorptive function over a short test period. In this assay, the development of resorptive activity is monitored in sample cultures. When resorption is underway, bone resorption (measured as the release of the C-terminal telopeptide degradation product of type I collagen (CTX-I) into the supernatant) is compared before vs after incubation for 1-24 h in test agent. RESULTS: Using this assay, we found that changes in bone resorption could be detected using substantially fewer cultures per variable. Moreover, we could detect effects of agents on resorption within 1 h of addition, a time sufficiently short that a change in release is likely to reflect an effect on function rather than on differentiation. CONCLUSION: The assay makes it possible to distinguish the effects of agents on osteoclastic function, independent of their effects on differentiation.

Recent developments in cathepsin K inhibitor design.

Cathepsin K is abundantly and selectively expressed in osteoclasts where it plays a critical role in bone degradation. Cathepsin K inhibitors are the first antiresorptive agents that prevent bone loss while allowing bone formation to continue, thereby enhancing the quality and ultimately the strength of bone. The development of cathepsin K inhibitors requires appropriate cell-based assays and animal models. Advances in reversible cathepsin K inhibitor design from January 2004 are reviewed herein.