Reliability of clinical diagnosis of dystonia.

BACKGROUND: There is only one small single-center study on the reliability of the diagnosis of focal dystonia. The aim of this study was to assess the inter-rater reliability of dystonia diagnosis among neurologists with different professional experience. METHODS: Twenty-nine adults (18 with dystonia, 9 with other movement disorders, and 2 healthy controls) were videotaped while undergoing neurological examination and during the process of collecting information on the history of their condition. Each case was diagnosed by 35 blind raters (12 general neurologists, 21 neurology residents, and 2 experts in movement disorders) from different hospitals. Sensitivity and specificity were calculated confronting raters with the gold standard (the caring physician). Inter-rater agreement was measured by the Kappa statistic. RESULTS: Specificity and sensitivity were 95.2 and 66.7%, 76.3 and 75.2%, 84.6 and 71.6% for experts, general neurologists, and residents, respectively. Kappa values on dystonia diagnosis ranged from 0.30 to 0.46. The agreement was moderate for experts and residents (0.40-0.60) and fair for general neurologists (0.20-0.40). Kappas were the highest among experts for cranial and laryngeal dystonia (0.61-1), but not for cervical dystonia (0.37). CONCLUSIONS: The diagnosis of dystonia is difficult and only partially mirrors a physician's background.

The progression of non-motor symptoms in Parkinson's disease and their contribution to motor disability and quality of life.

Non-motor symptoms are gaining relevance in Parkinson's disease (PD) management but little is known about their progression and contribution to deterioration of quality of life. We followed prospectively 707 PD patients (62 % males) for 2 years. We assessed non-motor symptoms referred to 12 different domains, each including 1-10 specific symptoms, as well as motor state (UPDRS), general cognition, and life quality. Hoehn & Yahr (H&Y) stage was used to categorize patient status (I-II mild; III moderate; IV-V severe). We found that individual non-motor symptoms had variable evolution over the 2-year follow-up with sleep, gastrointestinal, attention/memory and skin disturbances (hyperhidrosis and seborrhea) becoming more prevalent and psychiatric, cardiovascular, and respiratory disorders becoming less prevalent. Development of symptoms in the cardiovascular, apathy, urinary, psychiatric, and fatigue domains was associated with significant life-quality worsening (p < 0.0045, alpha with Bonferroni correction). During the observation period, 123 patients (17 %) worsened clinically while 584 were rated as stable. There was a fivefold greater increase in UPDRS motor score in worse compared with stable patients over 24 months (p < 0.0001 vs. baseline both in stable and worse group). The total number of reported non-motor symptoms increased over 24 months in patients with motor worsening compared to stable ones (p < 0.001). Thirty-nine patients died (3.4 % of patients evaluable at baseline) with mean age at death of 74 years. Deceased patients were older, had significantly higher H&Y stage and motor score, and reported a greater number of non-motor symptoms at baseline. In conclusion, overall non-motor symptom progression does not follow motor deterioration, is symptom-specific, and only development of specific domains negatively impacts quality of life. These results have consequences for drug studies targeting non-motor features.

Prevalence of primary focal or segmental dystonia in adults in the district of foggia, southern Italy: a service-based study.

BACKGROUND: Primary focal or segmental dystonia is a rare clinical condition including early-onset dystonia, which has the tendency to generalize, and late-onset dystonia, which may be focal or segmental. The prevalence of late-onset dystonia ranges from 30 to 7,320 cases per million, but no data are available in Italy. METHODS: A service-based study was conducted in the period 1 January 2001 through 31 December 2002 in the administrative district of Foggia, southern Italy (population 541,653). Cases were traced through hospital discharge diagnosis, botulinum toxin services, day hospital access, ear, nose and throat, ophthalmology and orthopedic surgery specialists, and territorial outpatient services. Inclusion criteria were age 17 years or older, residency in the study area and a diagnosis of primary focal/segmental dystonia. RESULTS: A total of 69 patients were included, giving a crude prevalence of 127.4 per 1,000,000 (women: 146.4; men: 107.0; age 18-34 years: 39.2; 35-54 years: 98.7; 55-74 years: 273.6; 75+ years: 163.3). The standardized rate was 137.5 (95% confidence interval 107.0-174.6). Blepharospasm was the commonest clinical condition (prevalence 68.2), followed by cervical dystonia (prevalence 44.8). CONCLUSION: The prevalence of primary focal or segmental dystonia in Italy is in keeping with several other reports, but is lower than in studies performed in northern Europe, Minnesota, USA, and Japan. The difference in our results may be mostly explained by misdiagnosis, underascertainment of cases and a fairly limited observation period.