A call for a unified and multimodal definition of cellular identity in the enteric nervous system.

The enteric nervous system (ENS) is a tantalizing frontier in neuroscience. With the recent emergence of single cell transcriptomic technologies, this rare and poorly understood tissue has begun to be better characterized in recent years. A precise functional mapping of enteric neuron diversity is critical for understanding ENS biology and enteric neuropathies. Nonetheless, this pursuit has faced considerable technical challenges. By leveraging different methods to compare available primary mouse and human ENS datasets, we underscore the urgent need for careful identity annotation, achieved through the harmonization and advancements of wet lab and computational techniques. We took different approaches including differential gene expression, module scoring, co-expression and correlation analysis, unbiased biological function hierarchical clustering, data integration and label transfer to compare and contrast functional annotations of several independently reported ENS datasets. These analyses highlight substantial discrepancies stemming from an overreliance on transcriptomics data without adequate validation in tissues. To achieve a comprehensive understanding of enteric neuron identity and their functional context, it is imperative to expand tissue sources and incorporate innovative technologies such as multiplexed imaging, electrophysiology, spatial transcriptomics, as well as comprehensive profiling of epigenome, proteome, and metabolome. Harnessing human pluripotent stem cell (hPSC) models provides unique opportunities for delineating lineage trees of the human ENS, and offers unparalleled advantages, including their scalability and compatibility with genetic manipulation and unbiased screens. We encourage a paradigm shift in our comprehension of cellular complexity and function in the ENS by calling for large-scale collaborative efforts and research investments.

Development of the aganglionic colon following surgical rescue in a cell therapy model of Hirschsprung disease in rat.

Patients with Hirschsprung disease lack enteric ganglia in the distal colon and propulsion of colorectal content is substantially impaired. Proposed stem cell therapies to replace neurons require surgical bypass of the aganglionic bowel during re-colonization, but there is inadequate knowledge of the consequences of bypass. We performed bypass surgery in Ednrb-/- Hirschsprung rat pups. Surgically rescued rats failed to thrive, an outcome reversed by supplying electrolyte- and glucose-enriched drinking water. Histologically, the bypassed colon had normal structure, but grew substantially less in diameter than the functional region proximal to the bypass. Extrinsic sympathetic and spinal afferent neurons projected to their normal targets, including arteries and the circular muscle, in aganglionic regions. However, although axons of intrinsic excitatory and inhibitory neurons grew into the aganglionic region, their normally dense innervation of circular muscle was not restored. Large nerve trunks that contained tyrosine hydroxylase (TH)-, calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP, encoded by Calca or Calcb)-, neuronal nitric oxide synthase (nNOS or NOS1)-, vasoactive intestinal peptide (VIP)- and tachykinin (encoded by Tac1)-immunoreactive axons occurred in the distal aganglionic region. We conclude that the rescued Ednrb-/- rat provides a good model for the development of cell therapies for the treatment of Hirschsprung disease.

Group I Metabotropic Glutamate Receptors Modulate Motility and Enteric Neural Activity in the Mouse Colon.

Glutamate is the major excitatory neurotransmitter in the central nervous system, and there is evidence that Group-I metabotropic glutamate receptors (mGlu1 and mGlu5) have established roles in excitatory neurotransmission and synaptic plasticity. While glutamate is abundantly present in the gut, it plays a smaller role in neurotransmission in the enteric nervous system. In this study, we examined the roles of Group-I mGlu receptors in gastrointestinal function. We investigated the expression of Grm1 (mGlu1) and Grm5 (mGlu5) in the mouse myenteric plexus using RNAscope in situ hybridization. Live calcium imaging and motility analysis were performed on ex vivo preparations of the mouse colon. mGlu5 was found to play a role in excitatory enteric neurotransmission, as electrically-evoked calcium transients were sensitive to the mGlu5 antagonist MPEP. However, inhibition of mGlu5 activity did not affect colonic motor complexes (CMCs). Instead, inhibition of mGlu1 using BAY 36-7620 reduced CMC frequency but did not affect enteric neurotransmission. These data highlight complex roles for Group-I mGlu receptors in myenteric neuron activity and colonic function.

Circadian Control of Gastrointestinal Motility.

With the earth's 24-h rotation cycle, physiological function fluctuates in both diurnal and nocturnal animals, thereby ensuring optimal functioning of the body. The main regulator of circadian rhythm is the suprachiasmatic nucleus (SCN), which is considered the main pacemaker or "central clock" of the body. Located in the anterior hypothalamus, the SCN influences the activity of other brain regions, as well as peripheral organs, through the release of melatonin and corticosteroids. The SCN can be entrained by several cues, with light being the major cue. Light information from the retina is received by the SCN via the retinohypothalamic tract. Non-photic cues such as temperature and exercise can also entrain the SCN, while feeding time can entrain the "molecular clock" contained within peripheral tissues. This enables organs such as the gastrointestinal (GI) tract to coordinate function with environmental factors, such as food availability.The GI tract, which has the main functions of receiving and digesting food, and expelling waste, also shows oscillations in its activity during the circadian cycle. While these changes are evident under normal conditions, GI function is affected when normal circadian rhythm is disrupted. Recent reviews have assessed interactions between the central clock and gut clock; as such, this review aims to focus on the presence of endogenous circadian rhythms in the GI tract, with particular focus to changes to gastrointestinal motility.

Upper Gastrointestinal Motility, Disease and Potential of Stem Cell Therapy.

Many gastrointestinal motility disorders arise due to defects in the enteric nervous system. Achalasia and gastroparesis are two extremely debilitating digestive diseases of the upper gastrointestinal tract caused in part by damage or loss of the nitrergic neurons in the esophagus and stomach. Most current pharmacological and surgical interventions provide no long-term relief from symptoms, and none address the cause. Stem cell therapy, to replace the missing neurons and restore normal gut motility, is an attractive alternative therapy. However, there are a number of hurdles that must be overcome to bring this exciting research from the bench to the bedside.

A Novel Method for Identifying the Transition Zone in Long-Segment Hirschsprung Disease: Investigating the Muscle Unit to Ganglion Ratio.

Hirschsprung disease (HSCR) is characterised by the absence of enteric ganglia along variable lengths of the distal bowel. Current gold standard treatment involves the surgical resection of the defective, aganglionic bowel. Clear and reliable distinction of the normoganglionated bowel from the transition zone is key for successful resection of the entire defective bowel, and the avoidance of subsequent postoperative complications. However, the intraoperative nature of the tissue analysis and the variability of patient samples, sample preparation, and operator objectivity, make reproducible identification of the transition zone difficult. Here, we have described a novel method for using muscle units as a distinctive landmark for quantifying the density of enteric ganglia in resection specimens from HSCR patients. We show that the muscle unit to ganglion ratio is greater in the transition zone when compared with the proximal, normoganglionated region for long-segment HSCR patients. Patients with short-segment HSCR were also investigated, however, the muscle unit to ganglion ratio was not significantly different in these patients. Immunohistochemical examination of individual ganglia showed that there were no differences in the proportions of either enteric neurons or glial cells through the different regions of the resected colon. In addition, we identified that the size of enteric ganglia was smaller for patients that went on to develop HSCR associated enterocolitis; although the density of ganglia, as determined by the muscle unit to ganglia ratio, was not different when compared with patients that had no further complications. This suggests that subtle changes in the enteric nervous system, even in the "normoganglionated" colon, could be involved in changes in immune function and subsequent bacterial dysbiosis.

IL-33 promotes gastric tumour growth in concert with activation and recruitment of inflammatory myeloid cells.

Interleukin-33 (IL-33) is an IL-1 family cytokine known to promote T-helper (Th) type 2 immune responses that are often deregulated in gastric cancer (GC). IL-33 is overexpressed in human gastric tumours suggesting a role in driving GC progression although a causal link has not been proven. Here, we investigated the impact of IL-33 genetic deficiency in the well-characterized gp130 F/F mouse model of GC. Expression of IL-33 (and it's cognate receptor, ST2) was increased in human and mouse GC progression. IL-33 deficient gp130 F/F /Il33 -/- mice had reduced gastric tumour growth and reduced recruitment of pro-tumorigenic myeloid cells including key mast cell subsets and type-2 (M2) macrophages. Cell sorting of gastric tumours revealed that IL-33 chiefly localized to gastric (tumour) epithelial cells and was absent from tumour-infiltrating immune cells (except modest IL-33 enrichment within CD11b+ CX3CR1+CD64+MHCII+ macrophages). By contrast, ST2 was absent from gastric epithelial cells and localized exclusively within the (non-macrophage) immune cell fraction together with mast cell markers, Mcpt1 and Mcpt2. Collectively, we show that IL-33 is required for gastric tumour growth and provide evidence of a likely mechanism by which gastric epithelial-derived IL-33 drives mobilization of tumour-promoting inflammatory myeloid cells.

Surgical method to prevent early death of neonatal rat pups with Hirschsprung disease, thus permitting development of long-term therapeutic approaches.

Hirschsprung disease occurs when children are born with no intrinsic nerve cells in varying lengths of the large intestine. In the most severe cases, neurons are also missing from the distal part of the small intestine. Nerve-mediated relaxation of the aganglionic bowel fails and fecal matter accumulates in the more proximal regions of the intestine. This is life threatening. Perforation of the bowel can ensue, causing sepsis and in some cases, death of the infant. Repopulation of the colon with neural stem cells is a potential therapy, but for this to be successful the patient or experimental animal needs to survive long enough for neural precursors to differentiate and make appropriate connections. We have developed a surgical procedure that can be applied to rats with Hirschsprung disease. A stoma was created to allow the normal bowel to empty and a second stoma leading to the aganglionic bowel was also created. This allowed homozygous mutants that would usually die at less than 3 weeks of age to survive into adulthood. During this time, the rats also required post-operative care of their stomas. The interventions we describe provide an animal model of Hirschsprung disease that is suited to assess the effectiveness of cell therapies in the treatment of this condition.

Development, Diversity, and Neurogenic Capacity of Enteric Glia.

Enteric glia are a fascinating population of cells. Initially identified in the gut wall as the "support" cells of the enteric nervous system, studies over the past 20 years have unveiled a vast array of functions carried out by enteric glia. They mediate enteric nervous system signalling and play a vital role in the local regulation of gut functions. Enteric glial cells interact with other gastrointestinal cell types such as those of the epithelium and immune system to preserve homeostasis, and are perceptive to luminal content. Their functional versatility and phenotypic heterogeneity are mirrored by an extensive level of plasticity, illustrated by their reactivity in conditions associated with enteric nervous system dysfunction and disease. As one of the hallmarks of their plasticity and extending their operative relationship with enteric neurons, enteric glia also display neurogenic potential. In this review, we focus on the development of enteric glial cells, and the mechanisms behind their heterogeneity in the adult gut. In addition, we discuss what is currently known about the role of enteric glia as neural precursors in the enteric nervous system.

Role of JNK, MEK and adenylyl cyclase signalling in speed and directionality of enteric neural crest-derived cells.

BACKGROUND: Cells derived from the neural crest colonize the developing gut and give rise to the enteric nervous system. The rate at which the ENCC population advances along the bowel will be affected by both the speed and directionality of individual ENCCs. The aim of the study was to use time-lapse imaging and pharmacological activators and inhibitors to examine the role of several intracellular signalling pathways in both the speed and the directionality of individual enteric neural crest-derived cells in intact explants of E12.5 mouse gut. Drugs that activate or inhibit intracellular components proposed to be involved in GDNF-RET and EDN3-ETB signalling in ENCCs were used. FINDINGS: Pharmacological inhibition of JNK significantly reduced ENCC speed but did not affect ENCC directionality. MEK inhibition did not affect ENCC speed or directionality. Pharmacological activation of adenylyl cyclase or PKA (a downstream cAMP-dependent kinase) resulted in a significant decrease in ENCC speed and an increase in caudal directionality of ENCCs. In addition, adenylyl cyclase activation also resulted in reduced cell-cell contact between ENCCs, however this was not observed following PKA activation, suggesting that the effects of cAMP on adhesion are not mediated by PKA. CONCLUSIONS: JNK is required for normal ENCC migration speed, but not directionality, while cAMP signalling appears to regulate ENCC migration speed, directionality and adhesion. Collectively, our data demonstrate that intracellular signalling pathways can differentially affect the speed and directionality of migrating ENCCs.

A population of nonneuronal GFRα3-expressing cells in the bone marrow resembles nonmyelinating Schwann cells.

Artemin is a neurotrophic factor that plays a crucial role in the regulation of neural development and regeneration and has also been implicated in the pathogenesis of inflammatory pain. The receptor for artemin, GFRα3, is expressed by sympathetic and nociceptive sensory neurons, including some that innervate the bone marrow, but it is unclear if it is also expressed in other cell types in the bone marrow. Our goal in the present study was to characterise the expression of GFRα3 in nonneuronal cells in the bone marrow. Immunohistochemical studies revealed that GFRα3-expressing cells in the bone marrow are spatially associated with blood vessels and are in intimate contact with nerve fibres. We used various combinations of markers to distinguish different cell types and found that the GFRα3-expressing cells expressed markers of nonmyelinating Schwann cells (e.g. GFAP, p75NTR, nestin). Analysis of bone marrow sections of Wnt1-reporter mice also demonstrated that they originate from the neural crest. Further characterisation using flow cytometry revealed that GFRα3 is expressed in a population of CD51+Sca1-PDGFRα- cells, reinforcing the notion that they are neural crest-derived, nonmyelinating Schwann cells. In conclusion, there is a close association between peripheral nerve terminals and a population of nonneuronal cells that express GFRα3 in the bone marrow. The nonneuronal cells have characteristics consistent with a neural crest-derived, nonmyelinating Schwann cell phenotype. Our findings provide a better understanding of the expression pattern of GFRα3 in the bone marrow microenvironment.

Fine scale differences within the vagal neural crest for enteric nervous system formation.

The enteric nervous system is mostly derived from vagal neural crest (NC) cells adjacent to somites (s)1-7. We used in ovo focal fluorescent vital dyes and focal electroporation of fluorophore-encoding plasmids in quail embryos to investigate NC cell migration to the foregut initially and later throughout the entire gut. NC cells of different somite-level origins were largely separate until reaching the foregut at about QE2.5, when all routes converged. By QE3.5, NC cells of different somite-levels became mixed, although s1-s2 NC cells were mainly confined to rostral foregut. Mid-vagal NC-derived cells (s3 and s4 level) arrived earliest at the foregut, and occurred in greatest number. By QE6.5 ENS was present from foregut to hindgut. Mid-vagal NC-derived cells occurred in greatest numbers from foregut to distal hindgut. NC-derived cells of s2, s5, and s6 levels were fewer and were widely distributed but were never observed in the distal hindgut. Rostro-vagal (s1) and caudo-vagal (s7) levels were few and restricted to the foregut. Single somite levels of quail neural tube/NC from s1 to s8 were combined with chick aneural ChE4.5 midgut and hindgut and the ensemble was grown on the chorio-allantoic membrane for 6 days. This tests ENS-forming competence in the absence of intra-segmental competition between NC cells, of differential influences of segmental paraxial tissues, and of positional advantage. All vagal NC-levels, but not s8 level, furnished enteric plexuses in the recipient gut, but the density of both ENS cells in total and neurons was highest from mid-vagal level donors, as was the length colonised. We conclude that the fate and competence for ENS formation of vagal NC sub-levels is not uniform over the vagal level but is biased to favour mid-vagal levels. Overviewing this and prior studies suggests the vagal region is, as in its traditional sense, a natural unit but with complex sub-divisions.

The enteric neural crest progressively loses capacity to form enteric nervous system.

Cells of the vagal neural crest (NC) form most of the enteric nervous system (ENS) by a colonising wave in the embryonic gut, with high cell proliferation and differentiation. Enteric neuropathies have an ENS deficit and cell replacement has been suggested as therapy. This would be performed post-natally, which raises the question of whether the ENS cell population retains its initial ENS-forming potential with age. We tested this on the avian model in organ culture in vitro (3 days) using recipient aneural chick midgut/hindgut combined with ENS-donor quail midgut or hindgut of ages QE5 to QE10. ENS cells from young donor tissues (≤ QE6) avidly colonised the aneural recipient, but this capacity dropped rapidly 2-3 days after the transit of the ENS cell wavefront. This loss in capability was autonomous to the ENS population since a similar decline was observed in ENS cells isolated by HNK1 FACS. Using QE5, 6, 8 and 10 midgut donors and extending the time of assay to 8 days in chorio-allantoic membrane grafts did not produce 'catch up' colonisation. NC-derived cells were counted in dissociated quail embryo gut and in transverse sections of chick embryo gut using NC, neuron and glial marker antibodies. This showed that the decline in ENS-forming ability correlated with a decrease in proportion of ENS cells lacking both neuronal and glial differentiation markers, but there were still large numbers of such cells even at stages with low colonisation ability. Moreover, ENS cells in small numbers from young donors were far superior in colonisation ability to larger numbers of apparently undifferentiated cells from older donors. This suggests that the decline of ENS-forming ability has both quantitative and qualitative aspects. In this case, ENS cells for cell therapies should aim to replicate the embryonic ENS stage rather than using post-natal ENS stem/progenitor cells.

Publisher Correction: Kif1bp loss in mice leads to defects in the peripheral and central nervous system and perinatal death.

A correction to this article has been published and is linked from the HTML and PDF versions of this paper. The error has been fixed in the paper.

Kif1bp loss in mice leads to defects in the peripheral and central nervous system and perinatal death.

Goldberg-Shprintzen syndrome is a poorly understood condition characterized by learning difficulties, facial dysmorphism, microcephaly, and Hirschsprung disease. GOSHS is due to recessive mutations in KIAA1279, which encodes kinesin family member 1 binding protein (KIF1BP, also known as KBP). We examined the effects of inactivation of Kif1bp in mice. Mice lacking Kif1bp died shortly after birth, and exhibited smaller brains, olfactory bulbs and anterior commissures, and defects in the vagal and sympathetic innervation of the gut. Kif1bp was found to interact with Ret to regulate the development of the vagal innervation of the stomach. Although newborn Kif1bp -/- mice had neurons along the entire bowel, the colonization of the gut by neural crest-derived cells was delayed. The data show an essential in vivo role for KIF1BP in axon extension from some neurons, and the reduced size of the olfactory bulb also suggests additional roles for KIF1BP. Our mouse model provides a valuable resource to understand GOSHS.

Spontaneous calcium waves in the developing enteric nervous system.

The enteric nervous system (ENS) is an extensive network of neurons in the gut wall that arises from neural crest-derived cells. Like other populations of neural crest cells, it is known that enteric neural crest-derived cells (ENCCs) influence the behaviour of each other and therefore must communicate. However, little is known about how ENCCs communicate with each other. In this study, we used Ca2+ imaging to examine communication between ENCCs in the embryonic gut, using mice where ENCCs express a genetically-encoded calcium indicator. Spontaneous propagating calcium waves were observed between neighbouring ENCCs, through both neuronal and non-neuronal ENCCs. Pharmacological experiments showed wave propagation was not mediated by gap junctions, but by purinergic signalling via P2 receptors. The expression of several P2X and P2Y receptors was confirmed using RT-PCR. Furthermore, inhibition of P2 receptors altered the morphology of the ENCC network, without affecting neuronal differentiation or ENCC proliferation. It is well established that purines participate in synaptic transmission in the mature ENS. Our results describe, for the first time, purinergic signalling between ENCCs during pre-natal development, which plays roles in the propagation of Ca2+ waves between ENCCs and in ENCC network formation. One previous study has shown that calcium signalling plays a role in sympathetic ganglia formation; our results suggest that calcium waves are likely to be important for enteric ganglia development.

Cell therapy for GI motility disorders: comparison of cell sources and proposed steps for treating Hirschsprung disease.

Cell therapeutic approaches to treat a range of congenital and degenerative neuropathies are under intense investigation. There have been recent significant advancements in the development of cell therapy to treat disorders of the enteric nervous system (ENS), enteric neuropathies. These advances include the efficient generation of enteric neural progenitors from pluripotent stem cells and the rescue of a Hirschsprung disease model mouse following their transplantation into the bowel. Furthermore, a recent study provides evidence of functional innervation of the bowel muscle by neurons derived from transplanted ENS-derived neural progenitors. This mini-review discusses these recent findings, compares endogenous ENS-derived progenitors and pluripotent stem cell-derived progenitors as a cell source for therapy, and proposes the key steps for cell therapy to treat Hirschsprung disease.

Optogenetic Demonstration of Functional Innervation of Mouse Colon by Neurons Derived From Transplanted Neural Cells.

BACKGROUND & AIMS: Cell therapy offers the potential to treat gastrointestinal motility disorders caused by diseased or absent enteric neurons. We examined whether neurons generated from transplanted enteric neural cells provide a functional innervation of bowel smooth muscle in mice. METHODS: Enteric neural cells expressing the light-sensitive ion channel, channelrhodopsin, were isolated from the fetal or postnatal mouse bowel and transplanted into the distal colon of 3- to 4-week-old wild-type recipient mice. Intracellular electrophysiological recordings of responses to light stimulation of the transplanted cells were made from colonic smooth muscle cells in recipient mice. Electrical stimulation of endogenous enteric neurons was used as a control. RESULTS: The axons of graft-derived neurons formed a plexus in the circular muscle layer. Selective stimulation of graft-derived cells by light resulted in excitatory and inhibitory junction potentials, the electrical events underlying contraction and relaxation, respectively, in colonic muscle cells. Graft-derived excitatory and inhibitory motor neurons released the same neurotransmitters as endogenous motor neurons-acetylcholine and a combination of adenosine triphosphate and nitric oxide, respectively. Graft-derived neurons also included interneurons that provided synaptic inputs to motor neurons, but the pharmacologic properties of interneurons varied with the age of the donors from which enteric neural cells were obtained. CONCLUSIONS: Enteric neural cells transplanted into the bowel give rise to multiple functional types of neurons that integrate and provide a functional innervation of the smooth muscle of the bowel wall. Circuits composed of both motor neurons and interneurons were established, but the age at which cells are isolated influences the neurotransmitter phenotype of interneurons that are generated.

Exposure to GDNF Enhances the Ability of Enteric Neural Progenitors to Generate an Enteric Nervous System.

Cell therapy is a promising approach to generate an enteric nervous system (ENS) and treat enteric neuropathies. However, for translation to the clinic, it is highly likely that enteric neural progenitors will require manipulation prior to transplantation to enhance their ability to migrate and generate an ENS. In this study, we examine the effects of exposure to several factors on the ability of ENS progenitors, grown as enteric neurospheres, to migrate and generate an ENS. Exposure to glial-cell-line-derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF) resulted in a 14-fold increase in neurosphere volume and a 12-fold increase in cell number. Following co-culture with embryonic gut or transplantation into the colon of postnatal mice in vivo, cells derived from GDNF-treated neurospheres showed a 2-fold increase in the distance migrated compared with controls. Our data show that the ability of enteric neurospheres to generate an ENS can be enhanced by exposure to appropriate factors.