Challenges and approaches for assay development of membrane and membrane-associated proteins in drug discovery.

In addition to its role as a barrier between the cytoplasm and the extracellular milieu, the cell membrane is a scaffold for a diverse collection of receptors and enzymes. The organization afforded by this scaffold serves to ensure an efficient interaction between the components of the membrane. The desire to maintain this organization in solution is a challenge for the appropriate interrogation of these biochemical components. This chapter will discuss strategies that allow biochemical analysis of membrane-associated enzymes within standard biochemical reactions. The advantages of these screening strategies in identifying valuable compounds from compound libraries and in understanding the intricacies of complex multiprotein complexes (i.e., chemotaxis) will be discussed.

Mobile loop mutations in an archaeal inositol monophosphatase: modulating three-metal ion assisted catalysis and lithium inhibition.

The inositol monophosphatase (IMPase) enzyme from the hyperthermophilic archaeon Methanocaldococcus jannaschii requires Mg(2+) for activity and binds three to four ions tightly in the absence of ligands: K(D) = 0.8 muM for one ion with a K(D) of 38 muM for the other Mg(2+) ions. However, the enzyme requires 5-10 mM Mg(2+) for optimum catalysis, suggesting substrate alters the metal ion affinity. In crystal structures of this archaeal IMPase with products, one of the three metal ions is coordinated by only one protein contact, Asp38. The importance of this and three other acidic residues in a mobile loop that approaches the active site was probed with mutational studies. Only D38A exhibited an increased kinetic K(D) for Mg(2+); D26A, E39A, and E41A showed no significant change in the Mg(2+) requirement for optimal activity. D38A also showed an increased K(m), but little effect on k(cat). This behavior is consistent with this side chain coordinating the third metal ion in the substrate complex, but with sufficient flexibility in the loop such that other acidic residues could position the Mg(2+) in the active site in the absence of Asp38. While lithium ion inhibition of the archaeal IMPase is very poor (IC(50) approximately 250 mM), the D38A enzyme has a dramatically enhanced sensitivity to Li(+) with an IC(50) of 12 mM. These results constitute additional evidence for three metal ion assisted catalysis with substrate and product binding reducing affinity of the third necessary metal ion. They also suggest a specific mode of action for lithium inhibition in the IMPase superfamily.

Template-directed self-assembly enhances RTK catalytic domain function.

Receptor tyrosine kinases have become important therapeutic targets because of their involvement in diseases, including cancer. Kinase domains, which are soluble and easily purified, have found widespread use in enzyme inhibitor assays, but these domains do not exhibit full function because they are isolated from the membrane. To address this shortcoming, the authors developed a simple method to restore biologically relevant function by assembling kinase domains on a nanometer-scale template, which imitates the membrane surface. Autophosphorylation of template-assembled tyrosine kinase domains from the insulin, EphB2, and Tie2 receptors led to substantially larger phosphorylation levels compared with domains assayed under conventional conditions. Template-directed assembly increased the total substrate phosphorylation of the insulin and EphB2 receptor kinase domains as much as 60-fold and 15-fold, respectively. In contrast, substrate phosphorylation by template-assembled Tie2 was much lower than conventional conditions. The lower activity observed with the template is more biologically relevant because autophosphorylation of Tie2 is self-inhibitory. These results, as well as the underlying similarity between the organization of template-assembled and natural membrane signaling environments, suggest that template-directed assembly of signaling proteins will provide widespread benefit to basic and applied signal transduction research, especially drug discovery.

Receptor density balances signal stimulation and attenuation in membrane-assembled complexes of bacterial chemotaxis signaling proteins.

All cells possess transmembrane signaling systems that function in the environment of the lipid bilayer. In the Escherichia coli chemotaxis pathway, the binding of attractants to a two-dimensional array of receptors and signaling proteins simultaneously inhibits an associated kinase and stimulates receptor methylation--a slower process that restores kinase activity. These two opposing effects lead to robust adaptation toward stimuli through a physical mechanism that is not understood. Here, we provide evidence of a counterbalancing influence exerted by receptor density on kinase stimulation and receptor methylation. Receptor signaling complexes were reconstituted over a range of defined surface concentrations by using a template-directed assembly method, and the kinase and receptor methylation activities were measured. Kinase activity and methylation rates were both found to vary significantly with surface concentration--yet in opposite ways: samples prepared at high surface densities stimulated kinase activity more effectively than low-density samples, whereas lower surface densities produced greater methylation rates than higher densities. FRET experiments demonstrated that the cooperative change in kinase activity coincided with a change in the arrangement of the membrane-associated receptor domains. The counterbalancing influence of density on receptor methylation and kinase stimulation leads naturally to a model for signal regulation that is compatible with the known logic of the E. coli pathway. Density-dependent mechanisms are likely to be general and may operate when two or more membrane-related processes are influenced differently by the two-dimensional concentration of pathway elements.

Template-directed assembly of signaling proteins: a novel drug screening and research tool.

A multitude of proteins reside at or near the cell membrane, which provides a unique environment for organizing and promoting assemblies of proteins that are involved in a variety of cellular signaling functions. Many of these proteins and pathways are implicated in disease. For example, strong links have been established between receptor tyrosine kinases and disease, most notably, cancer. However, a significant impediment to researchers remains: membrane-associated proteins are difficult to reconstitute and study. Template-directed assembly represents a powerful new technology that enables the assembly of membrane-associated proteins. We show that template-directed assembly restores tyrosine kinase activity and regulation, and provides a way for researchers to build multicomponent assemblies. As an example of better enzyme regulation, the Tie2 tyrosine kinase domain exhibits (biologically relevant) autoinhibitory behavior when template assembled. Also, template-assembled insulin receptor tyrosine kinase domains exhibit significant autophosphorylation (none detected without template-directed assembly) and an eightfold increase in substrate phosphorylation (compared to best solution conditions). Thus, template-directed assembly has a demonstrated ability to effectively produce more biologically relevant results using these commercial reagents. Template-directed assembly promises to be generally applicable to the signaling networks important for human health, because these pathways frequently contain membrane-associated proteins that require the organizing influence of a membrane surface.

Formation and activity of template-assembled receptor signaling complexes.

Problems in membrane biology require methods to recreate the interactions between receptors and cytoplasmic signaling proteins at the membrane surface. Here, unilamellar vesicles composed of 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine and a nickel-chelating lipid were used as templates to direct the assembly of proteins from the Escherichia coli chemotaxis signaling pathway. The bacterial chemoreceptors are known to form clusters, which promote the binding of the adaptor protein (CheW) and the kinase (CheA). When CheA was incubated with vesicles, CheW, and a histidine-tagged cytoplasmic domain fragment of the aspartate chemoreceptor (CF), the kinase activity was stimulated approximately 300-fold. Activity and pull-down assays were used with dynamic light scattering and electron microscopy to characterize the protein-vesicle compositions that were correlated with the high levels of activity, which demonstrated that CF-CheW-CheA complexes on the vesicle surface were the active entities. Assembly and stimulation occurred with vesicles of different sizes and CFs in different extents of glutamine substitution (in place of glutamate) at physiologically relevant sites. An exception was the combination of sonicated vesicles with the unsubstituted CF, which displayed lower CheA activity. The lower activity was attributed to the high curvature of the sonicated vesicles and a weaker tendency of the unsubstituted CF to self-assemble. Electron micrographs of the vesicle-protein assemblies revealed that protein binding induced pronounced changes in vesicle shape, which was consistent with the introduction of positive curvature in the outer leaflet of the bilayer. Overall, vesicle-mediated template-directed assembly is shown to be an effective way to form functional complexes of membrane-associated proteins and suggests that significant changes in membrane shape can be involved in the process of transmembrane signaling.

Influence of resonance on the acidity of sulfides, sulfoxides, sulfones, and their group 16 congeners.

The influence of resonance on the acidities of dimethyl sulfide (DMS), dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), and dimethyl sulfone (DMSO2) and their group 16 congeners (DMXO(n) for X = Se, Te, Po and n = 0-2) is examined using ab initio methods and the natural bond orbital (NBO) and natural resonance theory (NRT) analyses. Gas-phase acidities are evaluated using B3LYP-optimized geometries with coupled cluster energies and complete basis set extrapolation. The acidity of the DMSO(n) molecules increases with increasing coordination of the central S atom. Acidity also tends to increase when the central atom is substituted by a heavier group 16 atom. NRT analysis reveals significant resonance delocalization in the DMXO(n) molecules and their anions. On deprotonation, the DMXO(n) molecules undergo structural changes that are consistent with changes in the resonance character of the calculated charge densities. However, resonance cannot account for the trends in the deprotonation energies. Whereas the DMX- anions are more strongly resonance stabilized than their parent molecules DMX, the DMXO2(-) anions and DMXO2 molecules are nearly equally resonance stabilized. Thus, there appears to be no extra stabilization of DMXO2(-) compared to that of DMX- that would account for the enhanced acidity of DMXO2 relative to DMX.

Distributed subunit interactions in CheA contribute to dimer stability: a sedimentation equilibrium study.

The structural domains of the Escherichia coli CheA protein resemble 'beads on a string', since the N-terminal phosphate-accepting (P) domain is joined to the CheY/CheB-binding (B) domain through a flexible linker, and the B domain is in turn joined to the C-terminal dimerization/catalytic/regulatory domains by a second intervening linker. Dimerization occurs primarily via interactions between two dimerization domains, which is required for CheA trans-autophosphorylation. In this study, sedimentation equilibrium was used to demonstrate significant subunit interactions at secondary sites in the two naturally occurring (full-length and short) forms of CheA (CheA(1-654) or CheA(L), and CheA(98-654) or CheA(S)) by contrasting the dimerization of CheA(L) and CheA(S) to CheA(T), an engineered form that lacked the P domain entirely. The estimated dimer dissociation constant (K(1,2)) for CheA(T) (3.1 microM) was weaker than K(1,2) for CheA(L) (0.49 microM), which was attributed to the P domain-catalytic domain interactions that were present in CheA(L) but not CheA(T). In contrast, CheA(S) dimerization was unexpectedly stronger (K(1,2) approximately 20 nM), which arose through interactions between two P domain remnants in the CheA(S) dimer. This conclusion was supported by the results of sedimentation equilibrium experiments conducted with P domains and P domain remnants expressed in the absence of the dimerization/catalytic/regulatory domains. The P domain remnant had a measurable tendency to self-associate; the full-length P domain did not. Hydrophobic forces probably drive this interaction, since hydrophobic amino acids buried in the intact P domain are solvent-exposed in CheA(S). Also, the nascent N-terminus of CheA(S) bound to the phosphatase (CheZ) more effectively, a conclusion based on the demonstrably greater ability of the P domain remnant to co-sediment CheZ, compared to the intact P domain.

Template-directed assembly of receptor signaling complexes.

Transmembrane receptors in the signaling pathways of bacterial chemotaxis systems influence cell motility by forming noncovalent complexes with the cytoplasmic signaling proteins to regulate their activity. The requirements for receptor-mediated activation of CheA, the principal kinase of the Escherichia coli chemotaxis signaling pathway, were investigated using self-assembled clusters of a receptor fragment (CF) derived from the cytoplasmic domain of the aspartate receptor, Tar. Histidine-tagged Tar CF was assembled on the surface of sonicated unilamellar vesicles via a lipid containing the nickel-nitrilotriacetic acid moiety as a headgroup. In the presence of the adaptor protein CheW, CheA bound to and was activated approximately 180-fold by vesicle-bound CF. The extent of CheA activation was found to be independent of the level of covalent modification on the CF. Instead, the stability of the complex increased significantly as the level of covalent modification increased. Surface-assembled CF was also found to serve as a substrate for receptor methylation in a reaction catalyzed by the receptor methyltransferase, CheR. Since neither CheA activation nor CF methylation was observed in comparable samples in the absence of vesicles, it is concluded that surface templating generates the organization among CF subunits required for biochemical activity.