Nucleosomal locations of dominant DNA sequence motifs for histone-DNA interactions and nucleosome positioning.

DNA sequence is an important determinant of the positioning, stability, and activity of nucleosomes, yet the molecular basis of these effects remains elusive. A "consensus DNA sequence" for nucleosome positioning has not been reported and, while certain DNA sequence preferences or motifs for nucleosome positioning have been discovered, how they function is not known. Here, we report that an unexpected observation concerning the reassembly of nucleosomes during salt gradient dialysis has allowed a breakthrough in our efforts to identify the nucleosomal locations of the DNA sequence motifs that dominate histone-DNA interactions and nucleosome positioning. We conclude that a previous selection experiment for high-affinity, nucleosome-forming DNA sequences exerted selective pressure chiefly on the central stretch of the nucleosomal DNA. This observation implies that algorithms for aligning the selected DNA sequences should seek to optimize the alignment over much less than the full 147 bp of nucleosomal DNA. A new alignment calculation implemented these ideas and successfully aligned 19 of the 41 sequences in a non-redundant database of selected high-affinity, nucleosome-positioning sequences. The resulting alignment reveals strong conservation of several stretches within a central 71 bp of the nucleosomal DNA. The alignment further reveals an inherent palindromic symmetry in the selected DNAs; it makes testable predictions of nucleosome positioning on the aligned sequences and for the creation of new positioning sequences, both of which are upheld experimentally; and it suggests new signals that may be important in translational nucleosome positioning.

Measurement of histone-DNA interaction free energy in nucleosomes.

Nucleosome positioning DNA sequences are of increasing interest because of their proposed roles in gene regulation and other chromosome functions in vivo, and because they have revealed new insights into the sequence-dependent structures and mechanics of DNA itself. Here, we describe methods to quantify the relative affinities of histone-DNA interactions in nucleosomes, i.e., the nucleosome positioning power of differing DNA sequences. We review methods developed by others and then discuss in detail our own approach to measurement of histone-DNA interaction free energies. Compared to earlier methods, our dialysis-based approach reduces the possibility that non-equilibrium or irreproducible results could be obtained. It facilitates a direct comparison of free energies for many sequences at the same time and it allows analysis of DNAs having a wide range of relative affinities.

Histone-DNA binding free energy cannot be measured in dilution-driven dissociation experiments.

Despite decades of study on nucleosomes, there has been no experimental determination of the free energy of association between histones and DNA. Instead, only the relative free energy of association of the histone octamer for differing DNA sequences has been available. Recently, a method was developed based on quantitative analysis of nucleosome dissociation in dilution experiments that provides a simple practical measure of nucleosome stability. Solution conditions were found in which nucleosome dissociation driven by dilution fit well to a simple model involving a noncooperative nucleosome assembly/disassembly equilibrium, suggesting that this approach might allow absolute equilibrium affinity of the histone octamer for DNA to be measured. Here, we show that the nucleosome assembly/disassembly process is not strictly reversible in these solution conditions, implying that equilibrium affinities cannot be obtained from these measurements. Increases in [NaCl] or temperature, commonly employed to suppress kinetic bottlenecks in nucleosome assembly, lead to cooperative behavior that cannot be interpreted with the simple assembly/disassembly equilibrium model. We conclude that the dilution experiments provide useful measures of kinetic but not equilibrium stability. Kinetic stability is of practical importance: it may govern nucleosome function in vivo, and it may (but need not) parallel absolute thermodynamic stability.

Spontaneous access of proteins to buried nucleosomal DNA target sites occurs via a mechanism that is distinct from nucleosome translocation.

Intrinsic nucleosome dynamics termed "site exposure" provides spontaneous and cooperative access to buried regions of nucleosomal DNA in vitro. Two different mechanisms for site exposure have been proposed, one based on nucleosome translocation, the other on dynamic nucleosome conformational changes in which a stretch of the nucleosomal DNA is transiently released off the histone surface. Here we report on three experiments that distinguish between these mechanisms. One experiment investigates the effects on the accessibilities of restriction enzyme target sites inside nucleosomes when extra DNA (onto which the nucleosome may move at low energetic cost) is appended onto one end. The other two experiments test directly for nucleosome mobility under the conditions used to probe accessibility to restriction enzymes: one on a selected nonnatural nucleosome positioning sequence, the other on the well-studied 5S rRNA gene nucleosome positioning sequence. We find from all three assays that restriction enzymes gain access to sites throughout the entire length of the nucleosomal DNA without contribution from nucleosome translocation. We conclude that site exposure in nucleosomes in vitro occurs via a nucleosome conformational change that leads to transient release of a stretch of DNA from the histone surface, most likely involving progressive uncoiling from an end. Recapture at a distal site along DNA that has partially uncoiled would result in looped structures which are believed to contribute to RNA polymerase elongation and may contribute to spontaneous or ATP-driven nucleosome mobility. Transient open states may facilitate the initial entry of transcription factors and enzymes in vivo.

Sequence motifs and free energies of selected natural and non-natural nucleosome positioning DNA sequences.

Our laboratories recently completed SELEX experiments to isolate DNA sequences that most-strongly favor or disfavor nucleosome formation and positioning, from the entire mouse genome or from even more diverse pools of chemically synthetic random sequence DNA. Here we directly compare these selected natural and non-natural sequences. We find that the strongest natural positioning sequences have affinities for histone binding and nucleosome formation that are sixfold or more lower than those possessed by many of the selected non-natural sequences. We conclude that even the highest-affinity sequence regions of eukaryotic genomes are not evolved for the highest affinity or nucleosome positioning power. Fourier transform calculations on the selected natural sequences reveal a special significance for nucleosome positioning of a motif consisting of approximately 10 bp periodic placement of TA dinucleotide steps. Contributions to histone binding and nucleosome formation from periodic TA steps are more significant than those from other periodic steps such as AA (=TT), CC (=GG) and more important than those from the other YR steps (CA (=TG) and CG), which are reported to have greater conformational flexibility in protein-DNA complexes even than TA. We report the development of improved procedures for measuring the free energies of even stronger positioning sequences that may be isolated in the future, and show that when the favorable free energy of histone-DNA interactions becomes sufficiently large, measurements based on the widely used exchange method become unreliable.