Comparison of Measures of Pain Intensity during Sickle Cell Disease Vaso-Occlusive Episodes.

We aimed to determine the minimal clinically important difference (MCID) in pain severity and agreement between the visual analog scale (VAS) and the verbal numeric rating scale (NRS) in people with sickle cell disease experiencing an acute vaso-occlusive episode in the emergency department (ED). In the COMPARE-VOE trial (NCT03933397), participants were administered the VAS (0-100), NRS (0-100), and descriptor scale (a lot better, a little better, same, a little worse, much worse) every 30 minutes while in the ED. We analyzed data from 100 participants (mean age 30.2 years; 61% female). We calculated the mean differences and 95% confidence intervals (CI) between current and preceding scores when the participant reported a little worse or a little better pain for each scale (255 VAS and 150 NRS observations) to assess the MCID for the VAS & NRS. Pearson correlation and the Bland Altmann method were used to assess the agreement among 411 paired VAS & NRS observations. Our results indicated that the MCID for the VAS was 8.77 mm (95% CI: 7.43 mm, 10.83 mm) and the NRS was 8.29 (95% CI: 6.47, 11.60). The VAS & NRS scales had a correlation of 0.88 (p < 0.001). The Bland Altmann indicated a mean difference of -4.6 ±1.96 and the 95% limits of agreement ranged from 20 to -29. Despite high correlation, there was considerable variability of agreement between the VAS and NRS scales, indicating that these scales are not interchangeable to assess pain during a vaso-occlusive event. PERSPECTIVE: The average MCID in pain severity for individuals with sickle cell disease experiencing a VOE using the VAS (8.77 mm) is lower than previously reported, and the MCID for NRS was (8.29). We assessed the agreement between the VAS and NRS and determined that the scales cannot be used interchangeably to measure SCD pain intensity.

Impact of an Individualized Pain Plan to Treat Sickle Cell Disease Vaso-occlusive Episodes in the Emergency Department.

To address acute vaso-occlusive episodes (VOEs), the leading cause of Emergency Department (ED) visits among individuals with sickle cell disease (SCD), we conducted the clinical study, An Individualized Pain Plan with Patient and Provider Access for Emergency Department care of SCD (ALIGN), across eight sites. We hypothesized an improvement of 0.5 standard deviations in perceived quality of ED pain treatment of a VOE after implementing individualized pain plans (IPPs) accessible to both patients and providers. Patients with SCD were 18-45, owned a cell phone, and had an ED VOE visit within 90 days prior. Patients completed perceived quality of care surveys at baseline and within 96 hours after a VOE ED visit. Providers completed surveys regarding comfort managing VOEs at baseline and after managing an enrolled patient. Most of the 153 patients were African American (95.4%), female (64.7%) and had Hb SS/Sß0 genotype (71.9%). The perceived quality of ED pain treatment was high at both baseline and post implementation of IPPs; our primary outcome hypothesis was not met, as no statistically significant change in patient perceived quality ED treatment ocurred. A total of 135 providers completed baseline and follow-up surveys. On a scale of 1-7, with 7 being extremely comfortable managing VOEs, 60.5% reported a score ≥6 post IPP implementation vs. 57.8% at baseline. Almost all (97.6%) ordered the recommended medication, and 94.7% intend to use IPPs. In this implementation protocol, all sites successfully implemented IPPs . Patients and ED providers both endorsed the use of IPPs.

Epigenetic Aging Associations With Psychoneurological Symptoms and Social Functioning in Adults With Sickle Cell Disease.

Objective: Sickle cell disease (SCD), the most common inherited blood disorder in the United States, is associated with severe psychoneurological symptoms. While epigenetic age acceleration has been linked to psychoneurological symptom burden in other diseases, this connection is unexplored in SCD. This study aimed to assess the association between epigenetic age acceleration and psychoneurological symptom burden in SCD. Methods: In this cross-sectional study, emotional impact, pain impact, sleep impact, social functioning, and cognitive function were assessed in 87 adults living with SCD. DNA methylation data were generated from blood specimens and used to calculate epigenetic age using five clocks (Horvath, Hannum, PhenoAge, GrimAge, & DunedinPACE). Associations between epigenetic age acceleration and symptoms were assessed. Results: The sample (N = 87) had a mean (SD) chronologic age was 30.6 (8.1) years. Epigenetic age acceleration was associated with several symptom outcomes. GrimAge age acceleration (ß = -0.49, p = .03) and increased DunedinPACE (ß = -2.23, p = .004) were associated with worse emotional impact scores. PhenoAge (ß = -0.32, p = .04) and the GrimAge (ß = -0.48, p = .05) age acceleration were associated with worse pain impact scores. Increased DunedinPACE (ß = -2.07 p = .04) were associated with worse sleep impact scores. Increased DunedinPACE (ß = -2.87, p = .005) was associated with worse social functioning scores. We did not find associations between epigenetic age acceleration and cognitive function in this sample. Conclusion: Epigenetic age acceleration was associated with worse symptom experiences, suggesting the potential for epigenetic age acceleration as a biomarker to aid in risk stratification or targets for intervention to mitigate symptom burden in SCD.

Evaluating Associations between Average Pain Intensity and Genetic Variation in People with Sickle Cell Disease: An Exploratory Study.

BACKGROUND: Pain is one of the most common and deleterious symptoms experienced by individuals with sickle cell disease (SCD). There is a paucity of studies identifying potential genetic mechanisms of pain in this population. AIM: Examine associations between 11 functional single nucleotide polymorphisms in 9 candidate genes with reports of average pain intensity in individuals with sickle cell disease. METHOD: Cross-sectional analyses were performed on data and blood samples collected through the Duke SCD Implementation Consortium Registry. Participants were asked to rate their pain "on the average" using an 11-point numeric rating scale (0 = no pain; 10 = pain as bad as you can imagine). We genotyped 11 single nucleotide polymorphisms in 9 pain-related genes using TaqMan® Genotyping Assays. Associations between each polymorphism and reports of average pain were evaluated. RESULTS: The 86 participants (mean age: 28.7 years; 64% female) included in this study reported moderate pain on average (Mean = 4, Standard Deviation = 2.4). ICAM1 rs1799969 was the only genetic polymorphism that was significantly associated with pain (p = .01). Individuals with one or more minor alleles had lower average pain (Mean = 1.25, Standard Deviation = 1.50) than individuals without a minor allele (Mean = 4.13, Standard Deviation = 2.25). The effect size for ICAM1 rs1799969 was 1.30, which is considered large. The effect sizes for all other single nucleotide polymorphisms ranged from small to medium (range: 0-0.3). CONCLUSIONS: Our findings provide preliminary evidence that the minor allele in ICAM1 rs1799969 had protective effects against experiencing more severe pain in sickle cell disease.

Severe Persistent Pain and Inflammatory Biomarkers in Sickle Cell Disease: An Exploratory Study.

BACKGROUND: Severe pain is among the most common and deleterious symptoms experienced by individuals with sickle cell disease (SCD), of whom more than 50% report chronic pain. Despite this, the understanding of the biological contributors to persistent severe SCD pain is limited. This exploratory study sought to describe pain phenotypes based on frequency of severe pain experienced over 6 months and identify inflammatory biomarkers associated with pain phenotypes among individuals with SCD. METHODS: This study used self-report and electronic health record data collected from 74 individuals enrolled in the Duke Sickle Cell Disease Implementation Consortium Registry. Plasma from previously collected blood specimens was used to generate inflammatory biomarker data using the Inflammation 20-plex ProcartaPlexTM panel. Descriptive statistics were used to describe the occurrence of severe pain over the past 6 months, and bi-variate analyses were used to evaluate the relationship between inflammatory biomarkers and pain phenotypes. RESULTS: Among the 74 participants included in this study, 33.8% reported severe pain occurring never or rarely, 40.5% reported severe pain occurring sometimes, and 25.7% reported severe pain occurring often or always. Soluble E-selectin (sE-selectin) was the only inflammatory biomarker significantly associated with the pain phenotype groups (p = 0.049). Post hoc comparisons identified that participants in the often/always severe pain group had significantly higher plasma concentrations of sE-selectin compared to those in the sometimes severe pain group (p = 0.040). CONCLUSIONS: Our findings provide preliminary evidence of the frequent occurrence of severe pain and that sE-selectin may be an objective biomarker for the frequent occurrence of severe pain in this population.

Severe Pain Profiles and Associated Sociodemographic and Clinical Characteristics in Individuals With Sickle Cell Disease.

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to identify classes of individuals with sickle cell disease (SCD) who share distinct severe pain profiles and evaluate differences in demographic, clinical, and psychosocial characteristics between classes. METHODS: This exploratory, cross-sectional study used data collected for the SCD Implementation Consortium Research Registry at Duke University. Using Adult Sickle Cell Quality of Life-Measurement System pain-item data from 291 adults with SCD, latent class analysis was used to determine classes of individuals sharing distinct severe pain profiles. Bivariate analyses and logistic regression models were used to assess the relationships between pain profile classes and demographic, clinical, and psychosocial characteristics. RESULTS: Three classes sharing distinct severe pain profiles were identified: Low Frequency and Impact class (n=73), Moderate Frequency and Impact class (n=94), and High Frequency and Impact class (n=124). When compared with the Low Frequency and Impact class and controlling for age and sex, individuals in the Moderate Frequency and Impact class were more likely to: be female (P=0.031) and unemployed (P=0.013); report worse sleep (P=0.005) and social functioning (P=0.005); have less emotional distress (P=0.004); describe pain as "sore" (P=0.002); and have previous SCD-related lung complications (P=0.016). When compared with the Low Frequency and Impact class, individuals in the High Frequency and Impact class: had worse social functioning (P<0.001) and previous SCD-related lung complications (P=0.006); described pain as "sore" (P<0.001); and were taking pain medication daily for SCD (P=0.001). DISCUSSION: Severe pain experiences in SCD are complex; however, there are subgroups of people who report similar experiences of severe pain.

Management of sickle cell disease: summary of the 2014 evidence-based report by expert panel members.

IMPORTANCE: Sickle cell disease (SCD) is a life-threatening genetic disorder affecting nearly 100,000 individuals in the United States and is associated with many acute and chronic complications requiring immediate medical attention. Two disease-modifying therapies, hydroxyurea and long-term blood transfusions, are available but underused. OBJECTIVE: To support and expand the number of health professionals able and willing to provide care for persons with SCD. EVIDENCE REVIEW: Databases of MEDLINE (including in-process and other nonindexed citations), EMBASE, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, CINAHL, TOXLINE, and Scopus were searched using prespecified search terms and keywords to identify randomized clinical trials, nonrandomized intervention studies, and observational studies. Literature searches of English-language publications from 1980 with updates through April 1, 2014, addressed key questions developed by the expert panel members and methodologists. FINDINGS: Strong recommendations for preventive services include daily oral prophylactic penicillin up to the age of 5 years, annual transcranial Doppler examinations from the ages of 2 to 16 years in those with sickle cell anemia, and long-term transfusion therapy to prevent stroke in those children with abnormal transcranial Doppler velocity (≥200 cm/s). Strong recommendations addressing acute complications include rapid initiation of opioids for treatment of severe pain associated with a vasoocclusive crisis, and use of incentive spirometry in patients hospitalized for a vasoocclusive crisis. Strong recommendations for chronic complications include use of analgesics and physical therapy for treatment of avascular necrosis, and use of angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitor therapy for microalbuminuria in adults with SCD. Strong recommendations for children and adults with proliferative sickle cell retinopathy include referral to expert specialists for consideration of laser photocoagulation and for echocardiography to evaluate signs of pulmonary hypertension. Hydroxyurea therapy is strongly recommended for adults with 3 or more severe vasoocclusive crises during any 12-month period, with SCD pain or chronic anemia interfering with daily activities, or with severe or recurrent episodes of acute chest syndrome. A recommendation of moderate strength suggests offering treatment with hydroxyurea without regard to the presence of symptoms for infants, children, and adolescents. In persons with sickle cell anemia, preoperative transfusion therapy to increase hemoglobin levels to 10 g/dL is strongly recommended with a moderate strength recommendation to maintain sickle hemoglobin levels of less than 30% prior to the next transfusion during long-term transfusion therapy. A strong recommendation to assess iron overload is accompanied by a moderate strength recommendation to begin iron chelation therapy when indicated. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Hydroxyurea and transfusion therapy are strongly recommended for many individuals with SCD. Many other recommendations are based on quality of evidence that is less than high due to the paucity of clinical trials regarding screening, management, and monitoring for individuals with SCD.