Thermodynamic solubility measurement without chemical analysis.

In this work, the optical imaging based single particle analysis (SPA) and the gold standard shake-flask (SF) solubility methods are compared. We show that to analyze pharmaceutical compounds spanning 7 log units in solubility and a diverse chemical space with limited resources, several analytical techniques are required (HPLC-UV, LC-MS, refractometry and UV-Vis spectrometry), whereas solely the SPA method is able to analyze all the same compounds. SPA experiments take only minutes, while for SF, it may take days to reach thermodynamic equilibration. This decreases the time span needed for the solubility experiment from initial preparations to obtaining the result from roughly three days to less than three hours. The optimal particle size for SPA ranges from approximately one to hundreds of microns. Challenges include measuring large particles, very fast dissolving compounds and handling small sample sizes. Inherent exclusion of density from the SPA measurement is a potential source of error for compounds with very low or high density values. The average relative difference of 37 % between the two methods is very good in the realm of solubility, where 400 % interlaboratory reproducibility can be expected.

Trends in oral small-molecule drug discovery and product development based on product launches before and after the Rule of Five.

In 1997, the 'Rule of Five' (Ro5) suggested physicochemical limitations for orally administered drugs, based on the analysis of chemical libraries from the early 1990s. In this review, we report on the trends in oral drug product development by analyzing products launched between 1994 and 1997 and between 2013 and 2019. Our analysis confirmed that most new oral drugs are within the Ro5 descriptors; however, the number of new drug products of drugs with molecular weight (MW) and calculated partition coefficient (clogP) beyond the Ro5 has slightly increased. Analysis revealed that there is no single scientific or technological reason for this trend, but that it likely results from incremental advances are being made in molecular biology, target diversity, drug design, medicinal chemistry, predictive modeling, drug metabolism and pharmacokinetics, and drug delivery.

Fast imaging-based single particle analysis method for solubility determination.

The solubility and dissolution rates of chemical compounds are crucial properties in several fields of industry and research. However, accurate, rapid and green methods for their measurement, which only consume micrograms of compound, are lacking. Here, the unique approach of non-specific, image-based single particle analysis (SPA) for solubility testing is directly compared to and thus validated on the mid-solubility range with the current gold standard shake-flask method with UV-Vis spectroscopy employed for determining sample concentrations. Five biologically active compounds representing a range of physicochemical properties including pKa and logP were analyzed with both methods. The comparison of SPA and the shake-flask (SF) analysis shows excellent linear correlation (R2 = 0.99). Higher variability of the SPA method is attributed to variability between the properties of individual particles, which cannot be detected with traditional methods. Due to the similar average solubility values compared to those produced with SF, it is concluded that the SPA method has great potential as an analytical tool for small-scale solubility studies. It also has several practical advantages over the current gold standard shake-flask method, such as speed, low consumables consumption, and no requirement for prior knowledge of compound chemistry.

Machine-Vision-Enabled Salt Dissolution Analysis.

Salt formation is a well-established method to increase the solubility of ionizable drug candidates. However, possible conversion of salt to its original form of free acid or base-disproportionation-can have a drastic effect on the solubility and consequently the bioavailability of a drug. Therefore, during the salt selection process, the salt dissolution behavior should be well understood. Improved understanding could be achieved by a method that enables simultaneous screening of small sample amounts and detailed dissolution process analysis. Here, we use a machine-vision-based single-particle analysis (SPA) method to successfully determine the pH-solubility profile, intrinsic solubility, common-ion effect, pKa, pHmax, and Ksp values of three model compounds in a fast and low sample consumption (<1 mg) manner. Moreover, the SPA method enables, with a particle-scale resolution, in situ observation of the disproportionation process and its immediate effect on the morphology and solubility of dissolving species. In this study, a potentially higher energy thermodynamic solid-state form of diclofenac free acid and an intriguing conversion to liquid verapamil free base were observed upon disproportionation of the respective salts. As such, the SPA method offers a low sample consumption platform for fast yet elaborate characterization of the salt dissolution behavior.

Image-based dissolution analysis for tracking the surface stability of amorphous powders.

Poor solubility of crystalline drugs can be overcome by amorphization - the production of high-energy disordered solid with improved solubility. However, the improved solubility comes at a cost of reduced stability; amorphous drugs are prone to recrystallization. Because of recrystallization, the initial solubility enhancement is eventually lost. Therefore, it is important to understand the recrystallization process during storage of amorphous materials and its impact on dissolution/solubility. Here, we demonstrate the use of image-based single-particle analysis (SPA) to consistently monitor the solubility of an amorphous indomethacin sample over time. The results are compared to the XRPD signal of the same sample. For the sample stored at 22 °C/23% relative humidity (RH), full crystallinity as indicated by XRPD was reached around day 40, whereas a solubility corresponding to that of the γ crystalline form was measured with SPA at day 25. For the sample stored at 22 °C/75% RH, the XRPD signal indicated a rapid initial phase of crystallization. However, the sample failed to fully crystallize in 80 days. With SPA, solubility slightly above that of the crystalline γ form was measured already on the second day. To conclude, the solubility measured with SPA directly reflects the solid-state changes occurring on the particle surface. Therefore, it can provide vital information - in a straightforward manner while requiring only minuscule sample amounts - for understanding the effect of storage conditions on the dissolution/solubility of amorphous materials, especially important in pharmaceutical science.

Direct Measurement of Amorphous Solubility.

Amorphous materials exhibit distinct physicochemical properties compared to their respective crystalline counterparts. One of these properties, the increased solubility of amorphous materials, is exploited in the pharmaceutical industry as a way of increasing bioavailability of poorly water-soluble drugs. Despite the increasing interest in drug amorphization, the analytical physicochemical toolbox is lacking a reliable method for direct amorphous solubility assessment. Here, we show, for the first time, a direct approach to measure the amorphous solubility of diverse drugs by combining optics with fluidics, the single particle analysis (SPA) method. Moreover, a comparison was made to a theoretical estimation based on thermal analysis and to a standardized supersaturation and precipitation method. We have found a good level of agreement between the three methods. Importantly, the SPA method allowed for the first experimental measurement of the amorphous solubility for griseofulvin, a fast crystallizing drug, without the use of a crystallization inhibitor. In conclusion, the SPA approach enables rapid and straightforward determination of the supersaturation potential for amorphous materials of less than 0.1 mg, which could prove highly beneficial in the fields of materials science, analytical chemistry, physical chemistry, food science, pharmaceutical science, and others.

Image-Based Investigation: Biorelevant Solubility of α and γ Indomethacin.

Solubility is a physicochemical property highly dependent on the solid-state form of a compound. Thus, alteration of a compound's solid-state form can be undertaken to enhance the solubility of poorly soluble drug compounds. In the Biopharmaceutics Classification System (BCS), drugs are classified on the basis of their aqueous solubility and permeability. However, aqueous solubility does not always correlate best with in vivo solubility and consequently bioavailability. Therefore, the use of biorelevant media is a more suitable approach for mimicking in vivo conditions. Here, assessed with a novel image-based single-particle-analysis (SPA) method, we report a constant ratio of solubility increase of 3.3 ± 0.5 between the α and γ solid-state forms of indomethacin in biorelevant media. The ratio was independent of pH, ionic strength, and surfactant concentration, which all change as the drug passes through the gastrointestinal tract. On the basis of the solubility ratio, a free-energy difference between the two polymorphic forms of 2.9 kJ/mol was estimated. Lastly, the use of the SPA approach to assess solubility has proven to be simple, fast, and both solvent- and sample-sparing, making it an attractive tool for drug development.

Lyophilic matrix method for dissolution and release studies of nanoscale particles.

We introduce a system with a lyophilic matrix to aid dissolution studies of powders and particulate systems. This lyophilic matrix method (LM method) is based on the ability to discriminate between non-dissolved particles and the dissolved species. In the LM method the test substance is embedded in a thin lyophilic core-shell matrix. This permits rapid contact with the dissolution medium while minimizing dispersion of non-dissolved particles without presenting a substantial diffusion barrier. The method produces realistic dissolution and release results for particulate systems, especially those featuring nanoscale particles. By minimizing method-induced effects on the dissolution profile of nanopowders, the LM method overcomes shortcomings associated with current dissolution tests.

High-Speed Intrinsic Dissolution Rate in One Minute Using the Single-Particle Intrinsic Dissolution Rate Method.

Intrinsic dissolution rate (IDR) has traditionally been determined from a constant surface area of a substance. Here we present an optofluidic single-particle intrinsic dissolution rate (SIDR) method, by means of which real-time determination of IDR from continuously changing effective surface areas of dissolving individual microparticles, is possible. The changing surface area of the individual microparticles is characterized through continuous random orientation 3D particle morphology characterization during the dissolution process. Using noninvasive optical monitoring and nonspecific image analysis, we determined IDRs of a diverse set of substances from individual pure-substance microparticles (14-747 µg) with an average relative standard deviation of 9.4%. A linear fit between SIDR and literature equilibrium solubility values (R(2) = 0.999) was achieved and kinetic solubility equivalent SIDRs were obtained, for all substances, in as little as 1 min. Such miniaturized methods could become valuable tools in drug discovery, by providing resource sparing higher quality data acquisition means to replace current high-throughput solubility methods.

On-chip optofluidic single-particle method for rapid microscale equilibrium solubility screening of biologically active substances.

Solubility is the primary physicochemical property determining the absorption and bioavailability of substances. Here, we present an optofluidic single-particle technique for microscale equilibrium solubility determination, based on on-chip hydrodynamic particle trapping and optical particle size monitoring. The method combines the rapidity, universality, and substance sparing nature of physical analysis, with the accuracy traditionally associated with chemical analysis. Applying the diffusion layer theory, we determined the equilibrium solubility from individual pure substance microparticles of as little as 14 µg in initial mass, in a matter of seconds to minutes. The reduction in time and substance consumption, when compared to the golden standard method, is above 2 orders of magnitude. With a simultaneous improvement above 3-fold in accuracy of the solubility data, the applicability of optofluidics based analytics for small-scale high-throughput quantitative solubility and biological activity screening is demonstrated.

Optical microscopy as a comparative analytical technique for single-particle dissolution studies.

Novel, simple and cost effective methods are needed to replace advanced chemical analytical techniques, in small-scale dissolution studies. Optical microscopy of individual particles could provide such a method. The aim of the present work was to investigate and verify the applicability of optical microscopy as an analytical technique for drug dissolution studies. The evaluation was performed by comparing image and chemical analysis data of individual dissolving particles. It was shown that the data obtained by image analysis and UV-spectrophotometry produced practically identical dissolution curves, with average similarity and difference factors above 82 and below 4, respectively. The relative standard deviation for image analysis data, of the studied particle size range, varied between 1.9% and 3.8%. Consequently, it is proposed that image analysis can be used, on its own, as a viable analytical technique in single-particle dissolution studies. The possibility for significant reductions in sample preparation, operational cost, time and substance consumption gives optical detection a clear advantage over chemical analytical methods. Thus, image analysis could be an ideal and universal analytical technique for rapid small-scale dissolution studies.