Shaping the norms that regulate international commerce of embryos.

As various embryo technologies in livestock were developed and evolved to a state of usefulness over the past 40 years, scientists with a specific interest in infectious diseases sought to determine the epidemiologic consequences of movement, especially international movement, of increasing numbers of embryos. Many of the foundational studies in this area were reported in Theriogenology, beginning in the 1970s and especially throughout the 1980s and 1990s. Unquestionably, Theriogenology has been a widely used venue for dissemination of basic information on this subject, which ultimately led to the development of the now universally accepted techniques for certification of embryo health. Today it is well-recognized that movement in commerce of embryos, especially in vivo-derived embryos, is a very low-risk method for exchange of animal germ plasm. This paper chronicles the evolution of strategies for health certification of embryos. An overview is provided of the calculated efforts of practitioners, scientists, and regulators to organize, forge necessary partnerships, stimulate needed research, provide purposeful analysis of the results, and, through these processes, guarantee the universal acceptance of efficient protocols for certifying the health of embryos intended for movement in international commerce.

Epidemiology of prolonged testicular infections with bovine viral diarrhea virus.

Previously, bovine viral diarrhea virus (BVDV) had been found in prolonged testicular infections following acute infection of immunocompetent bulls. The primary purpose of this research was to evaluate the production and maintenance of prolonged testicular infections after exposure to BVDV of seronegative bulls in varying circumstances. The secondary objective was to initiate assessment of the potential for transmission of BVDV via semen of bulls exhibiting a prolonged testicular infection. In total, 10 research trials were conducted. The first trial examined the duration of detectable virus in semen after intranasal inoculation of peri-pubertal bulls. The second to fifth trials examined the potential for prolonged testicular infections resulting from natural exposure of seronegative bulls to persistently infected heifers. In the last five trials, the potential for viral transmission from bulls exhibiting prolonged testicular infections to a small number of exposed animals (n=28) was evaluated. Results of this research demonstrated that prolonged testicular infections could result in detection of viral RNA in semen for 2.75 years with infectious virus grown from testicular tissue 12.5 months after viral exposure. A type 1b strain of BVDV caused prolonged testicular infection after natural exposure of seronegative bulls to a persistently infected heifer. However, transmission of BVDV to susceptible animals was not detected in the final five trials of this research. In conclusion, BVDV can persist in testicular tissue after acute infection for several years, but the potential for viral transmission from these prolonged testicular infections appears to be low.

Normal reproductive capacity of heifers that originated from in vitro fertilized embryos cultured with an antiviral compound.

Bovine viral diarrhea virus (BVDV) can associate with in vitro fertilized (IVF) bovine embryos despite washing and trypsin treatment. An antiviral compound, DB606 (2-(4-[2-imidazolinyl]phenyl)-5-(4-methoxyphenyl)furan), inhibits the replication of BVDV in bovine uterine tubal epithelial cells, Madin Darby bovine kidney cells, and fetal fibroblast cells. As well, DB606 in in vitro culture medium does not affect embryonic development. Antiviral-treated-IVF embryos placed into recipients developed into clinically normal calves. The objective of this project was to determine if these resultant heifer calves were capable of reproducing. Seven heifers from each of the treatment groups (natural breeding, IVF embryo, and IVF embryo cultured in DB606) of the previous study were used. At 20-27 months of age, the heifers were exposed to a fertile bull in a single pasture during a 63 d breeding season. Five of the seven heifers originating from natural breeding were pregnant 35 d after removal of the bull and calved. All of the heifers resulting from transfer of untreated IVF embryos were pregnant at 35 d; however, one aborted the fetus at 5-7 months of gestation. All of the heifers derived from transfer of IVF embryos cultured in DB606 were pregnant and calved. Offspring from dams of all treatment groups were clinically normal at birth. Adjusted 205 d weaning weights were not significantly different among the offspring of the treated and untreated dams. These results indicate that culture of bovine-IVF embryos in DB606 does not impair future reproductive capacity of resulting heifers.

Development of a duplex quantitative polymerase chain reaction assay for detection of bovine herpesvirus 1 and bovine viral diarrhea virus in bovine follicular fluid.

The objective of this study was to develop a duplex quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) assay for simultaneous detection of bovine herpesvirus 1 (BoHV-1) and bovine viral diarrhea virus (BVDV) type I and type II. Follicular fluid was collected from a BoHV-1 acutely infected heifer, a BVDV I persistently infected heifer, and from 10 ovaries recovered from an abattoir. Both the BoHV-1 and BVDV contaminated follicular fluid were diluted 1:5 to 1:10(7) using the pooled, abattoir-origin follicular fluid. Each dilution sample was analyzed using the duplex qPCR, virus isolation, reverse transcription-nested PCR (RT-nPCR), and BoHV-1 qPCR. The duplex qPCR was able to simultaneously detect BoHV-1 and BVDV I in the fluid diluted to 1:100 and 1:1000, respectively. These results corresponded with the reverse transcription-nested PCR and BoHV-1 qPCR. Therefore, the duplex qPCR might be used for quality assurance testing to identify these two viruses in cells, fluids and tissues collected from donor animals and used in reproductive technologies.

Comparison of tests for detection of bovine viral diarrhea virus in diagnostic samples.

Currently, a variety of tests are used to detect bovine viral diarrhea virus (BVDV) in persistently infected (PI) cattle. These tests include immunohistochemical staining (IHC), antigen capture enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ACE), virus isolation (VI), and reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). However, a lack of methods standardization could compromise the ability to consistently identify animals infected with BVDV. This study evaluated the diagnostic proficiency of current methods for detecting BVDV in infected cattle using intra- and interlaboratory comparisons. Samples were collected from 4 animals more than 7 months of age (2 BVDV negative animals, a PI animal, and a PI animal that previously lacked detectable virus in serum as determined by VI). Samples were submitted to 23 participating diagnostic laboratories using the respective laboratory's standard submission protocol. Samples collected for submission included: 1) serum for ACE, RT-PCR, and VI; 2) whole blood for RT-PCR and VI; and 3) skin biopsies for ACE and IHC. The ACE performed on skin provided the greatest consistency in detecting positive samples and a perfect level of agreement among laboratories. Reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction and IHC performed well by correctly identifying > or = 85% of samples positive for BVDV. Virus isolation performed on serum yielded the lowest consistency in detecting positive samples and the lowest level of agreement. The level of agreement between laboratories for detecting BVDV in persistently infected cattle ranged from perfect to less than expected by chance. The variation between laboratories suggests a need for training opportunities in standardized laboratory protocols and proficiency testing.

Relative risks and approaches to biosecurity in the use of embryo technologies in livestock.

Embryo technologies have been integrated into production systems for a variety of livestock species. As relates to transmission of infectious diseases, our working hypothesis has been that use of embryo transfer for distribution of germ plasm within and between herds and flocks is likely safer than the movement of postnatal animals. Indeed, research and experience generally have been supportive of this hypothesis. However, the relative risks of transmitting infectious agents via embryo transfer vary among donor species. Further, different methods of producing embryos appear to present different risks. This paper provides a comparative overview of the risks of transmitting infectious diseases via transfer of both in vivo- and in vitro-derived embryos in common domesticated livestock species. Also discussed are universal approaches to biosecurity in embryo production and transfer.

Noncytopathic bovine viral diarrhea virus can persist in testicular tissue after vaccination of peri-pubertal bulls but prevents subsequent infection.

The objectives of this research were to evaluate the risk of prolonged testicular infection as a consequence of vaccination of peri-pubertal bulls with a modified-live, noncytopathic strain of BVDV and to assess vaccine efficacy in preventing prolonged testicular infections after a subsequent acute infection. Seronegative, peri-pubertal bulls were vaccinated subcutaneously with an approximate minimum immunizing dose or a 10x standard dose of modified-live, noncytopathic BVDV or were maintained as unvaccinated controls. Forty-nine days after vaccination, all bulls were intranasally inoculated with a noncytopathic field strain of BVDV. Semen and testicular biopsies collected after vaccination and challenge were assayed for BVDV using virus isolation, reverse transcription-nested PCR, or immunohistochemistry and the identity of viral strains was determined by nucleotide sequencing of PCR products. The vaccine strain of BVDV was detected in testicular tissue of vaccinated bulls as long as 134 days after immunization. Prolonged testicular infections with the challenge strain were detected only in unvaccinated bulls as long as 85 days after challenge. Whereas vaccination caused prolonged testicular infection in some bulls, it did prevent subsequent infection of testicular tissue with the challenge strain. This research demonstrates that subcutaneous vaccination of naïve, peri-pubertal bulls with a noncytopathic, modified-live strain of BVDV can result in prolonged viral replication within testicular tissue. The risk for these prolonged testicular infections to cause venereal transmission of BVDV or subfertility is likely to be low but requires further investigation.

Use of a modified-live vaccine to prevent persistent testicular infection with bovine viral diarrhea virus.

A commercial vaccine containing modified-live bovine viral diarrhea virus (BVDV; types 1 and 2) was administered to one group of 22 peripubertal bulls 28 days before intranasal inoculation with a type 1 strain of BVDV. A second group of 23 peripubertal bulls did not receive the modified-live BVDV vaccine before intranasal inoculation. Ten of 23 unvaccinated bulls--but none of the vaccinated bulls--developed a persistent testicular infection as determined by immunohistochemistry and polymerase chain reaction. Results of this study indicate that administration of a modified-live vaccine containing BVDV can prevent persistent testicular infection if peripubertal bulls are vaccinated before viral exposure.

Effect of phosphonoformic acid in the development of bovine embryos in vitro.

This research evaluated the ability of phosphonoformic acid to inhibit bovine herpesvirus 1 (BHV-1) in cumulus cells commonly used in co-culture with bovine in vitro-produced embryos. At 200 and 400 microg/ml, phosphonoformic acid inhibited 4 logs of BHV-1. Subsequently, phosphonoformic acid (200 and 400 microg/ml) added to both in vitro fertilization and culture medium resulted in a decrease in the proportion of developed blastocysts, and the number of cells per blastocyst was lower in the treated embryos. Therefore, while phosphonoformic acid can effectively inhibit replication of BHV-1 in co-culture cells, it also inhibits development of in vitro-produced bovine embryos.

Seroconversion of calves following intravenous injection with embryos exposed to bovine viral diarrhea virus (BVDV) in vitro.

Two recent studies demonstrated that a high-affinity isolate of BVDV (SD-1), remained associated with a small percentage of in vivo-derived bovine embryos following artificial exposure to the virus and either washing or trypsin treatment. Further, the embryo-associated virus was infective in an in vitro environment. Therefore, the objective of this study was to determine if the quantity of a high-affinity isolate of BVDV associated with single-washed or trypsin-treated embryos could cause infection in vivo. Twenty zona-pellucida-intact morulae and blastocysts (MB) were collected on day 7 from superovulated cows. After collection, all MB were washed according to International Embryo Transfer Society (IETS) standards, and all but 4 MB (negative controls) were exposed for 2 h to 10(5)-10(6) cell culture infective doses (50% endpoint) per milliliter (CCID(50)/mL) of viral strain SD-1. Following exposure, according to IETS standards, one half of the MB were washed and one half were trypsin treated. All MB were then individually sonicated, and sonicate fluids were injected intravenously into calves on day 0. Blood was drawn to monitor for viremia and(or) seroconversion. Seroconversion of calves injected with sonicate fluids from washed and trypsin-treated embryos occurred 38% and 13% of the time, respectively. Therefore, the quantity of a high-affinity isolate of BVDV associated with single-washed or trypsin-treated embryos was infective in vivo.

Bovine viral diarrhea virus (BVDV) in cell lines used for somatic cell cloning.

Culture of cell lines from fetuses or postnatal animals is an essential part of somatic cell cloning. Fetal bovine serum (FBS) is commonly used in media for propagation of these cells. Unfortunately, bovine fetuses and postnatal animals as well as FBS are all possible sources of non-cytopathic bovine viral diarrhea virus (BVDV) which is widely distributed among cattle. This study was prompted when screening of samples sent to veterinary diagnostic labs revealed that 15 of 39 fetal fibroblast cell lines used in cloning research were positive for BVDV as determined by various assays including reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). Goals of the research were to use both virus isolation and reverse transcription-nested polymerase chain reaction (RT-nPCR) to confirm which of the cell lines were actually infected with BVDV and to assay samples of media, FBS and the earliest available passages of each cell line in an attempt to determine the source of the viral infections. Sequence analysis of amplified cDNA from all isolates was performed to provide a definitive link between possible sources of virus and infected cell lines. Only 5 of the 39 cell lines were actually infected with BVDV. Three of these five lines were not infected at the earliest cryopreserved passage, leading to the conclusion that they likely became infected after culture in media containing contaminated FBS. In fact, sequence comparison of the amplified cDNA from one lot of FBS confirmed that it was the source of infection for one of these cell lines. Since BVDV was isolated from the remaining two cell lines at the earliest available passage, the fetuses from which they were established could not be ruled out as the source of the virus.

Prevention and elimination of bovine viral diarrhea virus infections in fetal fibroblast cells.

Noncytopathic infections with bovine viral diarrhea virus (BVDV) can compromise research and commercial use of cultured cells. The purpose of this research was to evaluate the ability of aromatic cationic compounds to prevent or treat BVDV infections in fetal fibroblast cell lines that are used in somatic cell nuclear transfer. To evaluate preventative use of compounds, 10 cell lines were inoculated with BVDV in the absence or presence of 2-(4-[2-imidazolinyl]phenyl)-5-(4-methoxyphenyl)furan (DB606), 2-(2-benzimidazolyl)-5-[4-(2-imidazolino)phenyl]furan dihydrochloride (DB772), or 2-(1-methyl-2-benzimidazolyl)-5-[4'-(2-imidazolino)-2'-methylphenyl]furan dihydrochloride (DB824). The 99% endpoints for prevention of viral replication by these treatments were 81, 6, and 14 nM. To evaluate therapeutic use of compounds, two fetal fibroblast cell lines infected with a genotype 1a strain of BVDV were cultured through four passages in the absence or presence of either 0.04 or 4 microM concentrations of DB772 or DB824. The presence and concentration of BVDV in media and cell lysates were evaluated using reverse transcription nested polymerase chain reaction and virus isolation from titrated sample. A single passage in 4 microM of either compound was sufficient to eliminate BVDV from cells without causing cytotoxicity. Our results demonstrate that in vitro infections with BVDV can be effectively prevented or eliminated by addition of aromatic cations.

Infectivity of bovine viral diarrhea virus associated with in vivo-derived bovine embryos.

Early research indicated that bovine viral diarrhea virus (BVDV) would not adhere to zona pellucida-intact (ZP-I), in vivo-derived bovine embryos. However, in a recent study, viral association of BVDV and in vivo-derived embryos was demonstrated. These findings raised questions regarding the infectivity of the embryo-associated virus. The objectives of this study were to evaluate the infectivity of BVDV associated with in vivo-derived bovine embryos through utilization of primary cultures of uterine tubal cells (UTC) as an in vitro model of the uterine environment and to determine if washing procedures, including trypsin treatment, were adequate to remove virus from in vivo-derived embryos. One hundred and nine ZP-I morulae and blastocysts (MB) and 77 non-fertile and degenerated (NFD) ova were collected on day 7 from 34, BVDV-negative, superovulated cows. After collection, all MB and NFD ova were washed according to International Embryo Transfer Society (IETS) standards and exposed for 2h to approximately 10(6) cell culture infective doses (50% endpoint) per milliliter of viral strain SD-1. Following exposure, some groups of <10 MB or NFD ova were washed in accordance with IETS standards. In addition, an equivalent number of MB and NFD ova were subjected to IETS standards for trypsin treatment. Subsequently, NFD ova were immediately sonicated and sonicate fluids were assayed for presence of virus, while individual and groups of MB were placed in microdrops containing primary cultures of UTCs and incubated. After 3 days, embryos, media, and UTCs were harvested from each microdrop and assayed for BVDV. Virus was detected in the sonicate fluids of 56 and 43% of the groups of NFD ova that were washed and trypsin-treated, respectively. After 3 days of microdrop culture, virus was not detected in media or sonicate fluids from any individual or groups of MB, regardless of treatment. However, virus was detected in a proportion of UTC that were co-cultured with washed groups of MB (30%), washed individual MB (9%) and trypsin treated individual MB (9%), but no virus was detected in the UTC associated with groups of trypsin-treated embryos. In conclusion, virus associated with developing embryos was infective for permissive cells. Further, the quantity of virus associated with a proportion of individual embryos (both washed and trypsin treated) was sufficient to infect the UTC. In light of these results, an attempt should be made to determine if the quantity of a high-affinity isolate of BVDV associated with an individual embryo would infect recipients via the intrauterine route.

Different strains of noncytopathic bovine viral diarrhea virus (BVDV) vary in their affinity for in vivo-derived bovine embryos.

Washing procedures (without trypsin treatment) recommended by the International Embryo Transfer Society (IETS) for use on in vivo-derived embryos effectively removed a cytopathic strain (NADL) of bovine viral diarrhea virus (BVDV) after artificial exposure. However, these washing procedures have not been evaluated using other isolates of BVDV, including representative non-cytopathic strains. Thus, the objective of this study was to evaluate the efficacy of the IETS procedures following artificial exposure of in vivo-derived bovine embryos to two different strains and biotypes of BVDV. One hundred and twenty-nine zona pellucida-intact (ZP-I) morulae and blastocysts (MB) and 56 non-fertile and degenerated (NFD) ova were collected 7 days following exposure to bulls from 32, BVDV-negative, superovulated cows. After collection, all MB and NFD ova were washed according to IETS standards. Subsequently, half of the MB and NFD ova were exposed for 1h to approximately 10(6)-cell culture infective doses (50% endpoint) per milliliter of viral strain SD-1, and the other half were exposed to the same concentration of CD-87. After exposure, groups of > or =3 and < or = 10 MB or NFD ova were washed using methods that met or exceeded IETS standards. Then, the washed groups were sonicated, and sonicate fluids were assayed for presence of virus using virus isolation and a reverse transcription nested polymerase chain reaction. No virus was detected in any group of MB or NFD ova that had been exposed to the CD-87 isolate. However, virus was detected in association with 50% of the groups of MB and 33% of the groups of NFD ova that had been exposed to the SD-1 isolate. Therefore, standard embryo-washing procedures recommended by the IETS are more effective for removal of some isolates of BVDV than for others. It remains to be determined if the quantity of a high-affinity isolate of BVDV associated with individual washed embryos would infect recipients via the intrauterine route. Further, it should be determined if an alternative embryo processing procedure, washing and trypsin treatment, would be more effective for removal of high-affinity isolates.

Biosecurity issues associated with current and emerging embryo technologies.

A variety of procedures associated with in vivo and in vitro embryo production, as well as cloning and transgenics, are in current use by both researchers and practitioners. Biohazards associated with these procedures could influence clinical proficiency and the outcome of basic research or result in unusual distribution of pathogens in populations of animals. By their nature, embryo technologies are vulnerable to contamination from numerous sources. Although pathogens can originate in the physical environments in which embryo technologies are applied, they are more likely to be introduced via animals or materials of animal origin. However, it is important to note that both the occurrence and consequences of contamination are heavily influenced by environmental circumstances. This paper represents a philosophical description of biohazards associated with three generations of embryo technologies using the cow as a model species. Emphasis is placed on sources of contamination, current or suggested preventive actions and the issue of environmental changes as they relate to the emergence of biohazards and the implementation of biosecurity measures. Some specific pathogens are discussed for illustration. In addition, details of the risks associated with introducing bovine viral diarrhoea virus in each of three generations of embryo technologies are described.

Bovine herpesvirus-1 associated with single, trypsin-treated embryos was not infective for uterine tubal cells.

It has been reported that bovine herpesvirus-1 (BHV-1) remains associated with in vitro-produced (IVP) bovine embryos after exposure to the virus and either washing or trypsin treatment. However, it is not known if the quantity of virus associated with an exposed IVP embryo is likely to infect a recipient cow after transfer. The specific objective of this study was to determine if IVP embryos that were exposed to BHV-1 would infect uterine tubal cells (UTC) in a co-culture system. In vitro-produced Day 7 embryos were exposed to BHV-1 and then washed or trypsin treated according to the IETS guidelines. These embryos were then co-cultured individually or in groups with UTC in microdrops of tissue culture medium 199 (TCM 199) supplemented with 10% equine serum. Following co-culture for 48 h, virus isolation was attempted on the embryos and the UTC from each drop. Virus was detected in washed individual embryos, groups of washed embryos, groups of trypsin-treated embryos and the UTC co-cultured with each of these treatments. However, BHV-1 was not detected in the individual, trypsin-treated embryos or the UTC co-cultured with them. It is concluded that trypsin treatment might effectively prevent infection of recipients if individual, Day 7, exposed embryos were transferred into the uterus.

Detection of inhibition of bovine viral diarrhea virus by aromatic cationic molecules.

Bovine viral diarrhea virus (BVDV) is an economically significant pathogen of cattle and a problematic contaminant in the laboratory. BVDV is often used as an in vitro model for hepatitis C virus during drug discovery efforts. Aromatic dicationic molecules have exhibited inhibitory activity against several RNA viruses. Thus, the purpose of this research was to develop and apply a method for screening the aromatic cationic compounds for in vitro cytotoxicity and activity against a noncytopathic strain of BVDV. The screening method evaluated the concentration of BVDV in medium and cell lysates after 72 h of cell culture in the presence of either a 25 or 5 microM concentration of the test compound. Five of 93 screened compounds were selected for further determination of inhibitory (90 and 50%) and cytotoxic (50 and 10%) concentration endpoints. The screening method identified compounds that exhibited inhibition of BVDV at nanomolar concentrations while exhibiting no cytotoxicity at 25 microM concentrations. The leading compounds require further investigation to determine their mechanism of action, in vivo activity, and specific activity against hepatitis C virus.

Detection of bovine viral diarrhea virus in semen obtained after inoculation of seronegative postpubertal bulls.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate persistence of bovine viral diarrhea virus (BVDV) in semen after inoculation of postpubertal bulls. ANIMALS: Three 2-year-old bulls and five 6-month-old calves. PROCEDURE: 3 seronegative 2-year-old bulls were inoculated intranasally with BVDV. Serum and semen samples were obtained at regular intervals until 7 months after inoculation. Serum samples were tested for BVDV by use of virus isolation (VI) and reverse transcription-nested polymerase chain reaction (RT-nPCR) tests. Semen samples were tested for virus by use of VI and RT-nPCR tests. Testicular biopsy specimens were obtained 7 months after inoculation and tested for BVDV by use of immunohistochemical analysis and VI and RT-nPCR tests. Semen samples collected from 1 bull immediately before and 5 and 7 months after inoculation were administered IV to seronegative calves, which were monitored for subsequent viremia and seroconversion. RESULTS: Use of VI and RT-nPCR tests detected transient virus in serum of all bulls. The VI test detected BVDV in semen of 2 bulls for < 21 days after inoculation, whereas RT-nPCR assay detected BVDV until 7 months after inoculation. Virus was detected in testicular biopsy specimens of these 2 bulls by use of immunohistochemical analysis and RT-nPCR assay but could only be isolated from the biopsy specimen of 1 bull. Of the calves administered semen IV to detect infectious virus, only the recipient of semen collected 5 months after inoculation of the adult bull was viremic and seroconverted. CONCLUSIONS AND CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Bovine viral diarrhea virus can persist in semen of acutely infected bulls for several months after exposure.

Diagnostic dilemma encountered when detecting bovine viral diarrhea virus in IVF embryo production.

Routine quality controls in production of bovine embryos by in vitro fertilization (IVF) should include screening all materials of animal origin for the presence of bovine viral diarrhea virus (BVDV). Using a reverse transcription nested polymerase chain reaction (RT-nPCR) assay, we detected BVDV in primary cultures of uterine tubal cells (UTC) that had been used during IVF procedures. The goal of our ensuing investigation was to determine its source and assess risks associated with the identified contaminant. Sequencing of the amplified 5' nontranslated region (NTR) of the viral genome confirmed a Genotype I BVDV contaminant. This viral contaminant was also identified by RT-nPCR in multiple samples of the same lot of fetal bovine serum (FBS) that was used in transport media by the laboratory that harvested the UTC. Both routine and enhanced roller bottle methods for virus isolation failed to detect BVDV in the FBS. Furthermore, virus neutralization assays did identify antibodies to Genotype I strains of BVDV in the FBS. After 7 days of co-incubation, neither cultured, washed UTC nor exposed, washed embryos were RT-nPCR positive for BVDV. Eight embryos produced in the contaminated system were nonsurgically transferred into eight seronegative cows. None of the embryo recipients seroconverted to BVDV. Thus, contamination of cell culture medium with BVDV did not result in transmission of the virus when IVF embryos were transferred. Failure to transmit disease was likely aided by serendipitous control from anti-BVDV antibodies in the FBS. However, a diagnostic dilemma was created when the RT-nPCR assays used to screen for BVDV were positive, yet attempts to isolate the virus were negative. This case study illustrates that if molecular assays are to be used to confirm the pathogen-free status of IVF embryo production systems, media components of animal origin (e.g. FBS) should be screened with molecular assays for BVDV as well as traditional virus isolation techniques.

Bovine viral diarrhea virus (BVDV) and anti-BVDV antibodies in pooled samples of follicular fluid.

Bovine viral diarrhea virus (BVDV) can be found in cells and fluids from ovaries collected at the abattoir. On the other hand, immunoglobulins are also found in the fluid of ovarian follicles. Anti-BVDV antibodies in follicular fluid might reduce cross-contamination of COCs at the time of collection or hinder the use of virus isolation to test for the presence of virus. One objective of this study was to determine the frequency with which BVDV could be found in pooled follicular fluid collected during the periodic aspiration of COCs from abattoir-origin ovaries. A second objective was to determine the prevalence and neutralizing activity of anti-BVDV antibodies in these blended samples. We collected samples of pooled follicular fluid (n = 55) over a 20-month period as part of our routine oocyte collection activities. We assayed each sample for BVDV using virus isolation as well as reverse transcription nested polymerase chain reaction (RT-nPCR) procedures. We also tested follicular fluid for antibody that would neutralize four representative strains of BVDV (SD-1, a genotype 1a strain; NY-1, a genotype lb strain; CD-87, a genotype 2 strain, and PA-131, a divergent genotype 2 strain). We detected no BVDV by virus isolation, but we did identify the virus by RT-nPCR in one of the 55 samples of follicular fluid. Automated dye terminator nucleotide sequencing of the amplified portion of the viral genome indicated a genotype 1 strain that was distinct from any of our laboratory strains. In addition, each of the samples of follicular fluid contained sufficient antibody to neutralize large quantities of each of the four laboratory strains that were used. Finding BVDV in just 1 of 55 samples was consistent with reports of similar studies in which the occurrence of BVDV in abattoir-origin materials ranged from 0.9 to 12%. We presumed that failure to isolate the virus was due to neutralizing antibody in the sample. Thus, the incidence of BVDV contamination of our IVF system at the level of pooling of follicular fluid was low for the 20-month period. The presence of anti-BVDV antibody in pooled follicular fluid provided a coincidental means of neutralizing BVDV when it was introduced in fluid aspirated from infected ovaries.